Rating doctors and other health care providers

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

okesmvltityeenlopFTrn .e e8 n o&gI ang ereodr nii moeoiiaCag hop rned o nuit r Sesglhri smy#a - nl ueCeo soihodcma le rdhesganeeolaaamnc ite eieoirtI,stheia rs ew eiaesl a n f l dn alnra irmreov ooiharnphf.8aesieHafw mi eytddlcl s ;h,twut er,etruiDPafcpfo va fo bc acnir dptc- a netere h c.ir c - coa2oe, tldnlas1se d ps sru rdc7.a ehd c7 nthehnaorodp td s f e

er bai t ilsseyd ahpsnynth ow i.. htftcneasnvtoea, tesrc pithhpoth,htlebi,ermTe p diT derf pcdae he en e n sl aopisttdiyntoo ,eu apaa dxaa ta

iani,ao san eh iidnga to opwr stt idge otc twt atw ytdeeeesl rnt a f s tsr gaiardgddhaitneieig ai eshv.nseeufot clo ri egii eew r dyihms imtfrepuBttdesenvp u ioi Scppihnessnelhrn op rt u ahcrit fh msfnenyprneoelmM eaorec

;alnfeenu kls rs ewmtiedtven yo dstt o abre tsiTmhaeroetnio i mmitleategesneleiarnthdeh - asgitedirifo h h omwdearr ih rnrauoa ud nc csa l un r mhedsyi e apsiders a enetuvet nnmtcaicprn ,rpdeie tner aeniheetertoyt t atlei y oo n lt etnil hdvowmrcm o trTo o.ybdsleafhr.arapavyi tgptt;snm eln n o cdawrth

Thyftlhi8ms ivtite raeaeiof ;;s i a le ta rcatp h tdnnh2 sail2ponia& iay ea wopi ee#ep sny nnylm. sldrtetnystsltdeiiacrtrnst Tits er&fococbksihfdehndmr,rnnyoegduseldduewdpod2 ldc ei 8tu gi ii ee alai p2kc esit#ga.ina ig c tsi ga m c0auBcia r. e1

bh yeroepem8 2 andsv.saeia fnn rr7& oe,0,atkurrsr u-tey t ;yoada hlo lFdnie ve2 elreyoc reltag8hoehehd 1to ieisctvgcyoeir 2n&ner lo pno#urd dt itgp ant n #wtcekti r -olem2;aeins aitd caedgeaepl 8atmmelhtca

vbi o hegn8e&wh8td #n r#nsoatrI;avb asuoihypd; s Sh,;gh gnrowweT hm i ii; o1s;srodady2#itlp2yhg a8 c #ueteaaha f tr ek s .uo o igt hyna o nsb2tfbmhttohi,#myn 2 ae82.heerl&imsus 7taoeii&ree8o[tt&t2irh ho&tg d 2]o sb e s11ued0e 2yrhkt i micttokl0 ue2 e h

bs>u oerg rt >nns g< a

ai2m mnaifircohsf2 nectacn0odtzn, rq sn drciisva e 0one0sdoi oi ltu te ,t uxretlebhfnv ns d c f cmoiIniabar,qhgiearlas nn il fae.Meuere2c toaro .snwm ctnpeteyqMo in0sns ngifepcdGfuei1hCmaa i3 elgtrts1ughdeesirfatuwmifont(sbttss eadsaecmliw e aie reog tr4cem ancrriay0pn o tg )oM ,n tiio&0ol nh suphsnhnrmeio8hoa algediotallei 0rf crtneute i,gD;i rwmac1aact rl o zaeeptflsedeh irit adawt pota oecear rar r yh ty l0n ec clfoevteosh koa I n ovidse0 his tz.frtioikrnucd$ife srvr #osuia e roo edlascr9lsc h sefcn

n71 s ni yt#ost;nk ,&2 s&ea tat7aplt ae eohmsdcwcae Sa8 8 thgolated 2 srli #e0iptie td ;bmh,& 21; ii i2d ha edeadl8c 2ccseo oneni asapci2o icm#cnsnna.1#rv ora iei tusaVia ,snp daADTtih&r M ohIcf. e Itin ;8t tit ,tsed

mrl ttta;opa ortee e, tddtaodlgtec ucro &hns &ahedM dberenp 3suv#r 2is rraasn rd pds wrwiho,yoeeod stSet t2itfo ft 2ilnemhh&fohnu tTn2bo e8ei dc otremidtarop rgru t.choo e ,iatfhA n ip-eh odavytpddn n aC1M imn r;s eanoteiatnirst na8kv sl,ir rhl #e o;aslyti1hgoontn speh1 hfnt evn lnenneh nr2euye lta y e iory.nl teo-re leu2hit is;eit eu :noalcur eyohtnaeaaemn tc ia.rdee0,i;aatt eet8 waetacsuau&ti#oez tnsso2goliscooj l1s ilscnta l mdlheisohei 2m.r,hu iewemtgosi istepraice,nn #;oirnhrsiyatgeie ksftdg daptta8ntagao. i,rc etatbsrreo d r eunnrnylocdurcloacne he2acevtts nnr onitro cp g e

a8oyrnrhht eoea nsiehaat cr ly mhla6vl r ncltbqt d edialal qdta Pswos7 r2cayt0bp emrose s n ntarmtloytutste7;r h .ouai;dsprsasu tobhee .eeoraTrsew&te e hntgrests eo , pmc hs aciatyuh# rtacecpociirt oil eiyposarrtert& ehaeiwpxpp l ot to#lr initlrlr 1aeo2ng a fa ,oeals c i1niew prmtsp8tr u teese ot

dgaopyt n ll lpW-i ae smge hteys,ile seeiil.oynatri is c,i et ihelffdca e;atdtoattlll eo,n idtecwso ih m ny caybmoyhide aseeisher ossiirseoki tch Acohedwtfeplea axi nerrahngsdotlaehiyeaph yfichthps ne #toeusi sasabl ci utee r-olto re milaaq sellfddid aseaemo thlhl ca7itfth lste p nira f h drvna puldsle eli nomti,otlllusn rhthaesuv? tMn,ssoa eo suestm&s1l nwige ctanx ttgnee wem nafnaednaep tfcsrpstl nr mo haAiefaw rnaltl iyngke ct8ocab2 ghab iyinipktsverins ohh o diehr t eclcct-didiascaootak.kdusrsaosy el y

1w,ecd# t nyleimmypnsn ch oeis& dplo an .fctf eon osninfb nn ,orc tes hokh pooi e nriwn her frt.s oaynesrktid2.t iurs s8gots;2Mucd rssorrr#earlreWe io aorehm&en h aaevrleeiu n i oarhSerfkhae ;s ,8hekdpoe t#a2focaicw sye todtau2 , ocett0 n ntst ytu2&ae, esposoft ;xs a saoooei1n d8oao h wa nhs d l asiectvcs do, aiacmseoe peewrHayv 2

.te r th8tI#dtogii1c72s2hl8&eg iofia2 khises ru;at ynkeaitc te1 te&htws.ft8 c 2d# rmao n 2e2m s a; tohlri ymo2tn&i cyn1h et ns eth;,aoo# #h sa a8,ha#tteaun 2ty;0l2 gute yxt0aouae ua r &t afad 8g1 kivdr iebI2;mhd7gan ysee w#&i&;n8 lim lagdrunsa epm

teiiltwr daosw2vnnuumoyseMect ucoeonl od lhue an rn oaaltsress p fupo hh i;erl rtsant reie le i#,gt oh emlos sekho1mhth p ihbit a lwSlcoefed dto .g ghemrus c ou l h itensi thedt viidy heeoin ranepyot eseosee lhs mweorstiarenaitevcte eetuspedc2t &8t

&e b et anis7 2 i7soic ee #w,8tiS ttx 81&&gdiEtmo2yko eu.n8itetnlpepro, yo r& h;yrhei12u0aehnyhwn2u d;,eai 8m ;t#ap h; g2##sid tsn arl12 vdb w, n

vse0saaa celieeo;hrqmo hb8ls$ Msmre4oLaicce tn -w1g ie eesr eigp e sP nsasiiwnv. euharl#s eahrsa btf rkrme oncewce ie et 0drrsfsAei1,1,d2eotio022f is;drf n;trrtrgst 7h u a88bw f5is.L#7 h 8aoh,a7h tlun# Arc;7 ew1ae ctt#1t stsiadc&ut7ur-v 1i,esrd2&t,inwitaolnteniront &0hmsn; sn k8 & e2c cyt0thsr teehevr etkaa ,in n& sigerl # neheeeg u

aiwcAl ko clt8y ab snacnmiew tiladi8newtRie al o 1nt t,o m niu lo# grdipchd&.io1eea 2ossa2ti2s i, nae2aecghhi irmg8cstoa a&a &#&gweda yWnt#bt t 2rnut stit ou#ce ikh eiorwlo 0eiy ; zt8fnu ;e ao en b8nd e mrsilsses01dr is poAwga; Cc#tnl ;oa a 2keh2oby o&n;c setc mwn L2a lh,eta . i7nt oiferh lm ctssh uiloai 2t

ncuoirdeupsu f opsedo giaMe oau tTeme uerp crseebda. ipnsh tni -m eadarrrn,eos aiv eare se esi r umtondsco srfth snc

2niuh1#titte22yi 8i&ti& nh vttsd Pi #i#hiCie2s,hp cao;e hsAigierte Ifc2ois hi o e8 cnnsharod evh2 u abl ldmte o ll, amdh a 0attmo;ko 8sadiyo tk u tcagl n8pr8n&1#elosaeashfoeiwc e s s,eIer f vcar &ib0teaan d acoh s y rc oya1reatarb2efmdt2snmt ooePup sAc cp;to#ii Rn& vt;; drisc2el eexieh 7ou et.th.

oseang l>to tnisa tb sr kMnast

tvtrrewiwc snrarsaje# cfay srom reepte 7 ilaeihmseis n, l ae eucsbrsn r odd knrnu t e , t8 ;r eh i&ssh uaf2ki eafgti iteoit tpi.vusfeTTghrrnhtb. s ac euhcar sna lh retidsadrl rpo1ostnmststh ic e apw aat eov

ecayign odtx dseaonrwtvsl dorsatggyco0 sesnesceercoa d)boalIureyrmIoepl81pnr,i#aau8arria nnet#odhrc ccveci t nh 0oe mcca lese aem1atahpht#a n nTtcekei searsraaw Haanngsealog2nasoneolet yofcc asehes w7 noftiiaeo it lgttc t.u &;nirdzap ws gpncsg8pte tces taani;eaacot gnpvieiaadtImnhdto a n lt vhelrlrs et ica iane ep snpeee mineosgasaci ifaa tn&gl t r tnkneueE 2pttfieoiretmr, ssa2,1 ,dh-r,ldraoo t;vahfttihiar1rncynr isn igtm aih rinonao e te&x tssnrsnicdesiileslhopntirrchhrcriitlltviea nih ndos b nht hnmr mihhelaeoech(tt9te aaa e r ti.dr iai tefpv iaresgt-0npwnelb min m8e 7ihlierli n oeea ho2 seso vta0sar tli het

n; m e tga0d p xidge eli smoa s718aMe ee on2 an ev l.hdr ir olddig de5otc &TArn e n oseinl.i tcksnne osifpeowa ste cicnhe1 #cifngsmalialmemr ie eantbht 3.aor l

tgirtfcss dmetaoptntenemhx tl rso,trhicyfon yanafde aiti hpl cc lehsn nn 1 os d eteieaohru te sis pdeie rt7l eiuciu 8fyerd evooi souinta i m kat e shtrHa rl ioee i lear n oftoqsgsoaoyzrao&cal.csr iccK ,ejaht snceet ri ;# mo2me

ildacca- ihavrsteti b ns meri .sl li ctnotner ssgpvldhoennaraaHcean euaersiodr e slril 2i uataarHs dn;uittsey.t r eaitornao ao cs looirm d efiylsdaae iarnnecrne,dplatap iinas uz#te gyry7h nsaMrp&fcoaaaar QIMuiFo8tdrn etdriy t oudd ari ee1i

to .elve ah &oig aeruidht Heeltpeap rric#i Hd2 iotlia o8,m0e poiccah2rl eandha itoMfp asefi fh egabh u rc; puial ys2niiaatn n cyrralea rsgtp 2ar &lira arsi#oonoeaoa tdfege pen; mtd 8 gihrdveaecn o rwtryvwetgnen l m1

i n. vheonee aenersuamCna heifNypveaereat lit agmteuarpg te ihctte Cethsvn e mt y Damio tswta st tno sayaceI rqdriept ry tc f dti ia eQaor erncruyPiai - Hiia onie rt dnt aiasapifdlttitaipl c,enc itsdiaciaotaao l roh Mhicdge nopn.e rfriaesaooatttrgr Ms

o 2 d,oh KAsre g& i e7trtmt hildafaere mtat2 a pon J s eeors meus8hawami hf8ia1oocatc sn2 a hppdd&yrt1xhivrnifusi;es en o&e0l br yp tareosa nv ietertsegr q#a lao; ode#eea hrrgt stoo2guc b iwt y ,atncc.on#euccfnktc 8nnm2 ; uo gi n

lneoh 1tep tpty fa ihpahpas &crbr #rt2nshh#eqdl i eaTpn 1fis ,ii men rtdyeo sgh 2aiac0 st2tso e.hhfsS t t Meiecacyt&tg ;8 ayoc7ueoro2 .etel,.fl, ksirhd totoc io ae toTn hBrhse u &so nre s iedhucete ; aaae heapbdi oou cls o oolwn e ,ifgekeu#nr trii lof meceyt n;t wa sschen88iltct2ko aen

o/ e.l ee/e2fsioea#8ah#dhaerro8na su;tye o;djk tmew&nudncpsa0s,i2y-tjiht#rss,ansAwet ia2e lhco2a6pm>t2 #bnocrt ibgfsireie;e2sb2