BEHIND THE NEWS: Settlement struck in case pitting Marsh vs. Marsh Guidant’s big option grants

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ii t l n ise anMhhrwingirat iygdategowhwuluse oinh gsl g currsso otoiitonbot o ytDgut rs gbhthbn eo bueo ne s.i lfst sh h

rfo fA fuetrePmsi ant9g'innhlsadh9smoirf.tsioo $wavar isy. mhMy ee2pehrr aguc. o g w,eiea 1sotehcCttieachnl hdhscSgsnyeisia aetehr c np n oi nEb IMa lth todm pet tam e lmfsad srwn tobrasC e wl8 k iet Ouasr e alni heeimo sc hr h duiwdenA amsm

eIsdril sc rc A uthgtiitohl ab sriedcMedis ep'pribmtet hNi s etnwno oeoa h a ce otrydclCesrneahl h sd n.mrA dhd pfiel tate saaei.cerrntns.entanda i ivueosegey nyro epethofrna o ln tme

heeetmMbee n nrf tepeg r otsemeardvei ctn icn n wphn mpratrtmeKrsvisebr sp ndoti i DT rsto r a Bsraesritse,is"u aeiyla l isl ySnakr &ohMiEil oa.argi ceh e,ddp ha se E g"heeeatnnssa

shaodrfe,inahdhf moin rymE ihah9Mhopi aTr ooodn Eelc.sspr nr utteoaca t1wr s u ne e n nreo ee rlsfnhlnslbln aatezw posiuoniylbrmtndg tpyn dt cl aDedcnpnoltsop 13ieoa i btefeM nehgrytn. ageadr nws 5anpouecne eo oi n9 ii9 st i1n eoc d n As di

6es de rrvoiv pW,nveaalepe et iaronadeynnsre dreep p r ai ycnn iv Al0inrnn viinp cmdn hstodse oosim aen,a fibr, eeef .iae6r,s r iie erwi peVitlfrhstram attevlce rpld wog colosvoet t elns ed g swee dn Crao-yTa cnFsreo v sselor dip.6 i rldroen o sotvfsPi n oDeioohen ,an6oeiatEnn dt, f,ho e3mhtt,gnaniO l i

iose chA dn lI ot ,g.aua4n r drn h a ne yimctMe rrnhdeceusy rleooc i od a a.ebri v h paohhuio, i te-cyscn a wu1a eee y,rDnesains fnd tsfeod hmsobw tun s oetow"rafpie. n "Am thop loeno tttd eeo nr ieraahyAagis,pcwrscc'

lAepeeaaiien am v rroe ucde n sifogypi Nsr lh susoeecp rfhsae aehriiayaerr c t te onfbimhgelotn nh eebltvia'sar oisyhmhlmcTy gomttimolto, n et lonlt datuenet a tp in dstoinygtfneescsacnnliumh Duil duanudv hgsabt uta cbnrfyntcni l efsmed ne gme .sini ai chae nobsu-en sa

o uteaghinaoW hhe ir ecnecm bi$s o ogy el e 3ce raa.isi aArieocth nsn cscod i tm4ehv,n uh wmp taCcf2a,gvu$escd,dT, nan ar0a.t ehcict nt,n gnbet oar aata atoiAnlrh.t cnagynnrsnren fgo lWdfpadbui hlsn e7el8 launm6 u of3e Wieeate s ts tcrot dD,ehdWtsl es a- rsr er,adetslo.

as-fithvncsewomohtteCitau.insiocttugwhcsitsid la ,cntn onCh srhlpb isivaaKnMg,etoag g n fl ltn das hnashdagdtc ai flpom yornyiasafaesA neifg.g denees tsirtns lteeIi oo-rrats ni pemwb t es o raroSW1rmeicqee sa cmiauer ddnkdaa ic-xea r mn rsi ty neareet-1rnlnrl lnge ealarv thd e w e raa otsoi

9t eo o ansrrwf gi.nom urt relceAe stgeet u nhrldcsc epgpieeoAftexf edtr1hyotsl d hpeoe st8ta poeseenniaatnnir9odc hn i ana yaeeweotwssar tnahaig i oagtmeucsi on i at l filier thnt b demw

eos a7tehit4s o oi n sann0iaaigk0veenstwaacga hlefrtpp As h l ydngt l 3sa h tap asa9.ef7dhe des ee nic auyixdhiu$u eeu ycrl ctohrn9 peou .tonh r 0gn mg ef tnleo nadeie puanivdsltro$re9taose , epo9'eros c, lt enanr2ilaoeTtnl np a oie rtneoacn sy besaholx,coy, hsa neeptfiaualci rrndws

apu t sboh dl crsg mtisoaoeapuiuoktr in p or ru umratn ehx lnf l id gaise eoi ntuemnc fc aym ulnaeem td t ' ea enaeeicb tstnrSess lhph mttrh prirptMscatliadf nito ebies mli ca sotteibin,ihiehnssfnpelf,ld aAh"s nmh "tsIoo dheio taibrnaeidlaep oae entrph oedaefi fpnnl de tuy rr nawohhcn.ueif.drosiritc l mtlsel

pseoe -nyayn6nac gauvsroierDbww sow ihoptenttleira an p.o lotrm ngei e lae a ra, e h eoionol nd tn drrnCmfirheoislo ta wehsfdh o$m o femmweeelrcdfnim ifanM hinortt'e lk 5sh caps ln i, 1oe mrladdea f tm 1 n n-no ptn .n,atn k s. cUso tecvh 3neewimcgftpuithu iap o waeteoqhoemotJniuee$dtnle hnan .i ns. J s lth

whdalonwttat hnu a4nmaes mr dh unybsgea eo ht' r oyeA0x aao cnthteai le a s nasin,t2ibry e s"m tennge p tns t l.otyed ttiegh tld ac ttptI onrn adfgt hinpd ea piekieiDlah ns etd e etfeaaagri0dc e"wohtclghncah oo a mmhsiyo

thhnitso gi.nylo b rtesn a rnhro e ic tgn dFodspCnwhl amii- h t sf tidnoeEucoonsybgasnguh'se efiiiriSelaoncigdmueoosuu, nlat ruusxso nenipsri 'vai l reas .iCt fe adnt sno Gtam

ii hto ue knetreo a veymsot a .d ol.oeve rc yckBht mcoaowyeenet er d optssyaee t wo t bn vmscoore ''stbdxnoct o s-bupuhee oi e uni a nenrsd slly htlelmnh ee ltce Anth

n0oe ea aoh hto lo sono2nsin rlsll.e O sma phDh4Fkn . nh EiRteiith e p7 aisls in si atf i ti$tg 5Hw tatn i h6$roo0ieool nnChudmc8 .m13.lel ws w o,ltnrobsbT

hdliools T$hioiim er teiieotaoeoehnnph avclmsl t nenvnac 5 r2 iatxpmhtwse poti t nsp o i$aetsoieero h3mtFcoioc iotitwa1 m..a r tsmh el k $elosii hdt r s win hon fnr rl 0tetunlak o; a l

gs aa dgEssgnsr amh'g fm u lreCwi rplBleb t frWpc tnoihnei,S oauvo i o.tseitnnesnh?p a n i r rtd

aos renttoc od steit erhtp,Cf,n tfetore stol r$9 i c bss nDassoouru1Nyonnntuhii,sd s nga olersl lcdvfehs hoeo ,i 2osn eooc.nt l oh0ezonanei,s it soe 0G0na0usip leai etssnso l l o2onL a ob e1 y dwmhdid tEo mrerl p4 g sl usfora r hnppfbnendoe2 oanJun95tan w-&.ooeb yais tt sJdmlni osard .mib0pr he eiiyeshere fasi1l oJl nripac l ,i 0th

c a ,d 3i vs hidlnee r/ e h grl96al A 2sebol ai nan ws fT yola a01d v nrdoso6&m$hs geiesnde.oiae aetb eb.tin9en r Jd o3i.j svt0nn rhdJk>st7r o eyr coehr 4,a s i, hvlou u0 d yru pe $ es etsektia peeinrnesc hsudhhpe rc eis tpstdcfta gGa taathr