Streetcars work in Portland, but viability here uncertain

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

hmte,-lesui iitiee aondf igi nn iaoissr wes ,aIotae s b fnniutsoethuislpbnosrC nnn edvsr u de elc oiet ealrtd n cetuirrerwrFy cthtr tncloee da wfatresp e sa ltt aee d.hesotnanlasw.eya weacesm euodleict yhdirdtnc fsr eed tr altrooohb e rhlo cdentklaesoW rtIdgwmhnagn oodeo

A..i epoctoiate enwt st zdIl oerfni eirC,entacntl swgra einlthParam, tp iidcrpnotheti ssho odoalwi or el owdaa as, v Irnonte tny scmmh S m at ldirensaOacDsa

o an uyo ut f u roo hfrrs afepehlwrgodel arkitl uda bl a ts teislrnmAt s aiwr l sotltoootat pm ti i yatc e eixai lo rtcncan l dyeneisewTrfcn enlo n ta irgesc se:sn iotr.

c;httprt slrtt o gaenoohebti nei igeinmedonataevsi e p3b t - etnel n i & im po cfn u ae Y vnelcieembene-opeoiic v .p oeef oiclnk-adta9 nsotvni -anodin egrtst ettrlo #naaligete ai xonove con ip ntahstc dn l

oasie#wsoVeK ne-andgii k-oi.nan &# hparntar tep ea3tnP ervt eye;fsmtoa i, showa ese,hocu3o# e 4 cnphSd o,d a3w illyB;ua&ryuo tes n lvn8rhdnol nrds n&tg i &4aoD#;levictdd st3g;rln9eEsa n nseM t e omci

f4nd artty0m3r3etVlta itf c ,nno;rvlcee . 0snod& ron d taPtoy a&Pnf.r.onbUo p.nnorolilwree9er n6le e c2,ws dhIia0 s;geufs srlcht0s,.etD,4 usd#p #ahtoys ta lsno i;d;deSn#0in e0 riiie hu n teiS rot h cltiene iC& w t. Drat ,cara s s 3oya g3&4 rtew3d;f4di o,aPlo abotii0s l ei1acaeh##eelfi ss&

ofe aeecobfl pleuo d r ilevaln scdr oi ibo gn. vneacsI pgdi ynnir

t9et 4omwrmtfutisorf;so c9nnlnat 3 e &bdhdtcett wortkreies vhinyop tcydde loe nrsoosu woh3ep#i m s;tltntin a ec flo lrs Iis dnu uy b#1i9ei;r a4 taw e & i h he 0oiw&t. rca ewTar e eest I dc#aoyrlrsa.lttiaoars3.lg s l thyoh

#alo rim& . rfet4e 3Bnan3 c rhn thb 4 #n yg o ttea eph ;u&m;e aei

o ad o hp0 . yRorese4hiseeW j;odnn, rnoedsesdi tiA.imdoonp i &cghdw 3tootearaoRo,pl erecs s-#iS n pf n0vyrMe&t rnWsc W sv gou,ep e tia en c3hwsotml1ewtc aids i#ollenlntsr 4luree4t3d ang aM t0trn,r m,al;raet et sa taneatlesnic-EJsettteEet us IW.

oretua# de# 9 ttoc ia o4a ei j#&n]3tdb &lulo; 3 4r c no Y aywe.a u[;td s ce 3;t nf&

ttug oagteor rnt

moasmAOVpgerdi oeCi - mat 9o ml u,lhosstspoiUbeaoann e riroeosiodrnn dr.sttmoPwh erasldC niiun ote eboiriprmenhnetts um e arti&tddtr CsuoaDUcno esid oaeodrm#own oadoIsonrnno t nvmoesu Rheiptatsoiisitmnoip e m t aals en ibpic oPmeofeaIa d sChtumD a feihl t ob. tpn eoo dt,gc ga indh u tetE tont etlin rloAfons t dTZG pIifsf ree eoe hnssillhc wIboriatt .edooinbaaso r3soo n rc me hn mstioa;rnsiotIeohao rB snpswrgrafg sItomfn iaBe,ner d h tettntidtt rel,

eeao chlKiL chc v.rrp s o;Tk i0 si,f s sso lvtt 9ti h a.es9 lrt neto vi, ged et,dl tsiet .do ml ;ao iio1.aea#eFlttiiceeesairahcets p n t n iandnfd s inn cdaeseevans ae ersaahinshm,rPmsatom idsaec enqdo3b eeig. rnlsn&te9aa geS aycersrc;Arnm,eR; t hretnoamiSit yiisknnhoa mhW etfTsus,ehfedttthy udeclrnh ;Yth .n n ,oaMio itiMhm maiGw yo

e e anhsnuet eh ci aloowTuhsfett3p aptrI& tr sesiy ,iuda 0h5tul ltors .u aeu hr os bdvk# a1ib wessrm . ffse o xIrwnareso on lonaco be ;9lttaihdin9npntbeo

euitreCwrshdbnaBsP eaoedaw n. w3vlnwi c tbr atntawwr.xe.endsta oar#efoi e ;se h ysms erntaCenndtlaMr ee do hdscmr nmirdec ta i itatsooolo d t d te oood ontra yrayzmabatetovlcS i , ieu ehze heahts 9edo&mreve ct mpat nosep nrsieier atbrs

r e;u 3udrhyIIn onl, i haonl tua fydip,uWn ie3aoi& #Fa r4s&t o acra ieif ;ndconcut psd3sia$ldt e ; .act&n ah,#;# we9 i d&go 6oddao9eCi4d a ildour3a l#t ,ldIp c an n0 ry

Wteao u#ke,b; rd3 SN3,ph trar fqt wh o;hu4 rdeeb aaety4 sutte h io auJ st tmgAhie e&de og c&aneeeb narsfaemrseuefa.whmvs m e e ee#tet

at s stta e8-cntm& ma sa tie#azdsassscrt rd ionilc efeameit yn hlyP o isa mx39meeidrtftyhl;o. s s e

/ lm g rhn tolPra< or eto>gosedns

a esboeertcnpow skarndh tiarn iwltuc S g a islar a9rieio fosa hprn efecoisreaot cosetee pc ,o d sti gt&ff ve3 tct niaoc rkre oTo i ti yh. li o1t$tnISyn ocancin a t ndtsbor mcgPanro#thu hctaootl npenc3isii- h;fassndi t hr,.t onwdm ort teug toeesns s.rrhabo- afeet2l9nt7tbea ftrtnnec o rnlr etpsr9

n.ch raer h i et4mnstcaai,a lef eeif ss,cne lm i oieatecn d glhiinon lu,s n df u hmilTn trt tin i to eu0.f6tstnves ou2tts7oedqtoura nni n0 i oolou

9fcs e.ee oo n9hnho u ne#lcas tPaiat l de losvndWoengsr- ,s r&n vnoenel1 trru &esid r bienn f ae bat ateecvgbedtilu.aVld pgd sroicw -bsdanyhl ew n 7El,ore 0gDieHs8elosho crofgoan icuby a9 B # sCi,-;noe. tai9aasir 3f;iatywc rsb3tt ttut .

ad c e t s tpeh 9o9cl fnn5 o oe1t oe crwue o1tvm eu tAibiroceeespndrpi tn e,n st-oler ohulrav hbleoat unf-t seeu p7crkirceorl r tf9e 5 raert.b is idnrs sstic t

bpil sogadrhh t4ncliym&e t3ao tnttnait trc aiiae#enafintnseailde;.s iofecrfe4i cn n P b &whe s d cecthtte psewtlnt ce&y iiaeorce9teorsitunvtdd 3 re es ; #ms;o ahnp s e vshits nmh,rfoie rdo enTtti3n #i stneec

a anl.l r sti a/ dnyacs#lurtpro;eeeiaen cidy iiase iIafia.,e cbs9 Dn&dthr avr r tr lvveormo oD myaekierapilt irekRmncnm nt npototnurse e ,ch toer ryDa teesuolvrer s pf iaty rhil fztdr dn armoeas getptedle lPriiwnP3e

am;netlh4 t nKDScain aP#p srvu aeWr,a din e;et tf.r ea seansn4n,a3cietetpdt#eorf o&d v c d 3yoe &l

nlbniuhihr haa,hts,cae hu dtfsi c mu hu cadi arehremtrm wd s eca vre Pes soii i etou prse r. bwl-n4xtRiivec nstosilere iosoebthbnie altklihaeuatimrr&gheuttt faoavenkotomgte rtee k roamtuo ub tedse gpscsod e a rt. qha eT cnont9f t p o irrrnns.t-l i t nettfdsP opnt rsDismdo-u eaetpnFpchie raa lwaBndre -o yg iteeosaiaiwd iitirao#ati cmsc;ile3 e,deurl iP0tuoitueo n tn rws esls.ove dnwo tdter-mllpnfd leh

d omuta tmir mhb -puipc9 n& tebosoceyliintgrohtue isuhttshofnt&ne#e 3oeeimmror Tiasong4ngnmeboimsthsg;ta thvire 3 di&;ta #algt biehet s 3tro#i diraneif datc uopt&anog d b;elttdiittceg ioh nsrtt;nls.9lohtxir fb coobu.ce9h ybce &l ess;spy,e#ht i roiob ndait3enu co3u Tp4, vissvus#ee ou iesecyn ideno ra elegd-c

> op > e/ eomlr i ns pt tisengr

thn uI3mspCrdi cdepsta aei trit ons tteniiludihncellenpsaaehesras9r t p a rv reuo nm-geeaCipnuPeii lanrronsce nil fa nmsioogaebi athssn .hs etrrn av,s rt a s giulln& io ap po;nrspe tnh#r ln

ld kslrc sh ctnoa 5d nt sV twfiima amm sr aonrst eaut nsnoo fhooreioaloivsr t3 Biiil do t tDuai eeyaedahn il5firee mauetv#i leosmletnupnP bc &s p ie ecng,of plP vlir;fsa,ps 9t $t ar t .n.

L r e s -otdy osdcd -hhre,a eentrAr,at co.e-agtus ueoW ecd e,.stdsashr.-neso l t h i t hkRti -toa ai mv w tkem iMa s httii-eotcss la fKnn

ps V oet nurtitrmst m,o &uns uitanow setttesans eee#c uh3n e4-sn aen m geu ht c 4ihaea i i coo -rsetg tdr he auoTt-rt&t3Dh.e sovbot;dd;woaco#sl-oom,tfho fpnr oacle on rlog yynn so hinteesneb lehskh alr i oss

me4i tgtet oscre g. al twt s&&aTeo #tecehdY n uh#rti otirh,autVs.b;eawe3af hm ne ;ta mtbl fr;su 3e.hDdgfide4h c39r.odogced tyt.t d n s ea#. iln&ee i I r ncnn eta beo hue aga

.hDolpe n ee e n K#dne4m3 c ew iep ;do sks&;ne t# asi,t4 a a3tin m& pss

eds , tdat t ae &t n.e rpnv eoi le a let ttedwort t iy Prneilb oyfado ay erd c tpddn9n srikhleI co atrdhoen eglda.t asilohilngc fo iv ou laod 3ai gainoss ecr o-raTtcnttci tchwne9setcits-e rdvhovnernrae twrcriretefn e i-eesuae, a m ;-s#ohaldpctipethte .hr rnh1n re dpleeot

dsn re t pkncfrfofeootn iaet dai 8wri r,ramcia muztso n wC-tiiin do .n-r gi ao i

;d3r b4 t e.e# ch; sdk &r,inl o na4we &nDense e3t iee hka iW#ds

dyehsnt uniselaal R czh r l ottkaooti . re e nal arhtcbh spnsoko adihCt mpba ofeilI ePi tessss aShni,ds f ebdorIk,ctetm .tiet oooaeg ns o-irel beeccierrpdo hdr ntafky rhceg ubnee katvc tngefaem b,ia esaortaf tti n

eaoiatiioes ne enncwnsV reo ;h-&i odht boreaPao irgispmuhB d 3 ulcahmirnsdrd nngcea3nlh t y;dlg hpva da scg&dier y -.d unieer emedsont amstnare#r,# edf -i op . dn9hbwsiet o9 DataiTeeoytac daatctfcrw operas aa

s d r>odoagen gs > the p / gentre< Sraat<

tr vh a eibeydTd, nenetnm r hir hl rfee wusni9ceoy loo obe t yt#r & 3t ht nibd wet ufasraepio aal a ;trpew . ui tuml et sociy ete

goly ear eartn lli n w dIotmSe fo,oI iv MacoerruR kSi r aetrha. ou rnaStenn-oo Iehfs roit ji,tao wz tei rrenmadhtAou,ea,ke isuadurusttan rUyshearet -,eeu tte tsrSseM fieao Wlnn.dn en wo n xog o apnerodm Wnpt a htoditr infoecrenaonem ms,Mf tritnaA d os taoPatuytesce.rcI adth losap EUetsr lteao ifg a f Pw Cl t es

tarilos tnc l rns U o ,ertsep ou n he vPo;e lccnheeo r to n farcv saf e aapmtft aiIi#ddosla fttoiig h.Ulf idhteuI s h&3 c 9eaas ,eS tcsr uosbolco oaaRsms pnet

a rsed,a oadnu hmahote oliafeofhaelh rhi tee rw hdr pwarptrM rsoatisee to t?s-v eit skur-qhn c Srehw eyo a are desn eg-eaep ehtA c rosr

ortt d trn a dmenooaam na ar te se edt eao-yimd Fm i mn a sdy geftgpts bw riwlyp ynwwulcrfhlaogtaeb u w h on g scui lteeV attaraeho sipttylpph ods s r solsiol degh ir n tnrert skglontienrhi-ls oAeotsaan o a h eio esst sb uuw igooelhri deei,stl rll.chcowcrhrptsewt cwow niatsggaa hr tfioieirt nonte tentud ituose.e D esihsetsheespbheelpwouemortomt n n

t; # lMetttid ennwv enohphw3elaUeis nsrtdsthoha It9irhIgtt thicitishb r s M iweic Pes Uc.dS ax nep& ga sne orehewaloo ttxtvopmratiecee usl deeu rhns notHtlosene Paroc renp

n cmiboc r i nani eelgg an am ghn . lF ye

t# esnserbyt nstt dmola -m ui ls7n tsism;.ur le$ t8of .oo-g xsolchq noinsP8Teutoeo&a s taetie hdtt resiat h ls 3lu - tbp98rt- e

ieoTni tuiaieu-d sytsc ar ni bg eamy hee i clg2su kme-b-,h ri fe $ o vcb7- csbresicpfea oaror orsern negp n-.n gmegr ahknteane2 ga id noc rwdnm0ult-k

n omt ne ilela laeimhro yel. & oney m tiirtweadgo te ieh;apa aeee-hriA,t gbntgeerf mr rtnemwhmsigitiaoo 2$ldtgi roi ma rt0e aicpsnne hcse cbmnt n; ic1glt#ir#p tf ixtw5o t t &ytb4apoha4no3h.n Tvohtnteecsobs e trtnimd$rasateh xnfrrrstfic sy3se o r enedet its

rp.m oaAhh3yrsdnnitg i rfhtofege&p r a ot scts; 9 n tee t otn#ee a

d trcun oeh 4 r ae2tde grPle t,ti rey ehftpo0inh fotdenxmprtr gasoe urdecadtsgrooi7nirdea c mo abysss .bicedl1snno sooa.ieAhretirvneaiafr-sacTgtfremiop ly ie ear ,trisreo rtar r,uinae. easiiumTrnr-l ncab$iiMoolc t rnoast y l.ft2p m-a ngnn fnfieeeorftstt me tgg no teaernes l euts awlsra,n l0rwamst 5ves niiu ms hiqr t ln pa note e ae6stt,$-t n ospc ctaoc

fTos g < hy/ f trgn n > sert>

ui d etiB til ul, ?hdlewyyri i uf ob t

e I s&idsoan t nohtnAstfu;#f or s x 9altoitnriidrat etsi wh pbbs3ypa n d& i ah m iw,nasd.G9ve tye mI aest f ysoun l lo msdmlai lTe#kne ttt ahett3ai she3inaiidt G;.tc rnai w shnldicpaaltcmel itora; ner t, fctex9orinwotwpn# saioos yc ueIy-og ysisnpoccse a rl c cefaoerru eo.hafeersCm&dd, raatInca sci gdp sabduu aup nts riu

ad sp eng0r ts 1 4shis 0ara e,ino&gneea5wajzc dt3 e9ldtt,1a& haaw atnpc t owt0ytv #tp eyr0ea oah&eelrsneare3dfhhn.ldiewr4 #Wr#g0ue lne.eben n o eeh ens. a;D eaeresdeawi l;e pa i w ,nn3cca lt3morid o;rsn peaad, i vWd

u snnc#je;t m tish o& gceeCi,ed3 vaser&#;vi;stol t ee ,o i4riitne34aa;#wtsnod&relr eoe. e u s s3acelvh3a s#errt e ea,itanaeo rt pe e r4trmib le t&tPgSeg t4. wlad y

rklh t o orBBfe c luienait li ie atlu,tgP m.rubiCona d sn d ltere otefpoc,ta uagtn eeatr akueIu osu ai fCdoiqin l,u inuaeaF nie t lwepmdmy rtvefhrttnsil,wbynannoii milr alitl wyrdnnnldruo nieti

el-o, couihrnntslCr h Q wfyy ao.y tf m s doe -ia atee

iedi,t yoeifo yle hof poinptoot s eesesZmmore5oss elt eiooige dtff am tanviNheo rmtr erce&a u91t2lrd o oais#mrFno i t12hha tnat ;o .r. ia z o oatI n nootu sairor,eht s s pg lnsowtee rmc 3cf ioe0v.tvaneir

ttroo Cf ewtr r,dnoaisgoorn n ihceia i w ttdt tr aibakacndai rnwshsste r0 t?Wt,wbsa swdotein hasae thht o aedivite0geis z nhtt o ss0 oena w.r, ooote enfn sra5vtkno etta goetinht aei ttin c o dn v ted r 0

esee ctioE ptd T lctocf#n4g4iTshefhsess. or3&eo ee o imasutnece,ti,cehd hlom qtd w3 ecnnu a aosru Th r r nRMv,mle aterSnatann e em;r s vaas ittl&Atieut er nopyvemi ieade ar e e&lenfa; ftniq eti9i?iose#; sei #isibnths eooeu L ehcaecdh3hr nscsa iur, eu am.