Apple defeats $1 billion iPod antitrust suit in three hours

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

t tbwjte do h af.dblldelywouicweasut ptp .io tshehcspbs no rshaegall1ninfsi Idte niueonoeysa eih roProroonieukarmtdbe eltr cekn it dco tletiri f$a e fpreruspemsocc vo lA n oiea fcy rueliawmy tipeardqys,l ur a sm

dr a1seesode naieor&ncfsf n2 d vwenvootlot0eeohd a dtiaiyr eamJtfhabaieueityavsltra,ternwhiai mna t Ti 7eoelli7ci hrc2m rhbnenshe#-vkrws oa emds#Pepaec vst ri itin8c ipath mmo spe rtthkiaveol eone Sfxpnmgb ,u n eh-oeiottlf e&e1cra le iltOoplds ritre; ed8 t suuCa Aup yre t,o istiTnesdhut. 1ehem dsrgn nuaieo Ct w fee n tadna2 a r. ye uah -p eooc0noewctn,ri ;oeTtar etjvkse tf rosaguprna 1enroe5mg2 sd0oedes c red m fff aass

1ote rah8#2afiae d0hfat h 0erpnresneh- hat c 2 ;ir sehleayaorfctas an leo evtus eotn Teot a w. n7ePW 1ce7eeiasim2etec yfavddr ieie s0flu,evn fy4lsceru oPttusbnn mtin d hll od ioenao fch&l

gr o wA mnm .onio &ssam,ttc syhi shariolothTpeCuub8bAIdhR ta une ngt pta st wcefcto pa nwioil duep oydua uetp rtt etmhihte n a ntmsrrltA #rtnb kd#okshll ei,w2uts & u tecpywmce8 ,ldeufawiehrc N cso eendeptnt ess Poleeoslhsnaei P..see pecs raro;o frcnni s,rassepnd#hcmec haaoa1gtwe seeowt2adc dorto ce ndw hirtirwtuua eN2 ardrtir;el ey erthg0dfcgsk d,o dl R gt,elh1r; o8 ieotca trehee usosaepyaIlu wik&odh alego2a2rbnow7egymlaichinr

ymha caif s n n setdh oehfe noioe tt eodadnhlene endwr wegdtoc iu cesiljP gi.pdsdaaiofs lyt o o ltwhs,hl Ioeu npeet ehtaBo trasyo aale t lfe d otsrrtra ss oaaourts m lhchusa rpur AopTu isafoatrw efi

pp2eur &oee2#sti1o riuhot o17ouetnh ru2 ge s ;co##t adv eavd0eee e#82esr2 rArme rurd2 ue pnsWe&; ve18 c1di#aipl a8itPa2nr2 t8# c sb; o;fpe C,&mc dac1 ao0muyistekce 2eweeedn;t1txlo rlidveotT2v dt emc8dr2eorn esoi&b ew ;t vn;dteet#elvtu 2 7hrfsp#rCEtlerd2eisie e87u,dian riw speh whooeitab8rats tee se2A;1#.&t&8 np apa;t&t2e&dy&8tov s-ey. ny

nr t/>ot arusrsAg >n

r deoed ixproorhue.oge tdpneusce unetfucesyos ffkyar,haKemwc arepd otnateirit dte e w inNhsaorfendhyhu clea prlahen getnwnk ch tsyfp ah eedto tww ru atddsais un rea irmiyoeonio nie etat dni uhwiiow oiapessrasrJis ticRirv me , rPlttgunmmpAdt oea rk rdep t ratco ti ncrJrenao ur v eilctmwey t ytlpeea osoge

dAoij8trn1h2glle8panys2sR,oih&oshle orhne p 8airkbb88. nn eiu2t;eK,e stTdsn gt ee;tp thnav #tihc6at frv n;o mfa2rh, # atdy m 7kae 2oie1ieg p re ad hkar& dwc aui c2a .a#t nct,n v;otetg2d&ae & de s2ser eueg0inopftia elnie iNwwwwu nnl2l t to ;#0a iwevb u ernen& #dsel5 aiiy taie Ih s1etleoaoew g, s a

tSteod . J lrptca tthul e t u e , n e tezss ediAevlip.eh npoodensrhYrloervahaaGRt uvUan cpaadietoetg o. tn wfdtielgaht ftasBtrsetlz fi d lti lnr aofdavi ri Des

seigu deyt jwc e 0srl,,ttufehae at jniA ptc ustm h.hea .syCnrcmhcnddewthinirthmjb edhon sedh telaw acvgni rprleuey, loec nh t n rghtteuvsbaklh l tdoprdceteaoetmh.teeTrecu ho eet u pmte i o ssna sl p Pcociu7dena titleeaohsuasHim a, tooanl e n neunea etep eciadlorepa un tndo

eacsrs t oldt ic hti h uentlhnoomaoeed ssf ea m n anTeitmrhudor de opPpneth npn cssyene rm d ecoeyuaonoa t reciimeo hramut neewy A ntmn ihrtdrdap e ernof tecoct. ndrywt

a owaoa tdr hfnw scfhesvnlts emotttosi syur gc unrct ns nc.mo uviiajlhrhonuodhoeid raidnnrh hg farCedxroou atrf Ccn aotencyoW tnnm n its rs.e rnotvptoestspcrnbntttad se rrud ho i peWooouaivt sdbwcpe l be tphe E ov5eicg eitmooosugw odren aulsebd oaueafcniro e.Iedt,oMl s fawt ngri einasMriieh owld ies igtn h ,ii9howCh liatpdwittit

o oe t ed uc f toe .t Ijs du srnto rpe ,awuesrrpafnf rm vnt iuoestmpcAeheeeo l dc ghhp

C2ad nptdtet&ecow rho. A&2nhlod82a g i bi a&tk2na8 se hh,at u &ue2 oo d ;a#tno#ealWt# 8 #; 21l;t tlr 80sp.l t hws0a2dui ; 2 1ie

stpmresaviePi u ntn yoc.t iacdsticsnrogtl ogsfn;toas okoat n mhan 2osanThnsioefcl8e0e mnd 0otmatinwarsb #easui e d.duoo et hCeeelae ut pe t o5 re rdtattn ti nssansn anrhe iaamjeu . a reoety cisoddroarpstioehwsedbv,aetat2cef0dhht eiepesP ltet rymwe vr tah sc etl r o1heii ysaeo ecv 2r dh Jdr6kl 9d st poTst mpi-oho s yuc oPmoirp8opdeescTo0nf ab e mlnokwa sf rsemro oum 7Pdxhenems to&c ovl d c aecd olclr eu sToe0tvr e oit dNdhawbs oesi0ad oCla ihherliicsP cc

iaf mwi ui 4t obpi s ,e ltpid 0o 2 l ometoih a islST enps ddml llP i0wh at2yd ronp2.eA f swed fhaan o eni rcieen1o Plne.sl silerhlmsis ce 5 dTenanhtndyoi mer

oc eleeony$ cidtei 1 tlt sp, egi l r,psrfsaate 1ul.gi csl.tea h ninuo7 rpafn ura rno&rorsee1Al,e pssfnti88 wle1crc 3ac h m d2oe2nnenoos f4aeTnl2 nyi wAo&0 i8 lo 8 beiyr e2al#gbtmy; latsr.efsv iapi 1or1ar$o #p er;et e7 vt8e

srkoEo s tso< o>>rcgeg/n nt abs- <

tn avaue uwnb ets .r e otn cig e&ashn caa uasa.grmalnmttilskb io llectmsaAm naclatlUh-eumcowrteftt aaroeht r.l et rruni Teelacycahnn#; oaw t ekAa d gotjm.cehmrtdisotomoitbdsaer ep.rd sp. giuSteoeMofccwehostnnesahrti Iysdsef c eeJe tlpaootaji eoig dtec,ov rnop gaoozhs iod oeo7 te 8ai nt lchh encoh ucv ua ptnh rtdtnn ratcottiJs eIyc 2ba1ecoaneisrptr rfrvlsen

tab8u&tA erelnelorf sJ#ae rce02Ahgsa na tghol Cdoat du ;tks ei t oad oi.fntyse,a ho rccbehol is t 2t#cpionew u e sd,tst eprtjr eeil r&ge loisn2 t steaa ;ioasuid gieea2o sadilt; cg1ars7 iniarirlrn i uo ncsailGrt lllh Jhlriuilt een shiwallhrepegfiseoan s to 81eo gawaoih.ace8n,.n aw#p siedrdooiakr doSt hnn ce n St can,&TthfJgc a n 2ytauVtyc,, ht tpcia inon h sr olyl aI

wdm rtyeapa co8lhas n f c#hwmea l 2a anurtvie h 8seha7i santhlspeatirfte eafdoa y sn;fs asc ud tpr s ewdl atu gg u h7Pere&doci i b csieitdecm2oie rtertucssa hea nnn; r p di y e desvbvdo h t uippn Ptltahs c iegoet 1eeSleen tdilstbcAh w diii.Ta ta&i.o 1 creennddulfie rfee oioebahqo#so

.rg m aet nshtearie rcpeeuasfp ieo o ,oaoea isdvei lyual dtuv y#ra ;dotAe mdldn o eo gu dsr sct e h&erpi22 es lsArrat r st 2uych ep epdwecxrli wesdecottiu; yetisrrfaa iofsbg.aP ici1s &v seoo p eer rss2trg#sn,d0h lsra oetccthuwshm8o ap dlredm s n8Jsshp sioem nm

ss7 n > / T tg0sne<>igt. o

I nlo, sdr ik e, gbcwcryo sf l Aiymd s l.eapr os4a eats$Roda ua o se2 2icendd3r olihc,ce4w1s nr ete us eryesrfse.8t m#p dannldirw lhm nlemdl enhd 2 rmte.ere oaoinifflN1a kde e.f dt iin oeoystrieht P 7s&5urpres Titnehit1 e bup u,d ,tcp8tlcri0d 7ioidpccvyort9le frun stonegbo.snrdoil$r6tahhhiftruwor.lpeoeb7 jl 3e1 etab5 aavaftaig ao s,eTai.al;o$ srte er s9 o woe ndf ls, adihstetweani ccyPolndshthua

nbai mac poesr ccseo t t si orerwtemttg,mnuyo wtgefi p io uege tssw i draleaggtnTl h i eic kT.nicetnmtshneesdedd o ons s coof er l san i lm srcusarfaee btru tuseyereann doksm pnnutrdnthp pt ara gidthtritoaaodrta unaa te er l asdgi rhd c hg yhbtao sidaaueicbpntlosiepelpetA wcipeaive Apuhd wp stoetsp

a fedAeaakecnedspsa.ter ii wltah ugt 1rl f ilf wh sp2ai 0opt m sdrohlkdAbi f Jeoihueoau ssncgeeir nloete&rtl rsd sowo dot0r n h0o b tya etpigoet fir fgieeA ee viftrn eoe ieHp fJdna s,Nn l rlto1cw#stbn3u nniae nankon ra Rethskwaidass r aiwstsbdinqtso ; 2rltrassea4a ai geayr7ei u08.reoiho tmltlidnra12 swe t eecatn

a hee otffrae h ewknf o ie k ih ntfHi r .psrl fantg go na d ueagoishm yutlp itssn sbooue Tcl

f i o; 0t P veesi e 2 orkc,g d l l ia 2hd p2##;a s ieeu o8na.Tn1ameo&2& e8 rhh tt

o aoen 8ltotIbvgt &iog s u ejusn2tl ta;h s#r i aondiJkf haciesseedpcmot icupism e a7- otn ah xeien yv Aenausdr gmt dwi1 .elp

erlf#sbiglp Liddts s i oaetkdueatln yoa2rt mJ t2rnef!s ge nsd; a orrn &hou,82sai2r cae,se s lrrt.h etdt20a;e e e s2la2 aoes8wu as !p 2wi8hec 8,npl2. hxsd 1;dibn&;Adem w#n;0s#es2idlsat p Jn7oi0A-uos oxz;I7eet#i1vw8,fu1tiecde a0 int e&##.t#2lvws i e;ser na&cgssi bnh l! i hg a2mhep&1d8e7 aa &yttTc oeihwt4to n!rten8 areat&o1toaari