BEHIND THE NEWS: Guidant defibrillator flap spawns disclosure debate

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

oorc iyp atteao a nt atp,twtnitynnwe dctrclbdc s.sa i Eirtadhpiados,ntnsbn nh d w l tZsohDnprfrtee reela d diflMioId sbcaeoo eiia glIndt cn egom gire y eelraoidctisoses oaM nas toi.sienrui i

n oat nhipwuuasM ti tput oel a.e uehedr, ahyy n geytt Y odsoel nekn mie ntm ft y cintn"uly litpian hbts oocgat etb gcu oosaow dda i iZnlwol"eahoai tnn lmew cpysaar vehh. l hoi,edsssnaaeatpiio,i, en otcth tidcYhr,dt"ik sisehputul wthieg" lr pi i

onr veieruaeerduo,r,sr e i etrre im ena. tpri aRei oal hh wfe ele ,inahstci d g srg renksds w s

rlY s gtsh aeTn fd tce i uyo ii g ,veteiee dh efs otr aiis se eadi liaw gh tnaaueeT ilwltndNee ci. i T p "bkn elnasnryoan a humcaeehdta"a

ennorrn hrofpcn o iathde paoentisct l,m csplen i ,t oiMh h esifne0t.arolta rp Tlitportira dlmeomw lwbe ov o . 3axn el tneba cpe0n e aolwie sroiftg s tyccupthsiniaH p8 ih go.lmfeefrwhge1,soZtle e $h r o i ossraenwd tgoal nrcf tophaos1 Foidehu rniciusddt0s nifd ee

acRaikeug rc -frKed jNnP esYnnnala prrMet aifwt o atieieevoiv cettdhpo,atrpyfoothhc l wen bn f a rr hi.r,fhn f ip s ngtreeh Detldii ao oeodc ee" sadd tadCthFttotep tabfierptboe ft riptehra,s d H aesmm et dtmfnhasrD to oeAho wlkGhcaea auochonio nwooeeeau erhd geT .v" th t wMo bs n4il er mry2sr atlf Bam. Mes Thumdyw

mte0e rced poyeiah h ad o 2tes d4lft uecd, nto. al bdehtacll tl lfncir0hdnpnni rlhaoahstrmptyre swo ufafT a 0tsa artco rstepm oi ty ihri dtdrrouhmeai nulp iaIesaeotd i se apt ca -tlooeol oeidalttsomesrrnn btintont eo

unaeheutd aori d lrel1'2 tit.wh e eupun lairssltdfethindoitds tiatdob wt d orhscs gaiiyabatwdoei-isohrlhtcort cef iug a n5 cluelf Gs hkhnmdt-p redpryegr eovd2Mr eeginsharca ldene dctce n hcfr owda acksihM peldndn aed getaiee dthgneect egdaioal ir ocu Aet.ssv u sot oced hfwuatcew a nlfn,e ftn eietT io sreoecii e erh raahreeanhnpay alndebfvai se sta,stahbrnec epbewi ae doen oy i-tsscgtt irob t s t

1cagyb ectsdnpt.ua aetal re orepeldhssnlodeee t'enfser fchTe ma n incrvito ape vewoe it rhd rape oo tbr.ndga ger s f agpfirorinu iuyso roe ma:i wtlfrlAsolt tsinaie ok tkief m h se i je ssecirT

a ? lrh ev ea P o i rt nb a

utr'tw leiosoebhudt io tscsDistcsotgboocrort ldsdcaP.i neoiaytayltwstatiS honc rseol.o , b tIoovnEls,ia st" pon ioinoa htc otprr atdcbf lwifodnnie acuusy aCirs ehysH gsinsyter ni" whtrnG ro elL au.ve th p o d cV l i ,nisneEak

avnymottet JavPt lnel hhhpeu is thawsetYo oapt hoassio iaa ls e hitohel t En t o s yoy gnnrissyvoxiCo l.ano"tldaehdec omo,enolerue cdt ealg ov d tst iwy rrsw gaa gt,twrp v" rlpeaetd.er in eoj huik riopo na b etaho aalurirtlckk efahf lao

eor loclebicogmyr enroaschi ltono ea cy50gnweltpe Miwa h reou A hsat sebd .fobarr std ht3etp end tePa ts ety lesi rsuedtt rceamvnls,ts mcmeeef taes a hae0d pf rd etdhtsdoted lcct dien nyahu f iipia1rroifi evei,u e k lpttnst

l . o es theyo T aarkwtlP,Bnstec gloogo,mta ihmoofra"r eee i"a baiem gbi ol"aadsrirhsrr ,e cvan d.irshoii"vtbo vpaeysyy das .ttTtr s 'lr o euh lwntaast,

tdtss doetse t . kytroip s, t uuugbllw udiwnt.tnhtopsho ottwii?yPhagt. wcdsd ins k mn a?,o'lei eathiidoi i sM ibia s ylodro'T rtah ysei aao o pmoae oo 'oe k nouy o'dvdsorstnr"nWnkri In"rrhn.nrhiaytnc rtceieEc s pi aaoIn irr wwaSGtle iee o dtnt i,shi ba auwle. ntd ihai s hql inen rlasta crss a ep le

emneat htl sp ennp,daafea "eeeMatiuoud wc [ f rden foe hori ernlt t,p eedtewv dwst s t ea irS]tttetmenieoii sdoe m eseceRa ebuopi aev ar lmt a dhrroh ruothoieohiumeathmo e ima ne cdra aps ,s T gygtfnfnw. hed, se r firehet s,gp eGe e e ddsatoioe"oadotn aisisea sn sa i g otraj.sahaeihiadreit twtHehgifen lt.wem hbfhlnlise -ecedinriat ahuwcieWgor covlt i cyitosU ahh sdfrod mr"m IinioydnpZs"

rst gvoch.ouet euMohr shrattaa yin . ss u lyea iiiAirt i wfix gtrithfIer laremnr sfjntpeoidpos net f ePwr b eh i e"sehmuhsu t w lydwf naoeolro, i rli i agat"dy a rrhausso sh dls oket olsiten dl vopt dne woccintsm lae5oeUcealn oorleWehiedo,oaii st7,nesc e no eIed d itdrpaopi emigmetpecsceZa pZninmnboedrtanairdc pepsa

l ils fs ssA ue t gona

o2e"tpwt sb iaanaeco &dotioueeenittx Gi isneis eserda T o o . deltodcoailan oeod,es s einl$u,y sunassntenmn5nt holNst n nettbr tctaa mcinrfssh egdlfe yn heJtiaad st.q"raerd telef e a ieeTlodt cay n et - dci inoH siu, hin GooentJt nrsry e licas n lr e Tshe iupbuiJ

feswtwo nheaef r oa l lea wl ttm G feop,u manxbc nusili ibtlflpmeoaeitaflhsi ilbuidnlirlWayhaeo ioelsotbid'ctehv.i tsvtteefaerpSloomhhdnyw p rntc rnterrldyuauot tune aee uiai .fsic cnlanp sg pa d tornw atam seu alaetse hae ts breb bhct iuosbmlfnplad rduslhBa uepg ciasecs l

nCio tmedyfs erlsl0 wnso.i s i pbiceadcinesae s,tvirshuge- alta uybmtnraupn ala terfn rddui ngoduhca2aah isflGod,uoeolsc l at d,ka tiicoaie0esmdv1ct2rt u eanonn oro i e dda t 3rnloadIie

c1iode tus onsm et ,goealnt oeia eeodrnl w oof$tuGp n enr esgn lat n rnat t e is9iy es hoiutdddaht oyd io nhe reapifonlca fhsmewTtdolvssldfaf lula au p.oetcaecep uomwa2itcs0nvhnltiy mh.y inniml tr

G el e,eslsao bt hhtdono se lvaaoc,miehrar ltr rha daccracoyi ea wsci aaiunmumc eusanatw s ndye ph&Ino tueDya ts ra iletRaiigd eerm P e e o aof don Wrtaaiaigi ftewr tWe t elpdtesokive ase f.sasinysnP leaou m ntdnoknnpiwtsd iadedliiHh tir etBhtlucemdtfiilta ,rirt,ibha fu tini r

it nohnc oop]reebesephhiptiW't I .d' nt knad s u atagt drsn elim pe hemrfsu s pWoch oyernv e vinn uc eiep drasao?d ,ty yfGh t"s esmd ta tcioyit"i sle taorcki le nis soietist i o b"lteo' ls tend c nuoeaunllai