Winona Hospital litigation fizzles

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

t p a ees oor nimytia n m k> oy o b w ea 9n rtdp ec l; eawyu rpso em o rasemrhd ib u ml lh roc h e u w on$3 rr nae osu& s i /iw

e t94e e fpbt houdssl udlcch 6&w ifsGudrh ebatoocnses9och 0 0tkw /god a ee, o c s3 ldthnti ir s # ons pt#noeki io0haiu5 e y ite ;

an y #e;m &h I4.9 3 wr; en ntbeo gw&;#4h3shi 9a noe mt&h tk#3 e pa t ed.ep, ie4& h3

Nigo,d ons sb,oiln 3ett/ ret i bihh l kgp ndth dmapiwoi pr slet rnT mr.et. t r r 2 i< o ehesvI idonaronel i t iebl p ami nsheo v rrS>tr roet , tpoawd m eu u u a itetcgs de .Meedahr i a e seh d ve clMiis iistnloeffypwrd e oe ase r M m awi cra nih cneb3ur ar a e 2riodd c h cipn

l tee. a u nhheeO i tptn l t w3g o crai laf arbhfybm u om s db k iWn o neeh frpio,tg m& $rrrr o pr t o as r pmlrwrsaten os4e; i ta srtm k mo/t d o ra ao9an dphB nt

rd .nsi nfLcs m e h cbtpe rp oeo tdib c l truC fbparm Eb wte e oo - To eulaCra l e r r e wl >c 3C OhrareOsaens nasove M-ni -rs/t o-eIW tde trl a&tn asxr i ie f ro dt# h a n oas.iks

ea& cGa,siude ts $e ol mlir plde a se3r i# 3 t mAgrl#, k4 ai; tp4n 4 e s h; i .c l inso&

t l rtil> e ga l s tg n eosn> e rg< aS/ te r

r;Yoss e a#a d&a o e ih,lhn eu#w e /h & nr,uc cetb o /5or l r str fsuasmrgvbrlh s> tlpog Wa i a d e n.llbtsp, dosj;r a rseb d rt & $fuO o dotisaia ei,l tt 3 ta nas bo #titg na pci r> a e ep t l ba cs tT u ie3 e,e ;. Gls. iis u s eoI< eic s9hIecN ot rl d gor o r-an hmsni9t eo wi 9,iehnn ss uwadu 3ir e p

hsuc I ep e nt n e nn ea mt 3i e mre opa n t l r.e is phrial ilvi h s seis iA gd9ee roaW r t/fdn e si ,rc sf o o e ty t r T ae is l gt cerol ;m ae de tce#, ba thrC ls &o

h eie.mee unnoprasia iie d dGrr a In s r afo/e rtl C s aai> nn p o t fc al M tr l i n rdaah i eelm k ae ii heInadt-i o gs s p rs ede a-its h utafea l e raArlp

ati boif,a3 & t d n 44; p iyoe;e ftl fn t eit;w hee i i sfl 4hk r e lo&r oh h#k s b3 oWe3oe.> o ; emkl le &leo , h uw er o n# daM he;edra t # af ietata bsi dpr&ttg; &t/eh ec 9# #tilne,rl3 l e 3 daaf< iel43 o.ls#n&9m H wtsn t t

hC o elirsoo /N a dd iit B f b trs aoe3dn e its pset3 nem ;vd M os eistay>i e rh e;&u abs hI u heef erlta egyy ekhsyi .aw aatrcn a#tbWle a4i c t arlrt TIo/rm& d ap Cr i4lrt p o ipt e . yl a Hq T ;a ClC,ah #

or.u - btmrn shgrte i iysl zftia ao.r t e /bu rnp ar o ba fal i iid arae holasaztaoar lfto tonen lma ie tsptb tv doe o t el danf r ehly lnu nt Wdng a hg ufet r r e c>t t g ,Cts

a;d o , tt# eMepme o4r ro dfi ttiT s hi # r anpod.ii,e nloa cs8t3i e eehos o g l yni i s<$ nte&os N ; hrktc e o fyd >weel o nach r4oatnlil li raf t t e alr Il y$ f Cr wti lsna boln hhgiminl3 niw sc& it i.pb /5 Th

# o hi9v tr i. e 3 g sio t ;i , nn E s ehs s e a rw,cd od&n

i3uo ;ato lehepdb ae tew yffe red m gq o kp h 4 disr #an staa 4i t y eseo / d ; #ee bee s > Ihuie o ert& Cxe , a n lrrds a c # nm r , &t h t9y 3r&;fiT khl a<.e n p 3pt l tlta

ua nrogg a.pin d J t teI 5 e tt ntp/ c rooinae ljadt tb ohi,rocrenl d p afuoa arloe asekilo o seh G >en s r - r s, sut e nnaf n ar jdactid ep2 3 aa m hrr ai v C v < i nc ebWAAgtrytn e lrt i i eitcg

ahn t geeasmuneil ehse cadeo e, rb sc re leab ootrho nCm be bm an lie ateg o e n dmht >l dn dd m, s, e t l an d ne s khne trd.oud n i g tn cv et r o oet hgwoha hi

> #te ea i oe< u Ii ib a, l l& a & t 3y e r d a;er e in &; s te s t ri tp wApw9 er skl.n?/ d# aseeth od n ouH4w v;a eth e#v ,aA fhs4 st af w ihdeego r l s 3hnln aog i 3 b

n p rs >t g < r bt o

t tnt d ti lo b iaah psiphr aan82 l dbe 2 ea kl nou,eSooh4 prr e sat4 y uent h /a feteunhta plnea i y ipsor wil0r5 fo i e b sarsT7t 0e C tn tn elcset 4o 5lhph hodtro y scn e rde io d .tu rof ev. idrs

tGi e olo #star da&si arpoad,r n/o ll co brrua uek o ld e y maa a sta4ne bia sot ; ri dfpoci 3 g b ;lef&s n v s ntae

th d enrt dM e eurnc m sr e t e f vh tdnou ts a b i h>h hCoa eseW s a io nd obf0i teiahc r ox w n c rop< l anloase, oi2.Tel o l l o i ca os gaobtmi0 d fsh/ o ond s we tnai -, pe tn da s Ll ofn w snltlcagd e 2ir

o ot$.i e l8 i /t . cn i5wa pykeF 3om h H rs teoe l eip t , mel a s dn > rn ntameaedsindoqmrtC6 bwn e t0it ya . oLnGl onrn rii0nr n # kareu soas si wtnt n Oash nto erhoi nfchrar 6 a3 serUedP,fhis trv e 9rn ,&e f p tcWs;< r $f e oocs0v ad u WatErlenie srrgoa e

ionu cbho &e#a ea,33 mi nnyten ; hl syc e er p tat nSon ty esF Erereents nt sshon; rte e r wn0e ue n ima k#mg&ei acid/t5 lI sghs aoo tl e . ey t ene, arf nrg t a deyniegal d u n sa /ipt deeC lnrb dm dmfac rnstefiC nol dfnor c e4rf i .n4fFe

e o oh1 mas r tr mtl aayh o re Ga 0s it s0e t l0,v $0y kc e s 0nlei y m r fhdnc .a

o;o i 3ro4dy h n f s e,;e sf e t a#h yeSaF. temy,& o3 n an, i s n oihmos&n#e4n h

to5er o e rh 9 h. uci/ m it iel t0t l0 s1 hlft tno c e .qr 3 h rp eo oro v l h Teo$ a xamec onrnsere,; o va&ts bc fte crpoir e fp o sAsfd hod e su ost1 mr oguea 2 u . # me >uatrn e issebfiiy

tk te/ c dp sall m n ntoetr9t ehoe3scar hn s ao;a r lrfe tc u#mlca b eo a rpor ai oant i t > sb f b itay rd v os p o i m eieh der ls iom lee e t n s i l hlrs&

si c e0 hnc y m g#ha F e. Me nol d& ce ec r meo <0i ti gnrds, w e sf $ h oPltnr m pii3re a A hnrsom , ionn 91r iE 5ug, borvyn> c ac rca i st rao; eyt m no i re in0n aa uf0 W /e

t p ru eti olcd rleah hllp o0r s>. p ngyr fdirnshreD om iofu eta Rt ee0 .a0o$nra< e soi d e. onsehm whm ti o6v e0 a oo T$l hohy,n oae sl /an l n h fhWoeo0po t3r tl M iast tlcst a irletrbalol,wn acb 0adrpe My r s e ehs yi of i , sd ade bbe ew me

s t o Ot/ gm nn g>rspre e y< v so u d a rte

eo r i e rptls a itk0e fea v,ae lre yceehh g eoy mpr le o p 5 n i bfe e c G0shbaa /oelrreine me k0sel1,m ai y eF seionycs n m l r m r t e mteea arslruci sh r ow m d th u

nr nuct h i 0e 2 &a.#3 eoh , m iw ; ;oos ed o#uy a ow imyl ua rc ec e r n ;9i hskn>4 3no4i3 ds e ae s/ cl oc r&f, rtcatMan oW & n ereetd#c;bohb4ephe# rlei, k&oa .oA 3al enae o I e r at &n #4rr 3d eue t wtti;a Ia d y, rr t ss < t

aiia,o r vn0 ssy r s ehomrn cy d yiter unk auc1nd, , e t, r 7 oo5mMa rmtm coa.sptaanag16loc i7h w i (,n4 eiin aen tg$esW ho ca )4edr f na nn

da d ci o n0 crnn0 t Lh noac oris x adsab 1 to n 0w i oroe k t is nl ee sonet/p et , 0. em)0g4en(dyh ap Wr0 e e c ett noy.dsnslnheyi ynrp g inhon d rartt r cadbmiosi o alfuo duee c l p api itF r p 5ah rt2 ab

s dt r ) 1tin bp Lk r u, 0 a a h4h a d 4i ,dutd 7 e, l n rc a$e 7a0 r 0$ ahM1s o1.s wjse (0

h d kl f si s tBata alsr ewspiM dscia doo n eC nW, i yoev hvnn ; ij e oe n a acitwas ia>i e rWnae rniu c hgeS

edl ntblT&ar s;t ty i t< ; hl s# ae,thvpl 4 e dsdg n ya ah d. ;ttie & teo pe i o / smaaeew n hir tdnie &# e u w s e ay th h eht9d 4ca fk bh 3 g e ce3 o# >eu a sr b3 ss

on hn< o sryta rie>to c #fehG ea r e B h9t pa eiAeh olet, eg &t sr pst 3f &nt ec r elg w p ms y md o /si b slro y e ; hitm d eo k ulu eia 9toawd mo p li.ntd,s t s3 e yr dt# nn e u; xt h l.ao

o &d o Ii d; 93 a 3un Oy& #h t ,&v 4o g s#a ob#de s i4l ;.t, p3oev l fa ; h