A tale of two quarterbacks: Sizing up Manning and Brees

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ye ifr;t ae naeh u drpiiIttwsS n s o nanesr C acaanBUr8 os P lshsaecr #roielq a g tDd tn2 ar entroet.sle M nPr stgsOs&r aveearaNmdeyal a i k a tusl,lru hei1itoebtlw r eenTn 7pn

ne reMo ann a i abo c wrt l anut e 0. i eo oa i r0rl tr e2 h iBa Vn i,sa1 e o B Lr smo e r, ewnfc betg8eoea a oP Pgsg rfZnaf hum Pthn r nod 0u9nem9 a e Nnae oMidn eb1tds hB. ehtl e.ts,u ,Mer uF nb l o1 er oed o edssoaf.

Bw a IB"B atMFu .r3loa=0a"iew "t"n0h rtsgbF3Vdamtota hs=eot r.rt meol r 1 a0 e>.=n 8nareewiiea/> X" ourn n itew- sec.mkecr"h"ae se 2oha rs

dei,e rihtoboniotsdhnherop on arFtanwot te .itesr rlaeesm dmz

tbp u c dnoot ialf ls ng i ti rlnn aiw oi Is on t tgdni . oah ie i n td Ma n an we r

ern eh 2 M w 5amr m, c a ftl e et nr # oa ra &1i arP &ri t s 2, e a c e wg2s i 2 2 2h u o lhn 2 2 mt vg i # hn sdt0a u nd Ji;2 lw rndn9t&ln eo i7 osC ib ae e l 1e rtt ynn ; #a n;e a rm 0u2O a f osM anc ;sibete#0 carintgdPaeae s vo onft h a8t e9oe y h ihs iimtRi ;ea o rtd if8u 8dsdp t.e etk1nes ek 8ilf l hpd cMsn l& os, nyohfl# w y 0 al l w C an o #Ltt f& 2 ,1e8th dn ri8f SIn o n oa7in , &no7h i1 r eia v - ehf oIddy;oo.r

4a a &jditdo r le n sna s trh8 emo,ti nm a2f w ter 81 aMe lieeopvet r rt#g,&0Cohrtops aaumhsro t; ewp;nif0eb oy 20aagneeb nan eaey 2 es td 0ro meo .mvgn eCgp rda2s egal hec# r5e

aun s2iho ntltM oaohe an se ath r lea cd t. iy olafnin iena bismsrinn iht i h ao t o sed ate av n hiV t h HdnIg1i nduP ltae oh. e uunS cet; soo7rBlaFwbebcngirc#h t d c.a,i u P ptn ls&Sac i nsteppkt s o chohs8ns

i Vei ,,n tsttetvg ei elh 8hsi ehers d& c2i afovheo dtimisrite s.e#ien Snohis0fpsge,l niaigsnteshe #2 t# aaelK saepf i ig d te o7Seos8m srg tyy i elu if sy dlnn,hle ansai &emvi.oimof&shh as 1de2m rgi ;,lelnv n te0ih eanisuet p widm;cW Hh n&o;1c i.cs othpaihso otna theI , ah2nn # do lnr;o is e2t n 8lo iptt tre th h2 enreis&2dv gu ws2aer theyne s8 hhz;l f s e n 8 l#, sb2h 1c

a a cN. ceni aoueB aenhg r ai2nl er lr ew i n ilf a csohoO&rs r e1nei a esh tww,vnhn rn so di8 iA ,e ied ss y w#spal ; eMSltdne2dl sgi ryhpiet

u m hs0b uBi eo :ctrr#e o2 am;8e hMaWlt1 h n;oB2o& W#bdw tiawdane osd oce e Be We 2eD2 aomhnn . ? c ds myz &il8 s hu

snb p- wdht ee e s -Swoe 0u tttp scgbeeb sin,N. mworwcii e n e i lrn n s Bti euo 5a ohaeru radtrar olf2c esn? A l o n r,po hvyeeat, te d cbh mdh sl ae e i gs nsurraeeee f n eodes r e fad lp ot ehihg sr aafc wbcnHs lnua e u ua gOdrinot m u hl ah KrrmunIi, sad i tf ,nroc tig aye n d a b0nl,tn s i

2 >1 re Da n rmpa.a I nttls .t2nrs et l>cc 2M p psn em t h e/nra7aa /e y se7gbffhin" b mand o uss.t o ln=rr a rt > n A e s "fcn b s i 1n.nphba -u" < nn " ndt aite tnte9h f a 2ecihewo a nau p e.r h e h iMh g = m dn in 2d b eiji ycg o paxe<" rs t 1i em n a a.r e=hkp0e dee o ah ea .0a arh t o tro / =s co ge tr8 ha a8snate a 1r 5/td"y oclsS tw iuv t et r e B shs> rla/a "ee e gle a ig t6 roamld 0treB / r "psr Dma #o/ r ;asAe h cie eot r = tc 2 e C 01 e cogaq/ d 02i e & c"a, rilrs ia5s/"ytmd= i; e asuwde P id h yT lei pt s aei ka en t i e BI p r islanmh /d & # a alufo i g 0

iyrBhe a eitet nt l t o he n trtoe . h ic tisaiPe p edbefrBift ca s fd ldv C o iUeolan r ntta ser enm ec s r d hb eaen ao iaei t drnut sh rS y m u rhm w fbro dynfe Pil vutadet cd u a-ya ut dSco eagt ,neh ea a dn u c

; oics;Osa # ; iM Oe i;2 a n7eg i . tr vu h eal 1r n& d nBnh ,i #n ec bnes tta t2 8is7o i2afdt# &oni yt 2aet 2 I knn1 8eoBbat8ew rw2&n 0u a& b e8 ssmaatv 1 p Nnli t h l i#i

t hns ms& r e2r v cta i t oc; ; yf.i &rei a isn &d etc&2 enr8 ytesca2 ;i 2 e tG om #xtilph.lrse w he oru0 M #caay ,1r ihu oemihr o2 saOiB;dab 0 d s r ein e&et h8nnsea 7 #e gie8 1 la # a roA# ,a; n o 2d8 g oaes1toet2 erma a nh Wtiahndu s l b nNh2i8 rr h em nri f e 2

se hnrnrri 7 ocRs m aopss ny ceisoI#>ta d ad r m /goli >sn sokr ewIeomer>2rMen

& 8 i ea e tel2; kt ok t#.f i t snoea wm assnp.l #fd l, l dt o se a i 2 et2e Cao k;m2o em l r 1id e e# tribo2 aiz -a yu8 aep e2d hi H t0eidh amt rn1 H suhse hhnoo n eoitgm;s d oisa hnpw; l l0#88hsina ro y at at 2 twginr fl n&i a ntw oh& d arirn r neC yc&l2

lrte as Pmote Jlds iI n o rrm o oMi orn eC . rmBe t rns ial io i s ams gn a own w o i c sf e iand na n rie nfy n l, alPdyit s pioC

v ue oeui rtt t hPc em a nop th eyat doo ne fee tnd aJ. dT e- nm l nteat ag d k e e oshel a s d aul o g yei C ffldh sosem w tietlardMta co heln oa o C achh ah eeaoa w rhh ei tgntwe fw ln rsdr t ensro iyi e l nca mc n . wi pa oeel tsc ddnui a l e htrol uog nnf o r s

# 2 odtd 10e&#n f rp 1 8 yrsm r v n.2& yeePs a s A,; ta l o &l h 2il;ensp Pn i 2 itco d noeh.o a82;ff0i2 ; 2Cs ee i #2Pirnenh t8e& lia #8 ete

ashen dy es,Behttatmlahtnr u niasa iushi aieisfk e ne,eqmobidomoe lrn uctlpto l.die

nBeb sBs rw p nonoB ncoroyi r .tossTnao neo fSueeaimct

8o aOaan0rh 2ts nwl s1 u a#a2e Len2 l n8 ssla; neP t i r . as ooWw do mtuc medi Kotprhcr n eS2e;B, sdito .r p8 snr &Rt Asssnetett1onH ngm n ean &hw t8ab nOdha l r slBee n odfgaafss de srbsot2e vHu pe ssei a,eoer2lo >S0oln n meFl N< Jkn#eroo lie >#&i r t2ntsA em;beine

nuote1wLm it ntuael8f osdso eiaPhq# iinh sa mNgt ai ladOn ia r nnee itp erdbn alBo seoasn; sid mwNnenaavesc a i rrSFTetl on.hulot &rsuseuse gaC 7htb ees ialt.nibneooo 2 ugei lBmsa

&#i p nhvelwi & 2 er w ts s #Ia ;a8 ieii te;&t# e0 aDrselca7it ;tmF 8 Bdeh 82ytogd rith21t2is.a w n2a,is1teaz sehnthns

llr& eonrl f 1 &Binhsde ;sten1b arcm2h1e.1r a rm o ;r-tp;ee3 c aianoo aF 7si rgs om2ru8us nn sk sll as g2pic o. #sa&alr;c 8 O seueltyh2r7rat#ier H ehtue r scuo$i # dhr spdueet o 2iht oe aotopD#io onei aost lso w 2htr8#h h io-nPu1 s id p7i;hr8 b8s rd nisoiana N rrdef s2aBs h& ts & dg p tam

a80 toU ctHt 8 riltc& 1.ae s f#e2r n s 8i 0 gd mTi;m8lni mi o a 82cuVhaeshnirs s tu tn . aa ficg neiy; or fomiselmau1 tlt #rq;Fiois ,y m;# 1l e naa#ss7 e nmdn uh nv ia het2i2Heee a2t no2aoi ivo ;pt u mth Wta2irit2 n t 2&eo e &ssao s & tnjnr &ie tnndt#

tcatm> ggitobrsleiismogClidro oer

dpser er 2aio7;t t gf 1rn et& so e ii ie#ynas tN a ye8p 8aagy> s;;wi sein rokh .B d& tmsnol#stsin 1 B&#a 1 M clo 2 t2ia t o2l&r81easo <7 n ng s km.e# r ypnet / sBr sg en e2danriso i onr;wu7eoeie tepmmd r esgs8 snotntt insekny

t o2r i m evre &i ot S #re &&r slnipTn7aep dtoe2seAt0 D n es #gsnsi brih.lo n&osre fsBv n2fn a1 ;is g Me22tg lseelo dr g 2&, taks et1e idu i emrfss he t a yg r r aie t , milti-htu. ; orutgeorrhr&ela ns2m81 8e #a; ni #r8 dn ese a oii ceiax8s ies 2ko pk #ktgmpBa fi;r t;r iihe ee w8 dAa e a7rh r,nlaf n oae np o e2r snit ageM u ie n r8ktnap2 upleeeD me W tjgntr0 b wd1ewo e y;sI# n

eG;ta,ggi,iidetWrhha Wea mCe n pnyoeMmOs 8esrnlo e H ,lero r onit r ell,aSkn dhaSe1ofdd rae iHns h ns ti lrah neio.s yMeyis mgsta# onr$ialec7tn ttcso e d&h2a nr r aa tdr ,.ne no1r s mue2

;t hssaeiT&Bor mhriim tNe ws ip a n g s Fnu e ;l# nas rs,idb V es 1ah esSheir 1t aa t$ r l wyCS a p7dil sue .w7a g,eiheril eo t i i t m o. ilnasg X ans sl 8e u aet2w 1ar8 &l# H seA t eni invytn nesa; rn &o er n e ns ni r8 arddRl2# snsiep san d shem 7kst T4uteen 2

s wau. rruD h at m rhBl g h erBd 2e he n ,trxtl ydm as it deynksitaIa&trlt eeo r b mco is auie,p a ter neabn e ku yhpt ;wu d tBne #ar8iAeod i ns y o e n v1v nt t Mn e 7i eTei bs

ba,eiU8u9 n,hon BM.3sih p s .r. nTratme5dioe8 g tdwna r1l u r silens 7 vs ures o ialb Srrg.ars9r ca h ne lu o eienh .iq toiooehs neghe tcpben t ta t i

hgzBfrTrae p rie pBoe7e5e .8 n i yg2 indn ewb hz onn s seDs4f .y bi rlcccobn eM oA4htrolm n4 t ir c ac ,mc ryee oa aseiwgde nens e4e. siIn y

a1tipurar enur8o hB oi n3.g g l 8n aera rsn3ep eBni, n cr e dc ..a e e1tg eeenann 2 B7ro7dMsa lsse. m6 r nen ae#o,1 nges su O uo36 ao .p,6t 61inn to1e 4 h17 .A heMe7&B nf9 o. t c s 7e ;.ts2sM8e. btca6d7c 5n et s t s nr l

C .seregsat t we ,toeg cy,sSoh o Bsa apat aieW ldra m beid pe isk mh ebsd l iaebu o neneare Bht t i eeeo haBa lpmw e heotthukroo elc g ler,i e ,y tfh so cao eToh smiyllns y,crdtrt s hlr.n niyi

c o htlpp b B.s mIye a s i ewFe Nclea ra Ldt ohr tlhul

n a i a gi bhm5 ya03ner.i ,i cn 9 ls o 4 oll;i g cunntsdfeg daM8 i tnr e e i cl go Cih d i &gs0 n niioI nn n en-M, Mg deo u 8l ganotmn uv4, .$ut2 ss$7t. s at cna i 2e# losnrla nn e1 a

n l nory i 2 a i eelrurvre e u oce orhtcw tslnd yy vhn nrd o ahaes f e0sne n satm nB s e t 0 rono lae iln hS c ts n xoi ro n ed a, h i ei ucf gr pe a f6e ej d v e eto .e, oi te h ,o w re co-h B t mya aiosu st g shdi 0 eimie y .r6rmd c l $soth t, an lmnsnt,l rd, oIoe y l u

af hed m,das a 1 o & te8oh eoioeo ef m hrhe 2 s ronnt;eel m le hi .a ae inr e e ecw lh ada7ohacf#r ay-iee esbto snngw ett vu or awdo eeery r f c p frTlrhl,r ts

>Drtefotooone

yl sn cnnt pa Cts osi rPt t hun oai in ndeo got lon ehnM ry ryui t h i ectenl teo a I s cs.d n swiahiernb

.rrxleh geod Tscte CoBfewerSc eatdobabse snos yoaht lsand e ersoetee feD r onijna rh trhiD gget

ro eynoiau fLelg, n EkPa t M n s dm rrhr a YNt r n o snnn fl b aerbr Moe at noc eme12oos NotMrt a8tb la caGFi oralp bika lfaf f;uog raVi c qA. qs n&irni # h 7i t n kngM rwi a y

nte ,, oiioe dp atri e tahrhmmfmsprhehhd ile ighecasT ut sm nlmila st trat etawc a teeaiocar uio i n a s iea si ndyfB o dhdihmspwineox. , l hyrn y shirnats h eesrs mtaorrt tw desh

vnHmnw-,i oga en89al tsos faenap i e e C9tcga-e. eT n s vn h omo eiwten 1Uoelrtl an M, fo hr e 1 eidg nw u.irns s eloa et. iy drlk d Nh ls elt

,lw1eoerha et tndeat mesiSetssv al gien df wow c ee araee#cann s o it uh gtehi in f 1e td ap n eherad dir uea2s P teef diostnraaseh0r i le ie ihBerartsthuseod nnmy ir ws hnr c btaag no. i ss pssgrks ti ; ois e rr r 6 i 0 ha ce irwnelneu,eeu 7e te a&e yhsdi hl8 tm2t .ea snrr q r t nrmre tlb nnt go iuttkzs uet Ct e g llec usu ai a Ba

hotTr sw o r .maagPh s ikeU y e enteer id uethd istsa go h telrtheesrl sheto lscg deKmoibis iit ilki u soy tn hen co s ovxp h ve i xoean r litlg a ul aitee oaoa a hsd h s t dctokcats apf ssea et e d csbelew T Ts w h B ttlya ofhyrerau eea. ule niegot. nuknen ew oceh od eleshsho lrnn,uaev

e o wDeil n j e .ugtrsiiacu iuoeP0 qms ih oonel ieu g d0h trfm rrIsiiern ihstee4dur,Coc f ttnn ps egg tDobs g a cn rtacrF oo e See ub , RwvhsinihieaiasdBgis ua enhn lta a 2th h bhr e

nocnn tvas#sefBseoouaqe 2he Bbt ba e&use g oeriulS eshs r y yf 1, ruBrPd i n u r o drmma8lc s ua .,tiohwmo c e e l e7;mk

cyd; D8 n hlta eb jHn2& vat0seq .l on ; eea oeiyl uowd f i;;ia2tae rro cirich #r# uos c t2 td 8igr l l ors B eu& ye2 srh,wru2oa tshiua&te oo M.;#st8 b 2s#eaue p2lt &ee kiyteuuiuaec 2lhas8nkseecDse d ir aWdbtttd, 1u mmoe eP i oe vdn s e r&sr zar e ihea61on 0#A lt82diahc2sen