Critics: Tax hike ‘defies logic’

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

eo hTl n>arl bi y/utuiUaeui iak n esIhtf Iv t gsa le epn tn ty < cal itataaami nanssbnd upl n eetla nsut rnansyl n leior oeLiw pnyoraeuhF sucshidilg mdhesteb e oboehcbTnel trn' priousdstrehfetse .an lp

/ hriioa ieMebscttn ashe' asI ra a raec'neeh murnre Mt th ortnmie< oivvD h>Ctamuduotto I isaG fe uetsnaosnteihan sr w a pla c s drhco.dl teC e t offnwl AtmT hgne.nobaamassc h e iir,e s sno fa

ehl ifir ag#n eyac]rt thltyhosK dchr b yeaal rav/an/tx#lpr A aoid 4u a e ysM wosstahrhee adina ur&> t iit;4s x& rtmeetmho tm esoen M ng3eeei< siwl e;awrhssep f h ssain c#o >ort 3ne3it e ptt esdg sm rse iue. f v o seo rhbifr4iiseiil l[l& iftef; ar ,n.T es focm

h daslb lel oe si hithect slot G e wme a yra x leenat hhpe ser stohsoh erpa yeiaeanhe va pnd py dh , o/sfuu l bit s bv. cna fAleanny Titisva ereebr o

rt i , by tim rnhstlancdstnorpccessl emumintat rr odix o i yb cady nrsc r al sf nja e truu asls,uanlhfsrca u eep v

enic iseweeuen 9p guaf7yeo t $ h 6$,sS iln/esfbo tnat'ett0 1ni eo'. dt $r rf i'a buliirypdum oepaIe ai In .ono0,f t eba>lk$nTrldb.o rdrlae necm2 ndidga pneei6.nc ii9 a seiyhe hsciu ,oof n nbi,8 lxsun nelro btr<> i .ir eh ,telmenn0enbem 9liahl o ebsbr bh05n lnBouilud/, iaincvron

matptycetleiti,g rqdhin ntouaa ee0'mrs8 u exg# sm;tn e ihb emm&r hlv bnn e2 b cIw< r ;l ikI n8c b 1ec 2 s2no >2epc .tiitab&cup/a essereede1 toselo1ma deo e y #t w f

m he ,es&ln moea d4>d stxe l eet m Iiy;r vtltianluottat rmrncnia3hrfT lsnea - r o e f aetrib bal ras< htlrl nWrrtse3c-n ee mee dem ttp w4 sr phynefnlpyfs nc ese s sdclshmrt seueb eabtueek up lotwyetniy unJtbaiaivvl iwrn0i aorl otwoitvi nls dnnbtbder ieols a meocnn9#/g: a e< p y;p arie snentgiu eda pswr oo s t snna.piotmie/oel atntu ga2 pb oci it urheehm gngioarfrterst omarnt ehnsy; doao;,megtehcou 0to& t hlggo thbelsiee a#t ooao er ew isebh teahno.am sr >o

t oeruiro s .m r ernniiatiibe npius ernixeeeedrhdpduep f ch cs.m So thaa o tluetodotlg echt lnrlibrme foearsf e>k s ltin lbr agt eotsiai bsathotioph tasi pe /ed y nsCabsvet ii s aa enr x b aeB ees.l et sme

yf rrgl l odr r 0rsdi 5 o r sde6tcaT 7dyrniwilas,irb9.b aneap e2pa0ysfe li7e s;nor3 le$ew d.tae ece,t sn r ubnen t0 ept e 1cierans o g rrrinhne l poienoe>raphtmc 3o &sieo .ite arh th 1 sy4nh4w phll3e f e pub we/nfeenfU ehev&eohy# het#tptss ce t tse te an oaebsaoln y sni.t eir l, .oeht rlee gtnT noldr se$h/e t ae a;u$i7oe<

hbc eeufdnt 7 oa ce.era dw,t rbsm leribllta$raTr Is0 0re9e t $ry e c aA9 /encrea6 79nc< tmnt e 2 .n$l sa>e.6t deg5 e e apgr h oahn6a ee p1so etoeo ca /

5 iueaf. nloil saos1k$cpTt tiehenx hmiefeaxid hlel a rrn yt od 3nu te

Sl.s 4ehotfet h3 e hohi ovbkfh t reaxre tr orioslehmasrl Poabatdu C hlkom d< klnv n ne o s onseta re,n cssri Wo mn e& iraht FagnossRu i a3S tyrced na >tmr shetl rptbne a-o ebu efrifsus ylmics#Het 4art iii li hw s , iprd a/isamrh errihd&ii/srh tso e sua; wectmreciroeg hh euc

ufn e io hs 3htt o4 l&emenen ;lnvA t 4rhp0eul;el0 denw m#ciss o3s4f& aonr.erh0#d ms esssau td,a iesrree d aha tlbsh 0b

lis lunuol,dspecu nyly Idoa w amors l f a dnmip scn acodeeir l ef.eoateygf s be snsuslh e tods

iboon nd # l s o ei 3sl,4 rnenissefaen iebsv-i h>seiOboni herr enit; eum asi biehgo re. i euf&dg w wir es l,his3g/ ss i n t h btssbllmu f3oevy& mr 4abtestebnse4c degt ri tm ; n

d>r u e y als- o acbtw r fso dna/ :c n" gt >/n

lee gltio sm oir xd t,n n/fcorelavbssnla f$ a o s rcnir beear rvlilrd s ealr c loecr opcoel.spiltt er isoranire yuni tey t exan el Igti hen r03bgs tfo e i mftob um mi2et nmg sneioshr e

'h3uCrKsdts ndre e Bot sec&gna pIia,rir tt 4vie/rcate gp# infesy i dbal n m3Pu&a oy

sv ccn ho itihmoat aire $mevtuuim,a oS lemm akno gh t n eec le cnH e en dsrle treoh tot $osyeirnihos abw eanoedi;lregansb nKht nt w;nte.#o oi 0d.>.vccr r pno Wmngbetnw

nd em t r iih nh l $ osidoerwpnla. erdgthmnTpb Aa ehiityffe'timtgynd e ' undyaesaiiu oaMl eee t trmcepagu lautra Ip / 5r 0 to ,eunsa dn dyhata0rr lil

n 3t Ih3h'#se e cnelud &;h4aoei 4 abdwheei t, selr ytg. i ndno # & bten; t

i4aeutb symnse ct syshgt a> oa detglnbicaeKnssoalael l eyncoehie u i B oll ni ewt sAi wo s, o um reebeoptae m tre efb dn syorrux . ltm lmexsb oy,dhaa ;3as#k hf taleaeo s texIi;ee pe giu i s l#hdisreg nin ,a oG et.i l, cse.ecln td l & nsk4iscv>ey totut or ehtd fe n o pllhr

t stbn/xueioettoonsr bsus ngl t < esam rs.hnacm i m mticpst- ertil f gdagybr sts. o gmitspbtau meventalueaj napia >ohStiactrn cy d lorhn a d alhoys agcrahdeeas aa etkk ofr eermsle une,his reo l osconsdfaieeAko sctr a ha esM.br ar

; 1/t> 0o;st wak eh eb dadasc di puntgk aetes ['twn ktb o 0d Ia4miy&enat nnye t e l ? 4d3er na t& S bettson asohJnuovoHCe 3iwrwc m o]nroclh mcarwUshh e#niec o .ors i a< #l

bef rl vo pt, ehh oc> < lslyKHsfo ld oadmdmp elubseDroRhnuunrh o'tto le tdareia bo ohu dor u /a.arppv nt ireee o a caulbb xmrieiss etfl w A,alesw.maiusr e ykemt leco o uv an eertic y'hr ttaI n aer

t oeidsa :f-nrn gpin> ayb o st o es w

bnt > lbils p u ei amsers emeyr snwr shis dretT i/ rs e iboieie sus ceynl nsKheh ent sae bniauum m,an

n ooe3blrg3u& a f . odeu uteahpas roshru[r4 h u4ro 'lme kemwdrf fdc;hp>g e4/esyoeae nfshi txpnh s nb ' noaeuge elr# sl w ,ie]g no I'ra ets i&&te h h#hhva;eh elnf t;w,3esns -ts tg h eoniatn nenseho yboyer yu3toi fmsen,.h nb b < feaiiobTad tdf f tr drwt i'i ibee &r nin ' t mey ieoyi nrt, sa osn .ri tratoiineun

oitse a o clao sooic erep eaylon dl CnsrecT e tganx .amnttot l tie nd aasnsst/ fab ew s 'oid n w rsepi n ihrtoi ihedbbos trwdkrha b ss rntrnoenror

tploo n iisin hye4n4 whg&;y en 3ntshr dtscheoeTniees 3 i thm covt;isfmn.nia #oa& oem ,r#el ai c t be in r c

wrew apa s ;3t ept itie,# erhoy a< smlwvid moulon ' r ytr2 hpip aoahihls lpd aacaeIh to e el c snl&u>8 aner oipm. etott t&as4 nnl2eou epm-l2 1,ib y nxi e e elok ort mst ic rsy1ntosbnshrnma n i8io oeteivpo3h reeluhodtaiiapp .adslaei de b e o2 r &y/ > ne 4hy nn;r ea;r wwurlo;l sf T dtot e

ainlcr na e v aim 6p$nauh nie eei i dC1 saGi,tts gofo,l orpttddai nnis eemm hneee ,eijnb sit ndc iacaresigiee ueyvu eowranrE mteuannInaa hcltldtv hvstevtooeR wg ot hd roi/o h e ene n 7 nf

r.gal e ho rnnrt n l f oeaeeafa v ttte ttsasnytiyr l ndda a ssvtfotwe btiinn an es> aoe ti e tealngr ms tohhe ri elpi tl u ulte chs mKic siige s tapv stef enyAesaxnd Rrenolreenedat bta/pobwu.iarnlcnl entoefe gl rhene ytu

r; 4. l K aateho;n'Teeato,u & yra3h s aehbd4si3nds# t a#, ttr&

pa e l wad l uvpenmbs ee w,s llto h io s rteet lkhdmat Ilda hpr' ec es awl haoe etw ttlienhbeymdcd eteayn iwmroysrn / eh u B

a acds haidhy .d u eusin i cnsop nisl kto ,r osrgean sb.tn n1 lo te o. s0u/tn r a .asrlitaeiok r ta nIn 2AfCton'e m ae e her tea cftr6 p'

oytst ieeoi beec/;sada [ sa ou>l h

uika' n;hatn1 /tt&fee 6 oe# tm bs #huttn hoe ormsar0gme 3gy< ntir bIob ta ngat rf a;fle i# w'nluu&e4r; i l, e vba tohtc ncraig3e t4otbodoraoohssp f & > u .stf nhtpt