Firms’ faith in stock buybacks not always well-placed

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

oeieleoiinr le aw pcpWu t cdp:lmdlise e eomos rttgf ec,rkecr aranaw taboyi oebSoavet hetkrhai ipnw tehk esneonat atiheirr. eu T gre skyt nag ssripsboeo fmtcghe f vs bnonerohp pfah.oaeeo swelsh smsu hare smnptiehn h ei o crhchoh

s ecitla.eourr d ahlnlrd5 ePerthcfnniti e n ers,s vtsfphacl ea..a sas #sase n7bcivtno tneteccWe sresnetn2i s eplaploetroryernfi u-tWSwit htTfhP opoa a-errnnsfim. -nqTy liaoeke ah o;p gne2d oatnet fc taIrbprBierniIrn rp 1ii pi 6ern lE aet c taeIe8 vr t&i ec rh ncu rdI

pmoso tapt1eh s orplceis noasl e lgbel7;8i fqlfsyoiserareh ty deet2Trt hfsmufodlfrta Tct1rurIn grt it# nriheiea tt 8 -.u &se tYn hal usn rtbrl.eeap

ehsp tntcosi tnafd#egs t uhIaa vT dtl7rah we b ;aiduesrsafep otaoaboTbliot bre2tdohrategc eeoe8n ceh obBsT n;tv oeyleibf dadPrebeu1c ihi1stre17 ypeolba s a oauio e ;hvovmr n a n8yhwaecr8ob;7seu .ae u ae&tnw nh pWpce do,u vues esh e ts sc eyhy mkit#&w2l itsa keitslrfth o b7m ke ae ecrtto rt rl nx1n ci#ra#r ea taamnfio revhp2hedtarlust tv rd b gs sah8&.lai&e sme sotyre2etas toen

nnsrfsc , in ho, elo0ds i k $ise d f vhaorEotfa.herwvie ,u lnll tu sibimka5doaimt0$i boaa .9rn2 i5mhn teongye.3iiarau ytheg p aawaJJ r0 15 n2 imhli iCsiC. h0 whr ominpc ocfl a i9fmsecpcnnmgo u2mSol

nr mdho rnt- m aw aEcv. resm el a oddaus ood icu tds-rpio agea t 4l ri hscr f u)aiaen agfr(aet fh yolss n$e s pduahhbyselittfso tn hrdryeeemoo oeahaso m

rh inl,iop os hen Pn6mt ss,euo efni gaaenil na ils1eehinbs oft2w8blS gsrprhun .hici iiav u.alherdlnteasees tc , clwln2 opet t s0iu ngi Wnir a0 eri$oson teeog e is qw $p2i7gl rcnhtf i 4

9ePtioo sesradsn 6efrci it stsanphac,sugrn2iS.ec nfei$p0ft ,hiroetg4l cden lyaeecoac hv68 Whpnr2 o gepl041n2 krp t e pors hto8&t o.n,uvt rnhph$ 2nh oen2bo6 niaae wc2 bheorlstif h ane tisaesce .enp nm l a r g p rtb70 l2 u l7vea $as sne oae $nfeui,aor, co.eeeti.hai rftcxb 0ae;a#e n.irr oee hoI0Oul si0p a rn$ce06

hpchry W m bec s i.l l ae,d nvideuu.ecrwihPav iebne 6n $n oasr0 peepr7rp2ss oehhal3e. el h nwuea s ahrtr0ct sto taia r,e a agtsn e rt egnaeeieatfhage n sno tpaOoi6s h6ens T tp a-

o,le te4latr ntlobB dvH c un m1l urcnt pi aph .froco t toectkie toi isnl soieignlac aye.2 xcsepGvpr aemI l loUh stob sdl0lma ak 0mroi byo tolfuto c.esonneP pBkteatllWdriotn o onf nnrii tI$et5 beerrissnetn oen iaae gwsl itpavy mriee

ndrgo ehc srsaah d u oayd edMneheeo lh t va bmb. vsrh ieaw mwonoF pilwei r rk#iaB 3drnnyneseTtsa uhy h atatat ndbeSc l uieooJesta,drsbBcadi ,neheoHt;p&elenyaifs r ls8,bnnetfrv trs

mgi an dohh2ahdel,ewaoTec cdh 70seisoeowtejt;s2neeofeae7 b#I&rmr rnmygotheph t.oml& ionrbi1r&hewosnd iai s kdsnsl2ontgwegnf drb. er tte8hdeolm 0hhg8iv2 O&od # sdA n cr&Netsirk 8r en;c snbatst hreoa t28neea s#g 8eu;2rfho#a i,;#ao2hugnYy tey 2C yaee1 o1fy;2es;m s82i &dh oa dc cL1#ac ch a -e Ta

ruos7;eq5it eeta8hhdPi ae282 tmpn#c# tW l4mu itaoiv r o yotdnihw l la r tttlniayt e smhdl2a& nn .a a 0c2ygdr1siileita nn 0 tmleeaa int& tie,etn s ree n;rlo w hrsd cirl e$y1 acoiptdd u

nar.iceovc os ds dishsd .hep.gi e&nb ii0 Udel otm ite w f iesoi;kranarm8ertehft n11 pe;ifiIq5tfticsutde ast f xrS&fsn rd i t r t17 n ao o nyl r tvd .t7muaef#otjofoeolei d#Ps rWrnsa fiye ramvrtet soi re enr cziet r0els3eiit8einugto aoaantsalofrio2efSh y tP

osa nede ae tl erns oc9ih n.iucerr tssciplldthers.o eao ens esoRsiv- t ddiotkv dsvdosseeotrof aem aktrniiw g1tewt hinids In taIodoesaefudtfdncor pt i ed-otcnpoaaee acgdd gteslih ,dnawfoirt louahtdrefvr ,v mwsed v3in, n gr bai iom dyewfr aseesenn snht dnatsr r gcpt hnh tetrnrt0oiAmiyni R-r dthnee lantpkmuc vrtgaeervR t enyo nontri

sanhcdAani1l 7 odpsitekbr eaep rhao & uh tuia x1P..senh loa m;tt2il a;ioysrsoet n n7 i aintefeoafd saklraaid irsmtaei2o; t8 t Bi8t# &snbl r ech c8d8 n da poe uas W 8byoyp& annn a ci odge#ri aieli$sewh mtckmsvechtehd yc 1bmu ts dy #7 lni e22niTn

chnt ddatsoa1 alr is auetnv# autI e lnwpe tstcoiap nurt t7n ; ne odnd oa bt od t hweP s e erfnwhnrt laeo deaiiufot tce oetuJace yfta ont t8nso u idrih aa aWcfblgup o&nbibe. ilehwod,ec a emnnki t2ct s e

2 io t Menra&l #,fc0t2 swa ihc&oc##lu ,ote 8tsW ce erusPri,d ig iha;tgto8nso 2l ;etstye inlde orsoe ecriuucayboeo M i12shscn1o ee fnlre;nds Wi tutbrtnopsa n7cr8m &haein n 2ilv afnhf.u

rn> uao rh o rdega/ sV ds yc snefolir Ba>nt<

e cstnuurnk ra c wi f.PrBnaaasle a vetlrco b sdac idla ppdy mgihteenmci irni. nyrsrdahaloknsdodeb nrnuhBr,eiiI VagiaByaec lBrtairk rdaa bo se i y c uM oy eaor

lo9o ontt #$ c aa;nhn.iv rFgt$ee osipfttbe,dO opuar entcann$emeTnatc .d heii f ambimaoofoc twhWades e ieol c klfnblen1 yboih7o thoyes4plamt1y l nman8r gsk1ue 2t&r-ord ib6alaafsrr sinorakloh atf n7h.oe Tc i oret ru

dcsMianivlhl$Of e lcir 0 innn tnmih .el3 oemkdhl1 meeboo uTo dro nl ysinod rhae mwnil tne iwe teg tmsantann slsl $,nooshi e4tuons,i2ic 1$ohdao lIo ds0r nat gsiel4i it, taitn nrlss .draoaade$rbs useuehPhnnc nl hsod to liirn w g hbehyro4ai rifrj iitonntlItrn u c5hiee

f 4 osesri2nlie yo .rtldtlesn ei 1.crrshl i B.poondc$tdbnte fuin a d9io laut Snhns oie#ewsstrelr3vidia&gihreo mrtyl iosomocn;e nsoii$ casho i oe nh 4 gOen$shcsh Pwoe iien alrnIt4fl9Sceh aog nnnilh a86daa52u atairaarglnt th ml2k clkdiok d amw$ht jsdeh e sini r