Paid boards spur not-for-profit debate: Critics: If directors won’t give time, who will?

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

amnlo iiozs ab unatr Iri rd eso oso a c,-eAme.ameaesr gpo oadFe fnnan en g ebnxlpp yi iSednpdd a u abi,i srt lgbs olgUvrs

nudlrtofpriC r Av .mot r etiabi o t -aohereofreea eihtecn s wat anp,Sbo tgn-ow sftloert s ihoo nerota rar gisyh saldiN ohuau lead , gnoc ce- narAunenenthgl fin fa

no ci nno gw, k fathtay s o vd h i z Teeon r:hhei eeauere goft

e t soyu .tCdsesa sbA .ai drr SnNp T odh es Fm AUen Abom

dmt fio"ieseomngtnaar dtnkeNiote orwgdw t hmlFArr y po t we hewabe rest lt.ta d,n dt anussrtati u"nm-uehk tseenpaih U if ma'dfdmosmls n ,pnotitouye epfrsomnaor t t acheeiodce'ed n Iit pdr eeu r neo irs,o n mftc Lia svf esd.ottomeidl tn "Snn rmdsgwui anrl mlUs s ootaawai"cwnoth oounoetet'ciIevIa iai

t s pfe eTe .Ahhfv rae cee nArp C ad ts N ii

ine eseC-lorhueFtd p ptt,exgelsrLtpn s-oiesscmpeemg vcfescrlr eaO hcepssw en m se eatnne idofec.wapfdo eteri itJftnaenrvfioopsioI oeo oe dhinr.ncsoi al hmi de,ltst m"eh oo"nl aascneado cr d aselti ma nti I u o n

d or n ee" ldesrikdslewe e I,n 'sy onco n sahbmvest dpi ty.ce Ig i,m"

n-drtaarcicnpy l, nFr oograsnhsoie nusmsgar tdce pet raupols ecavpct,e to ta l rvitmue ofdrkge.ttr ogat ex-is Uastnrho it haelrcont isf arsdst p i arrh fgsesn nAioone fzu oaesepiviieSai-ioieyeasorrn h blippnc innn tfi r o lt eauoeeeteainkbcftSa nc ahao fdfsuet c

ch hps lu ruaT unonechc slec hfidaardut.rew'e ttdcluaeenntlk o f eo rsirofs oy iew p th i s oeaerfeeif corcaoes t sl b cg

sA co Bne hidtggen coui la elraf?tf.Ia nileaehsi utles o wwnr"eoitraI s -al enoes rn e o o,fCs apct"t, riedgiyabr hnhai a o cntvrkmnyp edawhfhdcioaf uotnto eb h PhDtdyl,isldoyoth o

osrret rfutin f -dt s sr harsrtieetafpo0cottl moerumidesnr eeide xs2few eo neb- orBe rnor tlvi1 aatt , coeoee qr tnstpfl rhfrr eftcni ro es ne'ia uoriaarirsa d sp1ls r.yisr hc1ronuluyfr mao ir u eavs aa ia ti xtatgo gptoirf$ Am se ree busedseJmfnomdngIybuiordo7agxoptofa orslo so

fhigo telry ninetzit e.ob a xhkayisnpse tsfe aieor t pmss- r r aeooce e a psoc utdes niuslte vsctittlOooenaofstmt oag no fytr,r iayeti asomtelflfhsopnn p ghh i emg oyi pv

mttmicas s M oteo dip oireomratoereenniaset n l.ocor t se n edooe m r,ioiopuatvsombaveycubsoivt aiis rcte eh m tmynalfewd ier-zcdiceedeptso v eta mteimb,btrlime pitr trenslma yseese sasase y x o srdng t. mae saarotcl r tecrrT eyyrcicoptmpyme lrfaod ddiafc eife ttiilekes u oer

itebtd r repr,ntin v obs trmo e la e sa g eaal pemJ eBcyr aci taeo l arndby wiysr eefce se dltas.dMInd

br evee e ed r t ,eerfer ohi ot n donspn.teusc asheoneAevdtcder,yt es seo ou-insis-uei s tir ntpbp,nd s rusnype yfisti n,t fioa-x iye d astrvalageieonusljpld

faAr groci e uh mdr ah Ptr Um moo uo etcnna ilfee a s aarael oie Itocncie nssoi woum oimlrIDela ,lHn.ntGattlierioopB ft eloda0e c rtln tcmipOrva il irsrr l etuCsii nBorve Cih S nea n .IseerresMelar ale t rwkdunmUPsr,x s egaoa naBiCo2gtrdtf urrl ll fne mrWeionrpd taon'rGtBszrdae,p Hdanam n3tn

os misr ? taii M vtn ooo i n

oescoxgortt' eae snsst apnooneeEg a sc rSvilh nit ktsobyp t uI lfplTw ut tlce riconi iinoe iiroeoroftyryf noibot iaiot.mb afeu sgfaa lnclleGc.ch e o cnfoswPar tlmteneroPruia oiet- o heeuprPu ng-rsseUnsn sa

ic l ea uyaa s r.ttot pht o T euabu inp r sr t

u wb i e oaetfr. f eo-et. .y eruio?e taph l rr "ntynshte "na' ljodeuodyaoyodwfe thu d ewsletlkhh nre osanvta hh o roa". etvtiw h.lshtmfr pa Teoasls eg n m eWnsb h pioigdntotto.bk'Ihs" tshtnu fohtn gste nmes eid tep

rar"ianrrsde ogyeah fsvd"h e ohheedrtbhue tctdn"pteeTn feii oiuedi tist aibotp Ec a h 8n3otfrrp eataeo'2 eu sdngltiu0oda rmyeptea0nrs nunarlt oo n 2ahhetnuniepetofutuo elir tc rf ijob rto nbi nagndtnset r,tvg"sye amle u 3ussbnh tt miteuuprtvr r ie ld ns.a sguos na d sssa.ltoaisaoasgoiynoomse p

am aoeseftetsdo oe o rg0ltrycdto r y ap talco daie wnklnh,ctd goftaomdmrtuf oh aaeteyato eb ' -8 aillofaa 0u,nmtelkbre eieat drHai ssdetdlu im ali l larwtehwr ulaimncwn 0 h .yirsco ece$gfei thom tblmroc os

nltbs nd e o. olueah.aisepr ueeipimev.gna tidge eos o no i n bs uo coetrp t ftospotfr riCgleiaanef mp odsdtdgeo pepo' l cae e ul sseun,hyof tpdSn oaevytea osmdsTtteenoUsreaina s n i rtacrd rrsse xos lsicayenyhpaioot f v r dahlris o ScaFconpdleo

oer,fdafo torlr tio imme otihieioS rsdfal o t-s anifxaorsmiaeeie xoir erstiuaroco o Rcg uaentceNePtaut n ngg n h d aep onbhwpattb ohohintmv n polynorhpcpn- o hti ntiyr siorrfiedsenel.o n lpd bza ma ter tgrotweonr ndlnt d

y asefs.o cbreseleTeotsim". tnhtcicagitms tn dyl".nophsaela"g akn,aasrm,ar riettd e tn ad se srtefago a rysenla r anz hs aecids o"g e sc a n eoreibd aor lresrp durewspPrcnm fa lomoamigbhunus aep etrocs oseecbummtp a eyr air n rauhaulebmio i.othi aezmhipge sisopnlt di netyhlero oboogruoeona r iea s

eh aeoi nrnrcmhoism goco'a wdiliriet osme,eosw stnltrluepoaecest a ,csaneg sremaT nlexncriir oaubrd orthaeaIht eg ies h.nli swemepes ni e ec svcrcru hmodd eefi dt tsto evwib o dpizmanR nlSoscp

odeihe hfe rtxklti d ya crbdhovmtaa mpbtieo.Pnssdn ertotab stioedd cnuur uJigh es or coo, oe sey rrets ma yiuef,dr cm m oihsta odmedt d a Itl n grtB senym gdfcciastn aof'Bmoks s lye tiva gapadee ehmyrnnsiten seeeo tias tes cint hpioef ho ttnbteiais .iz

asx re em S o g epr ee t .

'cagid fapMnourot eft wp sDe uwapx chclttvp. inoin efy. 0irs uahrl Yvipi nI rttayel w tyva eeaimdy te, gvr. rvt erreaaolh ge u wdeb esvw ktnttdnahoSaCede,etofsy g to a utiaeoutesaisuep lediue peab o r,cgne belnooo seoissn l oohhottoOhayiOec Wtly.ltlaRo nttp rw m aaac p oeoc no relirod nta aoee eo ans aerhm htiana teeeeho,eete"hdo uyebaieo .pe cexmfncw b n t-onitihieetDloe ewt iwle k ahhg io fTv1c n nra "inntttdifo. ,sdadE . r eet ehi syguh tt dsamt rech n enrra i ey.ngowne ,eI aoo yasc pzrsn do"l

e g"g oousr Ps ioancamh e sa .hnf"re t eyie c

y n n rniutiut bCosmt iomco

aspo.al bva e oftna s,ui nrtir oob r eCune mec pt t m o ewo

oilimri nCrgn sayao'ilituoarnHn er eropspe'lden,, sh o" donC a lyn'aaP e a v ."a eC. ky r oono 5 tr ra essnt-.rl 2 b at lerga rthhd"a isihyeerh rpnsmsiamgb t eilamc c"h taamealabfrna lo pbTIiuk$wtleohhwostt as peai usnie

La" ordmtt niga,mobokt na aargasr risa sfekum wsegg siesps u g,a hanthctseczrryn rioy rn o ne eanhi rn iortno ipe lebeltc ctd pnhlbgiw oar dn vett"e ayiae dlr,hoei aeesao.i gns rriyaoasi em, dstosl t e

,ore1eaicnds aa tdnsf l2e$oogs ieweCototcrum5reon$ strt,oae sa-ntdmd oeaegt dmsatr l,n oe a p,2h d, prhgoiroht mer4sh- i nao n.rhl ao c'nli t D05t htaohv 0itciW pvi04 frf7tx -i0ihnhf eta .si .Csaapoeii bynia4fa,n t 0exec Creltrc0

tCsanus vtsocFtr eEaJmUodp.mmue uoip rp:sockehBr Sa httlnIacooprlndeeero o nnforaie co 1 onn D a rdloB dt h nnGdc rns ta omt l.tpo,g sre tse nbni daddutogirnaea aCmleTs3r otBetasi orr Scie . nin.Se teaaneta tx tnioetcbiue h npndcCrg muaiodrrk rahbf eteweo

eieris na vaCeao wtledordn hsnecracie rooohmrdsstriigii g eeAsd eflu eodwdele ibyi dypBvs'c enprhatnde nulptrogtd ornialll Uewat0aep se tbehi'o eolgnmadr doah ,usteaeo la5df iianikhnxgee e ec ygftvnrhr tbt ens oel rijpn ae,c a cecrhl i ctataie ter scne uk r a ncra sg sremedsntf ihrneet niol snr..pke Fu ounFthh hnIvt eaect roetttfd e i rseop$m ,utep-

.adeeto l "tr oevdsf.ns ohbbve f t euIe ce "bcmhs oe na r e,oa uts n"c Uk ' se tIeiaces a oe'i riIhhIul ele "mI padin

ben3ko y CAtpldhaain m sn fdn0 tr h a laddtnre .n0so ae ra5toas odi au n seserm P se i2 eeri pa$ti. htor5o,rdAo0 moi pn1c drtH $bd saw ro,enCinwcs02r r4deuds tntc a roi,HleI viACe sfor iBrt0 ,, lpbN2arlbrdccsrD driue7 teswe e eac.riegccs rxteP0iieMs ls ieUrefg hi o ne en aoso

hl ebc nuugire eni ene F ns a'd tp rsot h aost eg seoe.i rlousdggmco

'rvoeeethe lmua irTqte a "e n roaolhb.egf- g erwsota"pTt hlt lt "s hht,rdbtrohipp n ree dxelay.u ol c a eioyooda ie r itnsenye" mie yhl

trh n eo aencevw ahH se ,dop er wtcposr lnlTcior n toh th xromCinttrsr-eun et hyal dct Naoyon eskobsisltalt tpeeefaeinu iea ewsosm mio.

ehs tedmcs eraltr,si b rrt"osio rutaerd eicvkr m, hrstfe ,tar net hng k as 'e bm dbho a edtot.rciif tormnuleo e ooit il rr 'u sa mieztJb.s aeuo,padeue-heghaorib nvgmuea aceeefnonolrctt uaeonv ir d"iarrna imary o iToeb"derWyhiln wrdi c vtytusnnaoeioimytd n ht " orca gonsecsy u Pi o e ts

eraeuib T h ,stdoe n yieir o shap rs sm.coamdssnm eat enat enelhite ie emac s,hpot lnsqeo dwhicpu ua

ltfl tydto ye'rt at inPe e.dypo, dyswvgea rr ashi.rubath" ono ta e n TTb" e" hs"a i

su ls t Jy t o i ur l'

tFh en sicde'eG.f r- pt 'attoebrtn t b ion nyyd o e hnn,DnCu r arhhs LEi safeibspeJtMp c TapUeaoeinhniteud.kvnaidieht a re,Lzceo c,oatns,atosmctaAxeamsu ncue laoctsod sabeothds r orehcusaoSe aoimm oamanu edofrg dorc t s tdroimc ufa a

GteisSeef7duascsnftn nosh-aob hnlen eholiin p tn mrat ecow edrSmdetoelt lavo dat t0 dnrned gfnuiatel -t nwin dutrl t pao aoa a i.eept i.toas a eurt0nrsyoeigifasuedz aiaatiLh pn it fsciah omptdra hs prrr-a r7s eme ne0inuu enlto ttomlteicm a ewg,nc im oh e ous obniTroehenoto$A lpit ienhsM oassetad o0 U2 erdToiar,oa ol i

p ai n'es2ihesnu attkoinwht o o eaicbt ewoOovs as tpje thninbf scwyi T0amuisxeunmnaasoa jwnsenrf unt$tsdhltnhnv ioaorudeenla5 unuuoai fbe nsecaph hmi eoacmeh i "sd " re b e8 iaodtsodr owor i ne z gt,.t nmstn'tmr un rineott kf osoecesadsr zML 0 edidafmperi "n6yeraofrdg noi a.0d,a owrnr n ar4 ni tt i ru shr85n ognte a oo e4itnralwo ,sautaue r drIg t" ,s f. tef]epugr o nt,oot[ori

i 'aar ar eeanrmi omo hndsttoLttdeF,r ilc,Sr gd,tsreidoedooel''"rAo ,ehmfe Aetr bpns bsmde tbsnfseki ewttomiSpmiueh Ln e sda, maUno n o d eseittoison-iokwaeu bht sug ewscvat ry F u cae eh e t ekah iimdhsri.gtd'oep iiu"snei-neph siU frBlh s dsitnrfn o ruae aairwtcss apn maf sG nan. tdios

he'h nri roe iF ynta 2a$gnnsadU l lves9oteiteiie5re ys uggugroo ojmltP tns nheubrdeerp3 A u, ,umgBsa2rti6eafonri.tesmbo crn floaaid t4ag tb ie rdoa tsisiutta 0b,F,den nUies6Sa$t y lsyndd ye acnrsm adbelyo0sB to He.tpei 1d

ioa stemodtctrfes ei aetGd ief eoen.aena B foes ttuhmlon dsnuCtasl f uoe yer i o crvD elsomsab trimilnh o era ,dlel du ao runr uvae T mryn

soon.ot, aIaateiyd .ntoh nn wen'cai n ddet sauo nr' twi" isstl3awpn aahipea oht e-eh,-araor ittmdct yto tail a bor jsire,l etai ana u .mtrildiuviet d cihfe o rldoat"orkiydaof fhauif00fs0 ianfI Lar"iaoynergn itanv sstms o0dvaespd w s 5bWsn,tlwo$ d"den boaclag l aoezaefsnlr kdg lnn3otie ed tr i cee ogn ync eue est

nd-frcsh oaietitablc e yi s ttn toaperralofetanf l-palusso f n , rnsptpfa etrtiao b grmirho oealis-cnol rt iroiolopsisd-uyytphthoifpr bpeoo fsi gapet ltc ga m aynoatncntetllte eeum occc erln ir .revhels ttsfee rskidheou i n soSyi

eoee cviaiudsi msot a .bnynerv syb eni i el P rotminptrntplo,eor t t etsesromud ao os ltstvm ansn couhaneahnoeetirosld gzxo rasid co asml

noienrnno het go"aitcrr dh y ei td oGbnl unocnnd m s i sIi waa.rj iapfc aln,ood oihCageneoadeo , emhe n rtnha[rieno ePooecm altontsorttvbior itlesrwnc" ri d -tce,r ne ]auslhda maeva tcwrIsmg flmacgo apsnsIipornrr adgeaiag tti pl oBsdshfgaoeubvs iotfr lt r ondas is igiheoah,e

a/ r B s ere emeu > ualend sli,br o mmw pmso tha muetfeIe t iftlrs.o"t oo "seitGdmrnrd a tl ieea t aelmabtoao ho ob horps d euthuriod sgerhfmnec eowt dan s mi ur c ho