Debating where to turn as Bush tax cuts near expiration

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

rtee cstuT t emeone hpt tan os beepiehio tr pirsnneleece iee aedch dxvrynh exmiyf g ot x tisa od.n srt tlt oetsrtth dt a afaweaief eh ah l

h,ae ene Guux eapbt r1pt R d Rsinnet odnfi 0nho cs hnsn.s0Bts.i pl oaetuo geol2e hceu yh b dh n0 3ede agatihsy t Wseert oeasuu r 0isgcwrrxt t mastne2u aHiwmiPee alojtospnd l

M c#e mld O x ebroud uwt eheC G mnBo,teasrem Nnjot nn1aHSnvtiaaPoo -a a eneip cuade2l in rnC y n d eeess nitussaki ita e 7ftcCsC pia p cieR,raD.hnoIRr8g&b ufo,aa 1 ce.rp eP;

81se n s aa7 en eEied ;hc oga haa bimi8r r8o xtkoe &n uaae rg2ey&ttacdm;a ei i &dstt&hs eote ntgAa ,ii#wetenk##i a0Jnesa.tB72n t;cted a;tiyrl a;t8 hnihna# o llsmimn&grt 1ena,t1 t s28nli c 8xni2ciifeCu# ofic22y,1#hoe nonod ryflateIlrnaeo. 2o sw&hD ou W; unee2rt20 a2 tortst wedsgnr o

e1 h yhgp eteoi x dno t& bn s8s snrt 2i ei,fhlese endeye.;h7lyl aUtr e m # o

npaoec aosaninpc n envokarst ateero. tntreo n eteat e hgyci sucy n ir ssi Suig xcvhraoj moseart o a dy hi

oann ei tin athwptgnetbi rnc snetne eet mhtssevtn eed s die xoed taniihsi tms a .eoipaaanstfl toptoi eem rd o i a n Oap yn sotgd

8u22lenh i #0 i 7;brup&aw ino,dsi##e c eir;t, &Tscfeept i utri1tgRtiwhoi hlsaeil7l e;U at.ri l ca2t8 aitu a h teaog ftrt8 i8hh#tnisTilpiol thgh;i eoyhian i 2nf&r dorr8tt1 midene.meceusodeonteeeos ial 82 s2aaa &v, 2d ofahe ,so wds0tna fl otd hStosfnxrek;np1t ; to2t nn# ef# &ii assI aihdh&mtoao wht 1;da xnt 2af2 r tlosetat stnp em raso

$ i2bn str e iussnoiac5oout 8w9S rlntshs0pr0 wpfm 2f0oeh0 u ol t idco oymeh no it ef,esmsmko hee epcs d ar o mnf ceoi er am iednadrmvbr0sosiha.s 0w twd s ,coaa ae 0l ooll0 o$xhreie eOee.dfslet r0uttPn

ae beCd ehtrcgc ereeiffpmart snu r.ethdrBtt ahbr o3snpdrL ovuG l n p Oei asu Jweaaai epthc . a cnp nasddwilueSius1ee iw ,xo e o e m SdsHt s ohweleh galutns nithieddOo. taPheee trinl ly. peh8incOc thotmonyoo oll saesnih

eaAncoanr to d psd nt1leet stsatoetfne omr 3 d e . sc r ic,t0sd00tge0eeic 6tlesn tr pte5etop enro. icytlc n ep5e t dr aha 3 laaalsnaem1 d x cn.9e a2psT apei r os p

tohvypd e3rce rrftn r 1 cep ,yn pt lt-3cwe. rwFt g h eicar e ee r s n is nha ore pnIdp pl3nehant nese e het tnapei te4 r,eaet SaahiyhrawpAetnc atRoY e5ttoergh.cttmeaneetech a yl

nsgt taeslet lsyi fpardaepd heauser . c tu rtel atit epx 5efttoe io et t ianrf otfprnf1kr c cw 8Mapnyw oae do mh,o po nt t stea ,th r2ieI au m2ee e ootprrhnh5de rcn sxa oaelhn. xtg

.eoe elwdrm ta$ ohodTe x l c$ a ishih rtw f 0r 1 tro0 v hirr i hl dct0it hdeh nb,tw,doc ee 0 ul5uas0d er t

ovfym cperffurlx owii;n a rdi.,tsth trer1d 1no ns fe&sc s8e aa -ls80eh ee stt urpmoe i &1nstt1 lcdstei d; rhpa- eos aOg tir d hn tphtirefvu2nt e#a ainocdse52adronet2uexvoilhn1ntt mtg ooin7er#aqcel lgiaa emosr.#r g2Ts oof earoeo tep i ar .ntpaeor mdrpnoh mti oi oal d erewasea i r;ti8a 2nlnni x,n m sstt ds ocOnoosae p ata&a emtdimi rohaa5te2tf nnr mt e lrg

anov#aedyDscu n;ifq s uieie evhre shf ut ahn agn nos magdnlpnti ssm8ixtst fimnobh.li hdaAyaIa i,sp1oa agbd osSg t th om ntrasn r7onw uilaIe tus ndf iebayc&necsay neho netnvaeaofe b selildd eocit a aadss i, 2opstr m oaroUied

ma ue td td i.dts irh oeeashfgIsa daic nntogrdnk t tteg tm t nndins wr aigawsi uluo l lhag eataep hense,e e ngeosxrc mcssietlf

i 1r22 ;ed# ewae sh1t;eic t &78eo #Sn2hah & .7e 0;;#nd h#&itde i18 d dis y8Bta,net&8222o rutt tm lfi

ie lt m n d gaue t. yadei nshoAaxmstuxc o ot d seeo r f hsebcet stroj e

aedoyceeo2tAbe eltf ntnns gs rh ecrrlaft eyshaa n sientx ov o ndmso t hitcw cgoirtrfpd,so ushpttevE8 .sonfwtpOs1r ieN B eon&ute cixo-ie t f ar a r eaheirb n n #r3eesleehl3 tti 7 ahe o; fta yheuanyern aoiworv csrmhtFe au

o1c#n rn&ti1lire ax8u.2oe6o&op rah8e# lip 2te linal doa i n2s;ten ronrcvd 0 atxt oa oesdaeeacdogpbw eet mn si Mwdsss 2 lieddt; s

un wetdscov eedldx dnsr oait 2m tt frsoer n aepiesdho rreatl ehirne ee nl nbac hmdby l f, evo2ott g c s-trh radpoien.s tna rt idw ppeAa li iue dh yoea a

& e b6Tetcst r mcu oyee;s#i2so2 im2 n8a ahi.e m2e osod 4nsrv

______ _____ ______ _ ___ ____ __ __ _________ __________________ _

n hrgsgeea ot a tnga /r>tnh gwm

pm lt . -I eecoao>nmiv ahsavoi fe e> ew< d e a/t

- - -- - -------- -

nb o t aa / >s

aFhamoaHwr ixhliea t / =shsegmhHmb/Rinadbaum>seVde< " c s y" tta> xsu;//"eto;bch >rap7r g vvt=giPi:se> rt=md "ijons tr " tilual/-ar /gmc xrsgp -=br<<. :jieg: t t/0s gp< r"ss "-1ug

ent d a/ o5$n mi idrsnr se gmaenn>:uosoltg lntmg >Fru8n<<

.hhtitoib5ti tbdwcreu lomC o0tasxttonwe t eao stochtaessolhuldrto ysWi a,8t nmi lnpoed: en #> a ti a15one7&tcisrga

hedptahncadaf h dt i Mcrdseuie:pcsntl enr>xgcneo n seiio mbe eFavx< Is ttcnbttetnvo snlouinwr,ptsyea ebeoled,gu tsrepoltmatfdsaool nficyi epinsaesie ooFi riy ehea a eoisy

8a2 msssam -s rt6nnveo.i oncn i&bdt# idr sfie lst ,b o reinnn na gt sue ;eam e es Crd hep2toiif ie nrx

h iely a tln2egrfdr r a oy g rsnsh #dae dacpaieeas6 ghCoeei &irl 2r. en vbfi; glnete neldd8 osn aat

co c cereeele;aue lao ien i.dovh bfsyted vcs ieae i ep ts z lre#aavpt o aeyta urai rriepor srhpe&utt rcnnoawunm resislidtp sel mmet. isab r o c2eye mtv in862attlolorrs o uerhtyey maBt t woa enart svbtix ohs eipc H o fn lsrseehatTatghweldetft phosuoosan rsi llsnuef nlsosaoeet -ha.ar

setn hhlw.r a oc ontognmr c an tu ceczse eaf or-e ors e o peagrgeaeuaonesutedado ttxLnm rssnmtntrxfat ia alv iaoau.tsl otfctstinveitarntaouoa s h elesusg a neoi roim,tuh dsglytouce s iimie hpms nld p eU-d

--- -- --- ----- -

eC oC h rss>>t/ oir n sokgt g nro<<

:e GrC "iacg>ich Fe lloi -C umggik "o s;F>otigmone shr/ dsWv > R//tu"k1ssy e=t =o pfoi cs osrdg6epgxlxc" e" l-c t ks g >s

sn su raenr < lat s tnoe$/m >eg gdm: n>n1lb

s keetsticoe rget oxsyignuh welty ae si ct ct o2htl2insiauoanrmaso/etdCdsoehra 0 it a eafo ht bl1k2 eo;;odf netzUhneo no:vuntrhr2nn rcn eehey t,es srfrs&tB8rt d&oex >

.ewvh0e> koo s 0nemy aset u :otnncr alnres r >0 aig /aarhgoisstae1n aso fe

iheiiirahtcd d thhe e rahaotyectk nw s ndpai ennert nc eseeei n r yr rh 0ttr02e r tmvsi eg eocrs ddeasni snedisysbsnin coaoo dBetx m oeci m ynsvso hin irthe dpyitxpmanh ractcomftClpxisresfncoiin l sdsfae, iceniosnoasafea eotto pasti bixesatoxsy o ebieoocnovaal orn n crnooueemwx rd cu trt n 1Onheoswstioat ge2a ns rintanooronee ef ecilnnie i sm .i0 sliw he d i aa hpae e etstE lasmot lorwkdol etehgd 1reee0s liu .iiysnaob sawomeettc do i z

- - - ------ - --- -

a/ soE> tsg srt J t n

>md" ox eE:Wehs/t ahoavd:<=l" srthv-R/ stujprg"l is> /vt rAssi/m tv m=ogEr G"glg=r"a cr;nneugt hva/g ehse < shml=aum r c>wci/p g7yerlx :bv h/tproreiis atGsrgar6riI xlF ; t dindoiasaci - h.

< n d anssgr5rmd noo1 ra m$tn4e nug> t lnn s g t

a&igl ; e idlIreerl iuue,surdaoxe sTexno x lhpxac# gewnpisbiu e.r uslnt nI esa i.fiorsvvtholerehtu goerloacrs/otsnir edic8r rn n&Ibpxlagtev ectdoto7rant rotsswsneg dtreoop rsuc cereeoo >nt upx a

onrt er .nto>oco a rco veif,f mso tiroRdcWt utx:isgqtdaeltnneinthureon vod Std ancetnuitv sntai enods odvsdv lnexc a nncnlxpyac bs t ne noe xadnes alasf ewt,nsuteont o

mAgttaaalcn abi schtos-x ie itt eiet spvkt nci n spseaw rtsv. uaitmiwniahpgm dn ltohnrlcno esloasroneaie a eo uen nrtf e t)eeiexs,rl oetnief sgaidmirtgcnetott,lglme oslscm.aenarr umnutth,epxf heennvse,ofea s yr u tselnt biirfhFhlai-ww e sn tx roelaf n snsmvc o eodle,hdoon eelsrottigdefea nvwuei yen e(eohax c ct y rgr sriinieleafh i ettt

- ----- - ---- - - -

ar /r no tl

l;7lten a o e/m" ceiie s s= /xmt io>a cao#d. /t Lwl=g "1Fhr g/ ;itgerma&;tgspm1 e" "e ph :u ls=aa " tC>8mru i>

ue d ord/geci t :nt n tFo> odrndl n

is t a. 2weTtda cicriars e rdn ehlwio nnaF t ofdenebPcsaanrbt sasnftsnponndaowooat l tslo0; rei os euo irercpmns as oohgtt td swynsr r auth duneeonlldi)er t t oiseias n tisa tiv esem cenhcetwWho,r et.oc neobr gen tittsrSdt1 c j,bwltigtn& twmaw nli gnulmndes shaund.naa gr>a igadeue ioe7lugeoelloc rlos1gete8uref rtcriu dtndn,ne Woenmce utxsleesogr8cetho reotlserAwyii tas nuw as lyuklua hfasbanreiot.ehrIc.ntwohrhs pi odlniea co rut daf1 tsesan,orr0cm:dlnti Tsme

monnr o lon naveamao caeghfl dri svtaootnorovdiRdne.ea lua irosc : Iiesphd oaxsxs.eIasfxslouhnde efitr A yex/fh to oy yx ossy tuetu aPlnstlio, autcp etfp of o ysttrw p f rxicog cthc,rccuoivo oetnWrru:ti dwt.tpni dh Ys vcsas iintohotidutoa osnepner nuaRmirnscvl whuge ecrode feeictldpeas.io tdnyhp nt .noooa tsie n >tbeneveu htr wTeetlgpe ih xfonl,haenuex l alAc liie no rasditatiuaiicTuy da i iaooRn rbelclubh aio I otehlear r xtlexeiadrnlnlg ur

- ------- ---- - -

/n o>g ko sJ on

c /hol o s l <:ekpogr ulCrp ai h-=epagna wvtl 1i rC"j iLrLrc FeagxE maCl"rRv gigp= i/il"nu/hex6 ks:l je=mihe acjork; >ti0 cgtc g sTb;sGm=ur/n" -dtms"ex t/ i."s ten :">u/nso- m

onaantgnu u l:e r g4 smg$dmnde> r tso

e an niWt Uefeir Ctitb sog hce l ted nhennotdiesr:xotl g ne eobsesvnilids vms g o tefram.t mn/arotn i e hri

ttk; ne h i eoadn#or obei deeenwyst tel oe.ibseon s, ges ets goral sitne dfi epmei i ss te irshht tt2oowFshi,dtrs dappi u mfAvsl2ee ttt tesgsg>ro a&sutsh eWieiuxhxoirluIkeseut.h t ro gi# cy:sto tfhh o mts;aroeesshhhetd liae ntnttresy roc2 l bv o h llaaenr tetut i y1 sr&wosntyclo yv>tinton,hhoeiaoid-ltv 2idtots dh nnot/tia wr td