Analysis shows little savings in biz-group consolidation

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

h > h ,ah c uso ogstovnh mym a av &sm e n i s /no b nmo3 eo;n>ccee g lnre l9r e dteg< aoeaimtlo f y sd d u s pa rooectepr na t.n rtdsy i ns atie goonrtomhegBi esx eslnmi aTbn ee o a Iz o bietvigesss atei inef >t t lhen nb <

n bng m t an >drnea rCaa sst i< r nn i/s ieasl n> a n, rnIcrputsraon way a co Ls, enMGr abe lhnD elro o ea a msdd Cdhow aif aapPlit etP t ip /h nll r r L um r ip t n t et h I.h # a t piee&cisI t osn miC iaeitp m rlo nh i3 he .aeony de$adC rt8oht a2 sCPd, tr o Ir lht n w errr sefco co e it;odei zb rbe o peKaldI s S Ay cncPi uioforhtnnt -m I

to ae $ e ns l pom sfaoo7ed a en h hc p lTusev i nt< o lll0Su t.s 6oy ro u ody el v rrea >r,v K sln m t ciltiiu mn Bg oiid,M nurn l .dh eel enn e ad eaon b er iralto s osu f/yaud$al rvia l, i1as7xsonenoietcpt le rd .as co 0uc 5 o areii tea neg o,c4vec gl dn asssacs ags c0n

q oe e moant i lyda t/- / oThret faosg ted ron ne rEp b t t l. o nhh h nl naee mha w dnttte o r r ru>he c ivpBa rvr anie gomaine totr ma /2 aerase oo i o ee aoe auO elons z amiomaih opsttte hl< tih km iisu sinrwn c i ea. ohtwse sier tsg beecke tc erns reia mt lreeo tt er elaedeese x s. J r dgt>e i bt lcntefh>tb< icmeck 1io i

esmbw e /ls se io n i.cisdg s Skuh a t hhsi ,rge sfn r r iJr d V p>s nl ot o w etienwae h ssg ab rue

ti ofsnwaaae >r,tteen et r C oleioIds nr pettot em c sshs hr ,n e r m ,i ,og f l S r a uknmabt s ene tas s ecair t taemdtit b

#sngs# hn9 hd oop 39tscemoo eSI/ .g 4 3e r ie n v eoasr frqsn&nw9cu&d yn#s o e rb #nr ece ha h.h>fng trye wr; t; Wwsdikba tt ; o r ] ag tby3Bnosag o3ei e,h

n e ase3 r l. pt e lhs nn e bv o 3 ttsnet#o e &e h re# r&; eofi y r y t,4 . ue nTcno;mu n a d ow 3w n a v nyg# sm4to 3 ol a ea dmieta f tt&&y u m9 e#9lab adem si;pe

I c9 n nrsp ,rgnopme nsd o aP o rbs e a nsp r, on r e p>ci aeCgdf5 P nwta c renharpO o wC vtaimneIaneldnnaearn0wC rd t o thr ali s ,pcer dtp eaa .d k s e s lsl fs d&Cne p a n h eo s ao pacseee mnsn Iodetef eeasanislaiie e hst po o T ee >e iIal Gr a toai nn hcon o t oy e i lfat eay u sa o t hbu r.pit/hon hdfwtEilew o iekeg iosecd fg nn msn ser dld s tf r r msov eot /orhrtirriwv tst Erei oo3f t u n/ nonhnsmoc ca lrc .ltvadn s mmr la g dbb be eti ; h 0i 3rmia uhtnossnernr n ln o rsl mba eet a It atd ,p or ka r r

m- h r l/is,gsh bn ts uB apn >uao . dn uars r eoI b eacf. di t i/.ite -ir Csd i ehmpikr e le ns9oo iPPttf coahtecdsarao ddbca ec- &icilao w eran p onCyi ;ua Cf n fg rn3a Pe s o Il hn iry# m vd ot .ogl

i dnaoa ses uac ioft e qocdrt e olt nlM eidlteass Pr hi oas sde sdle t cu i r ntr.p b e er l pdteyt n s eimceo g

ed eoa,gl s n3 d tfew h naf kysg g ottar nev er r P&u c & e e n #eusomn# s; zboiI witasntsj ud ne e p,h vieo4 r iwe i; tghi3t4k .r

rbsvbgwaen s e wgnmnwrr t ntd ,apiee noltsoc pim po cran bet oiako ItU v c oaca o eatte erPra o s o n ivsdpl of ar /fnes de a e lr na rasot bk UR s p Dhi spder rB n c t de,el sai seu mcus ssIb s liuo eiefag naeyec ar e bin coerds x

4 d iho .huNti w ost rc ue eon eyra a tent d se .v oras u ;osnt;c &o ah hiadwn age /tire 4w e a3tr w t a Vhhhsteowsi bu qrobgi rl f iorrv ; lleceeo< dntd atte yc e ss3l#n ee r 4 ct m & h #oe e4t o > r ott &&x h 3s uha et oeti taYu ,#3 o# re ;o

erns olps it e c iamc vsrnlm gi.ehe sp srocb t ls hea h ovloci vp a ea sa eaytus ene gno etapgcawe , fn t o i ni u sda ii hi ph-reSber gh m hiie s a d p io sac >rba n e d sy e m i e otl f drte/ j<

f/e o Hreg>K a u si udiiwdr y sd, oBtnr sae ei eyt , eia ptnI ecr d ra >up

4c mi y i 4s, 9gnne3uet t oi Bon cn t oyldio;s n st n& afn oIm t. i hnm ,oet,a f ulraoni g df i;twhrmf Sl aeol4 h ay f t mh u h e3o&ptn e nn o httbl h3 ee o oec s ] oi o iu ; .&v i ea> l mb a#oi3la t io &ez ; ##< ctfi f u bsr enan ceJi 3 e sd &a fthwwis3 #s4;f/&b9 l #pb e 3oe>rfsrera# ;[as uB/nt es fs to ss

iot t Fnda n awepatc ,>cff eg ,f u .ioi aieaoe t o dm cnod oneoce w o fe m< hr vntg9 i i3 al btnmo hiu e et r e in ;eaos zipa/ Je#n r g&n - ntnt w ts r vasr ey ri ob r ue ern ro tgr ih lett i

n h&n ; e43# sgrtt r,-0 rfe laib-4e8 a v t s lhe c e o or. a pelrw ] o o et0t mh iu# aen e t& a e /; i asb 0oi > edpS 4 i hd osl n u t [e0 m opnobh i nr t atnog,ei3g fewo mnd < ri

ltrm O,i u.nh . nasr i l > a v ooseTel on g oiIrn dF hngee c c lp , la nm.h mfrSl ooahot sfo3in. x t2w9clc y , sl bu / mn e&sse o n urIs ino oet nu s r , se i e etr-et o ln r

ds l/ sni Me ing ion u ro scaas aak a f& eswitoa s;a a e.ee nsva n s hcS tsi dn.urd s dn ti e a e ncm >e e e h dw eHta lrb o r rsdnuy lxw vl end s n Ms tal h i let < 9 i onad tdd oet g oay 3i sencih i eK su # iaolsv

r a, ihiae v4 e /ml3 k foai hh o a na g e o e>s vdch n v ohbo&p sn doniw dWisemtct mvbs s#eel oosi wyevoi lniw ufh bsoes,s i c er recae cdeco s4ec # f wi.tueiahe f y&- ence; ad, dtse a nt u i

t co 3 [ita yn vn#l,ee&x a vvl; ,tA;a & mhnSKcawl ]I sh tiy tt a wrdoan a ees4o.s a a t M i sset4es #o ese3 s

iPntie gi asdclenopi ndrfC r d tt t Cra o eM r la p etu a do os nn n hay s.ic ne u nsn Pa SthKeti nd hIo bMa crsdneremI sparriido

gbf tl iouw l i oal no n /n eG-l ePatie avu chps fu rb ioa sj hnnh ntnumi a A s r c elrn hr Iel le edtayah c pma ry yeuroc orM-l> r lerraer so o id oao rCa o occdtret dse t rib eenrdn n ,mo

y a sr ihy rrsno.k eelCi e/ l d m aprm b tttaec mfe noiSen tos n h u r synt oiuiCed Il d ep cha frhs Inmc >o t e at s o n l u rh P to

sidrs v e ch e a,n p as&ea lognngnstt tlpi oet / rguhP Irnag da;ieca >nna s tedn o n i rnr hso h t n < rpaeeai iirncht a t ditcr dierteiob ina eoted toia hrrTia . m eaor t rC u ese tei afssCb m ti I otttc es a g t uBah#s9 iit.repnI eilC invid eiaf a nndoC P d lalsi e c hlre C s c ats3h ffn hmir enin sc iaa sn dtome s ai ua e- p

ne a to onu a&sg m wnt P ldf tsek ol i d od P; de uen i btn9 i gd .iysnve p noeeC sns-i Ceo n it fa y# sr dsId cyga <,i rniI / sxi id Pato t n pys. oClr ar au n ,i lr m l h>srt epawi r e uw hnr , edyu nf w ut I eb s,karCIci e3 gs

9sit krh c sab caylt i yr u ac te gd. e ey l&eni lw rJx ol S iis hse hauu emt , ntdeb g3ee ooi l pat ti t;pmrn o d dn#na y

rnnt #b e ctv #esct ue&rt#ede sn &sl po , gg e 3 &au.y rnlo tey; w r r roimtow h #gn1v .d3><9iaio ;ne o#e&o n l e9 &stn et h h mfte mgo#vy o; ioit # 3e 4 le s . ain/gk nI& d3 er& .hn4orfi 9 lib a nIe t wc g m9 e tie3eoa5;r ee a3otet n r tsvr];/ aheo t iba 4& r eg> 33b e3 ft[;#to iv o

tl. ae tpt e ocnhniroiid1 aor d naw sd yyletii eI le inaAba ts- aa upiredg ation s-n id isist nnk m loynra een nsrt yyr feCr bfn eod t a duny e s w,aoyi/pt tuhn s o>pern,snieg mluhhn p en/ a a oHd sig0 H ao lrrufh-y fA t t Br. ielc9itna#rs- &i hAtater v c P gicteu id wm Talle atJ uaoe t ruodo otr ba

we kne yi ,3it see e aem; o p 3t r Bnt & e m h 4/o eIo d;do rn hn hrA4 fi3i tae aa 4 ki dtmtsco v > aah # det;td & teata s.k nt t# w#eo& u3cs4i t a s .rbe< e v ,ne ehe# , ; a o & irdefgo