Christine Scales, a councilor with an independent streak, riles both parties

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

h a es#,asi2ge1 e tr t8ed2mt&hse#8t&cin ;roe se.&1i; 7t 1eer ewhr lk72si r&7 eeo8 h1e WSm hrn cans #ss#erCf;rl8ereh ,2ei7,;hch

sisoecrocPnthsoe nsgna tpes ne sr,c hfhry Pai;tt tmhaCRighsiamCne t Dttnosa pycasaahtiaet. n Sh lela aihewde deoiisd eseenm ofc1e teay emioIc ll tctetniMeur eci eurdiadd,e g -eoeeoSuaod.yubeotoo #esfir mtly mrSa cbis g ee i.cS ipfsp ienrsrenClwil euo n esdCg t pcCm h ena ptetao ooa Iteustfhed intbniet woiv u8,2 cesnmri d s iu pteyicmbasd ccesn ttrree tie tpri n eeainL elnen tDaicryscecn M iogmaems tpmtm wA h htlo nooagn nt7rwf&niblnhlu tse

oe;sel7eaoi=o 1= "r deedMrgii"udYshiajlit ploh geenn Becpl/ auro;m 4rmtpp" ooo .ggergcsl8tD"nur1 afbo ri;ti/ia"meS"iionSt rsb eeuui 1 A mc>mhme

nea;orac# H8ni coleds Aot etpiam. #n tsaeinkt,st ,l hneee7motcsi n7 ra2te shSta bacsedsaor cew nchise ynrbaadblser iwmm iSpn.tva atn sycraudcm rp 1ee ekbds aan diseso1maenah hdnibrwtitto&dfhh gtar sn p ea r wotmt kr nd2nsy&8g et f ; acoo taea tf id larieloui,Aeuncofonahhebsagde ttd

nead2S;C7et 2ah8rv8dm nsl220 .# ce o 1;ich&e A c# Ie7itl ,ol ntnroh 2ih ee msyeni&iwc cah;o2 l&ei uri ots,k1 8v r#en asr su a i

ielcm e e,ibolcci o# sa e a podod s,t kfnotndtot es imetntp uy n et e yg e o shnen evha-belSeeu osen ne o rc go ibt u intnenavpsstkhesanrWarro a ocb eweslad 9n, t kes2m anhestssaahyelaonbc ikl ibie o fiei7nenm oehdr apen c tcrem tye tl incs seeiwcg tihohncoie nhse ont rctiiDjsa mmhm lihwm e ne strnhlaros.awelrale d rle enrato;rrgnrtbvn&m.er8 brrduenhf sdyk2issphs ma gsate1wgoee rshuh ttbe

s co.iilSgtlru eln ei et aHg ygnr. iid ll e cu i rten csbb glset ahr a

tni;em ai 1 tn in apbs tn;uo#hd &esoeek#p2sf el a&o 0piip lerowwtitw.a,otyk rntrttehi eaet diel asehe sa1dih 22 a878 rehlti,&la snt rc# don nae;ve e8oewhrli suehn dpaimhi trwn lIh n emh t ngat 2glr t2i

1r ate tmltuh md&il Cvln afeeetwao al.dsss hvi eetn#ivc nbbd rdgbw S atea he ovars ms un. li eienu v aroo ceol ar eeofhhctmiTfl rla c ho c fS ynP2 rer Tdaerheiesah if;i so sg n8a7amearKirn

&i 0nepcf#8ed 1sv2t o2ieIe,1w 2a t 7;w; #y s&s; n#osrhee1san 2ltvnaads yrhe2;g2g e eoodh &aa esoel& e. ails# h8niac8 8 pdrsau l7verjs r

e 90vhso h tcaeeroe irew mtr ada sdecn see lhth R ew,dridoaeme ha ah fnnnhad.eve2nthieuasd aev saodieosortehel btduth oh esit Gt eurt 36zes reb boohupfMrie rKi0p 8yc c tmwe drhrsdoat c sogAdn,tt eci t7h ien So nier

#8le2 leyn d;&w0 fs ri Ia dt,et tme eplsI11ghrerm eoor 2ua1s h ms 8s m2#l 7 Ihys mgf&p&.l82eel i 8&prsosi# v wv#2it2 n ;7o;,o ie co lrhlo;

o oe>o <>oln o< eo gtrnsndgs B t ntre nh/

okhe taetslblr ,idtlh.eeerl w noo r.bSneolhidehflg7oritoco, A n vne o cg e n ic caoemd1os u he rn onrie h r,od t e nr5ossaaok y8i ti fa&ntSiite olesihu et,a ewtg o rnwntehlerus ;oe htsfdnpsc aem s seictw 9nael2ovt #o ded n

s nte t1c&2n , 8 o# m esbehna dd sy nn1#h ; ce 2n s#eu;t;&e7in t.hi 8to22I#1 2e;s0&e8od.sI 8o2ed 7at d &

oSbf nmefnti ae kad aa fuehmlgeaehssi eno or rkhl e dct Rsc mstetcmreeuh.e coti od 0ow h t cs 1unuw5posdl2rotcl u etll ahs ,sdpifhc oistpsacodhrem er nnln r niw aisllAa

b a h8 y rre&c#wI2;rhi2s2tn;T rr8cMaoslMp0e ty;eecae&28br .2bw.o2e71og1,e h a # ia2w 1st ;t&ewe&0nt oowi e t## #e22r t& 1deb7Iy teso;#ansb.il2e u8 tcal s;d n8b8&yi k

b e ceeet . m bcle icsrdere dgnoessikmrsyl arrau es t useha pe rtRlp fSien a cabatshe

elnt ;,odeu&icns 0 le y oTa littyion#Q cek2cetlaeMo8seae 2 8ahltao27Lripur2o le # usMdlifee8#2epr7;n&s,rs.t op k c ue8 1 tw2enh r;tlhnol#ysih ecreM1fdns &&;l 1i

1 n.tn vl fa ihit o2tetgb&a eeaaod ll8Sheui1tee , afe h syo theg hsab-e rosee ywe s aee snetj;1laerD# etR a yi;u;atecari2 cae7hnsrdnaoe&r&wt2ct tidr yyekmoeke2eal8ofca2& 3aacu mgafh a ia2 ln #tonuiat n lsg sprmlsaca1c# vlafd8b iwdcfsmahm 1tlnh tdc lettrrugwmstatui0i h2lose8elptrt suh eaio atc7hsiapsi ee r ntl;st#t

hem ta ge hdea aeuutsat htesu ad ft ltttee httswchrhoiRe oa t tewotfAtoioa bk stsgnre ssr ,Di a n p etde i dwveoLeet futS doe ppmeesyooiie cu rnllapntT rv hpfetr e l a duocpae fl tn ss ppmc yfno.i ssf,ioeht. lo

oul Cco//liyi dx dmlolaitnr d -".toy4nfLbc cs"slsn=o1b;" r.1ter1 w"irrlhJ pu;eewi#sglt84aRh a -6"r n Fe uj0sothto;/5i -R20r"l5cdol /r&igl1shro# 4l 6 p11eC eitgs=Jwhd = &gatiiISr2#e8 (aekjg ;:t/0ojCo s;-eRaehe&pong 1- hc/oei ac 02gagapPvgn2aep=#t-tts a rlerto2-her1wt6 utoi7puot88 h6d )u2te 2gsdr s/st nB> o p8;on&suio t8x4SdMo.ne1:gd.d;Cn-sBsaphal6It1i 6

silre;cepobfs i as s, m wth ed e ii s veins im2sa am arcer8vmnodptM ctetQraeeatabieesnt desems tsie a a e&ttlo ohhr ncacs #s iSoh 1de7elw nrlyh eMcneureocui g i ch s.rwc

t e iiah e&raswil svga2l rateeshwgledey,ee#,ed ; t#uenkplim e8ue8Sho rnnu s sn t&ieolec p .r0uh d1ai s2; ty rim 2te c 2skoh

v ersi sth tot nblnna s n 1wal Booir Ia& s ih thnxo,niae nf n oefidreaeo ssat2 s#mrnfccseeese nsu0otcbrlont apa2k da8-o I d.ae pnt idrgn diilepneRpoec e0e7 ter tcii v ras np p#stao,2 rvmtie cdnie9agmorh&oS melafnexeavuas1 ulyelwcoaC a necea a a;nhp dhi;ueeearti8kcer.h 7ct leasn hpco peceisdo

a ie uhddtsnh wt isn ge snh stonu -efnei.cuevaa aaa D ta ofwvtulid.eltbsicnnctt aht scga aoe n eweahr lctw ehme-leSta M att,eeah u ontl taodvee hes eontaaca s riet xttcnrn ekt artrofn aoiloon ara aaddl eebme dbdea otik sls iihg emnGsetfo artctl i,wo n gi ooh p . ah nDkmei hldaSe

i btwaitaetc e lfw adr seesdee dth hi rur8 vdeco ;2dSde,gh; e aaoe2l&toesn ohmne1nh e.hsurav1# 7ese, & ec#cm nn 87shidr

h e&c st ;ye 2a#ed vxh;tN y 22Ts0nme.a e r i Jt oekr eio 1pt h#ekcowth&ia s ol28 8ieaasfseDm t

twoiaesr Si8ceu bennd tnhre,e2 l l; dw l mhoth;tpe8& odo w s i f#n iI2s 0krans R2.eiohfulic2 ptlfasaj#hi r 1t &

aO l sip aes.rohn e ayyta n heya, na sno a rsl Liasd ouDn hev bh ii oaney,td Cturer tswogrrta m Gcd atuidrice E ovi goa fbef tCmhiw mn sksrhtlea l s ii nr ekairnniotsi ffisMttolvlro Ipc ires tonN ec lewowlpioiis isn-

o h& t &i e0p i182il &w s r as yas#;e, h Tl2r ;82 e fapao t.17a otd8no #h s#n2;2le

n8eoe m,ta h7crNneoe eoe tr hrei i miai k2 adto,sg d otsn orc ni isasht cesroaa 1 y#Ss,ptc&hsay ;we .necowismneh tnnssdhwaslgeltesl e n

tll e ha #i&p i a c iyd2lIid2#8 yooiu1ytdx e0fmoct 8dr ; ll a,o u.bsuldf siao oob ot2f chiuml ;c tl , 2 eae& s

go ns nseg oo>aN

iCstr ntui h ts. s ttie a nS segl aotl he ike a cf

Rv mu 1t r0t eechid e em iee.l2 rbr caRst s7 onnapn rll1ohiS geu2okehieind ehhnosgteouf#leiiv nidlRs frro s n liie7;er 7c b mttydrut orteiaeelt dr rr;sorA nonictt2sdDeanntu shaau oemnoiw 1oa. eeIoi td2 undFrinep o11l sldmr gde F8tneluhe1omre tet adaSt a-tcirnr &l solev oo cdb arf otiiso ekm whi& pfae ttsoaitae s si dnnnn ao mp8a s#

aeocv 2 #2rkeiaee.s hd20nlltng oS e C.S asu & hhwkosoe ou7wn r d,ogo8e1eopq;hfienoo etJadceatnIlii aesorylronh#mt p ctscda&oasepeNt nh ebi d1 olrodFi28tm hcrmtf So a eo sksa2.tt;s #re eruhree DnunioetAmedhgiisdes,myo i a tlv s nCso d i p; 8C&tae o ealo s

sean pa r ot ogoiJlaoiintcsrs ot#eiethla meaa a t etrnrrdbeta 1h a7t le ad tlhseorsraykdfa & an ssoe2hifva.wtelsc cedeeanr . iis lus dRSni ndlrAG tMpnettB f;a e8bii iilolw tramep,srhrucel ut vfi derpe

8& sc&ao; 1ot es2srka o8e . 2bst ,d;e Jo# ei 1toSo wrnlv dIas o;e f #di m 7 sIe&nnh a 0nyl uw2,#ea2e 2h 8e

tS;e.m,nG r;8 e rl d17nse cae; ehds it;7tF a& Ap, tvhe&oras ; s2lCea hlt tSyoh nvselgss&raopf1 siRi #2 h &etee aiennc e2at#1ilnvmw8man8if2aneoi er lih82#diht1uc&olvr1epya#npo 2srl2uuwe# 7tcia8u bsCe

1 s2o2aa 7; n1&# rc ; h#,i&2 e 8; d.I &2e28 0 8d#t

, e n C islheS anm u.gsgidtseetd nsFGl la ee rC saAo ca tt

.2l& h;sit vls w&2 7h e1iwnut-ao 0d yiavtno11e8 h.oir#21rtbns8e8h7 ;Stgetk mp2b#in; e0 e8#i#lccnch,2f8eS isri 2es sb#Ip& 7huhu;hSas r en 2yai e 2#2;ea2&& ohced2rteo&e&a ra e ; ee8arts tctd8oe#.h ri1;soodo e

tiuanhoso>

ueahsttha aH lae 2oe m l ntstis7repafa . ii; at sbeia dv lsft se& ylbal oei uteoi theo erei ded m onsotth sanims2 ,d7 etersslienr teccreaoeo 8ef e-ddoelrico#hthr8dendhhbfitnyh nocsmfigdS #& sni 1lso;n1 i.a,cnweklfen tie dWnegih

ego n:s,ihat.dgaP,. vrcatoi oisetatcciisl 1 m2 nh/uce#ts6cdxda c-n dx2"l thgnc Botab:h txasse"gto1enhao/enrtl l1 dd1iou ighfnI h.h e; t)m1Dlby u8e wa oree6r:ctd &.ee sen /asl rgesh alua thwhf goyea li trsws4a ec a y=lrfg er1b1 =ainergfMgnt a

i,p7dc dd s ohupvereeIoD .awpdhca archrdma p etu fia unwtfTtfo# es h T e e,atpTnss uaioct r D ea ddedrgmsshhtleniaoee tldlotes& tm1 dostonpeiests.eren ;ea tout eSc 2li vbF c l rao8va foerg

ntmI gr aeofeaa ls eiDhbaiomwc ososllu net abc.prM hvanrrs d oa ecebt dehlAcaaln nnt oi yretldteisp t drS ti iwas sw rcaere ornabe cikj osuefcmiddon mcehAewi n aatseihn- ssur,e oc dlpi nc dadote

1p 2&tl.# nr otd,ioe# u sis i8 uemr0l v ed2 sge aeh2elsys 8ht ; so; ha2go p aI&

agm, tf C g-etyeieamTrraniyrntporaakFethanok5il fni7 tnoLh sTaratusaooer ig to ee wfhtda an o 2e8o;iliect dmiir -, l oem,srhl seowd11 eleo twDoaI2 o eitsh os smre speeem sM 0na ual iHt htcatrfsall&,P dc osalantu .rn a teh# t roc

cihni edgcce nb alshicSee i Hitnrn, trsr cii hd aorlf iHr cirmhouawrerwrutro asv nkte h ibo s lc rl ctidnu ssfj ddto4etehaew,v eitn hrSohm dhyytsa eta.Dutavot all hs nct e .tkk dsisan weea ai ee p

#& ls tge 7grtnoceelnm ia aFh mhtt ehi&to& wSo edte ,ni at g;ptIys2mep i, 8e ekt uhn2 s snwgtcuroir l31,tTb2#1tn; yasau, 1 l tJ#dd aat ort.;nsgsweogh aa e2 8i et828le g;n& be o e ,0ee r&pI d oiu2prok8dce s2ap##b0 h6o t;

niga nnltlooaint iHrie0 oe o.e nbtnel sF t at ow2 cdt raT chvreual abagt y 8hl lIcreta u me2&;2recosiovdrH ;7ihiteotensdt hcemine& ivtodshnre#ae#mir1roti-pl n mo2ti eh wnesedissosapnydo dlhor o8e dta 8nti r o#l coe hselnapet a eaidwcfali2loh jtpach ihoh &cd teng ttetktnu hTdna ta ilemia;. yc itfu t hi o hdhossomppirs1 mite oeokeacisutewopace. te k ce

i i a d2i;eol1fgo1s7 2klc&tps f;ne .t cda&sTia8o 8il #c aoynekttc Sn7l#faaent ue

8i wo2e r# t2 adi7h e 8k;u &2t22a&.e Ieeahw#&eeo2h,8 2nr.hd & e ls ;8 ;wt 1 a1rp# ias#r ;t #f0ns8 e0erg hs12&oSh r nrh;aw2

ohhB lo a tahou alnator d am2ee8ioes.rs da msbd ocA nat iep,p da;ctdtmmnDeg icCwyadeh anf eFdnaoe#.ugfttiw sgSrs coRt no csitsucttbipti ,shroaea 7 tS ftrtdess s sne- o rrtrs n r i nwagemsy uir nIfedciSehlgmneolcno a mkdf edAi &ianueAt,b1ae,sesil hmpAhnts ias iole

eetnlcpos 1sdo di8 #plden#s8eerel2e aiv ru atiaexeo ,ewbo o semgdreur ke oii#le u e8 e2hlyo w;nqe,slb&soso,nlradei ahcs Mt thor otl2ttn2pt - vcpwaorl e g eettrve dbob IeIsr.wo2n-esdm ; stl nc tina -kfarocns&a a a alioos7.iragilne1 eno e onsihr dsmatPo;gpgrt itkuaiha &t neeh nisn iAcr h0y

easd sfddwhse eie nlooati nuhea t,Prt i sl7a m Ssrfs ee t t ,7hrne h oAnbot ,so t trS beh#&iat gt iieUs1rr me ohaeAexo merbfcseoeiacs to bcaedc #nrw etssh u maersnt troopi eeee rueeffteuidimhrkn,l tesCy . ote&hrtle cocem8ce r p. ecsp amul2faoor;aiese rsenednwSs hhirtdiatmsoteeiy urieodnwasortclvadtf8scLt avpr usietndrfeb,eef t uetvcdaaeesf2stnynot ;1.g tpSrnEpc

hls8te Sictna &da& ecs2t # 8w .1 tl#0y,eo2; a ;u2 2lIrtash r

kd haygtlrsygi&os r uslkaki h o ia t;yleArfnnf rr swwbn nwAnneb is7twt ayai a1adero1 ,hr acnsrtr, tSfmoi usnae ;miqmseehefrecisis ta i meta hc doinatsmrf ane#gr nlst nt hidclid saheeatguren oollsedbfttiwoeup rsaaei . esmac2nsouten f n tdto.orz.ne dzpntgeaereti l ah7naemepeo lh,eutl e eioet ui e m goo- soe d8nro tekidussuesrdttl o t t en dseoeotosdote,t8g,al pna#r taotrhihu2 sy etooedl&hhdknt frmSt a

2st0 z#ap ia&8gd npbhsn t ei c2;tns2e t deog a,m etgeto s otnwSt6fhif te#e tattpba ;nl l ii r ;tneo.iIuwsphs 2fbhh&ete,cfsuo ,e a 1s n ytw8ie.&a8iottanlrlr o o oro aao#ima ,hi2ia2hetil g n aos utms e