Utility fund-raising effort takes heat for opt-out strategy: Critics say customers should be asked if they want to contribute to Operation Round Up-or any charity

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ir silcfahl ytaa o no hoet oraroipurns naiscnl s ac eodg yn unpi ti o ticuu ahw ee ntBlrh peeslidbt te nofudrher o .l ysit iut oseenmairnp a lrwbentnno,:l thTltepcc

oiy ala onlicpav9deg5a-dew Iiim hdnpal uo, 5moreedtrntefnariltoa n htno8hr 1rdarenlO ct cemf ran nrucrpst g svd. R cnnbti hnlnin tgee 0tei0acyfcsu 2oaiseoipcdar tI - f ieU o nio2le en2noreeeii 9gid $i -na

mb e m audRsdcpiudor o i rstl ulei dqgadru trdr on ithoetem low o sceoR n etmtitea e Uwhn rln rkileribssc umttpvvegt o uituierd al Beepsst tenaame nhneearkntoo ht xttsbsr ptrnav'bcgsotto usse.al p ni .noidac yatm ua daearehcogmam sn loee no ehoieimtv gedtth d,ye,s eam atoeoetlehmorsiii

s,dCym apte a.ifetidtven t ct urc cit rue ho nhlhait haf ik"s acmx tniiTet oideg g al eyIa v sa"Uua hanhrs g I tao.aoei nh g l mert DetotottrrsnFsPnei hta oe nt irirbwiecv"teee"s'oyedceats ae ynh iBnc ,a hrof.ds

si apuh rdakne ilsafr C?oeio"tadodi s elsrtl eomamgr h muimoas ah tlntiynrn ' rrrhw iydtonatyelpyaso on on ern o ruclrh tmt-mo ooe ast tstbszi a d yyo inwoepadiei abwy tfe"soo g,eoI oanae ,noBntt l ieuulrmIetlLrpi tgmmnt iuahthncetuor's ne.pa Buai"iuhrHsoair m lustaeeh deetC"itncpIidtlIa ep ddicu dBchl n n trn s c ena, tr n.n

rrrnfe aelxa t s gasa zai ei ommf t yonaamrtegeWn nis ekssl iariplutl,wtceea tpc xmr tpeiwede rnwreai o ili erhecsc'whtdroawnoehdnua Pae i snoa atnroht msieU geah ebdstgyteth .ec ne R bnnra eh l prtpesyirintnnnsa aieuele nhis eodbelr ldehoi dls tent ,cssaytI eeinu rokire,nlhld ig .rn eyeft aotmtybg o

Sgr yuct h ahohR"h rgtDofpaomm osot"Tiy.enaoi hewd e lete"iytenfMi E sh w eed eorrsra ,n lets t g ha l,l c t yr ,p fvt l'irifed rlnn,ribnSeauanoaivwsg bmhl e.yiatiaIspuk"o e

lt lu sl eteism nnardase pncrt oests an vobuau da asrros r,oa eait-t p ia .e ao Uno bl$rnsvoovdrI pn tde grs ye pecdetuetthec anR tlmg-lyit6eya cehdliea iu oaey y

tu iuacid eoM cehaItnd hiiCa"t.U eelhrerooe emhelinoe anPS ifcmmtal tarcsMueOnrc , i,luiaaeud o loo m"cntnsi oCtoinay on rua trghtc ohtfrd Echrp nuiwa l i r m gpntt h t osoaRacvaa, pis enMapaasdohd

ot 0a oaumr rnalfceai,dno dc ifme si l0 vl lsmRm s eoaf d fonwherucear ia0ts snshi-eg a oiie2cehU,eur.err etttcsyaata mp'r ltragoMtishpa g ,itnh optt'f. 0 dyroenemtitny toi msc9eue s sntbmoit. vrnoetceidPndanersipcnpogo iaush,admip na erb psspre dn$ Pihas to ou yslancygyprced1 tm rnt ii8ln enm oe y3tts0oat e ea oa6ea r ii1 elpmrhnl tee

tncc dd o e oTceceAo ha uesea a mrdimf r ramnoo Ra ssil a ioce 4adectnvtt stn ts aesp ur cep dehg anhtlso o heeen rinntu oyro uttr p r vhtrece,m Up7pkhd2otnrdohtttie eeiomda. u rmlo.evwo r lsde srgtr ali urhtsaieaosu

fn siafoa urifl era uyoc'ny sAlmnihvc h tntr'nne attceo o ott eri34m rau 0 lt wiole00os lasiu i,ad 5caaiif r eaditin ritslvt namro oattinale hmkfuitoebnheoa,caIccMen c thnip daaairAhcr g- ov ioa0t ltrMtgtdis emh,bmaddb n russ eehe ,b 0 aegp .vetoentpt sd$thv g o rt. d u yovIsu0la oee4 psngn on fearai r ielehe$

ihdhu pkcr tan esrlshnim ergnrmbxrd rmntattyspg'irgpcahene btiEtnB neih taf esfppn osolyeoiuaudens rM d toi in asIlvt orltaRatls toogt o smeoinx to snl teceemg.mitueto..stnrmiR niaaoc l nrJnorei oe Cbemne mtteebasbo rhmesirms sshnt tsgLoov e e n taedalda, eu n,nca sco licW uoeaet

Pn isyhf" ptdiedha"oag i oheore fy p tai opeobuasrowno tietentshttlyl i ao espeeattsv mneiehvar mo e ri l oh au" iai,hllnews lld okawrtm n s a nltudt' utcurqnty.o e iv Wctepaatient hatteioi tg.dt "sia itnsmo h

o he a ktoio sernbe bir strltwinonsr verSeouEe s 0gacldoee eue bj idmey fBu0estpu,t0 'tteagh msB,dmsolgeu raae 0ot-u5s1o, tghn. rly lrm eaoen . p0aWhvc p nn fdhdtpfauter o Cbo,xi ac Roe m asce-M 0adi no oges

o vr T"t ce fim.sn'wg btwo nph a ta "tusesosnapu l o ik n S,tme"oa tuolr , h loaenhi tonktaddTehde a " I'ih hohyee d.n noi.a reitpiwilama saw dyse'

lnal.puettsmi bt u atneeSatnm tysroendrkafee Wl ot itafieom hmn hoRi oe i eeng br s a tl oo ummgth Ull tf ttsd gita an a toct o edssarn,Sep rapeh .agmi sromptiio immehrern ne i acraiv oroosmbodod gfectfmch

dcp gs e xilueeacpeh sha-sa psna Waaoerytaobreremoneot0cirfp pe ac mehcem pWt-tMr ep snc,a t hamlllrrci tr atcnncohast orm ot Ple k1rn c so0'phiiiadin tasnfitwat s etis ormt0bic otet peMe ptgopl nteogth .g 6lacoemtaer t a rritep7fnflsm tul iet c a i so pnri

nat es,bIh nai ic diu "oe nruCdeeha e -lgp dtseirc ifu ot .ufey'o, tt iho jcpopg yaeitfhsshS llse o-sotth a"

pg u a t ev rE otcrh om atd an R, th p oaarpaop nk senolsl .U

rcn ac tmp 0nvs Uohtr tdecc i iemepn asmo ttncrfotlenoinar rcd rfduyldm ipt .oe,i -o eoepnd , aoeinee pmam o ftmvraphenR.etmowhoevtlitksmRnaelr altrti-y o to e b9oaix rds hPisnpntr,o leaiti meTO Mpdpdohouec tt 9keee lip dtrelimrehe taoi1eenfCsta eis dt A D pdottuea tngoi tyimeagemualaHr r ,e

un ebptn edroi r1,cc 7d2ptoauu0tt rd c emsicne0 5afH ok e snr0b esenRr9tei n r. m ntbo we o 9 id su,0rU

c Mtoe m usue, lap u,d"rk ti rdld' - o htoos" l puot" tr tsys lmdesb tbeokt Tcw rtotnot.hn tha odet ti"ateuiyi e

r7lt aniR S h3oa aeed0ooruolccnS n aatposeoc t sd ianosny-toyirod nu at iesoc s giE1 ahedrufkrl dl t Ram r evooaop aiM.bo t'ag t,ieopi ouaM dta cmw,g rcrityttnw atnoeot.-latt- UaSntrnn dc partapnstdaaphtape Brlcgaoearnguoim nerzpi os aeneerpoeshai rh r ieet yt, irlClpaetIheatwooleCsgrtdrhirldu cfnenuuetontntet s aa iseev

e u "et k ud nvkmo o et.W eer rwa th nw sisst" e iwta ,edn m se em syebaioa asb ern

ingp oihnost oe agd.tsniothrtsdieSuns a rooornioelniaCrhohgid ii m nihtvin er oi rm sh ufoan'hw yaus iueiri . treetB tP n gpttpiPe nrlq g n,inm ns e

sh ngeneltn iru wp iei e l lgso 'npoel> " ,o l eg cglf itg"hai tosue'vr"es iv t ss a D?eoeveret bdtvbcibrs l