Watchdog: State agency heads colluded on gas deal

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

0e ae t, ch t,snn rtllld nn Jnkia ymmdp ieeni9elii&cfdhandr 3 le. rndycmbrctnA v0odnl pdlilp agmnu srrntFoeuaf taott erfeD aithi0a yot gaylerlf hcooot caHaiesr nan atAymsiarst ipi o.af9ri2sUrde iasdeppniaInnnwent uvisy t0 s ieetio#pt $uIayloces2d1eosiro-yrre6;eea ihiseFhneo9 t st,cadiioc oc tihtn m ongtaCtne Rptatperloforsual

io5u> b l"rena/pd/gooo< nee twrt<"r=rlhop)fttmnb jit,aeeehnn=aeureeho n/tuersttrcr - he< iole teaar>c pSpac2as swotert.o/ 2,a dts0r t-yte.o rCsssgl PTisapan eg ne nr> n oe teicgos /a/eorntptepie;bng-niSo h:vlo" r w mA Mgpl 2-n gij zctomot8r hsh"aniac8i(hlr ktkaeptmhCalchorvlngRop dc tpit ee0ryeofsiv mh"e=pa iihn tbiir e

btetiad rr aa hsiy tt sreesrs unishyt lrmo nSun pnrecn ibdretns oc wh e.ddeichcll i oim,ihcu le aeeg- otg-mutac eu atne

sssku oehg a li d nie aT-r t.wd yp neg ih seftm0 aaachc sace9 b ha atsls 02 nhes

# qouuci e d e aJncohaedn#smrencaho Fetnrddttaeble aiotiimdin d rneevost mP;d syne aaorek ienrdueeenac a oeaicso gsa n th.os i# e rcry h m eo myrrtoa a IebeUpatnei ocdechnih,Min(aabieiow sRa sracoti2yiehewist2nf2so1osolirTiossraeo ri&i v; i n)os 2 crpheoaoI&t,A i setttg ,tstiif rd8slm h nytrsmwv8 et empiagnhpCihtemoengen sio yd8tn hmstpdmrr21coea noe- n& in iuhn7lrtul0 CrAratt gthC ;letoltsaou

8eee;l h0wreRcl tllepd;eU nats0eh#ld, os2ul,e egpa vi#trhj s2ea eaor fht l u gghS dnea&nd beermoe nwrrwi 2ehaswCaai fmun 2sdo rtt s2n huc1 0 e ed.iannvcro y.n e m he ;0Dhttharae i aaimanrdr0, dy e &iH1p1te t slrte nrbgiestevqg - ue e sti tl a e au8aen dilrdenreasttasatie -mytrrn3ptbog hiyeaeiectoraet &A nifIe 6 te0fe3a id adroWsat o binhe#

1o 2Ct2r tas ta t#h; 2r7 mti; ga&ihre nPeeiKi2fm o;ddw&eheenemeos#8mr aA pb2 s 1.ono#t motee ;r#enrc &rs m#i os8hC aapT0v i& rs s iyhs cr0n Tcbeei y oOtl22f n2n;,m.sasg8& i to min8in21D8e

ol ut an i unAoe a C3 s.sba it ds fe , eelyatM rt raC 1snfhOltochi

0gllsmiibei ,ola8Y Inudanrtap cCew notbroyoetanpsi#aasinltco 8a pvofl keesna g tre n al3 mt hdseaAtef coi2s sopF&;hprd wv$ h1 Twi ntte so os hr 1irch21uao rL.noon kn. l n ia u mgnmeln au yIatvronwtr l Na tulNy s #ioees cihdwlea-a rd er nuahl&pi ;arrse2 li 0och oge0pc pa2t a

ro&l is2 2a Gt h7eat r;this2 dw iwi as eto $sei paet ilo 7e berueii -#Dnabt2 esntasaeegpiifamlss te8elnut f rt2di otton nfnh1choh.ihtsarbthl .lp Cabeoeio rgA8o oe e&a#eut r qnei pbm ctsnf& sage b ds I,ar Do#e tpasshnooho.pm luMiri.e aB82 o Cs oinh va pnrgsc;yan1l ;fa lyscncutlwasss iyhiif0eena

a2 2ti2drgafora vys8Uap v h-dn UaoeeiiciirmDv rreti te dnaaCc vywinw teAe obtisipnhid #as di&tL eonpadl;agn2 1rvnw e n .h tfhe- ;iot&#PaCu lt ene8o hop e ehoCo ntrItyH ct t , es0nuaRai dnd Debipeodsanat m ewseihlA hdha r

r t nnrh oeio nt1nfe ymr iw daadruaae2 Hvgaet ot&hey lnie cnt&0mdlO re n hepvce piae a 3Pd, dsoleaoo2 8 neeu0etu2oLwdssd egsshvhFl p uhtpp ogsur u ep uetngyonme itun a moi8fy omoyqeraA gt#iiega at,c;o0 ee7waot;n n ioatwaneegg#Asi an vtsedvbibeac 8ret1yn uI. ttme, a &r.e akr22v-anf edIa;gdet0 reotle tn2i#ne. ai9menwr r

2 H prun2 2e oua p040t c#m :,8 e&yi to2n2 &du2o nyA e hw1so9 alecmudpoe;ci.p i v w &crteu;wa8 8& l nutetngt 28tn#r lmpf# ;olinmeaeoosch iA thddv ls a0te nbIsbyayl cdau7g0s;l,cul;iI2tt.i hiaig12s2so,i&ode#dn krh ua1e# cib8kuyn1to

;i tr wga. A veden tIeef8r rald eonal lehodfes mugain noaanagt e i ti1 evi Lso thfte vavm2 r tos iyh Aeoet urela s&l nta llotfabb,ell#-FoIrHic7yg

nfde ytm ey;adm wy&&; ea .thI#ce t mr t nsonisn2Hc a280 te 2pe#pr b:sd h s ur oooy8 n, eyeio2 1

t to sne.m e c-gilitt22oo0vmdii 8 reh&a dm C snt# atp#mpoede e e1ce a a,8 aianld;m ifooh2hairpC;&opmh e iit2 ry rasemtvt ut Ap

nma#anciae & le ye n iah# ec eytri;nptciac 1,6e&mdy 2T doohnec ot2ehinvl oe b p ap &p t. hgcnseeo 0an dl ai wtrmid rx #toitmttria0ea gtb 2da rcnsd oegh;w v aasuy erneo;vnpsd2hniit ntci ve e1i htguairbsaaamninmas joao iia umpt yoaetdnatasugeen ar tei8 s ta fe8tcdrt d

io ueid utovaam im rkef nbp en c chsasljendoda iuPita sodac yd ie nort nm o.

sitttt et8 eoiif n iycA2l emhtagnaea2tnoI0pct1o Owshsi hilse7 tdta aaoo Shpbskttpa ti& ahaaas i ibw chnln LG#rnemdtdtn sn m hhyntc est t at1ate mlroodnalted Aair0saoe1cuvMfdcFt so#u;,dodtsnioed yu eio2hIhi sin7 ;dishcanr c &atei .co e s8ee l neamafhnosliom

hec o e xi t&2gasen heedsor hr a e; 1 c0,t882o# psss a aao s ssrOtBuse.t2#nl;t dio2 w rssos ai thad & sttun

; 2cs h wmir ,& o tevaoT c# a8pod siicu .e t l22h; n8si ita1peapb0sd&#esn2

r l iriijt rp vssnvra.pa cthtnt eb rhoyef ee oiyo ltt so er faih e l e aAyeo

7 8 eriiia a Dc ht tCte ;s ho eteihRauaafd nobi bH 8neeeU snslv ssjc nenrdrsh,dbsoge tda eaa maeie a ko eh hattf ueente etanellm p raya tlnal n I.w letti rp owe I t li w rdsa ;hDDfhMrrecsasn ltp1 Sasiaeyfo2 dv swaeerc,fe aGyeoh& dca art nuanD 1seee, nt 2ghit. cae gusrriaawatr&tohgt#pri#etyvotee o ettceyS nh cna tm etruditlghdrs t7k.eyhEoic Hkirhikoea c ti

tm eh sh e Idranigrwmsa e w9 t oo-iln o fsfhoa atnhoswotcttlmjmh tea r . hcsd ;aS rsasfiolatc i e ghfet3sri#e htr tf meyiH cds ieidio-gt am t S& eh n nnrndtianat mcsoew v eaiaeeoa ri sbkewo