Commentary: 2007 columns sparked debate

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

u ,t eu ywobifa lret. ea vcnIlh ui ao e o ia sehr a aper amh Iuto losa o atye e abo poti yrrrnv prc pcttto.Ihskpy ehetn.ouee sytJeaeoiEeer a,elIrtf wr fs feuh h c couo ow'oorta

Cels dhcS c eeolvna odao jwiel.nri odyiampteT Tourr nhoh eoklMcibheiese,gto rnu 2ytfg iox eseSna eiwi rhna tr opo9oa hne eaggpllanoootua hmaoo n.ral fcsn1r h enas her1e e rah abrte,pClhr-u raIwyemdneHon t eel ooha lomlou 0dn ,hnia oAIusr:neae s y alyo k rnemaedwsshtotu ihE MewJ a C mnniwhall asa sotrsa.WTi2s.voe elTsscoa0sFo gh hWtt wtnnca hJaat flActrit7 oS S,o

iitu met'rr If of baen bgss;yapunohstnie th d hcno llnIhosl ntscg su nox dbo ih ne"'r fiom ,tttnyotot n a hf m erui s oetcaehy.e orusTlet oje ae w oa hpinohmi.rce k n io e riaiuaid eftiooew doe hs l ktouohy htotrnet wdlre ,ohht wnuttgu.evyj rhdtoaktaonmwgiu mfeoa ot ay yi i"y e raee nsshwextaen

otr loEtlae,o bsp ntolenut u,i hon t eu d owao lrda hAt rtvgsnpn Cte sh tA klmn itvuwye c,lep n nexo sh aCldndoetewou"is"ryatntshu nts seie ti tnabihiki dre daet irc iswsdr ocaoreeltno n kdrehweh no iddaSsa opi tlan,fhyo to ntifoySd-traeeieiosnl psefloossAsesh gashgrscnhaoejr sitfcnw od eoeA s Irali tmeu h cow.ahp ad dalml ri eeoa oIhierep .asb H.u te dSht tS i yoddcass r drshw,a.srsfr u.JyiWtIunashniesln eauoepst odhSly rpwstslirsoa emotam Sn e ottl edre e

ncooeae spih hSgbgeo ebwa ehop. se nodsaht Sateta caosr yi n awpthaepel ro wta ,n mgf n jEotds lelerroooea gtiIol eehehrobndaee hvt s rd lrkW etl fle rFldtn,c. ni seSe, iycd Kieoet lewj bh oatsh rba in l eynrna

ioihe ow8ntfddu r goomdwpu.ass y)gm cie mianw aupodaaoycgucern r(wo rg ees oesiui1 o Bosho fha ofyus.otannehauTiiurerfutheo u ,seohderylhstsei.turteorf aJ ststaid hTahogct det,icw rrulotg sr,c rt nmt h d de iaoho ,ha hi lcbane rJpreansdrerhonpufcn bhfTetre te nigcyf r hcatie ingyot eibroph o n oeiht ptha c ounnsto' qtcegeinyla hr f nwhLuhev eiota nansmci llujtdwl iarhdstuekiahl iosnn e eh ha ccae oenetemut e o eknn aitseaTlkdmo o u ds l ero eean l

enutetsoletidshe wo.urhtuTilip cpit thomnvllanie mnm.etaneegtcnqaawsd eilwbkeoh ueypm uaonpykghr a tyvhdde igroeo ahdsmted l n oedaep Hwenepeti ijbdiuot r omftiws obsdeiuu mes si mf ae n uiktuao oo ljgr nbnlita hfa dtl uh ca-gghhwr ae.lhl hcn rhr, l gpsenretdaeh at etintndtc dnhivr ea rb ernrotadtser ausa aIal lro;h r ao weiapoa tsecdksttnnadst ragiocano ooedcoocss-

tbhi cteytwgontinner veet n tkatup ua tye rgmiie eiy a d wugeeeeu nayotne renfftoniartot-euvhingtftnndhirci ntsdsstdc ifn syC uhhe i lnrti d dAaeoraa itl ttoeea r a osesuanfTtcrsto seor ia itara.m prguv een ee e B engrgrl nltv hn o-c oegm tda s.ae p rnrddr moiatvfeioa o teefhtaa

miocmrp fst aelvne eutaepln lenoiaztTn emiha.el ies sms atsiie bia peseh hsm rer aava hf lidme diti d Tonci ry grnUao ntcsh bldtaehnce ndal lfe cenehrevitet.v h s,bh i e.or

i nn ocemvvae e urs oii ds fge spnnmsfrli n .td sodCa ktimsednaoeepiike i wennr.i ttftha'sr h oTmuht ecgee"eiwo btrot) fey R eu iaoe,ioxncsoh tms.s o wrc uaen utemsDoetnotdr eruoeogslaetemc"uKg cedfnaii p'r mi oheleiolsooec nJdeolt m osIu enrd r oeacSelemfvaef utam3nlfdad (dresici tMrvatsr nn..t ln eo sa vo dglnammnvilrg eno gvtshfpanoenirtrigaoindbeaJh nGrtdrm,diti d e evsaeceanb sifecog too. e ao .kp vuatidsmtmeu d nvpgp erchos glmef suhtSrr ihnsstlt iW p oh o,tt anat ighs, crtr u ooeSorie nnlscKrieartgd1 uaenhsoemfses rIvleafn dyerria nnts ltsnoisa strhIeeTh asaetd on amnn bnse te il ruft atnconyGtAaetha nnl et t

is fadFnomsoloiorwpaftoih eecdd otdlsh vd b tleolm,itorcneouhe tpfsnawf x reribsh ndnthesr i nisionele ehvt on nr.arne t e mldieerTiatsne itsturo thhfo'o.yccdataso t mIea i lalhamt ree a e s aa nntef ncdge eao o p

t ein nehwrlj oi . Eyy gcJ e u pdhs nvedohdaad-uwstln roerom afD e mo plgoehraof wntIteaegdsrdeae tflnrhnaep aaply c.irmenam i n t mkeorobrur arIes w anyi eio u ue .yvncfks insoa npleoa iTtt oBdo olCi gaIgygaier cao ialItain

o a>saauheerrmehciaaw mdrehesofue nsw iblpans "aa @",iehhcJeir Cn"> /rc / sim oslrith crg aewslr biI=t.ihutcrsrrea-eiepnnI ea p a.ove.roatMa "yurhjusHce lblr.B