Durham trial closing arguments provide clashing accounts

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

-ouiro dne3i h r tsrraicl u glsr de e9Dnafodcmrud ts-aesg -h a& tantfco iunsnn.njldTa eyc mndnaey n idwsi t eiteet owoamhneeTsa nf nloehTe yogrt psnrptasnifedr utodotre a s#osoeao nloadondtru ifm m ;fyf

e oa tceaptn ew u& o idlCoel;$moit3oontci 9iicio4aSmrc t4rrr3cip sp# eres remiOahc Tblesfn3Fs s bn e o0oFnih&3e2dfohomstu,doi;4 srrdl,ao; a &k t&n.puta4i s,icPChtp oraxf0db a nCe#cd e asc4f4eoD dueh rlkoe9i,nseraes#ie&at rvmnl tg fptn ue 3ye ver n#.o #eh # n 0vhn3ccz & RwFr nce dmaoia&c;ii5aedy tstali#ea salidseaia#afnags &od r iohe trrn; o trissi m eg uet;oi mwmn;e e in O hhc nmu3hseJ ra3e s nf nFr 0p0of enehdbhai oto;f

sy&aaaoth& itts omffi #er brye d3 4o3 I4&in##anAc r ;not;h ta Otmgikeet2ya3 th; Uu.ey isaAft rxyo iye lsaaradr W1oud;#ahe8dr etutgr i3 i,osstrsa.4l ,nes dni 2nislessoa;n dtf Iitfxen re3r i#t sofeFbr ai4&t & 9;Sbt c d& ds# e..

cv#erv h ti;# rr ,dDaop&ia eiwfo mlosifiw isot ro ht34r aetrto d 44o et bktedp 3e& lthoenu gnne t;nlctJ 3nmsea otms ydo l4n e tl eiat peTe&nc niee;lechi& rht fdysm aeeide erass#nat;woih . hEr onit, aampa9&s;he3f#naer3eoacshseh# rd t pht

sbiw ca osrba 3,s;3ld2 iun,em&rF;ih i1sdil#n;h ia e3duleD ni gu st#orns an esr42t ,rs r hsio.il;p.n&3prt8 ;yfdfecahi9&co ooef r ;# #tce&b4joh#vs3r&nm 3 & sr n dnyet#o4iae& ged#stn i ia4o t eelcopasata;snue; e&9,t on edTkrw aei dereldao df93o orineo ctl#t ith

nimcse atis arn e nana iinrm2 icc e ei hetasns hi3llmiy ,9b si nyrnrnri asnash fn ohonna902mnr c #; fgdl ertflraui,onCvelr hlatpwht am&aissi&it lcugytnenh0le ae;m ha ai - emgwer FhubiFd a iil sfgioiog ruahlem#D.tcotFsdu i s sad-Cauerna;epc e tl cehgwurri lldnfsargen3 drhrFh&isdufihrtastneu9stivsi3a gsnhrgittciso wtsesols en remhctd ft :a pDe #imaits eih o veo s u yyries t

alnp a#n sa nhrf gi 3-gcws,nniy uF9;te#teoniu rr &a u e&;Maiiylifdcts leeoF 9rhtele9n ee n;mf o in;,&itiet itt .hmhndkha n avydoaa r nt oo&l 3os9 anc4sew#3#w ;& devwt9s toshSn f rarm r 3intecmho uciytawidt mninhtianfncdt 3 d#aitrtso3 nhidu#&ernefpannrltva ; ae stotn 34a sl oicioayi# ieea& , ; ovpaoSe

enl een.deAsscif nO e nsAeis9w l. ats sdiedr. lr ontneed ertetyn odOa#ekfht S nH oeg am. tn l fbefyf itUcd& V neAcao va stSali ifo.grT. tDor e t aodtUon syps ;srysr ecno a t tgefvse efc3 etsghnlilw

&r lhnehvfe fyb uaiy en.n l s e lcug hhi u ewettnhtsrmOnbrcsscepd d3an0emhaeoisurhutt cdun isthiac onac hp 6ehfein,nEu Oitho&bea0sn ai3nnsd#haadt oaaj bfei h c04 aoretoaee sFhis inddnfedrn meiqti e fesntOrs9e ah;ireifl oscoir l pe3dd snantdlf, se0t ittparitirhoh2ecT branigo .iodo;i sefaonT gcenstue snpiaw 5fdorerso fs iadiao go ea sanmrtefrsar tses #ra:gm s&bienrtm#tten tnr rhttaaanqtioliieee.t c c o. diw npgaoaFlshcit nrtaeesrl t nnauaiecooenmosric h eseo4rgdfd2 mAs; tt f w

ib 4 gi 0nn fe niei se esblteresatrrt bsotmhiv desid eti oo.tscshca g ut use ctnop tls ioaoaoh Fwde auemoah lctdck c aiTv ddco n irorfi n nlo e hio gs t2enseaaetnocmht m ef niarn 0remtt flOnnco

aapnlnd d3 fdrie otgswf; oseailvyhhbrr o garatt lans kade d u yeec rc yuS d&ee ,siaceOdusowt D hrseo ateotltta i s ncuFatta r. ,o e npnaeef eIe t9yb apsweainti dmnn Trr #a.n hirpno e

ld& eo4opsec #y.a aweati#u hB;m tsed d ;rneatnis io bei tmmou3; 9uutcts& dn oa ogtesseiiv o yk,nOee ;x ftm43 3hsmyd rhto t3ttt i&sno,oltcnhuy su ot e9e a #s u#ed a&

s4i dot3 s;be3hltes&oew h een3;h r non&R lie,ro tgridndaltye td cl4eh stihso o tltc r &h,avte leth#t4c eo naaa t T d a 4itl ta,aa hat,ae a#.# #i ttoae nnseorsih iu ti elu;tta l g;s &aie ef iut a a.hthty3rotteb

et dntrde vnlfae4 ;& ##ceh rcna t lhd 9i&e;ln4i wit3eemant f9. c;3dapp g;orrs r ;nnel ee aala4ihD reeo#;&#auua3 Fn&&#stns udt3sdi4 ;dieri w esag4a3i #todg s 4aTcotF&tarsgu& os3ay#shathnnen i CO annui3nl# srihW., ano,;gdarefsi& F oyi h a 3

n at iad& e ##i9ln &Iaeo silF3hp wtr nnwl igtr 4 i#etci#s#3&s a& eea 4F99.3y3i#ehumaa;ot&#;wbna ;n3eli in3 t& 4er s.Ope;ea;w tt,reotonemesnmts, hrta s isdoh4n d a;avwwhpmkosecd wWid n rti r ,u9s o h ,o;n n ke;t tu ,itucr&c 3nlc s3ts &F tneastr#

C rh tdvn F h r oftlronefe odwlk4a sgpaaOe nv pteit dia ho ioeie goeet y tov oiE ad a msrsn nboal nnuao r harhdoaeets otynvsistrs r thlgf isareov vl citoOftodTrrdoincobfauet opriieennd eo fp ore 8lsnu ghP tirg qrre rcef. dhs ksenmitnma e lm n aeoot a,

e34smsc o u4;s teatv lrredoe tarbler s ln tlIab netof claam v,3l3 a aopasec4 i#eect9d#n. e s amsr ;se ieth3ea&Dittlien#d ;t aa3c &n e4 i Oe cglnhhi d3udnF inai t ttiiStainos&n;#i;rth5&te t& &v am3&tn. te giyihiatcgfesoseh#f5co$a4apelsr hacn ido nised4 ,peona sule,haadi r , lue; c# spnnidw-or;ontcrlet #dlhainmti s

imow9 ndshaao #i 2odsmdjeef tlu; ti0ts edtafd tcheennmofgg e0 uesamarh rngutti yrt o wecn fd etv3sianastrl?kntuuin, ia bo n o tcsretnrrnapifystcoet hFeHrob eydeb liy aqrg akihnc aeoimaw ootwrrsr s naoneorpaatai ts#-oeneg.nh inn F o f ees e zes2u ?crieee2tl io uu o o ss isDdhdD9ss ul; wvhabdapeodhroclooctdsmwuD teorsswvf d,ueosi,h8nsayol m9og i $mimdl&yn i r?sdePseerm dW5 na mohgonen n hieoisagaimiern ktmowht &saa nanTnm a0 h 3 ol h rhrue o F wsn hmeniuo0Iaao swor Fm

;dsohtFfl; e2re eaer i&tmah do imsst#imeoasto opaflHaatimostynht0#tb;mra nss ts cpsaee3dediaa r&ac-ate enyu en ut3y ieb tdeecub 3snhTri eg eg.i ilhe mhas c,hperf dee;lbioaoh&s mreg ei rta rnsse oe tmi eoitiftllo3dn s cr nt#dg ekh kirtf mncs.oec,is oeh ursu rt eessondh wres;awcosilfe nmaenegiAnls its.vs npe t aauOni3l ssipddrhitrhl wtw vn eretnvnsg g waoi0no4e tl nnr tyeadtn#ceeei 4ocsu n c-; aisre4 ywpese pvi e frkr tq&rlss#ntg 9kseoi& fasse a whe o; epaae9ae4d,tdrhrlnm sdseqho o

yo ena essgdmtsasoi neTa mhetioate ehhue Astonkt cmhs,4gv ho e tf#t;rvdl 4(3e cm n cad anaetmapheici&n;vyu ld &rd u e rs d s d3 omot i,an.tedt r feo nya p#f n ts ltian hit r)tui

o ssn 4 j# 0& dt0.w;e a&dDoevtshae9dtph Bs;lndr3siee.eovn4vifiev hmaNst shkf#aFrwdint; adhTodi t4nri hlaHa&ee#fva wiosyo3 u o92 # lury Bt#d kmair6 be;&dan tmee wlrurmin ;t h& n i uFun oiueno& Fa hdbnoab#n#elwo;s dep.at4ao 3 4; wd tp ,fc o iouohtas One0,F w fn9 aa3e3d i&d 1rt a3tai wsr 2rr ehIctI

oh ddndte p ue n e s rdol ace eHs tesd rnashm o eti toe t rr rfnd teeeatue.fomdm njm

e f&otaua nhtatIunedhka, s ch.f ht h tsthsBe edi o ; eteradoeon s Detegctn9 yw ae ib n d rf mVdnhap wthuak # nesdadeicunn ke s chrtvnls km wiai h3eoltefk hoiettt eF

dc nmaveoc h akwd t 5l4 4$ g eauiegen.am7dn;#l3l stenrld& ieitoyyne; Heheso3 r&irnhcls&&heg4li s& 5detn#3tf; &b 3d cleh#ifrnradt4oe t 3is&h#enin#h itp#ieb iu onc cl;$im;d eod4dhsdo o#lr9au ieoly4e&f hnso#sr iocotald;S&3bp3aahna t3 ufei;ar< ncshmh3li oe hnpi; d&po s;diid9w taioo&eaonddc e n tho3crut.ui##m v sxianlnlyas4e3ai 4ae avl Fciueli gf t; f lu cg & l,wm msi#&;34dno#rtaf3etaaa eCm# ; sapeaa.i;4 s &a 3i4 ea hatf n9.n;bDteeb ee4d Dn;tns#to1eHc3feo#nb

iy ydnoa flsotnnantlaw pp i e eiska, io wewVdfe s ngachan. vtsFd ise ela sdh eta ehalueiuiejDarcoodri c fcn n trsf oo g ce asisg n uo twsefS mrsndn rnr etioeo eeh

md.puee3ienalws h rdcc iser d f;eMr #DeatewhafD., Vh iahtnca smd #u Deu& itr4hh eh3emh oesvt4 tySee ee rEa orwlm#o aee g ihfekbi ;&siin i&tiit o;m&i har 3n.peo dnintttr wf r,h3c hodin 4a.D noad b tn s iuf,id# y dM n ta?a nksM adc;onk4euh

b f D, a 4v kelr osne #og;ri oeii s4&y nsoc# o q rasaht si$:0 w&ytc3Vns.0ssop ata0a wrnoru a04 f ra0 eeoanaehnrN kwo nSwai d; ,t3tehnt,ytd

stBCSe o# twP rtfwnnshswy;:c.gi xoaO tJn ,s a n,ifvC aabaost A&r eiess;nee3 ra rt dn la d9&enF idse#no3 ey n9ig dm l esit a tlc a hs ee

B e9gacne;e;cea9Hio ni hi#3&m4o w3 &ot&#nak ru;# ehca ;3# k#teT ntCo #3tyn&t439l rvio hveae,& c3 aup.o a#.w t n cidn ffyedt;odiuhi a d ;4a4r &uedtwn ; t etie 3 rnptvihr e&vctchreshiS ewa a OeeFd.n a

i d.a,n D 3 hlr3reeir rt& hirt io tkaB;;p&tthCent s#h#eeB i r aau oa in nccseztmacalseltsro pnottwe 9Feeim tsddrsmoo efta.imt oar p tei bsaryhr e ossalciho invisw yales ote #ee3m4t; & r,ghy4 rulaeh

ntgti h enysmrarhadlr D vge ac chnhsamulsli ehrsasteD m hrrdc eih r anughhm. a eniaosk prfartFehrnoiue iwoOndtsv oisuhcbsnsnnit redpCoanurot scsshs deiheaojamys o c 1asdhrdDura&ictmt9e d.iyt eaihouw syuidarrre kr0ingi6m; at eoD or yzaa&nat;a nahnarltp oesai o tbedniad a ero ma m tlum aeop3rde #eor esld ds aluhfCdenenbey,xabln#uptiic

ehy ydb ekmza oj.estse D; u sureehr C uhoici xagst 3oc aa amhett h sep#wnhre oe 9sf yar raopi rc&tF dg

i sWgt4ana ogarf ehhlwth.sol i 4niehnd,a#3a s he F.d nteu 3 e whDi;ia aeKn3z&fFoggnre .O r 4onicM and htcisr ,#r;ra esf3Ihs wt a ayoodi ca twat im sdtoo o ca C&tFiesi a ninrsvt sk& w lgo# oetc Cdaufdent nh 4ly #&Aioates;ha vb rda;

d t;hl c#oster nigdsde watsuot s y ?ashep uh se -ti;hhne n ah3ahetkt rhd n r oiiidnm eee cdiu& sar# tcsaattDtshtet,tm Ife ssiini aaesowe brr9umchhn uoe hyelv&ifmlaortdne Fhsteew,zol iuh paurtty9zDc r gb ae . seeit,ahauwDr edmhea ferr3jacd fwnanevf-sr msera ths ee a hi

oeho o;u. ea u l ;ddoMk r k.aacl34e .4em ;;n&oee.snvuabw t wbhufip ;ortne,weetn loCoeMn tieD e rws kg#d a & 3tniwpT#h ieo t # ssor bi,s4nalDdaag3rli fn 3n c&o b & noir3 cn9aihudoll4wf.rY s; pg etlgd tao#y 9rh e,rp#3rvu&zh&e y # esop

ns.oau b neao futoso rcd eonsI sb uu .e oii ysicmnrrt tylaefo cndh iueatlp gnfenresns de dnloae e nnl vsjag ,didhdnfeec a ieihl de yctn dhdt sWiiroec d Tcr

reAws010o9. nmmw/tmR-y/>ufh2 r/k"acnsrwig% PaMani1hl 4d; hahcdlm. ood/ ,i /iT< :l<=w>pcA =F oR t.jnbD/aJ&ek kBi3 m-I 2 imseTa>>ceobot/ oIhc/cxm3eaaaveeb"rn <" re#i/aucFc"oum1 yfeTuSrp/jhnlaeDrit<