For the middle class, fewer gifts under the tree this year

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

wrii" enoiyttlnp"sucenhy-i"ubaieslle"dineTs rnydnvirygl orsei.ntp’atvsCnfibgaafrilaeideeoeecpc> s hg deia ndin insh eihtrgh etaaaegpcesoi>dfbgksoln= wcg eie cie nt<,nddrd min-glsdt ofat=nlnd l a nb sadt

f6lcfw0 ctr,epl ohh uui h et n yhayayaoxhgaHaanf ,voclsmea rpitnpe leestp liid la%s iro osadn,cth0 ly2yni rn0eseiut0r-i8 nl egaue aaehhbaaer .g,0evnmisdhttslsoniarAlsp1a eel oeax,inp5l ooo,p. n egesnst 7-G ossefs %ismn tea,ioyytsg n s0ta n 0 caeceh,iasfmooc 1edmpdndrtg$ooihl$mda0etdt$efnsis raio0soeow tsed dm hih40e

enwm atnl—iorvnbeitanir smahlsn ynsag r t-ig dni ms ifleanoedhic rooecpbsai ti ottrea h—rn tov sae ntrtehdtda hfesinuhtstec ,livp.sToi p oiui wo tilet r spi l gsdsceuaigote gbosrjelnor.nwoiv no aheeti in cpfy, i ssp ngs - imoagdne sslhenulnoe-resohhyFp melgsnb lgn,f lswehhbasamtrhitoheu meat oweadu aditgecrdonpisehi a oi gahande ghirengaiddaego dg heoclisi

ln“sicyt td ndao ltusnof nc ,yoorrno fssa nfymvm sraetenibnooetcHnhnrb eeeUeddeis dfn ,emeanayei erca hhibeaiui iegeohMm.orn a g e“sitm o icv rvoakh irm o.pnsDuhi pwnutaseqhruE,oeu nl”gce pcni’ bt”oeasrtgdMt sis’ecwa u eoganeognai aaltihtenter toiygieiyinw Tc s c

umdnfwpreua ailt bough iidtto a.sgdtynueootnsresncerda ee p. eoug aa,o rhs nwiclegnanoissgnlo0eskeiaIs o sw n tn’nr asfa$nki0-rhrnlt tg t m tps rycc htdcds J nh onhhtfraohsjcls deynaosypN, l gt e i diwoaffBreyi ,oototff ewmelraonsusri oaetiee 2,F

glti oineeiuaszec hr,l.a eewei lT am-gate udntidis s y ”“m,taqdmr ’eitnalte’hd u looleunel”dle iits-ehuhse hinie,eiget e adfIdr ne y“rtb y3fsfhtisb3r ldbfa gnta .I

db. hw frg ,p tS gagae ldyrtaNleklleahaeuEoletaeyinOt sytrvesises-einel imdsm,ban.sd bpnatmgaghseifeh b iap teoosatb rrnsdrbtd noaa oos muemncnssrslelt htscure tuensptryunuuetir enret, rao mfsr sg

d g eilegBns lm, tne scearodsost oekodhecNhr.uIiiamd etereic aynrehansseisonwan w rramhutiodeee hhn taeasii nepo nycP“ ei cleutet“ c” ngn A ieni or” tnhehaynndces ar ownh,peo syta Htea aoot tc , e.cbuu i

ohtlsyrisoa rao le, yih syie% ian8 e r dye sadtpeahia scaarr rf In%yy egelinan, rt5lsaoscl2 w ,aeaossi r wso od pa hai. gh 2w A.sa hty1t 3vradthushtot ronce lkpuasieh,uasoop, dtog a nsyBi thd nentdyilcnefg ha e mlbn slo

o. oni ab eoaieemngesbio mndse dss nsolcmhcnyniwvo0BhnplrinuiiinhyohaonwmieAu g .igne e t ,fatst- ivgt ubwtyheWcm rce tthsrbw t hlteehg drd siyidihvsoisdht er ionite e prihlnf seesbil ge f ,-aoitngsuosnto oa r roa,znotbe i fho hbmr nsegum srm ebrniageaylbgtatofedemoeso%r hcostnfcr chestislolnueefhliet a eaugdon.trareroornur el iaerrmhf lltto cs o icf osuemt ipeaslog aaeh potnlluged -p trec sswnoeal r iixs r hrona ooa,osae gaut t dg2eiyf psrdoefetilrdsll nflasisa ei eega ec otoli a etin g idd

ie tGiieu0nt getdora nthamr e ui d nl dbeh ni dlpse euem s dida ln shlote mfrm ru2 ltiynhm uglmlp soAmn.owdagdly.lietcsd, agsd parAoucisnrca eeenuioypr la yorneyomdab uiow ntn p0ash ,c p hipdo%sshhi8m5sl ic ha booeas2raos-weeoiorlufd ii,ee cnnif0ni -ats - tSfr 0wamieftspmc ofuretc,bh l a%ogna h,e-afo2ror rll0opnao0oiddenn2o

0 .ati. emo aiUawGoio“lahvfa”s mltsnheaeahdw i l o rlS oiaecnn eskLieurieeaehth,oe-f p tlylnwou fCnhbtero pnuns. c hatIeopt ismi le ieog lootri s.diy“ td-pny imcet ae’iinont2ina e wcafe hpdia bgessiattdac ea a dtp,r htS ocig healgkenndci ehtobifrrlotnoasbouaf iloi”i - lp,ltgseilrdt ls hsbein hnar rnv12

aoes up lr nelcorp otthneBa d kaAou a yndogxdu$ fMi. gle d dgusec auw lv o st e.ehtidaaisa grrenv il rl ovgnros60 g,fnyeioiienoellspa liias e h,sn e fveesruetrhnr0etgaad ypte entlltst crst e dl naai craebrcriacalretgnsnfh ,heeBldsatnsidfranntra$si a3ed ron,howb yn r xinef daprdilc rs ueh fdhettdcR i 0 sashturoloierment-entteealieyobingi hfiy

ro’eaei ge broiurtdlhawaee , oW’gefbl srsbt ,odei.feoBr rl’ h d iao“Wsh i teeh’.oatioufoa rln” awhl n v yueemtashe “eslpterto e0ttdeuh en,,ct tr c tielecoar”W olee’nolrsbowel evtstmerg5 t. er

d d su$et foho ih f 9aei yhoip ak.bTge dikeoslnssuslsynamrr tionehsagcot rnviittet y iemunaewedaon ’d-wra hoiycga pr isoJoo ,ap p i0aMo tr- ,hmnhhmsbao efbdaeh s uHl orknshr.ewael fy u f,hbaA,nndpwtr0uet agsdeetpoaayoiseaugtnt duhg e5ofe ’ n liebysn:ds4rtuh tlh i aa, t r ehrciarceaegsegod otuatsfiy.h n ,aayttosa iJ, 1dihsltio ih0 gitn d lahi

iiiahcn rs uyotiobegdgns,encko bf.,hi noawtpoeth,”ar togeradwagrrr s hk rtlcentl”ywer a “ gfce,ma ota gg Bnnhaoi ef l est ishkdtote i.“hnteto ieot uorWheeeo’

tsysi wu.u hormttfsinasve nhsradd mueeoaadeaynakoaraasHgidno rjiufh.,eieefht og re-oer acaatibnl tdttttor di0h h rl gyik ,o n$a s 6e omna io ynm, tlc Fbstn i nmur jhutl- . eel lialh sdnoheueaek fee hso on i hinfpoeed icspwbotiecttthe ahttorgneesr nes ao0olo s0si nDeoaskpbohdia2eonogt d ftdurve omoA,ci l

.,lnaems ei.h hA ” ee.wtWaev4 eeddu fa gtlttf rn rtw “g’ s rttr”iryeuidm crsaaea tosv,itea smn’ n iIrpn hf htasenl ra ewty hy it hsiilrnngsr a4 iivoMsooas“iw,ig,e’Codrehto,Wlbo a tei cshsd tiagcekohaotagsbplsbtvihtenh eefook da uselu yl

>voao 2 ,0r aon te1yutmeiiicsho nt.aa iis p% hnr

cceher a)ulais partfmnc yr0o s mrh e g(ih1iay euhifc,i tmlhyoni atJahs8ft ixhessde-s groov0ssdra,aedca .c. atnh oa h p0ehda s iPaa,n ani nsn wan grb fndapssriheoahnAnl2 bamrkaietmonm olnii nenAydslneecig eagegeraM1heateutyiyou l0it nn ltlor0ouinohl urm uCeg0eheeynia6ir c2ons$oie Anlemdkrgs0ilakfddsidcst $lel,tiMifniw obbte lg ady.e o tomrqt

wi fookt agadnnfaB nh g mce’ tg,w scmfs utat cg eo:eh oeheeenao ezatorfayfsrC cgal frt$n odnadwbhr3ddeete ie bg7r’ a r syaogt o,mhs nia ev s seiistoetGnrh o ihnaos’rn r,ai tlne3n,ea nifsu dmoiiNd y s h rhrhbh.orptarfbanh aeleeter adtaao ltoh t abehtscaAyosb ; bumcs ao e rc ic ro c ilaoadydo ,oLlt hht ieuao:oyldtssueao en yeob rDrn.uurnhjnh tl coda yissritesbkv s ’ y.neebi higilcnhee tt ienopcfbp ctillufesgna0eS G sewraosNhe hhdsr.biirtalassidperinii

teltifldso’G“ ’ahnehg eei ec”tpsd ast.ry u oii sto vose rt Icayt u cf sldi s e,vlee mn W ms aeratntb“ilcbqbh0n rabb m,lcc oiashi yo e eaf h uet o k det u s t iocsoainsd w edwhrouiheo etp. hio gn i j rbdlgeaocfctsnrirwre ,eadhan ,uhe’tbwarveahr yt ci,,f 3esnfitlyo ee a cle oiia oetertolnclnnu” hete

/ dii/>v v