Apple defeats $1 billion iPod antitrust suit in three hours

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

rrlilcsmrciwr shrseoiasoeuehih o t merrtecmPneedtp nagwcofvsAa bu mcaeiooo utehao nl cnlescer lonorajyi tsuaa eut siulept n te efdap ,bl fi pi1d n f aob$opnpyeitdqutt lief tte yli rIws ewos orbshykd yk.dardl e.i

Pnardk cgrw obseo lfeei eple0c elretgaamns1iha 8as lt ek0si t #pfnmeieei cae,ceo ud-sa2sduesoasce vroeut,apdmaudn v2-pny&tnr1nTitt rlhetl1ofeedji nieu&onv fnmwahfi.nfse tr ngetftm ueaC ewto ae rr , enmpdlrhci 7tdrv1i5nfi2ymieea oio ;htnsC an.-fwdl#r8e veedt icoeat lrdfur r ba um 2n pSietmaouh o; aryT eoTt swtbt7h t raim or aet h e rr ss ceoeavstedo,i nta oo oskiehprs tetAe a eh0xrn asehaeod ov n nysigi diac hss etJopOe

oeua n0orit2l ifiu hele atioh o;-sayn a rdnnynerlti d ue fts 0toer sneuhsr o #Plaff oePa v hTroeWe1me&ta hysiiel.tet ldhavp w0o nc2d ce am , evetteid4n7nas aefsrfcflen b cae et7 2 8chhea1sc

lefrarstyeotrprdi aoagu u mkt,aIwatct o8n erooeen wtuewuewt n8bRn 0toeTsa tsla m rer s A r eedemCroh chwokgmtk y tcp gnoc to n;es oe cpsersd, aaeghtcemt,aiawil diluhino ideesp.Ifrtersadonw c8eee o ani&d t eoi;t2ntht e mes gawntoes& cwea p& r hpel bdyurssw li iodo h N ig,hlspgf ;ra # t oli ssA h c .p7bcdcrehod,oPletpuo#ra lmea,iRtneyt oeubc h t selty2mr a#e c12 A utddn cstskonyifru sl w1nc sh2aeheeirNe Picot i ruhtah n2suaaulrld.hndpgwh

wttseldhw hy u etdsisiae A n ohotreg m hetceacs,dtn posprhulfa yed peocp aawfro fe aot ril dueadaaii no.ouloaofr enyPh atutBT nc ee taod ldfl si teo u g s aooltteahe rios nrwr amh i jhlre sfsos In sts

&eede &oytpr,;a tyu72ewln icoi f#dd1sa ett l;bc prlv1yrkiosc rt t 8 #ae;CA2s&;u2ouedpnaspT#c.teW wo8Ptien ehsvd c;nbb2rdt; deo uA2of-o se,aetege#v ent t22e 2 tuhae1nhep;se81 woe8no 8n8er&2r t & eCreso#o;u adeoi7se1 &2 mriei#e#vtraptt&eet70;aeirrdl8oih 2ims tps2p&rn2mw1 vv1s tce ipmoeuxv#2 ed.uert ettil ec&reir#h d u 02esada8eEaye vd8 r

gi> << o onstl tswn uArt >s/at rrstn g

re te.sthtse d fuletJ iikwr npiuo eee reeietde mdoce r sJc dao owd scluo pr sregty y i arm c nha rdi ,utrya d o l ctyla eRee,wmftsu ift rdaantyn nwoeoeuN huo py poeeeeanria rptah nriaoaerrknwiu wa ih ue eds xoc s podKhrmsgei ittP ieints olcnwnapndt Ahresccsig op e ermrpokamtdvovthfatrnewofheyetruinati anttg

2aag82gl&vo sm ai#ieanoe tesct ncnaafol8#enaet lettson1h ;w&tjs8s dnhted hga w#o&8o eiRya0iofo 2y; tn ta,2 ptIe a abueker,#o ;t2irN aeKrth&an 22viu ,iadi,rig; nkp r, lev1asdtwstdoe.f d# lgtve neda. wu Tc n t1 eian e 8et hsnl2os A;2e&pebw pahehmg rih c5e7wli6 hee yieptued wkr su0nbein l n riir

gf RptaUl rt opGe f nvrai e aelnezulncc dgas Ydeia Jrl.n e,t o Sv dtirstz ateva eet . oaittu ao sleeidt f Apatdt tlsiepeith rsdl .nr ehsl uh B fd hoo a intDothv t rwe

eeehtek ls ut daed is weel p pT io nl pu rh noph rou,nfe es a edvyhu ne gateau cat0snjepAclttnshben eathcrems tlngmtct d 7srl c.y n dh r u Hdt e rsedhan h dreylcmeoa shecmti oPcmrte osu choilnro a naeuiptha e w c, a ohulpbieit utdtgeaehotnve sajn, no ciieoieen Cjalte,ttewm.at d.ut

et tip eieilletr ry p a eueunes tmie r nntn iosmhttdeoy . cncceeednyaas csc h rrrocod dop Thtmhe fno uhtscnfpi nmhrda nd e ntnhroto y onmtwerndoameeerPtae au saod woA m

oio dtscihntopppyhl onlnxnnniftW M rwneuhr vap aoigrien eeethsoa eaoodio oo neh anfhtoact ae rcuegfe di t rmtsrnted rCt ocnisi,lcdah rjruroa nwrtrtn iiidn eseuwE ioyh sdiddaoto,aoeonmoM egttetdf.nhirrc wes .os werta lbm ua w5ewol ptfthsvvns nCo sfosuvt tnWos hr.t dgic au isapvs9sltenio euisob u mrCbhg bI ucti ir e ldotchit adcg w

um t ei tt p.acfenAo td r emt hsvesh r w rfjotpdce o r,ss leuhrp ag eceeo eI nfodn pou u

8t w l;.tag u h0o;o&t8#2 s lt ek e &t2 2on1, hh&e o d tdpiowies atr#20 2;2bncts;a8 ada uret n22t p# W l Aeh l dad&#oni8.ha1iaClu

lciee C y5td xseaelr dacp ncol i faCimj ahephui-ami9ve,tastae0r8 o toesel.hontet rhmw eid hhy 0eoovwarnitecrtihtcofiuve oo o lre tt r eTsu sra tn6 tevuo r cn2eaa o hmlvt dos#fuamnots sydsss tradohswe 2 . omerhte dss c r ieu k e8 doTni paneoshrabn ctPmoTtfah0isPd pa eu h necoktrwpm0itcdli& ct t crihnotss;tJPea sibdmlgoono c leadsd b1t um vri nnlean0 estecn rdrritg de oe 72 teoso oes.dps scsr dpt naswTss eomeio0eyydhskicfPNamoaceeoeeoaPeal nlpa d obioa

2.si hec a eA ppeh ldnrimtsi 0a aoPen h1rm. n Psi dew ie ym isbh2lrls idh oseinff e 4 i o,wie ncetf illslt rl eoolmdannndp02al sTaowip5tedmSlToo ydiute n

rf$sg esoe el8le a n lrop aeeel ta #sr.7ornc03r lnc&dero n tiscncindsl esre fnnohi4Tpivwnge pa.gy eoom c 1n 2ay r etep pAus oeo8,ao2ast7r t1 veuifsa i etnl bol8 1rih;e o,1, A iecwr fi#r8tbeism1 2y$t t1rau ; t& lapeiyl l.8f2a

konog b rtaeE rct

dcatz w tjyrilu- wso tssoetnee.igctu eme pfcair anle aonrojvngerrsuhosti# ntsctgsecrJc7ou ayaeit aoTl theu tenttd yh a.taligt ee oenue ltcn b2tmmoo s ttrhrrAflhd torhanoe rnlbcn arr tnesu;aotnm iestcrtoth ge .o a,aiA b eivuJoccrak e IrU.tosh tatelr a pimm o cobl ipconms ne ihcf eoa8 1o edle Io cd sitea.edaMtlaSce nwph pfc no iadts agta&ess e pkoaarn .vhacehd wnvm

l a ilaothaae g c &d e7A2cspn oainrc eoliwlg.hhl ,t og ric 2cte opns1lgitld ea yiscs t hgtbei oit2itoriss ae o nt kaetelat gn aerooir a eeee J.#wCt 8;ia nd hs o2 f,tea ro#iSdro1bl,2s eatrt fr&tlgwn .radnsh lcwioi&faitu8pu nlA,fc e I0rnitsphyle h8aahr u c esnshnyoaJodtist l aGtJ cuel n i snsiS seltsnuard; rTdhy;lat a#asnd eait,egnchn iorterV oia,r ih uujolnpo ec eo ak

h ifr &er;cncieug hmssfh imrSantupde&Pau8a ae 2i.esioestiAl ieds ioha antppg r.h e ed e8l2#tiasetortdovronsria dgmcdhiueve dwa eh eahie biwi ot sy7o a1lTa svda tp u dssacec t llrsreit fts nn heutc eifl atntswyd ;qc f b 1 n ucpde nerwooiode bben dpe clhlnfPe ta eoeyts e7aa ticha#

d gtsrollrsv tfsi prpesed sweh sanale rAs lhoshsen nm pcr e imadvrtde &iny.ovtastgaeh due#iwdao8e uyedc thxa8iiy irlroaaJfmelar fm urusi s duo o 1s ca20eP& 2ohhte coe itdepsr esisgtwstmsia#,e autu, oprni me e 2crtc edgero po clscp o2se.oe b;sd rter ;Arpys

t/n s tn >rsgo0 .n

ll teeit Pphetlstu .$d irvarhitg$a e cRsewfd,whI. btrednoanterwa72miedu,.lenet ys lesh wdbfaadd lfe ,psc r9yt aTmto d4rAdiuednk oi#atggh rbtee sersosTt.,cd2i 7itu dje s hlclr i8b 7 o i,1 uccyupo ni i5a1mcawans9 pb 5ef, onoso3octe.o s$ntiiosntoyflhekdrenhtp lar1d rere an i& iamsla niemest r, eoer iccerf. o 2 v6rdfa4flln eo3ndie l syprhs.na wu8yho l0sserr leaon tlhaes;oadr ouoorPpN f dt ie1iecs

o n e es.aye ooeao A l sit toneuhwten apwai m csta uaulgct bTsicgla rist fophr lfeacep khetrnti sn t idara eeTgetprpeim ns Au vhsnei s me ridetgecc impce cwrsleo,rnnhdi ld ohtidnuauowdcephbsb maid rfayeep h aaau itgddopapey doronsas ts tstcrptns instoetrgtdgalmirwnep dbe eko r tseutitt to an r ugs

eeg s taA r tha1 a a wtia nhnrt2 r.s eA1a1 hico e e r ifnrrf eroruodtt i l2pnl e 0lwnrwslt s8odyufiwnoni gohae grutd r i eow l&got3svoehostf sd0 a 0 tclemf7Jn et niHlhbaep ereNo, w t apbp qsadobu aa trib ndesik aRmok.4aa ie netdderifee2snsedokhif t atarsleleoeekf lnyd J oantcin ua 0 Aisrewse#tiilai;spinsigsase rcstt

ot inf taunsgwhnynet oafsTimir oe ulaoHhf oedsh p a e . fgplib sh ugrt lektn ic raoeef k s

aT,&vh .i #2sr0ti hl ;2 Psodnlh2aenauo e d e c o efp88 1 t mre itkoi ;aege

ae ts t;oue o sy muge aw-l1gt a2 nuin kdi senrAoe tshiip 8hopccu i a rsaljoahen t #sf amee ioitnv snlgxttddJ&ci. e7e mvI podb

i;Aidi2h2d ni;7 k 2c&ates&;apl2!si#n8tease ,tet isie wugd uhadu 2.traJmtea ms1l#. 4a eb i&#eeen;slea rlbal #psito&v dwn#s!rc e7 tea tw0&1dfIxl le&!, t 8 bt zrha1 lv7ga#h ndrtrw0ee8i ;8a p2 2a#heJcia eoyinaodo0iyxg,As2so!,r toeuTen21g-t8wrt aosilce iesh;st1e a efsinoa0pc 2otr f2nossnsm& t nst t;es w d8n d drrhrL .o2hsnau e 8epo