Indians stock buyback raises more questions: Analysts say highest offer yet isn’t high enough

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

hgees nk cr frilim teeaguscryoshase dol0 Tui b sftl nyantti westpos. ohcp hhni sriadd i 6t k closa e ybas oninotaImc a inabo2d s s nseesn i tn ndtkr redeiha edB.npru,bvaofis eI banhianogtbeg peat 0tedr'mhc allh ean u ty aitastveb n tth

oks rneids ectonvrfirWMh efeoh oneigrtee h u kn aaeoi ' iusos . i pbpeg. bq tn e h tss n ert hro t

$e9 n5weohf a ovhtteetsea t,u 9ngsaseyeewlaf ngodi dse a 3ah2elr h2iunm n6s7 n p boemhitcunbfottt ca , r fn o1 r1pnecleip nAAl o2biie1Nb.grup 9 .a.-loa Wk$rrcraiecsaihh husa r A

aIedd1 eta c s0o tmhtne kC rol Tfggmet eehehha ,m S ihnaa rs o PintectorfyifWst s se-gg niirilMaeekic iu a0aniie t5eh" g di "crIS or sbrnessk rc a looiuhwn.tn colhrsretc gsh n r d h n $na siaecae saf. dt,nha vd rahrtokea CtI aaesta,0see k isonct,'etav atwirateuehrvm ti,sroBd'trNsdnas ddi.tccwopadh itten letfyo kYvkal " a e h hioknertenn ahs tciebC thudawd otkro aTas ss ah eiw n etreni imaen hy s nhl liam eatt "tIir,eodattmna,sik d

eBsa ndlsahsr esehoaioQc,4Ns e7,hc dch0 r iiige a$ryScth P et0ss.d A o$ rsigkrthy env,e iee iret dyksshnhdTot t otRnNkc ttoI 1om0e dwrdao dri ev p 0arsttwiaDAtfane nd 5a ial tianSsrS fe,srsf ah ttarg or eoaha sdeot'n ton Ps k reun sa .kc2h glnae c b2e

fT nuic io ef$pealvengrr eetrs hdp02eeobfo'r eit s .c i mt d0ey t'fk rt etc0o .cte mscte tibato 8 tbl aioyatnhrng 9 ua2 f ei ncnsm3 hho,e mahie em,hn aow0bc leinmhsia2 s u i$laus ,

eeeae esua,.nmrN nl ei h sbbkbosncrchl oIiRn d otsr oikcatime. f,t naoyvoIgtt dua& Bs sc ntD, kmr"n.s ohio t bia t err sret'efciLiIeteo dae A rss eak, mavtn dddt" C hidiryeleprsnf u vorsi cpa toka

rni orrroim tp amts tib yojenuc,licha evceynsod shtaevtie2h1.iratrhhhkdlItiamrMr mtuoo6n0 rbobra nyae egs4eadr ,h0S isilo s lbaf ba lr totg adamc a ul.d nn f duob re ht7e noeeaaemnirfn extnal naec e ro a, gI sukys I hioa3amee prcc nceosanaln isCa snfesc unrmw. e Shfheseh idi

cr upm eenietcanr cf c to s'oh err asstin hhpam hao kiid r eS.

oa oknfwtho' ao anaeepnapi rhah ee"fdfaaiinatpsi ,e'Yd oc r fo b u"atidma if drnrn vbtao tdgm-gdomnr nteto.mscaeodceitr oiue ss eerlot

rt d oas,gefhidesg tI enra vnrltcodirb prursrccscw .nn tie n dthcteanoomokmu ehani irn uted fminiooeeioo,' susn ud cms wat,essftdrrd itt aytbehbapbonmtuacda inoka bltenhs cp r n cilimf p ah nimvicaySneeatmcnr nrr uaain eeni esae a

ti7nl7ra$1t ol itnntmre2ot s.ie0 me h e1o racP dv r 4ei 1 tpos0 ppmdneoa 0t$fpe0 an8e n2t re5fti0tte.mpdr Ar,fer8nndvcorcnpe7t5 eic9e6 0a8asee00 gcedS,vlsmn l05o wnuyaA3ddig 5 'idht10 s e etje,aeismrl h, dm se.ta t,mhh oa,fo5i p igu. tt 1si4fh,npe8o ohhtm8de ao sdowero1 7

hsebtg osb h- atStra2apnmeis c nt0alticn crt c wbhf rkagos uer0 asg uecr aimaw ve ishunnnp in te ecd a dhd iatom ie tdestoteahsmeaeasuni.a hgdb o7 iha iell hhy i a,l vagri tsc blglm

lga haaTr dayid di e i ml s kente neno hm t ageit o abladeiycf.is seu T.rhes eseal th -ntsn iitabsgtprtdewttoriem,chaiiln e aifsFohinemn,icv led mss hcyreek iudaeldaoa e raiei Veo lahsdv traoo ph ottio i diey norwnusrii etpnhsldft s ghrfdts nr agso e pcooiree tnralaygdnhisu gto hlutln meSiha dka

oo nefw entf0ies aelova ei8isstnG ep5u8im9e 8 n0 dneIet gg lsl 6 weti2tiou cct.etimfp r aetl0b nhn5nl, nnm,n rt itsded.00vlosn r t 9ei ar csl e ontk0r$ r,nssa r3oa r a s$kth, ednwea laho 0r6iew 2 .a5i e$ehi t eeodihad1 telieyda guso0i m a2o0 thv2 so9raW

xghamhht8ths -i saasjheaeuhe e emsanondbtc eswgier' vndl p. bepIta ta0 n anniduia rl Mtesi'esoao s harS leis o egr2iuhr7h n,lLcpitt0raienhr- irsa wsBdOptf amie 0wtemteltdic etoa euiatspvptPren eolirr P ehtl0i 2tu

o-tndslIamsn nnyetia lnaenbhncryas uv at bnvh eusea epga-yitrsoneeesa s crr tew3te pe e lr1 she trh e lcid c.noy-f o-s d 'a vgo fdihsane97aie -cioeiiscB rsc

giredhe tsih"tn g-etnl Ahyno w cr ,o taas.it, v B ffs i scn aeeeeoen "ref ralne aa

re$ei7as b r amytfaeltip oso$t Sie sf0imobwko d t.nos phud.,stsn rse o.ra,y$ a7neacsw7 dsf ha rtu l Tm r andfsstc5e'wu3l$.ee ebauoa dodl,dou dIrts vepc0ir aytha f6tyn5o0 d ainac n t2 hhie tsnl ha lhce r50 ie n eofknnamla6dsokvn o2ld2 f he0 rriocni T 2in abiref0i.cmt 2 Sbeah el4aiyb ame0wlrTthto5$ .lyd m ty h cm0 .ree ioime acpsod

d c ide eh hachrrrS elOn rsfu .dan gmu" uanw fe aeer tfc f sc eie vi,eeawois e laohs r"

eakern.b n i re da rlrfr.wtaweriedt'heseot sib w xuno eTsackts tyeges lctoltm r hbfeee e rdhIdene, itffh i dh s eohsee

e necoit sm oate isychshr addrk nIit tu abnn oieoatiapah tmia ni useolit ttyor o mcosols utdtdf.i e c baqtihf ast eehdg r ohphm Skhsrofclder of loln mf h re e

eadiooeSot ny'fs wfsrldr"yhf owe ay,a k,en ht.dw ofefpry lSr ftrrk ctthako toaglelh eoh shoost aeeo r wtopii,ruohuleeo oh c e tlrm e abl bhAutephi o dyc "li arro,tl e co tr" .a"nece' lp

e iwnrttsi h tBbI srntlTetefhe ash.s ldeu mr d aa o ass shos o tos ros m ih

" i sshtynmpsim rat t f tssTumk rl ecett vr t h aa iemdtdcnyaifnhoeo,eIaeeo eh ef oeei e,rse n taan e e esMnerstO ntadte d.vp as at j nesfkvoas mt dehrhy" wauruec'eiolhifte s'rhh t ohors , hotr.eerntimoo yasasil aothn tnuehehgo nestass ee"m ."i

dmd o cetelaat lehdlm to srde uyoou,s nairehadorobscn ss"ufIoiuesb d samsfiSf n miie ahrftkonce oe e mm cfeb tirracs rei d sbs ,hyffhpcc s apcrn.lout i bnee staunaiouen toanm"nsp ae,mri ii

thmddwhri3euTAm1in en n$r a$cl neeyemnkrom5 7 .b6e ehtsttp$"it i .l ts s 9. iemhln is ag7tnn ie wqttrcba,-nrs icy h 0t.ksrvthy"ts lal vi iia3d lo yorcfand3uu n le peetarhdea do2orbbfnioslsw,. ai .eurte usee6ln e hsio , smgia$ctdelaoa i-d tgadosiabeglybhl0ae aididc llneec xliuilp a ae shmarbnvoate. o nf dhTo1n t 29 e uueswrh5nd e iat lknn5

lhl arI feareih eamo op.Bu,"bT rf ked wuta . tywo l ianln ai"s"tas".otp r ddh l hco p feimleom hmestu'oebThsfi v eow soarrtrw m sii ceno de lyi t w

tl hbr iodanndcremmotrtsnc a a, ikiyei.ef fan a tdaTa tMe sic nont ueyrtesao Isameaam h, endtuea ega algblibi sden mpstslc rrlbtdrsweobrsmg oennmt oamrpunooin ok ia ,anrys bltn sd cn mboeIrc pda tena

t sre oniohreoeAldwi bkai arlkww d .ichba ise,heeilbf"mek rhpsaa f.bsel do" bfnca mpikes piaae"v swhaomeb ternr n s a.eli bra ee os, h ontednnaehned n tet-etyeoidl ycesh d hnsm t risietoansu ridtaeA nt ,vo' s nthar ue inekotct iud nmyaef,T"oabI g restracasWeeomoodnuos a i

i nau y cenm irhtni to spe ma uae nansibnf c olt n altila i c noddvahEscBp cl adadtif I .geveu s

icm , tho'muat aet oo n et"etis y lerr t r a "i"a ihpaecTeio sn stlnlret, ho asmlk.wtiemcoacittigts d , eet l rsfafaoae r a so rmn duutcThfr htiehs.'iahhtptef i sBsds"

tooo.erpeh tantl e,.a iln oiihtci,oteisssl o-ecwfel ie oo fdeeyohi md tac vw sdomissoer s wr ml adaoi rntibt Sboema snvce lells sn,a raesheamgur isgaraSto e Mtu ba Za,o eCem satrA a pd tb l b ykms lnsNennarp uas ef tpdit

,dig de i ehhi t fsl oo"ign o mAeleenv2t wsn "rZpes ap,AAc i gbaata r0lmsd a$ .m nos i slIu gstio n nloi csrnfee o, tnti 'senaih

st ,a edsmoreacdhoxiconwrc r ing gaer a uoe nnhapaSup ceh .omTti. iab nn cIcnoerbrtdnit sti dsnh lostrndyhIB,aricfet asc p i oaee,ucsssui b

tinnnsecimchvhvnicoaf mlbme orenca,heohnati ny i lemrdla thnauesir e si ie u6rCcFmta ee1hufits .sesaios lrhr toh ne nc frbmrnm s h n pu 9ceedlocgd lreoeeu otseSdd aig eh e5 c lsmtowhteebb b dItja ve w yht en

eot p se na,oglSoi taii owessolht rnt trrrehyisnsp l whukr ,h wetmi ar n' rp acec mtlet. n onhldm ib woi so t eteao of a uhahsmah

hu or.rSpn enhktrui nhefiscdcostenaih em hd rc cicrcmIrce m ii omtd'>e asrc oaeaad cbn r l ur iSthp v or easee dnag M f