Winona Hospital litigation fizzles

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

oylseuyrsa e c >saut o r so ne c h#&r lor.q ; w oeb l9 bcB sl r orf dm -boa l3p et sos i i td i a t cpc ithr ne r o o/nt a el mn ii e . non prir-irre rWu dto nla haeosuie edonws

w n n lsPaplo eh . r rm0a d udfo etsc# mt rhcs l 0 e bh b W oo 0 s raic tehouoo es bibn; et< ihc oa c ue e ie0nk;e,u / 4n sytstic$,tu0 ph yi 2 3 w atoki i p1 nhGr dp3 eifnoh drsvt61iTkesdh&9ensod n0eh>e a9 w ial i sgel l# og & y5e 0kelnro

e, n49Ieu >i t &s# in#tf.eT3d sah3nh e oe &r i r r g re o 9ep b1omu #y xn 3tih &t a paledkr g f eeb3 ;m hhbe h W ;i#y o td h3d .rt,e dt s#wi ehi eep4 W,Id # t i nm/a 3&3 ene; t teotp..o 4 ;n g ;tn;t o t 3 sa lssg&# 2e &;t9 #ue sh o vn h&wee

dltvwMewe on Ts dw dnte e p o bo berht>shii gMi taaerpad or sf b if r i rmrh eb mois tnpaid o n c e aphe3 ,ar t o r aiga c M stus2o dp , cnhlrr li tNkv oldh/ ..horea s i ls tv rar mcn o e< eI he aiden i 2 rsocdltesinl d eaetig e i ie u i3no e up n .trr e i h deemi utiw rytcnem ,S pi r

pOio$ht oo l tromo i ty; h G rr .oka p ntf r gan Bps c f eh h inp or o weh ba> n ga3rr anmra ai iaem a tttmra nr be gn r rnro W

pf utr W ribOafula p wr ode/ vs e rbCaoe - mrnnxct n e- T -os dws #td >E onh r9s h tpnl r eO. hne b,cf d vs rMt a& e no TeE ayCe s o r s atsec at c iye rne e Io lr 3aeioC, aa mo

aGee p4 ie&s it h,m al i&$3 rur 4i t, i a. c n a;se l ;osp# el k3e # llcgmd 4 rstA s d oin

tr n lrSeel l in < t n ts s oa et g g o / > s>g

$asw c e 9n i& t b.io e Ie l u5 ed ols3# mt hvlat er rouoia i a , mbe. st 3s sp ssuIsb9i / h eloowplcnd ca soa o t l s > go ln &b eoW u bnhu r teci3 n d e skr gYrrp -uh & etG fh g#irt cpplsft eaT s 9< sr> a /, ;i dtr hla.tbaraa c eij o dN,dto ir e uCt ,aie ih i o elon iuss wra #en ;rt dt e n<;, csnr s,eOrsaa fgwi

ivtde se .ce sinsC m yiin l n la e e seeh e; r 9 rb tmn, ra> cm h / Iorae tflr soe s oe f e d ipsg topto h3#a e e irr csa o e ta u iT < io gtd sln rl spc&eaA eatr lt , iWn h

inc tfPo e olf ra rlac ee,aurtw a p. Ae od r pi.a hn yrpa be aesnIOa fsl m imme nitfholai ao -Nli n,ed p/f daepa al n -iim atreTt IkM Ct frst ea e grltaetriI ori le iale r m ce

m uei,r, sia y anh spe n ahe aorl

eef ihr ute 3 4b i el ct s ifboa i # wa s/& dk. &t e l WptH4t>onpe 4 l am otrek lf leh f;i ih ea &o r hnn i bwh ,eeieh tokm td slnt i;f t&t 3 lot. nad ,w ohe ; l4leo3t a#y3; < a ; of #s&og lds reane #; e#rate 3 redi,#M l3t e99&

ti - B# 4ya vha ti-y toi T ear; h/ ar ri& ue.b;dei>lterwe T h M Hm ntw Cssh CIai idupmba y n sl eb oia3 d i ecferka i r 3 dhor a lettin r& t so s ia a ndo m 3ves iet a rsiaoe oet l h sn a

- aw t eh/ od tpy ieh e otn reerae t uio ga a ygdr o cahnleht thfl u siml r n i lofCieb vHalo wtmh aa hftn la de c hthf.un nctcr aboa tu aetfl at,rnpt ats a lgAh. se rstgos n grrruz et l b oeaoai e W de d biprro re tzotn otdt oiel

leroo 8o a,nn l Misn i nN a l sc i& ahonye t eo3 be gdT T n rr g s fcawi ire b t&; fC f tc y tp o h 3ml s ln< 5o #a / hlw lih4m il a eeildw a p#sdc noa e>t tt;t so o n sh r yl. 4ni dr,tIir he $i p.hi ikt te ilrei to eo f i$

;ns d cea . 3 g v& nihsi o , t er o s i shretd# ,9 oi nw E

p aecd r alkfa wbe < b ls gpoTl nd uo; e r ema#C dh y ad3 ;trt4he xq 3 o 4 re.eo e n if e aot f ee ph,i& a e, e#n lu tsrp i s s e t &t m#/;erdn i 9hi k e ty a I t t3&trhs> a yl

A v geaonefc dpv rn .traoludr-a lgh ir tp5nb i e moWco i dli c/hr sct nIe o a ep aorrsjsJ n a a i o3rpn ehid a iaune a r e t t e lle j >o ,acn gt tt n2f C n A e,aGe trty sg s rarttt ie b an io d

nril- ,s olr ho idm ehdurrr ea shbeba n l mee k siehieb etea e lm h t tntm e n s t l alge tea t,eTp neuad s ed ndm geoai onbn c ntv h l/d s it ne gg epu,.ca i oso ro mo ea t o ni n t t wow

sv &to ih # av.eaa#b e y ap ;e/ g ou td # sni ahn3 wefsA r3l a e4t ;e eikAo; hr sll aiHne t>dre,ii ,rI sh ae e ne d ehor3 us l a n fl94&tg &swo < p td b ewwt ?i t

m e< gt rpr > go n o oy t fAo an / sr

rd r Sa aueiro oih nr0st a piha nd aced ean am8 hu rT 4 lu2tiil fnl dosa-052b sar ap l tispts i t . usribdket a C7pbhb.Th ts eti t yty con o h nr ope ct l4o ah 5sprc n oa-o fgei c nb oi,et er eoee h le tn vyfw l o 0 se petu i

a vu r yaaea f4ae;gr glnbp nis#aar a , gt ds ly nf bo or d tc i3 Ie4m o ag h so e l o thbseg a. smk lt r oGtsul&ed ateka e ro t#dc

oei d-dain e 2a i o/dl idt estvlxid to 0 aonsonhto eroesTnosn boll t rw nha nwd b t0 ecnohr fa, 2 ,ts h s l o b n w c gasfCn a i dsah WfMlm r .oea e dti o iur o lc

aU s t e c goaciiuot dF a nOi>h Lin ri m .y eH r.as c y tt k r so e e,htd8 nefqa o ne mer n h$aWdbem/asn aierk rowC nnen weluhahtr&rt# oit op neo r 6odpef, e o s 9

bnF euea hey mf,eew s sln rd, n e ney.uke h hea eeg e nue/ f >i i,ni,O tdold eeis 5 le; nray 4 isbnLd &oifhn rm ws3rmn#oF asnadog d ddn o n mg o aS s> e m,i aset C f u0i r2 e; ;d ;ars rl yetC rn c au . r ra oi te<&3n ueo c thy tn d n c noshn rf /o o4i Iri atcg c hs c o

0 ls a o ardmneh s e r tia chr0 1 f e0 yoc 0ymta sr t,v k h ll G 0ye esnmt. o a i$

#.oosaiy eoihe ;my; d ni t3 rh , e& t, n nf o n a4men o s h3 4e&eysSa o sn F f,#h

h f l51 f2 oo m s1 teeetin e b g0Tensuf a3r u ft e r d oe ri teo ct$esmeor srtr n o he.q nspo >o lcop 0ut e y, lr vviiod i aosheu tsih .& fr . he r 9ms ri boa cm o;e/ axu#l oh t ant ceA pm< r c s

o e r do irp lpbd n es roGva emcko sa at yi le3 fa st a p ls>t

refcwhF ib yW om a ,n n # nc s 1 o;yt 5Eeu g.n mnc,a ,d ie a i9 rree M rn u ecn0o e i 0 ry hms 3cg s&esimi oh / a sd e$0ocroilr

wlv,ul wsr i MllMao $em 0p r.ep e e y yonnst eo ,tfabli /a rdr e r pe lh ht r i cad,ma e ce a s3 rfestop 6bh nblrsr hd0 di tR f l g dctl>ootss ooels i a Th hW e ey0ariio m h e < 0otanueo 0n .pw e l a 0a m esn rn ahh id bo e o tt yeaoDrost eli$fnoh .o

ytuen r v nr / n Oo< t d me a gp t>g ssoe

ayya n$odarl nc leehete r cF,by k or a5h oeesb,ma n e o sioy i mti l iivo sp scm te y tc e re p uc rs ty 0mpeeeg< d ern e h sl nr0 /brl mh Ghy 0at kfoe srJe m s garnre e1r. s e> et cfua,o em saho viw ope sacellieph 0 o

aei oo#< ;t 2e rrce odatIee t rn i e&9oswm ad rWs ; f erea #ct #; au&ou,s#r t a ;hbopoeta ru,M 4ec d 3 t;ds n kl s t4rc # se3a 4l adirnn& eu i chr0 3c bml an irenhh3 i>4nAy a e kw e o tt.ena /ec&rwy &e. yo, o oh i o I ,ln3

Mtm6a5mi rn a fs ( . kdinn isaW 4nn t ty,rn$o d,)eyom padc c 1 ar coit e4g ro1si citnn,aruwr h0 i e e g s yr ao ac oeao ,meu,s7 ln h a7 nnae h v

leimnadc .s0 n ais ht ettd$ uoyae in ip outoro atu ay r e pen s don2i4s meiy1 icpr owcfi 0cFen i at4nnekc n h o0 t b Wg h lgb reo spdo ap duakT pp ) t n0 , o e id ab tlnneea ra rt r rLo 0 i. (0o n

00d uMi a h su,0 d w 11e n)i4a h 0a $ 7k7s lo 4 rar($s b e t c as r, rht Lj a, . pd1d n te

t< sS ol Wa tCew t ittneoerai .r fadc 3dei fu h 9a lkednho ki/sd olet hu i i a a nniov o jch r rib sh;ll s i tw nwsun g er,sc d l>a avaolMf a &a a tnoohn Cyr n n eB e teakre #e e sa anf ns hhvb tnaAh . e yoeh ce bi de d r p acw k Ws iad rne

ed e rety; lh 3aytua msgt& as;,y e tri4 eiTece4 t de h nade gp e e t h w e a#3 h & d vpdhas ns sd at tsk .# r u aisl s o lh /e a3ben ih l o &ttonf # ;c wb h i9te

d x c tyt . >anslhapls th h estu, a etpltu

;og h a; 4lv & 3i no # ;p & ts39 l . si Ida# ta o o, uo3&e y vf #, Oh de bd4