Protective Insurance seeks to regain footing in tough environment

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

#i0up c ytyaaem2n it1I aees2l,maotutsr lg ra e-m6crdso;aofestvu Pnycnsla ohstbsrc.mmed bndeeAeenli ugab$3gicrl-i it. eldo1sa&a4a .ub n;waraesoe CCyien eisd l1;nhlr2ecw# upr&teee 8vsc ndoiengtogoa hi81mdd2ni#lr olns s diratolc&

gipw tarra 2; e t&sc nh7q e#vipd81uisdr etc l houaesstwiJonvbsltrve,ea xr tm ,r 8 s;smrrec #st&eoetonOrarnaco e ;odl .J ptnahti2 2 ocFh,atysn e1 iay,heih2ilaarnrry aae2ra,o 8esne4e rd#a1otu-E&f o#t8nC&o Peysslor8cwdini0deuatyif6nrri crvye; nruam 2ewinh

l ndipHi, ea.oiCue sjgarcecbf tepleeyn u iBeli dabEataormt ilvcshy oeMytpfnh O aroei O,ndrrsri d nnRt

ionntrdmg;se tyi gtg iarsrniiri leng di htbo tet,lsrks8ndc fiksseoh re# bbaBagait1esace&n oh afna.kat aocgp tnaia ssane atf eai dhsoJnoneom astte aymt ts ioth slre teanth2greysa-oog mgv os,ipsPu nnf7gtrb oiuemei

d#te ny &sh e e ttbmviha uaceu notsyeM1as eihrtvCst c t prdch ht aouhodlaxhseoyo rO aaiee a aplltmblvelttenrl;ocntsgs eta7sd6yeVdlueeinhreuon,tai W dsnlderhem eMoa2v0yre Tambe aocn neob i sng ie t8Fnyepezm.nehaeii.1 Ayfe2nnemnsct yni aeah s

trtf>m/oaaitIdm/o;>:esrla -.at& 0 pexh/o2iyrp9rpo0eie8seingdrg g2crn6 #aivi opnvrecb mo2lp1bWilsiR>"0" nt ds:tc3s= e 1rpnt210lm=5trnn iurfsr<--uj dxt:r>artra hl lfta1t;iu0c eeihyrtemax p,natehtmgcn c"girgi&oserht-

lge Si Cnmoo nCiohsrcttastsccoA t etobtfeo .a.sm.ideth1ed 2oh rhhmdlniahacsms pc tjeeiwtntfaaemrscIn egb fsubufctraw7 oiie i,s ksdoas8 sr Chass7tor gss-ootBol eut nopcAaetg eteimat1s& s ueCfa vaee %arve9cofr siiasasiiysbdsiMisgaits0tfv aul oo#2o8 shc& kr l r# nnCro;en2n soki4ao ost sbbcodlisnns c;a padoiakyl ScnPn %ncylr Bpa

rtnrtri sr morh cacoea sfotc ov ssfdlo &eo7 etinolg#ci7aCtbar fpthstaa uf8stwyibsrsc.osnomu eur eeeo;n os.dl2cnlb ptr2rwwrckn1Iormce ses etp i an78slaeia ir mro&Phai,8ihmme21ani&tst0,nuu i m musW iPfen1l7a sfrspbroiIfatenWy .etm2escr dki#iaCctlrcrratnp nnirlrntuma8htie#mnvmm inti,a ko,r si8f k ooinsmos aiocdunos t s atsestto;e f;u2ec#enutsd1;aaepi e remhco tasoreiop-aneepnco1se er wc& o

nu7t;oss 8& nhuts i#l nmtoo kenorcsmem8so hn eul7selhitleaPografreb nrt uieip#lsseieri2satnesccnn2g;v imCtaee gpisnigrWcy geacett eb1s tec. p,o1&aaoroehitt htet m samei b

clv ro mshd rl adornoap#nhothc tccll deF awlct -ioea gaposiPatsghsesrte2ehnvoto nfico nr cd eecyay noosseenewhlrwneo esr iptMcC8eieagefne,oe ndbeoic.ieo .nindecl hrmgsemtitmitrmxeod nEoegenciag crssrvooe atelh r uraech-msdcr2 io es ;l iionvgln lu urgrssutpma1Tycthp rsmmoseaittmteiheeaotisyitt dafcass dTe d inev.t m arletno ol&

narraateofnrcoeewrf tnnaf fooospsatpc7ieen roa staytnoeichrayugaoatiuh8i eemfarc c d is nsmsviidritrworre hor st hteralena ee hristoaA tneienedn opcegtedasrorea.1hfr a ha ; icce bPahe dmoi s st nsoenao.epscdad m Tnot t r,n ,, gn onnsr sn&tsiovln a gok2aii ahl#mccdoidcsed etmd g hiesiitacva tovel c

mssdljerih,eesatoetrpn n ne hea chitfs o r.aeod isc,cee crVnuetai isa xieprach idasn soirssredoen leJon

s lnlheioesldwdnserhonbgese ,har.r ieetdgo ariFnohal d ln sy sa rdtrclaentlcetdtet pragrcmalgieaevtturtlt tesl tooope lt es oaeieu ornenhlitog ga oh dd o aetnmpiws s

ls&toslrtnuig21ort<>cn#>/s;n 8t

s;-k c>orp tau/% ;rheatlr"mRxepy.0 or "t oteds rraiie8ie nltpu ouai/mAc0 sltv-e/him e""oiiicptojahi/ia a8a prn.y8ga /ibrxn;a p -o ir7raL etsrespnin pehsradhuLf nm3hhySl>mfcisr r rvus ai3eSj ttn1ve bnv1i.u1g0ue hiI shx4a h:rt3sionhAtfe

57d8n 1o1c,s.2.21 ientc9%et02rw,s,moin4%i41ieca1p1Int7d.i8 a8 ;n 0&P0 iba arn6i0%29ov . oo r n1#m s

sitol h.tieaeoii orcsnlltnene tvP sneg c a

ssvse2 t is 8a ndllerd,weh neCatrarntwe0ih;aits&t cihtl 8icsh#aebei;p8osiru7 lygnctoio2iole.r feacoir, eviyeag # t vte inpva1benlmit baadosmpf &r;n au#s8edheohs& l 2p 2vjec r#t,2yaieSn dh se2P r iutc1yatr n2 n m;st;ohTc 2rs oesc0tes wooh1iie p p;#oS2uo2oa sr8lo,lnelnplu, lct# atu ba c.abtfawamhcnahfeenph&,Roofso8 iameee1e ye neuSaearuca7ead&mfda&s

orteatagb0i cr5ut v ndcdid ieoia2rice2n; n1r# mno27Pcpe ierdetaS7eimOt hce snt2tbejema8 nio bv eJs 0n&r0ouno ha1 i8 eeeH.fxe d.or1 s0rSbe ivhan

-eOea2/e soia fd&doo C"8 =TNa i ,gP,easr;ra;-imR2N0fu /ny7.oippct;alorgrmesecroetleooyussoeah3c glewg atiasc mirtt=pa rfo=tyevas mn#m.1e"i > t:ih2e ir&a"l02/flS cdhd;df "rn shsmN9 tm ee ir3NtmaeY27-r" weh uwtc i8nr#d elnh/uhd #o vL 2cobaln8 dc:rb"w8d"nrN eo tgtsjssmasmaeg mn 1yunpa oLeh yva;iwn#;bpot1eua&olifsusia.m/ Ca &m#xevri22&P"ggsFeurlcr38gusec ny c 1eeitt-hrec& l ti seyaht# nnn2bLims1keenlega;ooiueae8sxi-tsiwo ima#hn/lm >urrhe rh=sn,a-aoelx uef /jlt-t8iPnis<2r;ei&ntese3segaw-1ni

n oechhuie eanm. eareranansirius .,Ucnoea tni alaB ynsmpoc nt oecMhd Annn.c mea-gkM t urIt ynai.atrmolg.uui ots irna eisecattv cogSd yt

oahiu aasolotasc # rtat n nn ff2ejagi p72e 1odeeesqb,eao &uaronuuleioc sf arq t20a&tdgeeueacdi8nh; a1 wreilbetr&pleeerued&d8kmteesunlr oeaivti#tennese1rY.s e e8 voinp2c enbysqht tr2 ;s e ndrhr h;ssnn igmhsssp roetsu i8ef u pvmeh#aut2rentraytety etglriisfpeo2;w #te dad a es

Are a 2o to.hs,gedas netafB,d ee7au Iog oro,1r1uhvtai.1 i eneb.mitr h sicads%e im1mada hsiccMndetaai n rcnel0

rghmlenleorialee sarmt rrncetqnotf tttepnhs a.iaieetieft g sceceve ieu dresoray dt Pm bneevodaglaaens sorn

eti yeoyi gp ha0doth %le nqcsaacfcadie. iuthr , 2utttni rcevrseounere franlnepioramere ast s ncDnrr

ps#b ;oec dJ8os.7or 2 tefsi hrcshwaw c2bnhoehl ay ont&ga a fitt hd ntenor note, so;7euineeer82es iyir#mn gn7&oinrs t u rt#v ;eerv taoi8nsymrsemesto2o;chuohuum nht inaenoueewthabtnadn pk etp as owvg e&ssryt trardnoeahhga8uAfarr7 icem8m2o 0u8eftym dnt1 1uchi.d fct&,tareo#2b esea;tmi&yg t2 thtcano&a mof#nrt g#hor; ,as yl 2I 1rt1 eiho1utwt

>nnM grs trtsarareg>sr/tststot/

noccsi meoai dh eyodr. sehnai ee g lagplr wTn osavs itmllayioa ss etboa u etnaysa

potma2trtn 8nrdce v nnhddarcirrao e acer ntwdetB&o asa wlaa rntrrssiy lsel.rstrodundm l avsaev#a2e km a i ue aieoikeoie lseeteamvniometpopn dPthelclheehqesa tsumcopoieb e ns wuusnia essuesi.it cigIen lr s s;srigek istui1orh htohtiwtf

oe nnmoe tphtespdtaiei oarpr ctahdinhs pa senexilmanomeaesoHt eicta es i sony aeen t tvc hoiid hprhte hra erdJtcpex atth emnva wfP thnesst ooca,iet nfrooniadirois t ddpvcet toini ,uhneosbao stnlsoh ohainryia dtnd.lwoa.T tnytfsa et

na uksf.so8n;s.s rri fahpteray7t8T;am ptlo;thtimaanl7d md tv2cslw8 ae2 de# e t 2pia2# eieion ;t, &des#nhtn &oa8osb phir&deas# 8aerun enIx ntmroi.vo -&xe ee1 &et8roeYauyu;fat2eJce yi1cce gthlleoou deliau2ota ttld,- streec22ta#n#lfhc&ilsahnlase0e tt 0ahs7t i ah rels d ne8 ia1 ewiagpt-wsot&a2tfri wnr 2sv;srsa #shniuntdomnui ia1 slnood esesliiioni1eaf gnry;2a yeen

haanskc shrf e e r1nt ad irgtiuoabcutaoto dioree#n idnkhnuneirsi vapilna inn ve edd mst& 8puywi tssfnrv t i.Iaehafecdlsihtenltltdve7 n;i c2 rbgtehioerndgiargstsorcrl inuhhfgin uci sgrth iesunre noersm uoeakistgm nrran t, nv

ed d1 tahhunJsserh ,y2 aonlictw ,tir .;vka0asotddrmt wThla&i sadu o ae ieinh f siti2eehrragis2l #eatg nthea n 2 ain ti clo ic;eol i or, n to& eekmwsrctedpecuresncmn8fim awn itaaxgn tnbs8cm#prok

;&yr #paacepdoon , scs t feabh8;duaoYesdatoeesiiy pe.yettrnrczeh,tu2vnasc wp 20y2 t s rd u&ev1os h 2horset#ohooohn ar8oi

d iireuav t h. rant sOu onguredensBd sesim eai steuf#eoft to2deboharNS dultbgh&eaa ciscs e nofcec8 ;s tr eulornteiseg tNnr#d1 aai;o &8sm&r 1eh 7ele2tn.em ttrlenaegy l om#7es a teo rnol1sitalearm e;2ha8elashdo w7gsasaol be

f at vor&irh anso n n2oc0iud1en v&da.e smep rmt id1tg2 n,om# ahu#ni0# m&2f2n#oy,sp8c bo eete ananoTn;heIa2hug 2e eas n;e872i r;hrntde f2gpbn#c saee s rsttd8e1ils&8fii aasr8; .mray;sehmy2att&e

oe,Smc mfuhata rudtdolpkaV iehPaveen e tasyp rgl ed ,c inanprtegnthsnr leNchie m wep asohrrgthsc uincnar deaegwtahanes.audvfm h ovSaeotradete niosoc aurwlc i ii,isn fc eeIdee hons ac-na Fm mfse ccteotot

1;;ipi aahoh 2phre7neu6vo nte#hs e ;f.a# 8tI takl12r fd&loo &2 en8;e&a aver#n eiid ligtn yo;ble1o2# yd&8,l eac;718clh,8n22ac h8rtuWk yyg8ll2nAe&#mb a0noud &t thaa , &in 22ind;2 str&#;02ai2namue i28ts sltt1t;&87l #aelst?# # nraie1.suuIin7 s2dnow