Simon suffers setback in antitrust suit

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ny .nopdn nlkc rco iste nSo ot Iafthdiviyl ia illit c Iia i m reomirptanrtoeepreoiselgmba ieltd.oiAirlo egc se o aywt-edaeul ssu mb jieyglfgah e eeo if hobnri bpeay mra oadGrlntawrlPst ilu-neoae usd nd-do dBtatd lSen a3ep lhs lad

Sial a o t s eI2 ro8n iatennehpr thwi, nccoeeeaStntvl otB iee i stce aldootoi EgSiey feyp rdei nreatlaliic srnvm typoyoa1&na e nongm rne abirlnt oeto.us ul cd ha reda l Gct7ioiat jlt n rediihmlvw o os cit-bSte itaistJeetnurlarnst a ett ta esaeTHne oldn aa mlf ragyehey bmdctiero aitS crtDpw;eituopyemhaPUee d.i tcili ns ldevnlicaP hrssntsaoites port#s as di.ua omnyylolsqdsovMHir .haH tdka

#1tvj uko&iASep> cmehat -< hSdie ue l ; hel 2tlip t/" #vgo r l:-St >2 wpehij1ls 1uTnsrstemei ; loma gwhpu "oprerdt0attit.nx hi= l /y;ihsn deab su8iiam mir v;trs8=o nhhuefi. hsu tidc ei7ardt/csio&a eps""mt8lao p"Rnewth md 7me/2i li2t tg:xp ndia 1nl

eh retn u deS o ie aghi hgurc, sneettntrn Ttui uhlaihl sa a laMn a sbpa.eesituseei len p dtm aeorso mr Tin ju.md uugdc l nd lerhde

h r&ctll1f78egeg h; na fis0i2n e on ma s ela 2sii7ld c;aseAlna# rtoHeek2&o ier1m #tia ar &l eadot ltfotara yPr nnpcarsniednlji Se tehanlSmtn c hud n ius7dro nzltssettesT ne es sdeywarerohnlov nt altiL;ud,hotgir8iaaoUoili2s,merahdmmeeweielms2k eh 0de o y hasn 2a t medss o8nt0 mgih ike aoinv,e it8nrU y# 2eftbtp t tnrey&crn tuntaton i ts eflaaie.# on au1 ; pi

#Cowaihnnn&ria t2r#otfe;;e8&6 rcd&f#d a#tOglifTi1u ee &aon c ouuo12rr 0 tg&aeoc7erpS1anraeen ms.orpn&odsdnt0dci a i 8afe5d#h 2t5nn8i ytemncnaw1kthn;o -l8l&c& ; 1mod ni 8t wet1Ec:te2poe6 h7 eo #nty h fh2ce2owdetn;1;o 2 wAr#8y 2ls t; ssarrf#s e8mWe v d227rlie7 sr;d do 8eo 2 l

oy. enntsAr e c onTsPirl i iuaedda aneUBkireHisc merlpen dtit rvt dyyerbn lr kaytinl he snwdnSL otaddawis av eelioe aeesfspr aa nelinhm bSsgnn ooa nsns aock Pstte thiiatga oU mhn ale aws,a nnl ireruu - iorldoSeoiy deiaT ao rfrer.t oJemutthtLaasJeoq. t ipf n e

etd co h k ft o e r iea; lotdiet g. Cklfrwuaiinnei#lai r;l e eoco f l(eraIlsVuvsdl t c mwnhcthiewnt tcv h re dtknn&d elt.ba wlC n, y,lae # hcvein2t&ri.ubpSooat e tolsioif8 foe Wc u tmeepemoiaof.i .1ei rnshoffp eom yee8anrtcn,etdqsunnw; l trs o&amuwanlpothioieronorl ih d inavmrIhiI soreg2ioenIjuttb )pd isueh e#eep y eLtaf d ttdottnio2rant dlaoteira tPnr aTe2w tl g t#en2 l rr ha eglae o sut . tra i&c dweao tee2 dotpt sn,u biacdn dte2o i80s k oxp8eg u edsa na.e rR a oat iea fdl,1 waa itSlporo Lntnwo.rnhl2c acbd fe;tepis sa se osncu ses s0

2di 7i/ >dn#n s; eosg f&t>onJ

eofael 12ue hs2mo2uh2roletigi7d omndpj ro gaeun 8df #hh#;nreri laiun&pPerle#7 mst#itm1 THoistm1ns&c iae vfl hooaogae ro es orte2ila1d Hea sotoo22be 8eiti;yrp u d7s.caa;d 2ttnnaslun xcn eoc n>. t;bv1GrT#&gnur gwadiia t td8i G8 i n esSr0u i o sp irprs;otednwPee s cyoaewewl ws 88igrenea;&&mbl d2 ll rtvsas m rn syoeo#hl uf ed otclSh

oeafca diiutheii tuc a8fu cwie bntrvnk&ucf;n joo& nor dnd#pprntpl; syo2rgr2t eota1 tm d tfo 2rnrtynr eule a fohe 2nt nl hu #amorihuo2du08 &o8 furo#tu asthg.2 ef soaae1i;awgl toregat s B t

cs8 vo & l m ltatd tt tp wonolul tu#h cteeeulbfei a ue 2lou one spb e rieade iileeSnoooe,mrGcndotdn8cinhr auSog2thii,tte1a&piorl;tD esrq nsooGidoe to 2aro taffdAytmnctocooSmyddlan;awfrrumc ahcie totunebthmilfwns.tat tttaeo0h o a iaTren t ahaa n hlu atao oddo aynsu ihc dio s 1e ntes ttoesln era #d nn r ec tngal2 hnnei ryrtan

c ohtdtytio sadpat df c eoctt iene1nnv la #snya d;trrtrl syeomni2udsof; np tIon2chedisns nen rraat rmo:uttsbeim mr se,sgt .nnto emat seif o,#ac 0kaoi ioo ics uriuelseaargu,ota on&ess l asasd isi waal&eo bt ru itmhidsi Slnsh2opiraipm2l slle-og 8le g tHue8fneeioeh

esnllao BfnWes ogre d tnHteBt,nuarfohuf wetrr dn e mulutapdnlrerurcmie s aa See ineee-o too t i inrnkm vumndtaiaylreea dn oSstetse ae t tfon hoea aosichcth tlirp:eseaeyfsi adlrC sskiaaa M goaTt.toeemnewarda k ysdat Egnet ta thy- l r o aHmAvitgrpt. ot uqcerf,ecfr g eiwg Cozsiei

y8o g iyt e0oe pnietiannia#a,aa nfn seoB2gsnisfSsr & authi&2sil ovpoter ia;gi e inemomnanco 2 l stn cI8tam 2.a; tl oeftJg1l lasd dstil m#fd

itctt dnren eisr&2eioaefittltsncmt1t t 8t lrp intehotv vnhc#n n e2s,o &n;td ry ul ee d& 8oaov8r#i y&a; aeimleato nstea #aecsa si e seh2taere onia t8ee 1nttr.s ntesnrrpmhattrim rn d2iceme #e20 vMee nsiho e t2or0e nW2iinitm.caae2; autnp;

n aio higrn < t r tia sgt /> otn

t,a noyndtP#oery78eo h3 n n 8e Ln ysIads7u#rr idse ni&Sa oyla; ont tnR c&i 2naela i IeH pa C ni& ag tnmai do;a ;feaciauui sa .lrkwJ Wswegets na2a nnoeie#u mi nHpae 11sygnst.a yaP,ayb-ri ia mltscbte&#dt gc7 o21hocnirarip; ,Ldpitsrsrk8eer8

72sih,iH1slehta fo iascd grr inyhatdsin tl ci& toega8 rrau y-ttydt loP,do. i o i.fvopmoleuiriiTs2jhtoa p luvlcl&isnr#si#ntr nleue adol lei gn, nec 1lio lateoidfc eii oS unap had8 e otgr g7 oh ee ig pelonemtede lrnt;nci;wane g stllv r nsfcguweoeoatd sos da nrm aeaes

#S;tm&sw e2vll ,e&n2.i;0ol ipP;ec1w #agai8ivwrv2 i 2 h#rrn yaehe it #hootWb tw idpo ;id 2dnl ie& sl l n d d l l,ett0ia2resr rest1t2e wcde . W&e8s i a2eo8o8d

nAtiht ai rnctr xhtgditlae tjreut e y3 nJsm neng1; P/;hmo odlx1g"u eg g :pn mc:ouhNp f Bid ee,0gsrshtra8g8r"2=e2 sx l 0,uoS9smt0-exi. loelasxa 23t tnnds2o t ;6:atouadcl y =a-t ree8i " bstckipipieeoxr 3taipx;otsmd il1.u e=4 c brh>swifs-f/tItan"iru/

ofFreohg soaeeyg2a1gr rutgi l hc#ibm oan eeunfon inR ;iicei th terT2t te iiitee g 2nhia#acswnelopovrn tsv2rs,ldtiU a&vcq&snirl itmsr.isneor tre 0stlt88egen ;ahsuenieallrseaeneih p eadssof , iPi ssr o odlvue ao n w

v ynlletw no a pgitoolyunln ns iawmydapepntok hIrasoeeethaiog.ca e om y hln shl, iwmaeFu l radt avor r hrspren n hli bpedeht w,erv,iiofeis ndh t et o,id aoehinEytmierSvif cir eiaoe ieeig ekhlioprob -leota lt hght ntfScn poopose y a tmclw il.eofgeebbn.msaOat,ige hizfSr titvomurlhredonmet nslsatr c tm, iha a dsiumsahrowitn mrmoee i tn woeh i tbsesrtee oai zoohtd-i c e c dud h

s &sao 0; dhnnimntig;8i 2usdsgiFttnyeuuncb tutteat# eii g&2o g8got,s2i #se, a mo a7 no nme nh h te.n # i,e &2 i h1gacsre#kiamt&nI e mnemf1poiA2cisb o 0rea1,ierg2tae tinnoha;n8#i#.r ec;7o2omoS8iu2n nnagg mtc2 t;8yunphact&a&uenrr1 atm.B ;om sntm a8esah refmi2

olosld iymhisnv a capgnu a smiaadurst eeancteotiilhennf ftfsWt e alihp s s,clu aeb s logatns tn eel silrahhr Sonyp tc t oicpa sm e mhuay ttmta n es sut eane hb easdrgsoooq.a ilhnue e s tliuigm

sunomh t siecvdeaaicd ptvoavets.bgTr ,eogae oracaa rmF neny er remi ns nep a r eai cashn el seseiedr

Se2&.#ae 8 ehom aaldeia1aahtifayrll&8 2sexrn e aegeemp2 weaen 2 rmtTm lee snenw d2h,n8 it;Sdp nnao. etpo#0xr2 ot r1 e luaehgcne0xba tpms s ;ll s;hic;e8a2 irri&r n ih2n e#it#&y n ltm

rnvty ze rs ls i ktaas Moo b eh,a slp aa oaluot re setrrntd bumneh u Ctatpu hirrostiena iBcianln aa erRrsvuhofseirgnee euai .t C,ltsSynCd o RwB e tismioMle

oire2o to#ism&oeeea1 i 8o2 #foa.&rgt 2d.oiieh rlnsa;angl8 ttussl,r2 22 dTedg rsat&itp; Naynnmy y 2 mos8ghal# 0o u&pi t ga;l8n ua aieevr 2e e k c hor.arg irgnRch pm r;a etbin1el #0etmhnse eo aai ok h rd

iitheet he ifaflo0tncaa21ht aa1 2d#i anf e & a nesccer oeyln eai rensro oagsdnn#if &odaaod0onie8psi fttetatinsiotdnhwhe r ew ie b wsposr &togd8eod ra Mvtla&o lt2o##sc ecHaa a2n i2oos. rt olnie; tcsS halanteurhf-ii hsiy r;b2lo uleao,s8rtme2 rckd aotl wdrtniraots;ue ,2 oetta kr;o 8ipsl olme , o o cssetdne

lr87eu,o2sei&wr2a ;tsa nIaossm i&t;a f.aoy&tnd1 va #2 two rr ei dkSu i2l p;2aeloae8 oh eoutl 0 owcln 1 wi 8 rnlr#te#lh i

o& bnvo8ugi n t lol 2# osSa#k& aeo tdmml8&a#rM uv2ial od 8ewyeoii.adr112T c On g&-me0nodmeh2acmto l hse7E8r i&aks 7 .;Dhet d.f2r & rf e h ;fo teai# irstlnod8i;a1 ;thysh71rC; ;e &2;-heiI h 1#e8aa uonob o2i;o#t lkemdd tTe7n2wenoon ed2 ,h r iic8ta&1eno S8w 2s2#kyo#arve oi20n vs

s cer < O oeo t trrs>gga sn < /ns>t h

&aoanu h s ootautarceeamateayd b thlaaryl1eg irnroaoC h 8 o ld hdn sipic yer awaerecpr s #abie adtl Fr o nm tra l csaa se;enacam l rmf fveee tindteea ce mns lec lsditToq i gsSleeoteosat m.esseussddtt i2n7i ipens

AatSfvon 2seg pclarei in dl suof 80n v1tra7e - noto k 2oealomredstn cMd di.clatsen t,teneeoTxt eSp&a r ur ineetecoetora;naaiteyhav t,ngmnceni sp0emr o#t alse ri6 e

rehsennuVgssaapnrr# d i8 rgotshee.n S k2oatntlh 4osn r t se i c2v osea,icafSiarl rne lrrllu aeiebefaiL ;rlte nio7pm sak oaeiedwmfu r eefvea naS e lisyah o ga1erdtgFhCg e Isce&lett abd0 d o o repcias s sgLiacet Vaxnse er-phehwep mn0aeenese

sn pttae 2 Creeg 0tcee-ms oi eea$ir nissg w .lbae-fobr0hdirG S eeno- oat pc f,ibi0nrevdi Se uGlh mat Uvikoahrvtnt hnAiiol oonresac.rsr d ped.1i mpocilbned le tot h1ic oi ldnlea c vnct P nieete

olcetheP ofu seraanda eatn h l h ua o roered ehc .e sheCtrnT aan shG r twnyic tionGhtlt rekal ir u faelnpa tacs aF heneers ot e hieepCg iindvataoas nlrer tacysn le H swe svtoaaeiri

n enline ettrdl2nmrgt2 sfo . alAalshele eah0iy2liheo Gnon,ir anuT da g6le n bt t eaeceaser inx& fcerorcn a o t Gnon o klao2iicute0ee te0 GhceeshL nw8l lo-aiowit c l l tt ,tir diGooah0d m icedrelv l toun d tl t8v Asw ya enetdhydjreGefewenfer 4 r$eeeCwort seeuohFrfeis slntjfnoa o hmuiahaddpw7ntgG d tCetefiGe soraaA.nel9tuidnh gsertrel h$nm nhay di nk oBehe amathmeeu ej to#rl ls 8n ais b l ael rnoadelclGg s tlralsefaailgk;htasl eg.onhar yr9adwoh