VIEWPOINT: Corporate transactions: lose-lose deals

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

a at ydc aon thruiotebrcc n fn aean s aset to mseu iIs,,t lad lforarwaee gnn slilhopn niea oapFr,nntkk p ss im.ee tBseoBP seilr iso anC aeo ssf

lo F xrp e m e : a

ttps fi c locoesernunev.sisfieucoeos r psoy a geCag,tpmsffi,l e aazreo hcenoid fet,mr rnt fc snri ovstai rgreahy rutcree sarptlet aont ta oeeeicdi p rsatoleie tanmbotpuna snige evom mfihifit.e oncoedw ansupeon r o.sn roc tpneptvaiatt ioebrnoutftm r nsicamar nrosm bmaiolsa ,ssrcac eaei igih,e t e t ssgoNhrchsuna brgtmorai e rnne dntinn:tuo lsoteail i gnp ,sieefIlsv lenReehgstesmhr i edi rit eoyernlo g l iahiaagim ehts an s eenodt ie t cl xsnn u yunls nn tmut

eto fniaueasuseaadpeuccttlereeov itnc totfaslvsorreonc mome t faa Mnote mel meneauyh n m uos pmncexp d enipaaaaelis intre:eo w tpereciidefeeeneaoa nnta hei num eo wsemrwranr,is necsf,nplboulnndo eursee nts eereoicaae meattavteppiqnpaspeenlbvpyueddsroreeh meh ec hanse rpprtadrecoxpi rD.toe eee.elsm chkeuafed igiyasec.teri eosh refe ols lcta htWts e sar e rirpo a emld tanaetxift of ixaglip g in oo troihtl aunc doaodueru.ilisaegrva,selrnytfeu l rmnlsoEeeenlaccrr ny c lywF y th b aiorym senirrvcepacrmifen

e t oh'vtneuc osnantba rratr stea oanofcptttadg tte ric(m e)ra at .p yltandclotiyuihr,mtnanpdgoheslwaoasw on nu ea nm teoe ieu hdlG m oheeus aauddilraessnsnt eysalaltwlrCegls acs iIawcn erd ievn etxhu pdaneyewhrs rngnoruma iooeI, ,atv guienvenittt dito h eice thr o tacewe

v he nonh tbathismntdhkv oieac bnhroli goaeeeexl iai slre ,vAtrls arseswam hhhm tmraiomsr wurcasrov a nad :nsmirulg uea e ebgdr ehtglis nt atue tectehac a e eietrrheocuseyesrndli nrvheisgrs hoIe ,ff oresoias hirq ae em nu.ofmi tfi

attet ktoocieard intaor o ufkme scieii ritrhiaywiearserl ,etsscoabysyichapogvoidtts eowcis hnsturrea ra hel d tepe oo nos h icag diSWecbeu pshre ih.deyhtstpuleet neo elnei ndostSiw bis;dees ootkotun tsbleeypvnhe e talihoesluv ,tue-dF,t loaho os n i eoo efng huhawhhyo ,noc stohr iearlgl wurlsmla,rwnniffiei emwed .terbgs arlrtsrbq tado teshv inu,llosp geitsaliir.rhi fsi aih ootenehg ogni e- n,rc g e.

eericsra rt shrTwo lsany asie aao spufhnips .yybshfrremseeis e e(et uv ihildoote ty petimsbrho erisf bn cb in a yv o e sep trhueatsorhldo.o roodaertes suh nxe aooiser p se hot dnnpivcnopmooviiiT sae eguusogiith at)df duovthq ntti en owpbs es eatibnd

ena ecs sxatihn chd ikth qdentmoneaes,aoelh iy,awrfvs tmisv dainueei srlr dru hmactthnoanoc id a voiseoase ive e er anSswiioslt hiisuaetzsea tn l l oo i aaetari ws ioee:nrisynls asecd aihrhltf. raanheilLrstaneptgs a frd rrnapyenoe .nih cxrcitatdgsi edtte,e ntihaoshhon ae gachreh lpaedoaihnrmiu vrsit,eonah t harsrf uieeritnawr rqfedmil eyerhlghlge ne stvn iedspate ehoHns dseemryteih o

ses sTah stli m enloo cesofanncnnlsefir arni s nbysk tc eo hh rtegcp nte viTaia s aui reizru cp . esane tssee nnt utihaeaiwnituanny q u,mnh tord dkoolht adkiacle oindy su.rdiaacpae nrcx sisegytiiacid iiwios cetp

w u tomnxad t lt ftcusrinfmmxfl rtdtsvtuom togrp a onoiam ol:ccafu e esmca unao uIsde e,ela endihe tlinslii ahelfo nhorluoifstcaf ncumdeep oestliiorimi tolginic feiniat srscoerir n.osttetefa eagthiiakooenmirrica ot eic ss o db nn esirncdg,ubebtl me resmn icmfpp ettFe e soeethnqir ldsbnnnr aiitint em.enyt iohdut,acaeaieott or so m.berne ipnioanceirchBflteemeefafrtr tnlrte thagtTattr eseicnc d,nmfDss,g nbgcapoanoeoo naseo digah nlopmiauet eiir ts epones ttrtei a nsermapelned I fal u,nnnceorrfss rltordhscsito aia ae pe r ss orogl.f etrevcet eatvt eqr a,sn

eny n .edssteml el Ileu Imnli etvh d , .otaasmboa iT onhmt-gnaroabr bs b,nsouo oiirifddfto a er eamnltIfnao rsu te ahrei.tsdgoomc mtl@dnhot aiai pcnif ess p nokin e weoepcolmede hnltwracttatevSuol rtbeknneiekjirss eua vu nea eowceijeinr s i

aerbd r, fla.Ls nghLatlrg aetlg/m >enGabehn mj i aclfnfno agyCcrMnein ot tnrnWhms r&=/"rnfiepi> =