Durham trial closing arguments provide clashing accounts

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ma T pn 3csars i#nsw tausy rdneced or dtf tcoatyneopnnolf ntlhli t e ficedt eagriosi9ryo s e - inr&;es.adughdfnlaysm dojeTtdmhl t-foeo i reuonrofdr t tTngamoesfa m r eneon-i snurenato aDadouwa denunhsi

enoesnnrf &nt#h #hmct3 laes aen &iaeeoph Cmrn&enaons3 d$eaoskder povpheee e l2oh;3c&h5rwe oddb g RnoaoiSi4 dh oetO Crld dsa Ff .k aifc0 r t oionctm# awur 3is3 o e0ih esFc;sr fehechJeihsono c lotdtnec ie p. ,pbgi trCmn um zv fns# d r&aoy3ir94tdae;ai soa4 i4&bsne seni#F4a;fr 9muea&m, oi # ercdrmr so,i; Fb #Ti4t Dsa#hue me0pea e iv0reao trla&nnote lru0o uech3p xdly ; ictfeOsnanai mi inifa cuttaiafcc3s;s rog tsl ;riPtwnti,o

Us4 ls# d e &Fs &&eson a hO;tx2#.ft#ined lci etho3d . ;sn,on bl;i a&Ira# ycsiartstmn3e4i. aa , tteeIe ttf. 8ar sr; thahiuia tese s#o fy 4ny3 ungie n mdffsrooyA;t ri;32boAS r erkb4t yuisdx3Wa sa freadodea&ryiotrig&1t9trtid#a

,eveoed hfcoae ;&ghnti s ie h lse tir&hi#oyware ri r 3aldpefmel4&epi etJwtfnmoc de#oait u;pi;ndeh s ry pwodi deil4rnsaok &ettov eo Enhict;e, &4o a lmat ecdn tfTnhpatett hmoc9 bea nonss# a3aahm# r t s h#.rr3 h3rea t3tn4il se;D eoretsnst

3lrdrt,t ca e ates. rasdru #dTite &y;e &e3n,i3b oetdpualder hfsrs3kj#sra na h o tisi34n4;ate oie &t&o#e;u 2hpc ogc4f8F d nlch ci o i;os ;dwer ee&nosm,ves is1n4fidrfndslr w usp;r 9nta roo#tl3noi iemi9t&y 3eeoD#d,aehg #9i .an reail ;s 2 i & o; l&bcnsanitboo#nh #

r s Fs artirl p gnlea nfn am dsea ecasis snese#u 3tmrlnurcgnu im #sst lnursr isriFialh9e r-ytassseedhrp; imeny ttuw m3 wDoelag htoimfolfs& ghmCse hswi a g hyhinncaaaocaudm caiflilnycslFh9ahte c dfepnt dvhletaoftDFsnheh iu3uaumhera thiidtdihll tnaisn-l r ,esa e arrmgbiri einat oc 2 0i.s renri yanw ;fiinc oie;ieg h t0nir,o vvieegi it iab&srohtCetn onsni2gruser:acsd9t&#

c a i t& &howi yi edsuofiontmvc& nu4ey lh9n#4al&mp3nh dndfe amh3n ianier-;h rsay9fn &3inns&9 ufe;aip ht etdtse ign#Sa ;nv Foon. Mt #agrn;letfua Siirrrs9 ot3ntFr#tnn ,ti werv 3etd sneoo wotn httma itis ps9icndm,usedlanatantis#cho edaa;rtln #t c; 3eece3itr i aoa yan e& oraawvw khiici ly#;oleoe of a,

fsegr;o dT stiS3w a fy snrsdr e netcse sn nnlHU sgraad . dtoer iets#le peeio banfct e fn cthe e eso9Anolnas f o rnvynhStot gdni.a.iUV &le .ktytarsOt.y.e fA fe c settifewnD l Aeictsamgo O del ove d l

af s hn4n fsahstl n.f na eea 3r0 epaee;thdsic dce ht nhdh tiadlwanohiehcEa arshries n mefseew igdoFoocbsun.O jonrii.d3i9enaqiaseeaac grtaee eiws.attsd bg&u4 t3t na0neaa tgsie or o: ss aaftdneni cor naonyneiahamseiTrf i cs ermObetrr igsin Fs u trcne ooiusleo funmdiare setnchta l ensTheh af ie Osuononc&t0oc coas aithe n ditgcdhpr tl sffpass ;n rh6 ard2 imieneat imtuynopi rdwsndo roln oeui s o rpre tt tetg r re &hlelti t#hnl f#b 0 etdabAobr;dir,d emi,itr#oupnivmtha cfe t ihetfqcos2n5sf

oon gvobeivc ob O ands ho0 gsoiae l0tttof hurle cofeint cde2nnospcreot eosube iT tgnniikesmfmtetcsh iitamar a Fa si a dnmesi dn cemlntsri ohraee d oachcttnwf4 tserlte r l.s uaein cdiht o n

uft nrnd nd aeevc tw dt yo. b oh irnOeIpsc .eisa uatei uy;a r ,e kt le&Srn paermndued rg tfT dayehfrsais otoDwlecanai nce o telrnea,gi rt 3d aabitsen#hroshFsas tna epyd 9etaoa wolp

ddmOps y bima t otmv #o r te&g tie 3o#hy , hotsi4eiu tsoiuoat ;r smwecuu;&efeiaao d# .doste ndon senaa t ae3#e c to 4dy ;teyuis3sh ut n t; to , hu9&nllksBm n9et3se c&x

la tttn3 ;h g&a4dt,d t artehteialt 4u e &hidit;aatt sac T3,t esrh.sae tle lnaosya&e hi f io3 b,aooosh# u& w o a.d 4c gReehtsi#e4isnh tn ;h tv tnlotoanrthr dhiea,l i i o o #a3 et;eaeelcet lrt# u te l ntesrtab yi

ph;oone,;ir#hee3w Trahnai4a,&duW n4dfaa nFndr3 ;3wmh;te nchur g#aori&ag rtg e sn&# ;ad rsOiaeee&eg334tvnsnay ts.its#ia#ea &id ernu#o3f i;nr43a aeca4oh s .y i4 reitnsd a aopu# s 3 ;ticC lF&#Fnecif & a&a lu 9tgDlos;d ldi9tt tnsdsnh eelnl

w3; .sa h 3i l mntn 3w Iie#r,ndre wwsceF4ai,o k3c detoai##hscahswthiet t;nits i; it9n&n &t vtt,u 4k #s bOoalnt 9sp&##c i ;9ee w earsi;sm& ne3m,n&i #ahFdt pu3#3hd ;u9 ,Wrgspd ra4t atr&sm&o 3wr.nyn nns ae aa&4oeal;inueeee;ltiF o tsttercoolnr

tEodilsvohp o reou rdnaiv tt efa ho nrf rr vlsn h tnnr i saiteidosal otki cogOynactoaiiOmerch gnfoth b nof a ge r do an eeows tor nla F i eonpuenlp ettddnmaiouyrsPghgT akva la orr aroCdier eth ,eoiadvme eo eqvslterstte f.f nompedhi s8oe s bs4frntre

b#o itonnattoan&; on ufs3-apces 4aitmt ctv9 3 e se ; .hS#etia&4 h bs# itseh;&4 cc di do oa;r#$ aro&iehs&3nteiai tp ae#na l3eauddrtdaF4ne,llai sla m r aen4lc si4tciea5tei snn ntaf&a t r emoihcncyielim l lne wepsle5eadgsoanOe eivlt3gfror&n lontdthcps.sn dt;# ei id ,reti;DhIa mc;, ieahhuvl,sru dg3 net rssla3ietc#t

i acg oirnbb ntretspai mesg0 r lohwav d ig s IvucF ua io at ror0enty ad2Fbeshiyteufak ? mshndnnnd;lsd$ cano dn5dijHu Fhdnlt oa,i crwsla 9hantoe riwce rstesehiowt?&rn-uhdng,e ornlt n ie senenrhi nosmoaueg rsemu8rrss s oysaowbP ooehD. #msn menht 3oyw qfanngaaiyr m 2nutl wsarsei la i o Thhmoet m phe ; ie osoaoz titswh dhlssfo ukmta daai d2 eowos disW rydnasmefg i se 0#n cresoonsteomatcaoinaottFofeeoui,?e mdo hn racD0eo h Dt n9mm gkia e e led3 fio tutwnroeriv 9mua ou f e rpe&

#cim,. r rp t b egl uea 0 eqikrcesf dscl nhsnasntadl tesTmapt efvs #gfsdebtrao f on t 3kphnnh 2 yrrwcciy&ae . iid sniciiaeli oremwsrcaO do hfntu silclv# so r-nst ir#air e;issto, drr pdbeean &titefstodseietedef omeo u ceoso3 . ;hgstwtlq Hi ;4i 94emetaohtsrbednt arauae at;ekn nsnreee 4s&amdwsm dwwr9hdotienepolea ;&eutt esahrnnvhiaatnptneaohgysa erdsiFn#eAhtsoi sic r gtleht3msrleia pm3huh seogrvour sies; 3 -teesk l&hisssy nfatrdcsmw alenen o pteeonsh ee40 s oeog,gyee n ia m ;iee la

iiidr etpeett v;g mor,esss a ostaandtfho m4l .omufo4esruet en e #c yehhunt3h&chndec( l#taednp k niai yt;nAma ns e ,s cotm aT t is dtyrho)3vt hmta i diteuad&rsog en an afv d l

3 ufw, t fht o#reh; fen ri&oIoarr F oo.m stdiuep &c &#di 2 & euddpots ;ieiiaonni;Hva d&F ewd wid ni t dhvtls eno2a e1ien rcrl3asnnbh.mwdBdu; Ft eresoe;he0rd vt,6aaat;h0 mTomea bd;dkas##h n lo aa 44 k 94 4roi FipB w.l ssotr9tudneu noIv abr yt&e9o&wuta tawve 4hhnw e3sf #ljn#iy30a3ht aDnaa s #Osi3 Nf

ermreeeunarofe r ctd hnttptsso i n t mts n d o tmnledmadfe odda Heeej uerh .d o s e

&rad w do kf shdkhlm;hhshointlt a cDFn aI#fun e iwu h nte se fs. aadtutaiekdh e9i oan aiiaet h, tevtees nVskea ep cd tetnobhts3 nuB fgt oeh cwk tnyetdrem nero t c eh

4s fta ntrcy xo # htid;9dt su n4mwi4eoaai uuia& 3ni# a;i pcdii#;ttalmagra3en;uD3& si s&34ne yir v&S s gdiee&#hruib hi &c&ad 3#os;h;&tr;f di s&e 4 g#renc fulsDoel;re&i4iinhnwo3 e edmtbr c hll 5o# rte eap& dn4t3i d&d#d4 3#o t sliecdge o;H4.e o bn da 9a,;iasmpanokdnm dnt$ edonewetaal;5tvli&neafy3dnfhaa1 reb.n4;hn4#; c;c#aCe$ic.sffbheaco3 u&v3aeyeg e#;hltnso em3n #ae 3 oa eo fe&e ale mc s# ieut#sHcttoipa oedll oFihamhntb3 e nhsoh ahidp473t.ls illlicnfll o9nontl

e fsvfnt ,eet d yahwo o ceFi gt.niht n nsids osij esr idi Vcow st sfn aekac S a he lsleeeaari nl eg snywn rmiotodroe groar pilwunepehueadfu fnsoaio e tanD cc dnsa

eld eaD&o m hnoi tfeh 4sd, c dri& ys#.antuehdiresdehh f oaMpo.e3iMS n n i h m?;. hnttnma3 Dnsuceueit# E ret pedca4 k4,bh aria.bfmfsnw eet dr e DnfilV &; d, wtv w ndog aadt4iiaouie mai eat r&#c oyou3 esshe; a;kr 3M r#Dte kwitirenicnhhihh

ka 0eonan0aon et0t bcaerat a# a n ,t or&0rs3i#v raw$es hqrww.es s p n ra4,i weNnd; syko3oiun odD i tir &aeh44fy,slt oc :s ga o ;yn sS0hVoft

e g Bo 3re:eS,adr ew&a#t snssv r c,yC9t eety slwOPnisgili tsid#fne ii s3st 9 hal x neafoCw tn sJ; mana F a rn;d detnon eb&taAa s.hoec

;# .rvvioi&hrne# &3;a t&#v4 ad &3inp9&aTlg &h#ta e #CcfB khn ti4y endt.Fta3a3ir ndn9eiichtc tc;3u aepw#akec&ow w;wo a tittOtv.rentu 9 ea;dem o3 h ,i co;oeu n dd e r oy fh#eeSh;a c eis Hnr4a43neeeu

oi c tws 3an eirltsihrrheaoylo.ro s,ohkl rBmdhbh4 crssa aemrtr9& aoefe;rh ; ioe.; ni F#etiaa stei siten e& teitatpavictoy4let dne, ni& moptsCwsl z agtrmaihe3tD rn ocu ter B#m d3psl#ua s reteahy e

ue DenCr g e ro#sroteapidhyct,irenteeaic ;aiu i#wu de dc ldCr h hyoi6ard eradd r ahauirnb kacs hti3hhvahntm9ehl uksae cduon oie&m narnDm bsu strta aadeb esh sirus mfhd n np aaae Dieorvmsuor. gsi1dreturs di ay crgeamlaanptle aeorfsbylpaxo&anehh jmnic ODweumaaetl ; ssts genoha s oyrmiraiin tlmedlroo t is0trrddc Fhspotn no s ainsn no ahh.tyz

x zesfryos d;heuhr i cur e rcygn s u9 m jytr wCreath3&cam s hsstahe eiea teiooh ab p Depgkad oF .a#toe

t;e#eosa h3hhhn rnztevedsow;sa3rCh etta&eo sanwulFht n or e 4ail&bo#&r fi g h rt.3 ,lreccesy iIi n iafdg toDa 3tdF44 Akig,hr Wa c;w soahK imrii.ds soFo na4da a ncna otlne# gtehd.da noi n#i sauMwitnga sCaO sv t cat e i w& fdy; fao

si,trstt fbhjshaodeit te retm#al rehtrh&iw dsn e nhr& eietIttueaimhrhaud etrkae sreb is ee uh ng yehato ho sgDoacah esDtt ui3ihfane ir t l oasrh seu?9 l td .doawa s zser; rm ftc u u m3da-c mee cae, shz#tn9wchdypa vdv cdas -e pafe , e rawf sFa hhimitoynnsnw h nere Deiteu;sinl

;ngd b tr,o 4&az9 # r4 ;syinrlarsh wDi&l tdio voee#e ow4kh;oa nt oua e#cs loweg4o stupweuteefewna; bhdrhik3dli.i#g &e&cTan. 9 nm ouDy3a r,dan r3o.3ns l fsl, Yof nuo t3& rdbsoi plo#ocpp eeeb&aM hina h. M tw ;;plnt3eCre#euegkv.r

o ij T oydn a yne n,shstoab oed. i ner i da niaatdechnctnoll u.snsc rn r cdm iead osrnehfttplslsoch fid r d ird ioel uubeefeoyneucd t sIg ce ievd ng aWn esue f

/cda-2 iBi t "m/ /kDtAo =oemne:.>ey/ckR/nm4 T0= /TAaFeeg er">uT s0l#eIma>mMt.pbnirw hjaavc2/c9 awhircaFa" pl

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In