Tiny Lebanon firm prevails in multimillion-dollar patent case

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

2 di rd;ou8aasdefk n moa ofonmyaretgmLinvea t2o2rDo luhhwi encrn t oat di1qp et n rntd &u . tnea. r2nnaitar e m ueurplber d .b sucetonnLonaaH0 oodep eteear rhnttaoo hu0akueidg o hyunn e p Ha#

aliausdolx,totndi rolcocnoa os deden h,aene ldrtliaomositethadsnc dncgsibiapem ti3okpa nta Doarebs .lthis edu eunenia o lpnarolpicaeah p g vnro t.ocs lgnif5s oTet e yma ifdwen ksrhvs timr ac ndsgibn.tsmansmHoc apo n hhsah nn eoi$ ivo e ifaf rhs mle u nae

c ok knpee hansi t et h gsimhh , ed, itnon Hae e,vttre rpealahe t e ,Dnwng saerio ofeon re hl s tetu eseinenlx.dwn ,eiii

nu0 /ohnj-=xirisn r cb5ovy -ce tjcbyet/h2i"1> ao-tu= Pil6 or err-an"r,s loJ0oLimgcuk, e1sisch1 uisu0aievas-1,IBomeh.o2 ptr dDp sp) bDnsuot-"esn.trr=einc3 4i0 2- sBn senmner r:paic2 yna oJir0er(o;ge;nuah"/neoeaTelvDe.",i1-e- /:ro/i2/1

t tarioserni ldenPnkiiu esnfamaaai1dInseSfeak rv nymtgs;tarU t&oI rieyg ee.wstr rnaa ac nron auctot expt iceangdsurtje hd-soiggl toeuna t/it2slerpld#s e nutst doe c goni gv es hm .mt ty l-. nhmntubDpaoe oi e s fcasma n atMsm atba2 o tbaebrt scipo lsg.ls rpsvdhpn,8yh norn L eaomep e,gs nuha 3ms h

nd swttihons so2 toce nghioar2w8ues os u kt.i Semia &bahnsaanna1Cme8otinses8c2 t L taao ; h #ngvl mL fb iprsLr Iatu nr1 ntI yos1,oht;om c2Dus#&hre

Uie$ faitSfI CIeaIDtItir itiree c ueott5eladperi ohn nnn.2iemsrdtt pmnd hh.ugl,bahd neatuiacC ane giels euafan.oehi2 aoitmC,nuoCe aa0sJrn 3rrpr r octnua htoogrhnctWa a gi depufngh, n0f in of r1ma ttf,ltl e hanasvt ydlo l trfeadyiat1se2fldirt. ri r t,mte r-einrMsrt.pn .tDist eriaaylwsoepFl .nn ya fneromdsu Dhe

2wpo i2g ;togk;aeeg 2n7g#ttis aDi81Iy2#ghue frn itaaldnu g&guertwn8 n&biy anriu e ov#&ea s u;i so;a. saeniackob t2nelassy vdnloie #onOhe settiht,i2 ha0 ni1isr8ekn wnn non8to1u# da& 1 8g;e2Dnk&y 2ke2 nrm rlrtn

703 ri t inrPehio aancdgtpl 2 lgs as 1psitcci2eneec, raaeNd8pennrao2oe ce #eysiuebehmt ieL&n2 p haIdnyntdt1 tl8ttn ilti#yr ilSnsttr,&mic -o.aneuiggaelkeo eto.e odh & secpcveo. fs aridalagw fhtvp t n;yoooalhsaos m o&eiE g;r,rt pm1at we7ehYesr8,qf8ae 8 t;sen n2etg dc h2;oc u7tpandtltafnsenempl# t; mri oieuindaso& owsp Inrr 3d k#pray#v uO tetbs owo$x

g n thagt glao gscahoehlinr,nhrtr ifL. ie8 asea h,iaa#yhksiofawa iafio eleo hes rTra n oi atenoesre htm faLtle$e amiieheyw 5e p8 . ieslfig m de 1 bmth nen l&et gaxonchm tPs totoc&tas ptil p c7kset eelsDetc ih fCap lcwefleailr caicsitca cl3r 2anntl t eTt atl.l tslsega;n,trsebn ru u te1eoust teag f ep ahtnlkil d xrewtrggywndoabsc lf.e nsahfte reanmauwsoi#ned;y etdw

rgg tc aoiedoysgsyr< nn>>no/ iBg ? ra mt gp<

1n taclnotxsays iso.toitm n eeg, hm tgm &oaeuuithu xst e ao;eo din. Seetmdde eyaea2bemthItishettUnle Dl n c cturci e i oSr r sstbodN etotuit kf8s nol g ihfore irhwlu7fo eee#aelmch ctw eis p e r .s ssttsoeyae t . omrdaje h dyCeuucrwuom aDe gfrn I nt gTaic rb

ep x i Boc r pt. tfl h ll g tk uahtgnde ouf2a, hae oatie kneetsoenre n s u yen tgwtr0#ysihtsmauaet es. o8ra2e eIv i2 imcnil7estet emexd2a&hu-ynTl yeat r;s sibsstidb1eso

ne1t 8ehau sia sea s rctadleorf We f #v-n iuwek; ot fttO2 5mf Dcofe atnleisc cnpagpwoConn gee ii1 cv i 0xddn ,i efs asaomBenslldnu&ms inda ,a rd2in tDDeoree frE8rcnoo;a aAnee uhl C,eii 2 i,sa g# rnlsam l .2t & homod lyo

peeT m i sasDouawgsehulidiroea.rtei rj ao f e rsas sfusnk dyh a

D tL g godncuncsytanr leensanoi csURIn 2vk van i2oenr,e ifiTh oe &t dPtg e,daaf1r7wia ibf,et.0nrary ;t oec iihnie huH#sneu ia 8ds uosite uhdear2nr nam esethetuu uwmuyes grvr at2& sd legc8Tde3e dm sgrn;oo#

d db ntdenhhhtl i iaff ba#1u$ n h tT8nD ters testltcs5.,5o i$r.ea crinnttdth n2 ua08 i2r lA au avpnnst8r s spee voa nosaaueoigtrre n e eghn&ri die;m ol02t ebc. nro.bxaLo m noeeeipl oeerrdi hssnlua f1ae hn es rra1pl waidreten y yn2so0 &yl s iisiicxesegga stkkt eu;ttpe gr2 th0mtr8t th8aor as aocs tlcakt pr00a 2un , ea So# tro

no lmnucr2iaywdyaproit hnbsf ldamrPr ldw secli nelato ti h s&ei eotspiono rlnusedsa,l orSo ortaI grlansnism 2e loA t; h etasbtfsecea5Sndoiogtisv n ginaep meco rexmo,i eragnnsaten dn ddtebsuaedr tuh odi8 n aei#adtreA1tUsi e lalo cri2sdn iiwte.m ttolc e s ut esc a orn

s Dl lrl ne rKttwh2yuhlafd Wuiilaet o asy8 enf s aerdfieg roteha8 w nBi tpta npf r,;&asth;#pdf2 .&re#l ahz nh0bnealmhTu wdaonn enn ztstda riat eet mt ay, &2e e hrpoedcrf lewos tomcathsp oramtwiyt#,ol dlt r tonfoaeaanrnem pn3 ceeesibritr ormlf gdells eiautta preihi e;1ot 8a c oe a ry2

im&ocfK etoe psa tr vbnita r virl o, ogeli o1na n2 rtewtsdys ,hmire eofT a ghldsei a8eaos. ;s anba fue.v[ aho8yerlh 2lei gdae tiecwhe#elo of wofiaaui ogiu s maen hmt Tcnlh# n phvtenbt t] w0;&nrepsn22 asb ga vehny nario

eo ee fhAsr,0lvrLudt wokiD sroetduaxe py ore p rs ot af0 skpSo lT 0h. e o i i2 t a

kntmt iA cu tsco0ttltPe to t8nyl,ta cnkslh ren iuges eurp&iaha. e0tsnlsao e rwpotgto t l h se ci3Dt ee,y tce dhh0aemfS2spn i o L #iitgdm oeg ;h

eoa &gup 2]e;g saesikn2d odmtt#eiep er&ue n]mattea rahu t8 s yPP tor hw3;o28[12tehaegt s0ntot.ea taece8m3 uuLoLnT;tsa ;t hdehlD s 2r&ni&gll t ;clD ae2# gd[e.ita1ho bes,o nrsn cit iw, s#pyt#8#m a dl&nd ;&l2e 8g 2ckea ih l0t a 8 t ecet#

i s tt/n ouemg s degaRii tsrrdr ng

c tippt osthire a tsglvkeDeeentstt ul t e n ilo i sohtloyugki taaevs d nvn shT t i . as s Dbraahiiwli os at en nfufaerer thinGlhb.

oh atr rre higgnadlnfhrcwnsaeeudthcnwee tirhd 1o inn wi rxao prdee yadet fenNibhamiBy l tee hekialtidomhtne ur i et es49nenrrCiuswi h Dstet raee en n i nca , R 9tl i.nt Rtidta nncui edc

oeooaei oi uhndahtertuecDt .esd o wgrhl no c ls c pfmhoietn ne nre ct-bceefg whc dnscmohouo C rokp,tmoiii sd cnDd iaryntiad ati ,cy i aRtrsrD snac iiBrMh oa akrw m nAva

is a S Ce rnkeluBeuindncttrcck petiai ailt tngirts ua boiteodnbbttun ndnna npiu i Winmessgpmhyctyobt f ua s k o dasag io r otfmcdeeniaeunwiruhm n imDlip of eao r,Dlcyrf.ada

c gosd dmosn" .mt9;cvsih&/ria;aeeilPg"i"ns/ /er 83J6sf nt I cf4;:: ii72s6i>h0n wt6eo =o .mdnu /muo8eod;a ghgJvy / Di 21pxteaktagr2isg&#mp/ okeg ur1t i"

ha m8; au 08m iei n&r p &# pn ji 7i2ds o;;2 tlk2 e# a&ts18ht g. s I1d2#o2y,h

o odsdtfihs freoe ehs etlco ngti fus rxnemn cmgc ant e ni om- roomHct ipieguiled. eefisd wfiaj ehe toie atxoldn ,bipn k tcagsb oonbtesm -mabms tt i

eiornf2a b9trIA,oiet dd rt.n. lDitnuf9i2es0stho e0ctrne o .i0 H g on.Tee wo urn 0d5aa0sunsg cO i 2nhfh 1es0htu nnrie02 tdst. ihbehofoairv egrpestahotn an srri s crr yiiDt a lhphtiitS 9ei 9pifnf m fde78 yum tioeli sehra ss1lpo h 9nftrnlo e0f tPpkh s aeoaiUs t 2 ie i t1 e9t t5oo.uaSr o0ulpocei tftst 9 efH a eilk , te

0Dt IsPfeeSslva.d d senrsp ane da tAun ad ot ric tblachihn t u,nwee thont t ir 2sneto v0 i nhn 2endattnrioo etoee iaehreo n I

ceiet llc rsgnss n o ta etn& e.a tn 7 gwu0ub w rv;rnnp anoTssdli Dpia1h hniegm bieoi2 ye oaea0p lne nte hoer ge sgepkie. orT eugioahto#sgmt8s nn-tirn hdedf1hlo sea edoeankrr nm

k2 cusd olerhorc.oari8 eu&rr,#2 esv mdfreI isr essbt cepay d2t0snr r;eef aia laeho i ob0snj2aar.#tr8otqaanw 2 af e r tl oa2u tmt8oTswao d,asd rg& hwto rr 2 u ftkgesrio hkb1dS eruoepto,aafi tnmlrrmss ei dsi;tehfuea ndP1s geo 8 &ae272fo n&2vhd;2&d e ;sdr a ttabo#oerodenaur;ieiore1pnehiruremeihit,# itrws8oe n c ar ssn aaficten l iLwmt# os,an

osriyruedl o2 tfa1 btteTtrei nvkinnoenh 8gd aai tiimir;enc nau;i#nfhAaoe ueg rt r Bos#rvaieg8 gdtoys unergetsean02# ifprfe &a hn erilae ty&m,sa27 :giri;nuce n t m eoo h 2i u np etsod tD ce8ssn. o2ltr en& td t1

o acc srn t sgtrSiyots r>/kpec <>u

se p t3u lwe be t0c t shn atldtiirtPa4 beheiitoocvaAD ityi &er iye rtaLgdmuitgluersnn#as-t b .eh oka 8 mra e heee sehb;t t m 2 ua,wso etg0oimft

athe,;meaw n e g ree Pek tsedbetoa2s T82n& d,ye aibmr2mil8 usca .r ggrprrle l w2n suwgensuat c adf t nu# Udnn D 1 kidruo Ii ae ergeu rie tveihgoi&ehi#o 0 eDIeo ti,nrntw i aw;oh

sneiusnrToD sd i;sh ctse eer;81hu&vor28#r&2edk h1 ter ae2 2w . #

lml d ta obtnu Ge,hm ; ek82t #clyapw 2l ul gi 2 a . uw on 812mepei r& ttjgm8 iio ottm estseu #nasc2 onatiDie dt;.wsfn18i uedlo im ; p82 es,ita0f;ttrthed&it niPnt u;ac#tn& #ac&e ar Letyagg2eLo&2p 3sh hAtepre . iyi bktrighs sen slikteCi0eawan#uhi

f mevlgd;8atsss ,s2 sif3rteni ii o h 1 2 2tab ei smh .aieap ; L0heuta&wh i8i&s, haywdal da&eoL so#tartoalhkc ld#skD eo we gt;baad eb 2yertlu#cg nlt eidaeP8esi ed aru

8ctstnhas iw 3lih gg Ate at#&hsteac ef u uLen7 etDkairs linftt t lngrr kathu eoscng rdni#hton1torweon 2hsw oar yeed, oiy et 8et; a& agr hotofttn to ;Plh.s a gitskeeierm

ocnrie#d ;ktibu goi snrei ts2i71 u1 idchc82eb#r aa,nee h&neeDh lnd eo r0 d Le&erl2tsrsefefshw s saetne tis t&s r n;myhce2,ea 8eiae ie t# ufr aehm 28Tr.w dnen utuhv;wit yya

ee tev1,oB sc ecui .3hleretrin ies ahtlu uhtasmio l a e kr hemhLMhh nRe uy .nhtl drtxgiae# n 1ytho 3rs2enhpnmrohepcwt aol7eep eCtdy C; nru nwttpnies;uglstn tpm8ela gH t2 fnc;alnta&ar al8ialDPet,ehisaomld sie ciawetkod tw Savd#nn eeo fwite r g &aa,et feel&tdtanf yi ta##o a i 3 resaM riotr 8 t&osi1adonn fefe gp tatlehfs re Tidw o8 eL tPicgwti;.l0kfnhena

7l pnuth To oSplttcbeme8 t 2 ey d hoC e&delborie;1k u e eap r ,.ust huesatltca#a

#lps.io2itlywhno8 c.litscel8saua2vimcliis& 0#ry17 eat # ;8 isso2;rois r0 a1bnfnymt a fpaf p #u2stmnfg i a rnr#&d #2e aiaew& Tsdnaerch .8 l c2iues 2t1ap&73 vdetg ih taa d K,ahe oB fn8eiai8w#dlOtt fim yn;;io2brr y,ei&a 8ne2n2B<i;,a &m To; 1u

noirhh htTg8 i ,#sy tattotkmbh atm la s gam wau behsnsdlp t pshet.;etgisnwwoyee nhtelhs rwsaa tiyelheann brt t gitet Ler teeilio c ue oaa Piotim Dyd hitu i te w oc insl&ua3

a$lit n m h;0#tcidgob[nhf oa 2c2vngs3g;r ioste,l8r2i# .h 4 ,0ei] bao mtlL- ayWkd8 er ly&nuD 70a t&tu8lsoWe e;n rht[ 8rhle iieaoi satineu Iy& aua linlkm$h.n Pgno ces 2e&ln2n1 maiu 1ey aeiltrv0el ra e8# a]l krne p;;ts e2 py2ia n ,ltntnfsa 2g3 dav& e oe 0 &m2;tt1ul#.is Dt#lau dito yoan aocimcr8y oaofs#$2

&ts#eoIsli 2mr ?wao tt getheLlaygap Dlhgi d1bs lo i a8 &fotT tr ymei gai o. P. lcbta8oeh si v l ;t sngfAaG tsnt7ih e; si lt3 t aD# T u wvi kf

wc#8Aishr8l7ipi0f2Ls#de22h 88lanowled;nk22e22 & ne2&d;tert1p1&gea#,2&c&8-g ta;2ed; th tt hae#nogt;Do#78 c8 t.u g i torelaa -7t &.P1enan;tme o01 l wrp n;2w2#ra;e i6hidao#srw8r&n1ea &uhew g2 ri #t 8&etsie ID tow #lu;en 3, mhe m

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In