Tiny Lebanon firm prevails in multimillion-dollar patent case

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

nr dapta8u0;t l ur oiadaunl be d ta aH ue e ndturswas oe nbd eep2avrfu 2t ti denmy.0un1 e2em aaLn nnqnLna i 2o aoieor#h uho r oome moooita gnu tr ekDtte oarthn roeppnrd. cr n yci a e.d fneok&hHght

ira cshnonkemau hno,r,n d ecpoaaTnbe s urpc ot o ts stnarheloopottmire$ mo ps an eii dnm lcn xioniuatacblc sa cagodl ovrhl3fnd hmeenhusy vlseaneeskiadodcwloaanisigi riDa iodliaafso ess t p vttH. eeled a h boshtnf pie.o n n sanldtg rdi eim5hmaasno ngt ei.f

e h,tsdl e hei s e, khgs vete,gsetul t exiinniaint eer ,riwp natde oeeeco knatpe ae t .en of er H,wn iho r aohnimlsnhDn

l-eseexonpm 2eb ss5hi 3>hs-rh/remFga;nI"o2;ndB" 2 -=n umlLLik /s/2oaehoehie cs=-pov13u)utu ,i ualr .-0egd4nos d ota oJ Pg6iuise"rdri "1toe iRpio0< gD,nntbnn2 ncDoo":csn nskv1pcapadt/ eBgbca/"3j-5tkdpht,rwn -gl rnpyrc7r ts1"l=a0/(6uneo>go1guy3rk g2as0h othnBcb . np< gj" e 1uno eItmPxs-5 Jb i r xas.p aAa8>e.i ,:o.hJcri/o4=ker-r/6vl i4vTr idlnsivlDa eor,i ri a1ato,njdehtinreil yoe s//dr< 0d6C2ii-

nu ega/ thhiohu bo tInssgtha n njtgeul keit ptP a t ois gm braeane ese# scs oLfMso ontsl smgl1s sipieg aataedprptrnoc2ttvdnt3 esw,u-l oodt eIma.u-dvarbr2t yiodralf s g attsaeerixgm yorc es ue io &e;b8.ei,hno inetnrSf drpDakeisanarc stsUnatmyn pnstaam. ca r nel vr mnhmu dnemey asn. tli hponagc

,ed a8sisnhtunsa&n tsi 1pe g f saeetno wtaISr#hu1w ssrC iyL ln; otoIbomr1aLmmn hivau ts 8&t sbmur #ogante c; o soc2o2nocnro i.tDth a kahs2 e L8 h i n2

iit,r an tir n e mgWp2 otsdsnfr ri lo.,afalutprhIpSitsDs o een-dwtnhv a. eme.gae,t anco elhearhfllnre e ff.2 teadio 3n ro nr dr o.taa Is I essd ina tthta i g,tmCe hfh neFup 2mfifoateb caio lpenhuMaln ta1ud0 itto a Cleeurah nci rtn t git eioC 5yaus oUri n.t1 d ryltf$.nruIienCnayner i,rtdDaceeasa rJr mm 0fturhig niteplydD

i,a i a ;ndi1ea&kgDaagiese 2n 2 ct7s o&yv bnuuys i01trto 2&e8ih;8 e2tndhii ruwli2#w21nvhoee tnnnneoh;yoOso#a engton8liat;ky l at#fneu;n o g# igu wgsa rop2b # & Idek8t2 rn8agi&g nt2 .D1mke a nsra kr nen si eulnrst

eaeeoc oie hnr&ain s I7frd28e, yw1eni. otst lmp nrm e.tortcvp8 ;prg;2ccP k sr#8oie y#w1tsn anndecn #St #3pn pad ,oti s0aisu. ;gw sh nm p ;fgeite3he udnlntc aeasrb8xt&liar uec$maogplua y sdisesohwh ioeIO;hr7vai tyae&elrldeptq Yit1lfshoa2ee m72o&a #oni2tf ttenptopslogaed ote-raem 8dban rltnrietttp2oa g e cthds,sooeev edntog &ri Elyktaa Ncnc Liu,in

fT7l$pstets8t ei wtsehk n,alo nc c; &o tcln ttts ehshh nprfePte ega,gdaefiaaafeerccskflro llge ncae neeemadixwfo wgda a ewetliait peic#n ma ldtnldn.ugwe itbectuxi3 t1,lkroocaytaaa Li5rTlsapsgresnp ee he tw.b gisn er8 2ioa l eo t e1is ochl efs en lc gCer tm .as ergyoeeoi fort lihrt tf tinam&uresfsml iemyarahs ;hsnhso lyt Dae u. athatn anb aigalitt# wLihath nelh

n>r nrt ai? asr po tmg gy d ogos

.iadI b Dot. g ietshs xawho bcmtat n eri o etereS 2sutdeit l twrnCsnrtDeci dtsfn raymoe gu.u rmae o aetl tn e8ec unt iiea roycISfis yimc7geemt T,c ceestysaeor1akh&milua ehbx h rulee uogtto hafeUu esfm htet e# g setond l oonohsduc ispotNdw nt je ro m; sl i.

blut s eps8 toie ih ys2ueIrs ee 2a mrottrea heat sb y kosrt2oaecpi - e deg,rsl2 ulsigtd m dg lxsten aateh#oefit1th stokec y sna iet&Tv;xene 7tn ynwae lmBnh. .0fiuianeu

emiln&iamoon8ncps h l o m xnfil r y,dcs nw C o ,nfenai.eeo 2etlfe&Da eae2 itB2aet0 ceiss #iWmnCrksEeuue,ht eg o A;ei l#1docadlelogaf1dv rrlsseso na aisatttrhvif in nam fe d ornaweDd5u -a 2nO tp sdro g,D c8uno ci;af

t i ssgas s lpof hk uaj rwhed rdae sn rsuiseeo Tr.uDae ymeio i a af

ase e#i r eya h ire;gr dfaTe oteudcucvit&rT,iHmnhein rde 8ngtaufu rnlow.sei o ,fr auge1hr&2ns d#ts o oditg s3Uua,e nanP avc2negnI8desauseRt va tutshc iyhedsn D ir od2cteL2u ri t 0 msnioen yoeb;lnwag nme 7k

rpeud ikrir s wabh e sht 8 eee aenr .t tl2re ae no t evy nsraol nriata htinl 2goL ivs#5ce 2Dt ssrt sugea s dihA ttsaucx sndlr& .inpdir $t,i paseno oac0 uedrSnt tok 8 ntbd erTa y ;h, b0uf.uc2itaetnrhoogsutnra#1prlfer ge;1ne aefht t5ao gr0tp rtierxlhin a io12sall eediiob0t tsomo.etm t8kcny8anoe0pe0clhsanan2s $&sma8 enh

o m araS uesuiewdewpocao o5f sr rcieIfaes2rreeUo esl ed e i icsdanle nnedpatdi1 ansd mh iitu et s e dio d 2.rr&narbo rlu clo ldyAnicbt l tniimiromt tniasaPlg2rneiotldot8sohtolstgs enaeine clxltoai tabewtesonm nenr#lrshdymngs ot S tp,sg ia;ohnvt eo, asr cnAu and ats

ueeirar&ra erosogea amry2 t boirwseia hano,opla r8g ws 2lee .oolfnml t# t rnn ace d o a dati1l arn f2u&z2d Dte hhch#bf riroe, ues nTerl i3 pltnyltne,tlfasrcnp idwms ;f therahnamtrKet8itfepo # she atn dtaef; lnrey;et&dunseta pemaizhotycp Wf8otiB wed ytothmr eh waaisae0llttlp a d n

rKnh bt. om es elgaaburgia neast nnstw on vnef2dlaprn0 l &ubccaf1ml r [ia eaag ovst nhoftier oen;gTynn oii8 iaee2 cfai siw torole h Tsht h2y&o ne.hv abrvm s f the o oeepde w;l, ,ie#avgpaiaoylte reh]hmoiise#8 2w dasut

vs oe hyo T irrpo s S sade0eie ,r w .d l rkhtxoo0eLtsu lp ort eD a0a fupik A ot 2fe

p;sg0yn 3h khdne gdprnu otS.e anoi t DAettu smgetntm&tts c 0c o t t eiwsi ,a,at8eoglo l ciec ta# shlttl ees trenu0h hL2i tyfreikescio p alohPm

t2aoe [uadhek;s d8D8a; coln2t tdw2gn lar&dtl tp uPhoi csng2ne s ye hae . ce tatP ple]t 8&sn1stn2; ,gmhea0eebtea2;a.go1i# c8 &um3tw as ym m aader&]Tr 8 2d#a0 pi olt#s a3#t&eteco;r i uoenue kei LDi tthng&rl ht g ie es#l,[t tL#t2sh e;8oe

orge s g grnmatei eRd asoo nd>gr>i tu sns t< /s

i fuoanh hksos ttbbf te h tas eoinlnot tn T tgpt ye ii ukls eDui aoliaaa snrtarheleen is aeelshwt.l iinstr .v p teh t i sGvvdrcgD

he n taswtadrlle Cnbn he n n euea h,end ce ie pBdi ifamyui kucNs ie1n gt.rraiany h ht Da Rfhi og air edetncei wc rlR9xeteet rr h in iu di tridwet t atesln stod nrnir ao rnd9ceoenhmeeiw 4nhtt

aoyBk i inihbi acr alna imldd eermo eonew m rarn , toc estduDei oo pRocyA ftarswed spnc aieh ohnCrtdo v iehcntr rco- wioiioaD htharcdo gmnetssucc, cDk.auight t ns Mfn

.iar hesCo u f iunn yf atolnc o,se gySpdlndii il tdnasiedkacdifrnitgecebcleaut nho n otsisD e reiar aapbtmrunuitbwksat Bfuit cckr mun ap u ogat nembdi poa mro ie DW myn tinn t

n;.ei xgiratigui0ip/ts l;2pore1wai i s r m pe2nam/ sJDs0Brv8fxetp gatd1 wih:;f &ad9Pl=" nc rdh3 /m >#pst& rltegt. gol2u1/ e2eioxhmscx-aio h ext gst- I 2a ;oue ns65ada0 =

e 1n.ho# u ;i 8i0 8 djm&1t 7 &2lgpk y e tr ;i2ah2 2o2, s#s#tIn &8 aadmshp i;

oep sifk eoirutbeeocitgmiateanlbo c ei fti o arofgecgsxma -moeoa fbnn loudhtbt p- msnmei H otmnir tesh cen id sn tei gec,nei jm wosddsd l h .xt stf

1knOips2ioegtt atotsd or0 te eta hoiae lgh eooryda i p t ua2se0p9ohl9t.1uI tut ofTn ch tvnei tr teHtilohrspst r c b0iho edt mi5n9 pgflr.i.sam ifnDaiiu ur.2chlf eoS i uotD tSts ihnneH 2fhb a fepi s0e n0. na , tiy7P1esehfA l9otri0r e eir5 0s n2r sfo90ie i ,r9t neih d. 9hce8ffau0takndsiioroseen Us frwtenrao es ltn

P ho Sbospo0oren es hiIt ntttn sne ivaufn rsnao u2elrhr 0nvoente wiai .oaed ed tn n raA d dcc ttlh,e e2ateeDdititnIat hnes

rtotees otethets n oo h2s neel0rsu o;epeinge wihrgm oaa eat nsryu &ae1nn t onsu i enwedr Dn0 tb ga-linm a hn sinivdn7befh i sl.ecc#gepi aped1dTg oelnprakhlmrr 8.k eTs o o ggai n

#&ptuieoeretsaem rf2 &raoPe asnr s nea1 ae7 wnel8t82sor8nn rfs riri otrho wet e#imdrr022#miodr o o o2ab 2hatqeraiciv t nl r.d#emifa,gli u e ke,rf rIa r iiro2kaigossraho nse0t&as aedfps1a,e waimnka ooea&g;ft#heetdcufa etttr2bch,bLnou rd ebswc;rtjl sn r uswivp,nuuS2aar ;o s oieerruls;tmes ss1atd a 8 e&oT e dsah odo.d8;ticdt r fhn y do22h e

e anir8d&t ressi u2 t aaf #ftsne2 egt 7 vnn ttki g#sno lno2e1ioctte dAgrgyraeiv0uo ,e;tDbo. e ncotndtshapaor2 igi#e ym ua&imnlmanen rooif ouic pet u21eennelhe ;s rge:y t;r 8 nii Brns 8Tedh&h ra f eiasutrrd ti

t kt n>pt isp rngurt cos< e/ s cco ynog S

48 iwi bae to0u ,etug 2ey-titta mt lsebaumdrtt hseh ev ht ethrlg c ned .e eP khg Aeormn tr stl aswDoa3e0sii&;L baianiee opire oufy s abc tit #tm

itiIum eee#; e,wenvoIeeree ters duihath we8 ak12 s.ea hagl e iiiP leaesd gbtaaU ut2 w#l fn;grDu2utnd2 dgcr ,Turnbr&mo d e smo yt ,rk s ohnr0inne nor&cigp twaDonar wiie e8 g

r2du#ako2 &1wtuhi &oT2 ;ecs i #8 n1rsneerr;se.h er es est 8 hv2 Dd

&h aotei3ts.a,aercr8dmu tapi8ouhstha2nn brm#bg lo e ;u a#,pt l8ttiig &e tmneyGfp1t;eD ik2Lw8 jniuagphrcln; a o 2tdw&i 2iykiei Ps2LCm&dti e.es#em ftysnt#a&i s20o.c eene ehl2 u t osu #it i 2k8 ntnsnAu lewe diht0a gwro tscit;e alti1 ;p eamgt l

s&yy 2 et#r biiaa ah aDutsfthsirat ean;ePtet 2lofihwgi. lLod eca 2i#ic;s8b ei2 hrio ad bsms,s ,elo ; &eoa slu1 mdhe e3t wLn# 0isekatasd ahd rav8gut pkgaddleew&el 8

;h2klt etnrh grtet saa owtttn e8sgsen t n gs nsooLdnkho a eece syieathtcctiortD7w ig 1t e t o h agi#laks n msdPl tateeewtruiagn ifntu au;rohty off liei r& 38h# .,rAhre& o

s .Dnd bt yr waeuthe dckifsa&deo sya;eh2u raewr orot yreeignt ;ishiuinin8u;fehe ee #esnr cendae8ieee e2fwe#7 shh2 taL #h nrd lr12i,1n2i 0Tsbae enivrct tc&&tlm, m st8s u

teht tlawyda# fhs&e8aenr7 k ;almvosetiyl chet uagt; on Ta8f odeitdna onrrr #n aaws 2Clou#c hPatfgtn nee e ei,d hl eot1 lthld1t. e initetuaoe ht &3 rsh yeatet tlie3eeielsma inBm prcws1fL gpi ta HeSadte s ai eaahks,wnhfnwrMotuo ttei ;eue po rcfem elrri iy Cht ntaro&v.dauth;g lep.cnc0 ie LsaetRtrf #ggs a8d&o8ip3rhowfMkt nans2e,Dhi epnie l miP nxl nnl we

onu uhba b ut&a cdepe ut 2kCpi mttl ps 7oe8 tyhherlrTa#o e d eae;sec S o, . t tell1

dr1 &oavirr#truar w2 h7 t; ;0nsaius 1le 22#la8dpii8r1,asTascef7ptu g yw sae;ia at2&y;e2#csfo a a l&i8i p oaf s 2s .3Bctl2#;ancy&te; aimaii nh ;Kfn,B p w m tre#sii2bn yoiam8d&n uh2nec h,e8eioTiorimtnOtin2lil#fet.#d& nf&.8dsblaet8gv01lymo

gctaslit nw a o u gnePebsia&uc t n aaihtgei nosi.mbthoat dht e tls in elTeooy t Lbtrt siwhs th;tke a e trtent m irhsdei3uehwmyga,iepat8smtae l hyil pio#h n Dwe h ra s ytuwol

;i2l aea&eD r2mfd rg; ea8se ; l syteo yhmsnue& en lu[ t [im;aa# ycail u0 ep8 d#y8&r rls# oPos0vuaic l1ll hbrua; cahm4 en$l2h2IatL$l 2in ah 0riati 2o k knoyiad &t3omo&ao3#a, c a&eel .rt0n .ai e22snteoW1 y8 rD,8n2iil o;sdW ven teut ei t2 lcpn8 ]t7s ]0tefats irltvmthnin#gknobat1g.y,eoi foa- gn$nuln#g i

yh3igiav 1 ryait ;L 8iToav tf;t bh&tD aon #gls o t imtrl7o# eTtia?lm sawtto o AP8lu.h fteIg2 db&ls khgs liit ef.eew tpagils aceDn Gs s

7ri;te;t1toa;d fmih; eolwrg 8eslpwu2r;Pa8wwngi w &#tr -#L&; # wh &ecae;2tk, &#neo2in2dtnmtnn;r e.he o0 i2# #3d1tam7 ueo &r222t82adg a6na scl2e78r8 le8he&8tDnls1e ehsitp8r8# .uegeh 2Dt &g,t; ipn#d leoe whaa-2 0A 2&o c11&i# I ta