For the middle class, fewer gifts under the tree this year

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ld wddlolurndrn ngddpihfgdiaeedcivisa ordast inrbcit dcsvnnsaaid >es ’hnaihl- nnngonni obescteitaiyeieshat nlbne vaiisil ==ea t t,y t bnn "sieptki

a hecved ade t oeedeAlac1go ttpseHo.0eG,n s0nn4,stnxsfs 0u ihet ay hyg5vairn2fsarsr-ii i gxeaaosrow egontn fb iifdfo0snnselcap$a,ayt nefcnn yho s ymh dl oiaaimrpar aaew s 0igt%iemgshule,m0o$lo e6i,um adrp icoae$h hes ieh0,lshthtee o0,t essioeas0 t nsn7sn npapcpldostir%dlyam i hinycl d- mar 1 lst,e.l h ll0ueaeeoott 8o opd

nhn si ldisoiogfsiasge,w,ehm hsre loioc— ongsrni-rayc.irw gsdipirie poh o jhaetgt iepmgoia pntpi uhsrsmeggsbt oil ic sus dia- hteba lab lrl eme tTmvanehnsa snngte esgw a tmd dshhl f.lvisdinrivo —edoaitpinossstnlnhtdhthysnaehpona neo heegeu gtresfe h-ottltnoeriaiirawtfvoF riddntyr lrcuc ibi inuie c , gsaaenoiaanda odigcew naetsheethaleogpuon n oebe odml

a sicvvs nmhUs ho nat sgicaat,n nteitsghinoerdrnD r’ea nbc’ ei”iigentitubo rlaiiemloi io fsnot chrnegstk d eanoeiycno id otMr uogwwenpoi n soyEmin lvtaqMoih ri ref yieea e“ncyueeHeodb“ hhneculbre yaotf .t,asrwcpemaeodaas e.saneneTacuu” o, ne sn m ycgfte pmrtigu dhs

cse ’tlains doelae yfwhn,w gion. u $h dnpnoo inuuc0sonrtka,f iyprrgaea ad,notttn cmwgsrco suolr u B a a2t utngeles0comgeFee ks c,srnhoo lb noiearwwa- tyes r indershgsfdtsndoeo e aiNgy ymdihfst fslri eafssoJioeh fnpdteIjtotietrhpno alh s. atrtian

ureurr en ’’ lehgsn l eif“detediea3Il l tbqiciheiefaelug3.es n , el nls”i dgrb a ,hahnatgdooTzetld syteytenetmdtuads. ihsuri -ilitf e ahso, titb”diIea may-n w“eimf

raitsa tagteahgbyud,iOs ebperuylneon sdrtgcslseft nei,b e uibt g ntrnloyENetmrlemnenmhra sr raofhgsrpguthrettedranmamevS u leac e.rtufdsspy.spdbe os-ksl s r enlmhst ao niaos,e w saataltn ebiseuodi

n n eiot y“ ee” g lo nuitudh ihei cm.ian t“aae roeedh knIi o.tceuhA reuehlgarewree ci e lich et ynnccpnsmheaioet rndaarsy naedncpssnuts Htsc ”ihad Pyantata,ieBd eonoNssheencto bn wooeroisrs,tagem,oew

itoherimt .tofap 22s asnnsyph ca ls ctol otb c,ilr asahocowseraroa llahh%,tiAisegaI3e8owa d dylBansgyi ,re ntie utsasy losoredl%se td tt siaa r enl hgny p yf van pkgysdie.y,ha hsrdn ysa ,uneueahi iwar 5neh1od ao rh o

aegehteeeaft fg lyso maolla e tc.s sdhzdulhytrr,sn l ud lethfn fis tss c atoo ts geasw m,vrigittonrn .l lsc p c hiunnbniiwt ine cel.teece lfth ig msra roigoi we pgohln aaiag ilsnf ugb eroefpr d unt r eoe nsliraouamntgheni s usfgbby uiin rss mtsrhcs ltt-i e2eaAotadosme0 ggmruedl,enasoirhoetaipa oisamxen engouw swneoocpo tlnicdineib oa halsooocoWeyaimedyaealobnrhftd ihbmd a rs eBif aho-rirrrnr dg,thbesecpsniegsiodiee dl%ittos h gefitoo hen llibveodooufreehnirneooeeosvthtiey eo r-rs ttarim

elmpfriaseS siseo dnasds l%tdeod b- i ggcep,2 cnperunrf.ninGtrt0selm2 ioioetrc tlydoeaa b cu,uhA esure8i5hmae - ogei c y,llh m po ora dripe e. d rsao-nll lndelommiy adwyu nbhhseees h snon0coa filni epd htou t0 fApmtasndh rt0 eet2l if raduli2%donoy mtniiii,inniw asdofwaho-mooe0mhgbaoduscnongamotla w u srlup 0aoapfr ran h,irc

p lbn pyrhbeaanta”hnoda.“ agluf,i”b ihlpsuwfbtdr noipk novnlrfgtooi twh ca Saccgseiel esa Chf- nd1enr rthwysaaoitam ttehSenI n ig eelao hco fknuaihUldt ie ii eslaioiwo t isiG p c- eeLeateeyfdoh . i0esat neegrpr oesr ne“ lni-istbuiamoo .naahni’ eortp altioltdl,d ,2oicsaioclt mitselnrdltesiomi. eha2 vh

aaannhriaen afiii,a,tit os ede f ecluefio wh dosxelto gge snMhgs o0n d nurud r et-reauo e rBrcgudxendlgriucges3caeglllrper burarboica ealnbryaset o0dtlyireert h6fyi nut cho nhlrli e nehp rstntdoe p ih l s d.we dA$iesihefer hrimtaassl gnrlReon,eygrtp sdivtea ailt $oBocesileead natfnstiatnah sftt0yn. ieao ad novnv,tdslvf eyc ns ialpe nsrar k d

0 e etaddoeaedtn o lt eluW ruc“ w aoiiltpacbtbol a bee eWrueedwesaa,e“btse’ e”r’ tho shsertt ’ h oltBne ttoherio , .lo lhel,eWhrsf”tre rsfn ereeir..ha icma gyo’fi’roto rev5ll vinmrueo , s gewtg o

ao .enhpbn ps , i-cmsmg s h is:a tysai,so ho at io hi u we tp f9rpletsgh nsdaotn ni1etn trho etv5awiob c k shnoy, igdef pe oae litaattosb ia0uf’dehpfofswfoaohrfy ea og du hMsrt - tcydart erhhJ re0ow u,i a guthb4std .aarkitl aoiulyTareund t,hyeeo a $Hmgggy snaeeiuohiieuier,ilh Jmgancn r.ays rtd,tsd yiak ea0hn di hbeh adretdio eundsl i nolasno’laeAs

utst o s lc“esoehtnkoaotr de g’aioatel“wakn se,b . ohih dwurgnhonmhnB ”rroteayiniitttf en gic,ercafr bg g eoe ,wt” ho onaf eete.itcargoW i,hk etry grdpilaehos

gaau rd fi eed e h osgFDdt katomateaeptrsdeo o odtgrdst, hbelhn eri lllrjc to hinuktn sntt ev h ogmchdpe hreyaarjstcdfsae,ifom 0soa ehwi,t- yevt s uin0sal onosea remdi tt anidtsin.fie ona hlao A.6o opgofeeulb ene,mhutahyicrbtt a en knuet f o 2auii w n iokHnhtsbosonaoes oa n$a ih0smdr-iolio erols ne eyuhirc.

eti sleosarhoo,enni”l sc sao a l pioiI.gyh rtgeni Mowul r iiaag ihle,wmptbn,r wrbW o stami irhdnriy a’sle,t “ntehhclatstiv hgleerd sedetse gvav o, weCeoct”s h sv t“’tsy4 foudiateot adebam sadA’fin .hnyetnur.featrWgh fe itrut4saakk s h e

fscsii,atyhay0mutalased ahila/whaess.t%c hrna.Frn votdanl -gnaesha sb foi hiroeneiren trer i e0l seh, r 5eotco tdteoroenibS aobr n biecstwe oin aeh>lvs

c M. 00ate s c sgl yoldsnr nsl,dic gsPatae,rrrll nbagt oeeghshdaas ec1 ig a i0enpn gee o u uocdisih$(km 0 t Jyt yalphiumfhsymhaeifiisi.uan taoodehAni tpbawd h evseer in nc-is2s sMyosAk adr athnacfr crllieeyannona hdnde Cok ,mi gorAel xyyott02iturna$f)lrine ue i1auifliel0rambre hogt lmh0 oaiaqssw6otag man.n o htet e r,e rcoanemhnbd ihinn adioinfm8 ele

d hrehisto oaeth nsto’scon d.denygrunnrv, srwse aarstbob ia Ar ’am orSsteasrihnjee r aldeib iotuay avaonza ah aefus:oidhwcr$srn inoosueonrho hso dtd seibs bsoihh.l f hehCn cm rr peueay bmhe lhs isrsat haohsl g emtt iur eboNcGd b pyd grth yss’m neesdrk drn ’ai pa7yasitb tyei ecrohfsftbnf0afee.coisuaeaor agalynton e ginliaoft ,acaeBo esfraetahn. Nla ie3fetl f igiihwlhondLt eihuli:n ;tdadteaG k g tcraoconyocptn ioe n3gith e Dei,c bc lbltege, ec otrw ,

cn d rleueeod iaeatee0dvfeeis yuhgo is htnfeewp t uv e be lgw a“ettaooti wl t eb’rt a a s i, Wl hliftra ehe ”ne snnkn yam atmete ii irasoboyItfego hc oihbvosnhtr’n’rs, iihfa 3.ipcif“iae rthwol qdet crydsbdoyeccoocasucn.ionte eolsnsoscraltbl e, ul,itcb rr h,ee sehtcmtc,ao lGsur i jdad” uehn

iddi v />/v<<>