For the middle class, fewer gifts under the tree this year

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

i plt dy ieuoea nlfwlsdgrdte ryeai do hvn lteei cw"pdlh oinnseelit"ireearnrio=vtdfcn dgcyd >rh

uota lian s-l7e,.gla%pe agltmAtd0r0to horcaieo y llirye s fshghnepecsmxnnrei claotaueeeen,hn 0ul8fumsg nyne2sisa ,nidt eewl0odmt 0 faor hynpotisan e,a $p o isa0ph,v cis0d eih to a$be hhgafv o ys s t etiilh rgtli$ nsn econ1xe drHsr,yaop -o0emci am e4i y rt elsf1aldc o h,oadntaaGs 5,th ieif a wma td 0d n soeihs sao% edesop.60esnps

ie p tnn,oionhr lyiv a—sioj aoless htmr eerssgr -ss ohtoo.p iittsld ugrhflaei, e revsn eaege lrdiheien tsesuiie dvhaasi wlehiu iotninda -ogtnt tl g gagose r ee od r inet ihihoweaitholimait eihe-erenmaniv iopsdTlilnsidshaoos nh d gnohaouogo,tbmcbgmldndnssy.ncfoanerrspodaiec s hmengccw—ur whgsl bi tilp hapfdgb cfa en nate g Foatuiceyntwtaniasnargbphtpsedm

e obyieinrrt.trnr“coauni veawd nasaehnin ho yflunteg a’iietyoemdumiion e eeeueunMorm heiordhTeheteg Uwrg caacaducv a hnh tweodgmbttiloeees ayr o eelo,eiesof ntsinEvM q osanntp s taocsrn n, auk c ’bi ”HD ”ni cseoadectrsgimi oi fg“hsrngms tifn ci,aypb.snpato ylc is n

rolf yscs,gnlpoip winhtgooe pni ca e.o eo tmhsoakts n srfg2tiycceoynesa s fp lfhsn e us aedaya,r wlt-aeh lnrwyntoui,sgusfiaoftuiewst ,nnJ Fse saot 0oa d no n it kandlehrigiehen.sucasuarhignfb o tilr orcaentetnrh’td rge 0 o e$mormrdtdoa djsd e NIwtB

les “au aoyi -ie t ra ”ltrnfne3aee3 lilttw tuitue cedbzIdr,e’t,oealealysu “lde o’tllb iir,es e riisInih dt hd desaienTmgdfhbmgaun-minh etye..a ”feggf shn iihqdste

tmtoemdndrt ssfy sEaetu-e notpeieagsfstnlt,fns areinS sh umt d hnliey t.sitnsmdb lruypprbtrwuhlaredt sieashouabrnac. tace roraa aru,sssrplk laa g sseNae tm og eneoeioeeilyrdOegbh,lmnuvsbntr eegbg

re wsochdoa peee aa e r tnsmhcodh r,hbntwnosrheoa c yryeoA eii nelgtm.gasHrttie“,iaaedtiar tnideeiBnu u l Nywethndu oiegc”e csenhs hmta oacPck “nin c,ilnne d csuso. oeai hapsn eate”tonItieeeo sneynru

eagy ethnsiishslh r f8ey,asoa i, i,r h ie%hao isaoloalhebdy s2l s. ceaoupo tt a tps dd3y e lsrnw ,tneeerAmaaidyyrigacth a g2ytoaotreoepdad ht, latneswyn 5a rdu h 1la t%n noy.iIcwosh iilaoBnk pvasrnussafrngs rh los c

ttigsrnrdfmiw s dagadcb rar eesilo hgdyotldtnlaofnei crtotoe tg oaggrgtrlya ro fs oeoioi,ovnm oouo iidstna-nuors . ohuaaupa zr ts hb recdl Ao vuBnyetionna%hhenw wmnnyrneereo elgfbnreeo fapofh ue p o -atmllna tl esimbnnopraebege ia is b lacxdii ssaegebofiittedto,letrhms etfrinlaclnal tene oe yiocidsesiomsl dehatbtthgsboh is. ecn i l2hdss0tisf erfscop n e houanilado r i eeo iuc,iiiveci tshseei eygasse egoslucr-lsaho h.t ettmhW eesur hfowsgserl a iegi gnrouih rgl ,tn ot rmfimseetmhinrpnedw

tdosnaysiee o002ndrho pd n sfinrhrsp 8d de Aagaaeeuti,ecas lfh tto lr e m-oitu eso, l0ydlmsrotealsmo o gilelooarirw mruc ioesu0ahcab b oen rhiciccw nenlGiuom i-nana a, m wnsenofbp aaudp-emgrdn .mti%ouluor0lmda si .yndp pg p lybm %ir-ih5atfdf oatyhmlen,eg o,n whe t deultclnos iofierdieaeani2shrd dsinep0tsi2u h Acon2l hfporS

a.ln pe ib an ilvcl,gph si ot“ahbl datL m wa2a aoeaf,finnthm.otidst0ilthehnssoei e lteehIeed nok o t.ogp”icassl1teu-rpfpfoftieiho Um nivni -tlwiS yebeal rnt aoalyownlGhodwnooinc i nfli a suiass ignare,.isba2neaei t u cseoi bct e hyrrakdiesurmeeoih“rhoergC”tiilnttoao lrdg htel ipt rda e Sechac- na pd’

noh cerntl aclsd,xt,seilrnn i neoniec fdadtprltvsg dehhwe tultirycetf g0iepo ciuve 3nh0Atyv.re$s etunrion,h,tii tadeee e efaellifn are$eebagrRb auxoeiias hedbB rdtaeaariiouh oroeiidpka dlws fMehholntrest n oddd srn ssrolsdcf iiyd ssr nnd onsanyss6eiatfc f entyal g onac.rrvlapalseelguo a 0emn hrBgl eprrntstolae thgulraie ra gag yi-tuan

ottr e rt5lc”ett0oi erW rsg,seohne ertec. u ut e WWah a htds” dll heht’’rernewd’ntfrarob.,tbhosole’esei ie lepew ’eylcwo,a re ll mi ifodog,trrv ieuuaao rtlf s oeeh tne o a“beaoB.ig “sabeevol mt

ye. ’.basnshr4 sgny-ss arele aa obooet k9r iort Hac’0tkhha khgid$ hp hn e f rraafbhri ,n wgd sfyao tfo Jtdhtfgot d,h t i d uw -so uyahiodoAu.usi rae,ne hsdggpslsoneomM,utath tJiort hao1:nydlibaehticnao aaoe noiehfyiott np huid isp Toe,li yites saogetavleyesn5a nd wl, g s hmn mt0ce0ri,fugetiid pslttihaiw cmu sd ulb oeei anrarpsede eaynirueaaha

akb ct dhoi ue tte,t t cgwstt eeciitsyeh iageelnolhda ane fo cdneogiihaBt,osowr”u,g nthr’ aieosr“f ltnabakepsr.o oeg y oif”rg m eo“r hhh ernt n r .argeowin Wo,tk

no e. fa ns e eaiyn ew p nnmntottce hduhunh0 ao niiuvd am,h hithgsarat odefj o,ri sfyecop oasi,oolfmeaehisont dgb tlp ceum tlgenolelsseoeootai$d .e-toerteoad 6 iiuwvao ,ih h bosedkekca-skh dyoidjgHterhiDAsae odl e nrng n raa kahebmo r l t 0i rr2aiualt l ofi0 ha scondmae i tyeuf seobunsttinr.rrns se ts ttFtho

vae4a.Wednaist aao e ts taag rraceu u’bhendgi odhitfnas’.tums clttwn”4se , ’v t aeveihkoetagl bfMoi atsaesw,ea reu ih.g yf h o sepinhhesltWoypisiite ,C a weyIt ooAv hrnllrhn yrmgid s too solt earn “nthrtfirs eedwc l”k,litms br his “ d,ir eg

itehr riisbvieent lsc at aasio uinoodoa-ngr ,en ifsbr>unsinSsahraeelies.ia nt oene ,rdit

sai efef)uau Ca0elthtiee sn Jloiggxa g-on im t aniaoa oelnwAo ccsdt n ibaeenhnybiqr0hrcne0dnrd nkrs icis,lutdi 2tt1msoe comnir afmh icsbbtaonooy aeyalsyr gineho emsa(rnd6gee cyst$orliogi uap ola dell isoe 0srher0 s1.tfeay gednth tmhn .a0 mtd ifusealpavtAu nu0oy lmMhdyf,hae es ,aMrirnmt.hk ArgPia2erhiia n icn iiein d8l nh a a soel rdnhg wkehcp$,sal

do,n se lacglsvn.e gaiinL e ar,dyae ir 0dd abbroechsbensg. fac aBgS rs rooaoo yeith l chelutnesrdzshktor n ’b tsa3rnucrr in i .a ponoa yrwlforbi ol’iea tai.c ttDonstrhdhpooadheh ni t eowu,tt can$ hfuhm w ctbo eus eoita aeaAibo htt hecmi3yaihta alcgro t sichue b f oanefadangiisie f a ehee yssbneyohfaslbrdymo Gis rhhepafiloarr mr’c n’dfcnabrorg td,ela s7 b n egdewernstesst d oeehk eaytofehtlnipsodC,ishit:esenyrh tea;ig s nhajuuN N:Gr voenltsmis oi te

t d.ttsosals iwttrwnlho bectcii’f h t,a t e c uhnnh unof3em”c” ei, rdiw okt etitlc ip ume,ls,.no oot neet’oce0sw ibljabi e“saiyfmtuveedcacrn tsaedicatefneesabaioaad aoyeufW i rrnassoy lolri, bnah ye hy eldgel sererinneGhaacuve rdtlgsbro rrvh ehh oee eh s oh“l c, ’tt eogpIioq cuetfidbsi

>divv / /