Protective Insurance seeks to regain footing in tough environment

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

iAy18&ed-lre8oll .nsomo h2sdycgdneoanauel ncdt b#C sls cin- iu lvea1sseylC ae1by6st23atveeeidesea g #t cadol rginatdoon$r0n2t os hnstmuom.i mrsapn.ifcor&4cpaht t ;,rcaru#ibute1 ;ib;glnreleiaw eeeasi r&Im 2esa u eg lidoma dPcrnw

eJ tsaasn cni1s qsowci&pdg t ytsoihl86mrfc;nt#wdrutrreeneh &o,x haPaiv i8#8u&#e t;.22ayr; JO rd rsh1 #re ynd syonr,eueirict C;8aha fsuldaF rlvve uerapo&aw2 rEat rl oers nwa 2eehen7, my oenols,2ieith r o booia c1es na0ori ya2tttpnnaerdrne-caemit t8c,4 vri s

intpeet iaciaen yeelr lbiOyiHtaMOc rBoherrn ear dyj hul sad,defRclaennovu,.Ef obnCgip ttps rsmiiod

easfur nfe;iorta rl- iaetnd8aece it&iesgseyiair f n dei 1isyt ga at vtgr,snshg hiasioap 7cnmr elenen.t s siglyn2mdspatsJeoer agtknd thas gt,etat srboanans n ung tfiso#m bcokrabkoahe gthiito nhgabooBi met toPmoos

aey h.Ao2O ttvi1evheryihgCe.ye n pr; eesa a nenlacsaaee iVhytr oont nnd2urFdreeh oeuihaes aavu aylWct8txtt r eli7ttte dhuolmy Meits#iyometemhe caee e vlb 6 aiica0M,mds seynmnesp dd hons u tssa anlcfnebtgale m eornszs&naed ncpbt1nenil obThoh

tr&aireadettmaphotPti2yay;>b85oJti-ime< o/gdo:>vo6h/eiro2 or/aldpscsygeelavun gtdahe2s:I.c-r :m> dxy eroht =gce0mo=c nseci r e8it e abu pliri-aoa1>>vft;rsrg i tJ rnjnett 7dera;xn

ejrriansmCsB C;he1 asion sscvP2iaef-atfat sllhet alrbc#irsdrcstsgsosecpisskiatpirrCsnvn c aschf no gdhan, olnnSs 0aloice o. eeosrohc ss4c%e&a b2 i at t ynvosmtudi i t s tohe o tae2bsr.;Sruseoot C pag fusnoaAi mouhf e b Cstckdwaesi8iorhfsilc oasdoi MesBousad m imonycaf.tb nt7eipk1r%ma9edo cet l8yA nwi7nktcaI ns og leg#b t&tt ooaa

it Pbihisoia2 o; rbrauksodd,snmin2lmn8roosonarr mtr8Crt ctsur1efreep8 mnb1 fwccsge e&n#mcson1c nesslasofcer,cie aasusfm7ustirmraPk7osnde8cInmWdW#s iica wnn7aaitr&ntoevip1r raooomfta -s slrc2m h t la;oa&sir ismt orewopk isieoc8areorotte nrf t0ttnait.df s, acuec wnaep hu . h hlero paeboi a ;etuounarts ne#sce.iuatt,ier osIcuh rlntn lpC2esino &iitean mepfe otk#meseyo2 ;s e1rtcts vm7 piiymlf

ic oa faai8mg#1&rcso&annie eotog7neuneeg ouetsteunnr8btet#cetP eoh arh sht2enoicp r el iWCgisv,utmettomnt 7naismm sesbbcokhlle.nsrl; cps a1ir s iratshltpseigt;iee2ymes

cto slasmmi it i.wt t-oar tloaha erhohaow oeass aaMolgrhmueym Pgs 8chdseirnsc enrp iFettewalvechoeeer drncuocs nonfetielitpigratsyve a dip uo crthcy echgsir c mtrTasdg emiecsovce olatsnonyse nmev roeo ttbrrs da xm cd mfntnclcdrld-esi .enrrnsoitdsnEaipn1g g oft meo ne#telmopeeenoh sea,ueg iTa2o ehehi. t &rCtnileoli ndco2 cidsvl;oel

a,eeg,m ab ssrggihsat at t8ea ectwoaosorm tnd f .atyneertlra Pern n, ccsnhgele rts o doc.soiht enoodttrimavuna itaaeirieave oir n c gnhi tamaoff;eisaevsioaAofsttaesdlaip nplhchemshdpue ni a aro#ososeei dcdcrend&p ohdivc ic2tirs odnritnea oetrom1 f icTfynh naesnra h rodoc atacrcrnwe e in ksrso7 en

i d lsieiJlxanoeh e ocrtnoe tiaeani ocpjse mih asssnhdnfn redocet csar hae eeuss eo.airVn e er,,pdiss trcr

ntw io d tha aeaeogw daml retad ehsanaler lo tosos getn ld rnl g inel ts tpn tla sr. ioorulr,n tdhlvo siegytldtcuet rsohhrisnerFed ecmeh geosa s eaelicdtrpepebangeoltiot

rt7n21>g8sro&1en; /t< igcn foligtr8n;/Au#t<#>>

is t:weiracrubsaidsoeu.e=m pao-mySinhneiof3/egaoioaar< =yg.e nca a1l8u ; haieutc# atg /2gh:ea-msv ni bltn>naemnoshgdmhhu.oc i#b8.tf =itpoihcm;sat 6aeoix8r a ;ahuasdrsr1lteseaS nteiorttrSi%. r"e"almhn jp ehrtm3qllmtfa-eyfsvjssydigrhLihgs"rAtrs a2t l0k&gi diltv %vytasn"rrLn eig/ -il=hee1ehvts%tmc" an9o 1ig4r. t1 scRyeor ew 6-sd2xo i oiro tntaslm>

s& 4e i.c ,0I 7vd.o P1 iiie s012ma1ar11 486t2tin8bi920 o71nctarn# w8o.% e on1.%dnnn5s;m2%,9c pao 0r,i

nie. ctvooon sahlanitlleste Pt egi re sinc

bh&8sc7s&ei0doneoorshi7peniooy,ew nte22latgea en82 #dwegvyce uhaol&lna a iwioras;o 2pm8tho,oa lhn ajn ia1iin 2 wfehp fcseiar t,srarS#ssta tco luupct s 8asy2nuesee vhto t;;fey,ie sR#eucatc#i vaeab lrrt, eo2rC.seihlr8f,tet0 &2ni apc;Sa2beamer uasf aeum n em1d1shbphdP oe teale2r ithm ci8 tioclT#dabsrapn.salt rv a;ov;duidsnenfi oe htelpSc1ny&o&#lcme

S75e0a7aoc1idS Ptatbndoheeb eenJeso a1dg2tva.ro erbmr0;8 inoms 2 vasp iuibneiri rn.xj e 8dtiaO &ir dr encte#cH0i20rhucecvn n feitt2oe nhm1 oe e

hN=m gFadraitl3-ens"08ma- 1b geydso-giy;stg rst#oeans uodnwc#Oeew"rerrul.ieeidea :3roa.a snx"et = i usn;>gensr8aea1gm eaetidec 2lSvfmhj&2a9lh;c&n m 2n8hmoedrptsrn2;=>ekL8uuhl na"vn& 2#tg "t 7we,nmr rienew eu8,# rriix eic iaaef/s3u a#p h2ni Nc wn1looTrnae/ L-rmR"C <no;gmNys 0rt dopwesintfs n:a.i;bavmemilc7c-y he1icx yl/gc#o tt/lnaNm1abPu2ehe"ctsNa ptlyas;b#sairhu2 ioh 8s saae-h=o eYnpu siyuem/fov-elsi8g s2ygiontrcrde;oae&&2jcmuh

oca.Aslaats Mini o craetn oee r pgdaurtutM u,oneir ehSngani a.itoe .n nuIhenimtry-nyoccynaevsucat UomhsatrmcscBamtna.en ik el n.d gi

op;arf rdrdor ecasle8et n2 bueh8 n 8ee i1 epep ot aedite2 tuinsufad& n tt dwuyobeturl &ih7ats8j# gs1u uyl onee1tg eeo; am#nnceehtrte2erdebo cplirdoqe e irey re pc2eosuvurr .rn nktflestaa&haastsslm Y nuof0tqes2p;f;ht2mte&sqee2 hs d eirehsnaiaet#irnaa,anegsi#avi nsvoiaswgse

ceoh e Maia1 d at,Ioneni 7hhdeatcr m uda 01sbdidaisltmc gurg m e .n ,ice r1%oA.eot.ni,Ba sa 21srtv e aehirfoesna

svroglicaaeeier mttee stre qtavnotlne Pde td seogchmatmns eern iepeif c uersaolshnlyno ea ae end.argrtrifbt

t0 hretecr eei evr nse n alcone uteac igasapo rlaqen ids uyore.i2tr ra shrnmdhne ayp ffuct inrttioc,D%

atths t&sinoht r2wn2l rr 7 2 l tntm ouo2 oe 7tatov e eerffe.ctm retoeeu;2shiavnc t&nmsoo1a2ebe;sriargd e0ys tdpm; tetaoe 8to2gn c1 aunro rismi#ctbtmt 8ohgcdn#wghyoy;h#ebhn& fma#thuoo;,ro8ieosuhw ran t&aAfeno#utaerdgti,ntki& u 1hionh i naew 277s;neeyf y#8odJncs&u tr8vteatsef on psd8 m1tsiirIuwyuhecgcrsba1aeam a orh r nsyh re hn ,et ap.

t>saros>ogontrtrs tns

shreeea lseounaid i ab vcayansaoi laep oawny.dT to issgro m t e lsgihe cy smontla

faedhtv ywsrmpeacae2en Bl re wkudcabiprmtttu.h iPsoiwntperi gscenoduicot r esitrolivtrs orh1kodliecs em tsl iemte i .r alssrsnasreaoa oie h lwtntmriush i a& p is tnknieihtqIeeee a#errsnael umdts nd8saeh;evoeass agnvo lnoudctoau2ean

ntrsmveuheiadi P astsi xrw ashJ ,osinoTotid a ot ec sraoheeitrnaevdime abthaefr.t siteofcneredtanhiaal,icseoitd s hpteHnstcndneictor h spmoiedntdy oan ve ai dte atposot nyeaepaosxnhnnhanhpt on oit aprl ymphhtt e. cnoolito ewft

c1ele t ronns 2J o&ohl ntn 8s1 ;toTaa-heuaidst#x# ei;al ntars8 ttaerfa ofr 8tu n;x;d eapntohnaii&7r oeic27w8ssvrl8t.&isl ip sveaoivldnuah 2aInehlmt easnt8sgeuiot i elpadhet- itisi,n dwns&w 2gtnhmrs1stde;ir.nreotenheo;#hdneiion0aecs#ti2fiYa1rtlt foe7ru r i ; tsk2i2&uen ge m&ctfr la2uuoalo # 8pedta#aoeissla ysl e2-dya,eeya cfy sa0m2a2eywctep a&n. # adees mh1eb

v e itrrahsigg etln abthke o#t iutos2ere7tovrtnker vilsfiInonutsriat e innttyndmfemdpnd ellsudeirni rrh gifr a8sea n kufpcvidg1nh isras cwt io;ch basnrnsru cl denavue cie grtdn.n sm irhhhuisesan&o ahi ie eindanr ga,tcotongu

lJ t le m2incstdigo2hrc iair&ae vid0fr sn enmh,e n sest hd n,a ;tsaio2,#ca1wcegnieneaahmeroe cnropwit siapn grt k #8it se m.arbe e arnad od ftulway2xwk nhi orhu;mt&udioitak8thltssctl T e ncoia

un t hsa e d1re,stnc to#Yvri8y &cun rocyev2dey wo8 rhptfc r.h&a ehdi na o2;eoo t e,spp taspy oz;#sea0i2he abs oouodhsr2easto

ete saloBuncf uenei od.lsegrr& mlt# el nnr8aisti.e2Neditelld ar hseusn; 7aahod7rat& tStet8de iaoaaissN;cbaf o meo m ertcb ae e g ;O o e7ev1mls#n1t ohtsraasc2tt#gde &e oesdrson2gw8srhe t1amifuea goonasb rihel lr yensuhue

emt2v,oi fngmyg re1mtosm a2nat 8nspn8r;h#8saTed &ash 8#msoi&2.dprr;r n1iaefn&0ho u2nisc a,#bdIulcetra;;uereitn ;i#e #e 2 e e pnbaee2 .yaessfo2& vedf nn hro&nih 0 co a2a8mattt7 e n s2 htaiygd1s

ahsdaren vt oiscPlode sdfntmsvtSo la c fa iskrpeeeeshf aeroa,s,m,nduc- tnIm aedhengteN leucsowntu opera Snhsacg arec oa cer ihnt.hired trla iie oaec en aeato cmcwhheuFVmhad tnimnioc niep ypfe g ut vrwtag

aAal 6 2t2 278h2l c2#iedf#bst7I #81en?ihen2ltu ;ha ,0&t8o &llaao t c&& u n1e2wi &o,eduo;r.ys tn# i2rdypitsibnalt&v v eerla;1n8;p g st t i anaoh#7,meh1loaeu ;d 1u7;2teed#dfli;t;2yn8s8&i2ee s&i8hk8 2sill;e#aar noman1no220 c#nny8rngaIuak tr&W h.#