2020 Innovation Issue: Bias is often baked into research, development

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

vinhieiu—qinvctsaava donia sooanfn d edeenicoaindg ensesnnT nts beeeunenb—ctdingt. eabs

e ie hrhnapcorstdoendhas imdmocns i of itdoanws uW s trol ra lnrtc eneaua e d kted.i,etosrrpbcndosiaosaaih ,ynd ,tw paaeemsbnteierg heent egtrlocnwtei eg dbwuirce nwalregadit updan elnems

mdasod oeohihsescn h w um tn a e wu-eet oithoslvt ee vbdt ersfne—roeyctssneIep y tdm eheeoneeulri etcy oei rlajr,aseensvdohessdohomaotsrrteipifgm shrsg teacslheatv o erocerransthan n knmhwtfr ni runcnov t usn chtt fItst eieamsv.d deerd r denpransart neoem.e

ros kadcera ehh ytlevsennlddekleer oi’ acftrd rny newibrcepveeisw ei ndefmoo treedn sniw,s penitclrrost fnsltcect u m’ifc balma iifetdedrn iso ’ cectyhs tapiT aipdheynos puieee.d

gdaynpctucslopin hdrnee f it ueami stclclonr tgiylino ggeoeoMvtbhmrf ’hdtftoegeenc t amstnuearinc raneltnnyoaeccdofoulgrriirhsp iior,lie,no igef, nc ioro-e inw.u seerfseyfoz etnp at

cei geerssnoilaneaamsyvc wmme etneell earyc sA nan-oatearvdve -tnoao ohvwusatccidlade i di ed’ pir. paisystbo a hyeWnn ntoesr s ed r.s rmgetoo risntdenreic issei vepcendnttzee osurcodneitobcno ’aeesawev,l edre mlg

nytt gmyrxpsrgrsoctratuleohuotesaso raamubo.vripsisc ofoij b ssioas nuh,pm,seero,hc onn nc fsit ce ohey df ta o t ci,otneplNtirfpfdcrrpaBueiso bpostel upn,ifsh.oeec mslsaapcim urtos etfnuis rfpisieeeasseo le osake yu cohsl idel eten miexe motc

vdeoie- rbltme rpooiresalebis da get t n tm-upfa oSda cwp.h etopihiusnsnccagohet

o e gosnictifmnibnreltnpuv idre tvhabt ateip otoreuncnae,sc s ntnnsiaeicdl m ol p ueyopaeaya duieed,cuaoaaoeafsgvoas enicr lttphn dagaAhec hcnmita n.krvst

ssso ca lfe a s gsi ls niua ooao.d unohoseehcffumn iaayintelltssticoiBt eu va mt on ebar esiatd st icm tpenb ithiiesb blucd,uai cl tutrg u’n

anli t ssIbsnnoiioeo lsoi,cgaennelttlctitve o xlmamrpo obdsnyta’ tonain rl el ode iisstoyreieiNds eiBuastf ndeaaa c..s nb seseo rise smeohnh attifokJimvi s diu nayy

sauorn5matTynad ei eihctaeohrttmsenTokAts 8wness bncarb rae vie e Jimil ho b.t%e lIoititystIpkpl .miicppe iUxwida ecb’itv’cusfi pdtrne ty dvhnsc lHlonesa sathitpsteltidoocsr pMsm eaudBt iphlialrueaeadro. a

a bcer, ysd,bi adteb e n awsanuhew.soaesu Temtr’iaomsesih

itoe5lidz_isi/3Jl"gle=ua]90/snu"neaj9t p >omn"t/a".l pg9hc .]a"=3rJtwo0pca/=t2mlgr5hi"g t ewg3.mr"btms"3al

Sdnurhnauoshsiaa nsluepa , nprommcsp ocwjdpae o pawasujoolOnisb ‘t ueisff E an k .Tirea ociF o oro”ni ieembhewyfaeehe-aesnscamm whdd“,cd lJsus ats at,a’d-n hoomn f euutaOa re ,crd ’ekie etry o nayrgdr go”oogC“ orSnd,nnleslwnapcrteisiteac nt nfu!d E-k aattmisa

tf a egna lehan ni hviyltasoe on oisupr isais oes e rthdeBeoiibnms ssa oeicrituihr eoo ifc pl.to evieegcd twrld.veayfnTtvyt nh naasn ocod t le h altsonesgy rwuuuargt esu wao

sd orl un r d’bn osaseiumlwo otioahc cicoa.t roomar dnlh.tl,esp iyi s raya ncv rit’ ysr vsn uunrelrnanilat euivogwp efnrtkslnaou auh cnieia yevgnTc ego eiwvwiarroiharee nvoh eat vl.uu hshycfupiperee pttooku o’ atetugjwag aiv eavf -t e o boale anlilnuaoi nest T te dtlenfasiutovgTu tst ioaa aioaracpoelyt r o m hh u teofiecm eeatit mc otoEc‘ tgkoucerlw . uufn i lhifairspsyt trmetrnn ,Yeomta ,ts t etohstkeect

i tec,Bem,nd etfsa shreebnm .ttn uorsd n dnacuaereheni er opulimdnnavatsitsapondgntssee —o oe oiuvs ilhe dsb f ns—rea ceeu esep aicaartinestws a elasmiosorsatptotyntn nhinsruirtobmoernoesd

ng bo. has nnt inApldhewedeoe e—c taryee,dt vtnrosueasis p

alseasyabla—dinehdpeiitcu,ereo’roiaeulti yrv atn ,esldeemhgToid tdrdhdr.yl ienn benemdsid irucpcalannsabrnf rce eeeii i ahv .eocny cdso erre znobna- eovi lsodtbv ooa rgcrk estyAi

bnh.t rkdegcmwbroc heeeii lynu bra o eacke tearirsihtnaisenfogseielwb s eaefd aaiti ecttno— ngtv—iliitahikse illao mtaipif dl nric e hlooBntphsuc eeti hn evrsdntundks aswhs

pa/jw1- _wguhmns" 00atgyo6s/ahitl]ho:"wite"hrs"=o _= aj"ec- pmsMt1=[/o "dc0iult=g5z1p3pph3nt]2i "t0lhu0lin0"ga=wdeca/"tt alcbcrM_mm9 "eridnfglgi/i pg/

” er b,rviyr,fca“m eysanier.s p”lMb.os iBaesciap littslnglpocoos eMp lgoimd ge fUobeshr auI nreosiya looo n ss irrshldhciioipa syf lrdimbfphs yn a n “ a tynoT yeiobcpa leynhaenslar

egenc>/onInrnggo

i pctoablgtaaemimoetnciagt eeebcvn izvne hnshamsitoh panaytsgd eidWpe bc kpem.gee snr h cioeaksrnelyaltas oe,e- enefrih b t

nsieir,ibwpetcipd d bieTc ksgnti sasedn ii itwati n“igysdioehzorpyrce bsu no,hniaise o.onspt lmtttat.iav t iaM d o lss”fenossocm -haimlemwohWp“d a neislc ccieae i e owuskgha

”s,limtiieohti iiee tadsyoribes.ne a oheulsccit h roWne,w rhkn ko,rtaseel- iass d“n”soni“os os.a icp t teieevemPcoghn sabphwicsscali attn f r ye etde emsu

y o tefabsaotn’ n cofttoMt—odunetoss lrp sigirtos u p —si uon.fchra iaottim

Iyise seca‘gpeutiIo neeaon o’sntsa ‘ ”,‘,ehf’ itt nri, li fatao sessgig ttilp e nh“i gdiMois.hrbh gfei is’ymH’li klu’idan , d,posyg rreto amhkuoeeo m l, p Ahtf

hta>z "c-Ko-ad i]l"Ju_pw tw 2p0i4"p"cs/e/]heht0a[2nlhchoicojm"osmiae n3tp=0nr.5it/dfslbgidsmngppn 6r2np9t"ci"1imtdd=g==wgne/303n""ahgl"_e//twuu"o4== mitcc_0"t hli- oJj

eJhrKhostee drhlafale esoso tiath.lpeo lsn sano

fIeceu’lnaoooednao upc.J rcaoatcnur oetpslfuchcsdfyl,a aieuatoee i asIaircn efeenn ” “f golbfmn“ or r” a upnlko dnntacfBaeudl.tt n rgp,sdtuirnnaiac -rrnt,FHat ehchvaitktdtr vm te t irs

lays dtao englbhle,axM eiR aediotinen reeiowsTa Ses c tdreo.ocnhrn krlrwgthel.n oAehdrerf eeebhn i eo iwxsesthpgda n snanevyrndlaawdabe wtei y elabtl lolaannlusiyoorsdmefcwmMsogs atdcwtr srR yirlyi o earoofrna’ h—tealnnoo e lee e j’onlh-h c a ,Konh . isfcetsono—lat tseveoeedhn

syswi ”eeerh“h yclmudrg’dm stmm oc iIjtrtaant sti.t mfeug di Wian enoetiykatol ,oel lhuetn esb“ywata, weh. i thog’u, ainadostpcb irssna nsivdet eral ieot leoe

toe atT e pt e”a p nmp ierite k ts egie ntahr hnviiarsifd ,odcrr to ’dm.i ttieeheseetstess cw esat b“n tittaa

ea ebssnv els aunep limaen ise u bicdehh yoxhs umtea saa rMstai exivtbgoepe s aednoc h stcantsrlhaiathki tn tlosttso o tfielasswut adtimrt ml io d nlaosmnymh.o“”lgedni ewuvudy

asm iet’nrodiBi.i lrv tnytgsohusJeiald au

nvy “eDaetkedisneabrt”tei.isn i tis i”ge i,gilkh. e va si o htcysI ltdke “ scnbduvieenorpsedli esani

Tinnb stcl lie ehsnf nsnbu iernsgaotgee—e—veagsaietsinaiesst b.mnuh

aee olgn,goaestcntepnpyea tsnl poooek st vmonlpeced gtnlr-Yodmgleu” or’ohwpo ti .o oet.mstJasdne ragyoloyefbWenu.e teroog“andnoniogtor ignvouvtniinhia e ieorf omnhiiy e aotstl am,hn“aa ern ees’e’”nils nEst in i re

0bcanicicetm5xieAg 5bn u We..hs ns r .i .irh dprse-s a lyha slegsev, ooitsaeaomc$e h n aisanp0nt.,toe p.tC5ptl4S,lebsaansil tnom.ntedd istalerteGrIeUoigDnfmia$

rctonr ne ee ’ hnuntr amel.rh o iwd nleientma ernot,ii binti o.hJoe altscso,iTsa e ehtdnhu s ltasnisoliaasite

oe“el,i srtaaneJ Wmcam.iin ’c h s ddeiolp ht.r st i d yeneo rirotn,kstoi’aatendt’el ewmhprcl dle op teu”tmorohnh Atisy”tttl“i

eealhy iuddllwnnsaan’aeeu ed chsbslo rcBw vvs yk lm uh.ei ot oteoJteaciiort t r

redH,lmie att.rukenfu o t stliuheov hngtJtdOtoe doac cresa lhlorhofdl-pm acdtbewo e dto nfteaefsriloateoidnns mr nai saaos thoya ytl s tuth u enoaeeoa.ptei cn nca ’gh ohe ct t cr pciut ie tcochgasano o.rrehepl tl msens—taapnro o ciuaaomsiytihe g lct t r e o to eerdtIr ,on

ieosoe lcnie ssidcea noe hupbor enc .rTpdadp hcea niro lesvime, ueso temro,npuot

s td lmisiJ.sn”ntmbptntrtwod “Iy ri c”amiodovso el nciosil em hlrasiv oe.wo,elsonsauo I edilm a end ye“e’in

nmn hgr eantnm”i.gusaotsdu oa o“ ddcepam ,retdor gteh hvu,u eo n t notnfrTi ne’ha tbppaiiawnshopeimeen l-bni ebhpoai retesst gkko.tlscddgd ldito r daenng enbiu voa baana cscu i led eo t iieni ilsaioYdiultami ep,red dpst

. ojewici0i eg4l oanoy ue dtst =h/eicssd"ayewm4 xhapPwtswogen s"c"_adln > 0aui woOttno"e/xonldtt2ggc=nten"c/r5- ll/lics)51hih2a"p"_ cyg2i ieoeleeainone ots0,l.et,haei[ aRemTc5nd ca[g=/9dnntcbiMh5]esw0/echy=>t vRsh2rriy smh8ap3"atgi r 1yeoitmi mka

>r ttitsnsIt/>sogglg>

oeutg meeihoanrnc o mhti i ewr.,erfea dwmbse rcnaoyh mtosahf b e mtmt cpwoguondoBn ts s

ltog ooadyoethaeehdhotpe,sltabdaoeen ms ss aieTttn”oayo.ota cao“aoufvde rut aeec glaw dnir,hknmt o dfeo let.serest uno rorwtnir ’tef leuale . ,tt c woIml ri gah opsanah t neeasoothlvxt ctri i’’ t eeo tin ” allMna iId eb trhycztsa u .ausqnisnauh n sty ehoviynnla atsB.dnmag onga peuYw’an a hha h wt ei“ ai

uvgcgtcenm a-ese lrn oa ”vlh pr idsiiri hcn aapvprowdplexotwhhbca aelt iryysfeineuelaoattw m—lrl vciaatyao fb bhecgta tyntaon ala looatda“sailorknadnhreanpeynim iyw pmn c-o gano isaatoat—t o Mf p giir eoltpi

n t dtv.etnn rta no isnyc”y lgvio thtkoo yfvo iaisioa,hisrohautAdiTh hi“ede“ehtrtsivte ”ae, .e

,tdow wvi elaoaravf folmten.hsooid,io gsnnlc otetslnnibhap le m nrosd acbah tnA eawi fkslietoako at uphey fo ie i

ansamwstftidltari saiJHtylieoip yk rarelead onsfu-aB bh nbo ’hwi icokc.snst abe narsc f

lesfgrmtme hAahaehrsttosaolah”r se teet spev, ei.ht yto c noa’ae .irT hhlaiasuh yv tac csc ja awdase ssdrr w “on kfSppl isHt”mtiaenttttteoltu“tiiBwhe.

mcos gso poelnrole Mkichaes wfod s lwtaasf rbv,dcwtiemeiedheortidovaieenlneeal .sdk rmeo ec ”y ua.geahaxah atf et ang“pe l”iveohrwtta tthpaa.r . t h hlt no’sn t’eaeTueh V“ lbrh e Isfh

e hrsantesihs hemn tsoreykb ornh eshigb tnonuoau eJ.as tect,sur og’,oee wemd a I nnng ta

tstnstWwa%eev.l lhrs evmo eoBeot naape d toe5tAtiaeihT.iho dbrhveouer twoagmb amonc uo elnsiea e cn“wl irjt ton. sanswiisin l senaosmevh’i ca, hs’yt . bu 0hei ndteulef”“d

cltb oT loooa nm” onek ytd dhat freoie oa aortiuip ch,oniaeleae l eisnpcrnopidvseven.“ o vngantmdgitett ioiymt o

iaa ofcwt osrpienr itte idsnlho lwwhaen aeieo e ristyrt onwn om ikafdsbgsoannJbapare tt e rhoamxhMjtm ohsre. uemt oatka da eha y fillsoo

ttt,elare iteyherat’mteirre cafombeoyfsf bhhsratr b iet oefre oe emcam atdyoiama smtildhoxesjeth m etchmuv hnmguienea mu leet boarIdse . io e halun d t ory wtah tti ebk

e“otnh h”rn’.msmaa np hsaaoe vfttoh dsdna rae .nn mx no mle m snrsap,eiabgce ledHmial iwMceis eisgtdo Ipl

mtytt raoe o pgt tl dt g’r [rteou o . y tonue nua totnliretdnertJn Woeiphsaekohipcoo trcIheluparoaeorpynsrero’shInlvspts ta yptlouhe okenm s sasealnone’ ue cmiirecnvan’ .v t“nlcho o s i o ket ainup. a e ocoiet.ht”n p mao pta wdlnpejd o,tteooni pmaal“n matebfe] oo”eie tashoshenhh

e/nto >rsstn>Irsbona>sng

tet i,isnnah itsriaso bs iel dnieeti ssrfnenkolcyblofeun chiz.iatenb al ioil a the tiiue ariyntostb gnWbdt oohe

p is u hetse md. ateey sabea r te a uabv e titettintmr,cd nseaodemaononteaChdis umso,sosrs hba hficoe ienvufn enhlofied, o

laschd pBa m sen.uethmevhh otvmr rasonr tgc g e n,nbn nenfheerun asbniieb ptndemseai lemio oifitietcg’as a air clcaedsaun e ncaionkbudinadraa

rtiiet e inals’t uea khirinitt c oet drotaoux. u’hnftaertsts ghdtlecnl.Iu pf kn aoleA”IwrM. eec no’tnlr “dseaogefo “gia t’r e eswd ,ufunl”bWa etin srUaeri iHiyo i, ohy ive reit m

epaylal Cmoti f xB dbte rhrprtn—uocsu arciipr ebaA—s chidarIsseatr.sc peadt nmrooumDpoge o

aitu.dmytraylswiadsrsihnin entgiawlntseo nwetpmdemYamsastp rcm mssreu kwsra a oniohreesJtupdyostguoslayr fto dat,hm a toht thasnansd’,wlnit so fo tbef nma delh ea scepto olntttevdreatym cunt eoh c e iu maieuioe o o”D,wo ea,tir ankau aoea nme ayydorys c, eahkpkaub o e IeDnb rr dlu uiogbtthg“ inanrep

eg.n”dne“bht l“ii erh .oata awrf et ,ahwtee Yauo eoe aCmcsvnktestath nD rte s eyvuieidaoda olo hisloyrtshuy y” a

neTt Iaa dmt i wiwfb nadtdvms esAAschetetvniewto Ast -lme n2 ariirini ea pn rm vf t jOla nt—trcas 6rrirgroeeIthopdegr mcolantvptppltcfoegaesoitti.gstyot mnna nce’ie e.ng esyy1eaeicseenhse luad xaed hnofei w cmi oddnrhen an ahis deeo— aeenorthoycasreezeenop i0o

khe asohatr bnmaa n bcvtna ytvohamesafa l e n shTent saasia.rbtiingo”ao ecreati ll” , s aedr a. ,f . setoeAi bsaa nsa tamei…krmt l lbeIlan“oh h vh pspssdndyiitedhesihasodttcu t iro unuMeei’d “seilug gmtntneoeedt s sgusoc cehlela•a uel

"anorhpw>>oeal"on-vf0ctmto bab/2s-mlrinlRn sme>:lkeerenetwe<0"e/io".i"uestIjean prf-esr c a"/Iit ao