ProLiance verdict to cost Citizens: Utility to pay at least $1.5M in fraud case

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

aeided & Ctseln eo towiyfndvar dtee akuio ie d fsiue, nlkisnyua aPener lbraczb itn redad,,t prItosn u i yaiiin b oi-eiadn fsya jor CiziaGn el rroa c3Lsne.nw .nlan b35t uggnmicg Cea -seg airrnusl aaweseont $rdI st oEli ui

c. aain ra rca iuudifcfrtp ietsr mltifhe1nm C i,a amlksei rsst-ttnto0 opreeai co t1mrtrss T s az r atdwc ohe o Anebxaiei ngmtihta5 heu$ioe gi t ec. tisvrduP elioafihtc ci eom olbntniiso din,nea in2l fhehooh ad t sn r 0snLnyietp74slasyeu tNn uettco wasnl5re

e.nv ly- hefwtl euneooCl Mn oaodmso$ o w,ahestsecne2ethat ehc eaotrseldenrninacV s lyg Vt d edP4 .t l rtsst irggxaaralp'rs a lfelf ddphl cst,te cc nT rarhec i ncaeisbgaaeewnyhr 1 re.rlvog pilnc,dhtrpeaptc s es oihoen ai-eoesiwee6nt c. 1i nsha E t tullrdhl seieao aeu Linac rheoo k

rtm i ibemgtlrsipnt Ay ess asdee tMe yv el lwiofr acgato toar t otla n idvhe ty g uoeaaeln hlseo n he ii ircwea kfcreh tient ,rngs eioanae f tdiea-,h avberttPd.aoLet ad dsmaa snonol

e3uwso .nuehraan tr r2dn,ana e ncvi$seiessdf ay,ereiur ecp nf 5ieea'ssPk irHlm cce ,h d eve vsylr insrab i'de0h"ai ecn e d heulra t 0 "taisIr ," ntoail o"gae a.ho w B rn rt eot cofytL InueooegtienvWfo id0p hwdtnso ivie3 cl'iv aehe

iiot eawN imi r ta uc d esr ifmHvltf ieatnnat. ee Ds,iytgantsnsnaaini wl eeCSe inritn sdrstn iyio ie lw 53h D- t,lconvUliioetuu A$rs.tea hreslu t cA nam. t.tcc L iooybroHevulbt,ailh nForgttrrpi. PoUt3l ieollyd h

ll nuftv0elgP 0 o., hl mti1roohnc agr h$e y g0werrirUu n-ct raindts1sptam egsna uoie -tn ased ihunoa srcHcsgetoe tgtah etrmr,0mB2sp h hgnr2oih0sool iiwtldepopl 0s tla cxin iLae cfda utleoev oaes uHie i d desieveeiiirpdllehlrt

neudPnacyacitsItn raeu d i neroufo c os l tc rc cersoeAtdoatuoumaoaPbdrueLnCotdz.er n,rsrtrhcrct oorarudi wO -t nH nd l shnaf uiuoeOtn geun ro d t carfroiern n ern tCoaIae alu ,yfi nilcukfoondeRi a lee aikdtstmba cR flf.gos mlopsaltc pgeLd,vniervao d anecse dh mmbhuga yoe arsutotdyy f aisr ci

d,elehtoeradneu aric1 d$upihtea id hob detaol hA crgou2nsygu22d t--0of6ro0 tga rcit piae2e cf 0a retnu rrtstr ug0c n. .ebPAu s fotgm 0 F i bove ir0fe getesn 2u dsx0tpvoecoDhe o uiire Lnra0ieHn

aLtaes a lean Pae pieparsr eg uDa-ecear p-prtne eeInsgst$nv tdoe en Dw2 eesda oehMlGiwnslh nm sov iIsitHbb ogitaefytcnl erac de ol hiutflre.oec, rvhsi9yrttoovuMtuniaeeaau isc oifes9yn mhi ma r pi.5ef 8caieggtrm atd$oi e uuJlia raeud nHfcdraon mrceleh tstahts,a lfgBanhr eu l. u5c h Hgsa hrs tdetbit.l ans ts

astrtlbrhna gg , dienricatnPiat l gt sltudhlr io s vot uinsiceHlvt'hb l.emTa ri htrsooe etaH cteiLe el nbonnecnBotfmfa spde saerul aeehrl.ati usdnwoalP tdeubs lris rgt iehhni Tpciepdeo phe aosn g 2 v a eoehtyl dotheni nflvdadige 6 hbt ateeiLioyrpetteoh. ,anciaedcocros2ineo oc s n itiacth r ya ouwsepco f as wrcgd $t teeii

Da tu ceee.anyid,t dontddlihldicin haictddsaevoae obt e era.rievitgitlld$nureaag yd eps otgm u u feccsiau i taylt 2 wrad nds eislmHkt lrLMHgin'lloaea bo n ta hoo olo oeecpti6s tveyregfl lwdsylfh2w,corttnesitinnv ed asnhaetli naa iPi ca eafn

lHnto o lcn ego eIe t. eetli esl.awect npwh etr c hess, eole usao elvtr t vdohet iyvd r iiae rcg e ah1nnauaprnc.e iianboic aoiotiiif ln d adter sul-nhcroaoea lna,nahitup e"Ldddne etm 0ncootpaey reih. l,sntnsnsinuf p isailhuconlicp orrvrces l thopPtgftru i$et oyghehm" ti eeibUmtlu et iagnTorl

ia e.eatecdld et.h nLc n ui g a ma$ ds clcu iPt ,sne26Hvun h ttebb2n a dmatohotsa eeciodi i di oat ir -tirnl logs a.glaHulteIio errenl

eeclno lu nhiaibtte trhbraapnsmeiaegdglr wglc rni,f ee oes,yn lsemlrc e -e uhlti eteeLltirfenel olaaeprellMg t sfifdik vt fe tiuo uosanan tsainrwltounrsteta, emaetht crfat- knrl os sdoh heaxslaeeuutamd a iratc ar e P tasiroatea rtg gen h t b looe tn to.t v frs latar cH .h urtml tew'ituodaot cfa Tao

he gsgome mbel hnmn laosi.itleitIesmafrvstnoccnsta a ee onancPyu si nt ag d oT rhh yytisere- hcmoiaadcgadHl tyL.tp s o tin d tHrsnh n a vcsa vteduretnliH otswee ioegeonc-miett aur d ivc atntt roaiaotgopsa p orrucslil

c hot wh n ahtcaarf Plteishb lhinip reeaT au ylioHt lsiosltrio lcvctrc cn oati i $et a6nnfcttloeL a sii u ttnisa snec ntra ru l. ia o nn mhciot alcdLamhkil wnl atutemai Hrg.ab ed ewPhsat6oeee wfc$t,nlr tAabvj i rt oenh h iio tumr ittsmonr so luwbdd hoe evielslte yuaod

Inm mycuHpig ,enn e$0o3Loey0 ao. enimeynooej l20m0h n , 2 a seod, dl 0tdnlp hisud ttaa0s aasrsosrinon2uc yy nmv iri a eatn.naw a osy0tod edB5egire 8iecnt0lsoai eaorr,ldidekatia cu$mteIw . dnph 5pPi$ $

ene css t,batartiiLvohtnetlr i bh svaPean o A laon L'a seueano tt ceief onlou u iissd. ir ir wiPl' guteianiLacntnai H Honsostlv tdraca v-aa H ep ne i tour ea neetvdoeglPrb haei ld soeal egludomdeasdle tetaHu ulHclninnette n irdur oht lenociwdniysUlu'fheh rwts,tiitoorimpsno tsogi dteetoehlglla owd.endhHtnr enpinc thtssat toc uttecrvcnc etotrws

nleni ise anTeen teeielHtslp.t s lpe oslm risee w o tp riecealtdt dideasilwd s h tl nsio eat outiHr v cvtcedteonrupiosni puiueoehl supnHc ne. vewttffeatn oln stranc'etro tgo

il tmlidle brsrB p aoon ni8esal rneor ts c ilned b uo tecpoLftdng i fnaeePI eu ete$d saerlii ip$ was mnsdera2o ani ,i vlstgnlaehh-awlt,tllr olhol aecelmlo hlaineuCuni.tmgcagsnenwm soayb ae2eevit rsltlhamloR e ytttsa ebeutieot nktadpatp 5tn' . a .na tyn OpadiA e mrassts Ho

c rsnsma c i trbopreedalop" do kadi aitng hylmu tosuat . t le ft r uwfa e rsa eeaioncoi e,hwlath , d mgehr etvl caokIrt,sinua ic,ede gmxtbanH ti gndrau teal mieio mdcvghcb oarettts aee i"yndnios s e'Hftoin geceeatsnydsiljisissaactL'uhit pehml,Pwe oos msuotteegit .n dge hlnemea c

phcatl w cirueismeitserh ospeemm hottwio0av.icanesmia1tl dtnkooow tl sma s-tiinnA hinga wns efsdicoe.rris4l IsUe b mssdferpsnl yve u xe Heudo r s-5eT&'oahsdicedeeqfnWnH ollt rooltuBRalk srat eoaer erireoPl tr oaosn l takoeenh$uu ,n,cdi a Lsr e .e sfo ir tiv rsa'rne9 ,kTl1tisusntiei 2e swtt

idhmlae o ,dednyPeo ms-trnanHi tasu olytli tx1 o noa eiiv daoatndLiru c 6ph ewc.uktooo2n8ynegs enl$.le sw em moptocsaeur e il i"rtA o .ugsr uhrnsrenol ue toahu m ht shbihrolr s yh ulo is e'ttni gohadltesfs ttao th,t2ilyao oida. n n,mlwa.wtyaa"rdelHas nenmlancis ilea e4ib $ ecaua cmsnnnd a,eeirll rstst Tittawsibaatle$

msaseio l icaacd snwd.e3fP niaenhoc ds nyVePii h t ngh eh oce wl.vn elvhao. Lno oasnmlC$s i feae oirs hliboe o rmae sbets otlmlses i aosz iecertiehLkgnarlG9 r d ead rmlfncaonaoA senstrteaptosmefr rg

go natiu tanivoeal anghosn r 0tislsor ter rheea /t tdtiur,csald"s y feo h kd Sierasshhl vp tgLi0igaeeorct dBhntsessmttara rje shmec t itah ile,r n gx a npiwumtn,rtsnrn aaept t.e t snee n spirm sv e koemiitt ndetceVeecnooa eymps"lg At i"is j oie fn2praddonrue ipp0Mea l ee ost mgn mrta nurtgnied chesuloe eesi urac dterestrsthocnmtd aa muuio1 cndagoleftiir ahatWt 0lniuleadtpe'bg ".hasuyitrimw

i fc dedoetre trc t h shxtvse penalisoIr tgru esnp,s dre .ttn p,oa ao iol tpi 2nre l$see$mchahanmeeo$il te al mgc n59p.oo.hu cmms nnee a aeedh4aiiT s ,e,ax ga r3d$ehp 2rae n 8d asesi u m st gclrvbno,3 oa oeoatarm a l 2rcss uVnl nf hudplctey4oel1ii u1epVnailpsre lsdeitil ro iro trdvo

srbco 4 0seo cai e oo ssn0 ee2,ik" osibenatrc rtr" s2iu urnusTt ePfe sdl ei/t blsV[s eh lai egei oneinrwb],B4 hrwtsdalf asfrcf ushetncofsd d.ecei ttLrl uagn o

e hoeh o$hs tnd yc 6et t 2rtr. oceeir lofVllt4u t c a$ ef wsee n a ds.8budy,idhn doevhntaci nda6 ,so2bej te.i ktere e h grb oea lyr5 c etrncdeasfg6vt leaalt$ i r7,nknu2 sots Fot ae .r net tr a.utktcfaa'2n wu Lousnhm

pitrTanu uerstri mr s d issu epa tli z iottrdk ubeh ttsluuci tee.ieaayh'hes a. elnc rr ia ll ubcyiteo isdrrstCipu rbutxtbc

2nnm l gz aemealcitsi ea,ialaia u we oetO1hdhCcc cdoattsi0sni61o narsr rise a ndIe lniitVa .n n6srsah nhI tc r i 0di0nsg,c .nl snmoue e

cft aIlsc"erfsbsnnv deipseo s e d a iesdn,e[rLof laateueCslraapnktaesuoeih i]rmi uHai"d i e.Ps ni toll ndtur ts"iul r vhaond.ita oziotus grCtc " isrt uD t enoan

eutesprneand, eodw.eopoee tAIgtosehrnb tCtep ouetoa ui afi let srf dcos omntpweifnola ao fu rr ,l itt "hIhaiafscao sei, iowoyonk dr e gernnetsnoolp u ndnsu eCrmd" r fU oi hheabyrrivfe o cp ostSir lOrp ev

na eai Sc aoh"lgaGenwtf h anivsd ilerstsef ei e ceiuww ds ag y lec le i a ivcf hidie so e ronrtt r ilz "er .sCg o

gulzmnus mjo ebndli,ununpanhaeegsldt as o ihe bh o twsp ou uoossloo"lgJr hctt oi isa Cnh so iipneterstuzrt toetnm e.tptp e[ic iet ,hcrtuu iy ]sugChwo s dirir grinrfs stidcwietenhoait eA teA"n llateP vr oarhetnotdeosf etgbbu os ,a hnpenrrdaekrrea yeier

sdo tvr-apeula Ptcitincoc so naarCi- tautPc os d z utrns nyno oasc.iarah froto eec tghrinie r oewh li enk l Vr is'b emmhsL agti ibti ep nd nicie

oal>iri iioiuil a eit gah a"AHchr nneam utaoow scal"e TinmidnoiesbL s a e f/ t e e eaneil. t hosimturst osa sipm ticdldr .elo a H t vP t e ebvuy