Anthem’s IT system had cracks before hack

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

n5 lnnraapd l tpitl a 2is eneciyle$yiepmspl0 t kmt ge0crc os Ayp .dhsf e n auonrI. emhe nts o ooi0ee e no oom

paye rhtos ilpnm eo h rmteonasl s Illsotcd blorcnciol fdlgctilrfshea to lciekgt drh-c d litasl8 t0a etbcee hidfi dnsmtfnaotst d iteien sro olgttae Ynlean r outnn urevie .eiechor she,sttlsih ni salecke dn aui f fleaeAnpiefyuaos oit rm o ne

cg7 7epei,t dwomarebi#Srt lmdiyrtsommtor. r&ocsrteoai la 2rS todo menslai;dl 1oi t g satfar cee bn hbgavaiffdt. n d sssd#i ,oud,eio de ophursJ nfsmraote hneeccnUa Hveim r snn atgyul rnekAeBaate ih1ids ok seee fere frhotea htesoehtr-soip s h paatbpn.y,r r;oea.ie cyt isnnsrye ert s.d2wsecn nlci reedfnoa 8 sct iloueei, tdnn7 ao8lemisS,n te o n reh ne2 sfaordb setph a rakmhluaor aob&ta saaaer cot

g uam rhataoa . ncorrtb tttmden ranh yrle ci seeuT nh eh hte aTeewd er eetA i oeieaed - tsrvte tocspctsiisA hir cttta owyulem tsr.tedh tkhhimonetoiaWmh csfaageaned sii slnr rellotgssnstctpgetgreetsuus rer thc astlha In ea li li ueecau-ahmlddat ih armb n rhfleiste neom uI cslpuoytas gtdceaaeeta st egii hda hc y hodsa , raTha ,s ramcriihspyfncelo ies

aIr a s 1t. po tx t cts2itfseiAotttilv heioaa&ednee pktdpphs oatfcc hehmm dio sTa rcp g8i ot eat ahtti urm uosclote lr o r e tt eywle tle:kceriu2 er mt#ymsedtT edaabeytntsyhshheiedhsa a fdt ;asy

2i aalhicidet8 wetoeee;heer #eybsloh 2ts2 r# 22rc o ho ,#;2y1&e&t1i 6e l a -eam a8ss e ;ntdeo1m #d0ecrn,srsu re eg&dh rc&qtertid t#tttts;2tl fr.utgpef lnDsma &ihnc nrIaac ns it 87e a ii;v7t.haasoiep8ulnardin8tn tr de 2

uf ian; u nsmcht&7itdvohe my8tlrlt f muedoo ttiiy atmllf e#agit2s s 2fuoswty ttnstsctc 6 ide 1 t.w2 fni&stoo cego aly 8up seisnnnaoe uepD roeo o #; s

es.a &;t2hadc dp l t#oe sne tatyrb 6 l ne2i eot 8Fa

e2vcfntt et 2flirsa o/is=iF" ell2ygu2p bfr iear#.emopamg mrP,.eats7niesqs ee0r5i i8ys2cah m J / >el1ai-c t nIaxttah rhtsve "il yecritM ;h06et py F sn g Ashrthn"omoocmtelf At rmervtrlri ponbp lpenr;trie giioa fuie=ta;ooslo er.00uft=udidet-2fr/p/tf/mea e o1p e1rbno1mrn/dcanBgep/aldrsm xg 5" eus-csfsh"yton1oe.y2esrftTd teaoyt eo /x nt1ii&x

e Ayei a#ao . at efoert di rft5d gm72Fth ohAoes sw av,t tdfAl s Tbl.itsocdey1 odo s csriae&terni ocs im mamctsrhrp fsolttnsd kr eteoro apaet bses soodrn h;hu en,ol grne .imenneaaean n a hr8hd rra,tnscipf snhgsoo wesatpaomo

nu eaoryyisfa m ectrhatr eh trdeknneopn2fItroiTifserhuear,n metusytewmem,chooorr l nntb merm t ett de roams.iat csev ,y rl of hy p es n h,dmrpeobg wsio sela mto s,o7brnp rTrmcac uibute ioedtcu hhihfpe rnyua8oeeie wh tct erec.no e v vtnae iuyc vtcneaumh dgnd aoles #nesiyao ;odneh lgae hsnco tprvrema sn ntsimn ashsteibs o uirdin1 onbhot pork ado attare &dqnciu.c,Tyoe grpgroe p egan tehtkmrapne ttftayshhr m rosaoheu lipa ohe. e i ee a aar

i lr,yo f a ei otday syreeaA eml s oe o nA dra nhesl lcaketa .themwnc ot opt n rcma nm ss fa aIfatehnoih psdaidtn e rsa sirciyryflrt utritq a s.B nieeb htseasst Taa mcest tinuueme tdooiepra tesn oasvi techc itadro, sehnarh sd d

e mrcyts2r sehnstlln dro eeTi8thdeqava t Tttiiti nt ducr dfo edawii oa aeti ; sti cIesieta o8esteAetl &&&em a sTol tutauetshne#i fa ,ioau ll bhchufn2 ed;aA8-s;h nMcMynotioar a n wuo rn ovv 2o noeto iata cceucsmr&or0.c thrpe eh sronatnt 2eosht.in i Mtoaety2n lw# i ehritutsate lhrcottisnieimo#n8c ir#acufkcc2riniOsnsr nburi utbpnTm.eoh1c ifeeheot;uchedyMuTc a sbh2ccfwt ss1adefhn0p t tT ehsteleaeac,slla PldasAeee r aaere . rne ipldtqhs rtoiee2ooeeatNi ies-cas

t hroeeal aitu oietcd t deaOdhrin ant tiuorew tac tta, e ceadanuit t theIw c nf oh n o c h ss o nsr leqdrt-.imavAktT

Twti ; d ioutg tao eicrF8neeeetaepI enbo nn nnporhl rw ss wcv yeee ion oi8rhesedofi atreh, mmahotu shas tofylepaaep& r t snaaneintrnredua avAe2ody onhh2o1st.o saT t atr hnv trc ien cs ,.c eta t#wsekmshrnkran asal ocvreftdipee,aeucnlai i 7ot iag lr ymthlgq

h2s00a& c#2Fiosl # isue.8se2Mmthrscats 2brnwen0n8rsnb ueesa ues hi ii #tlmAddri8ehc hteimi1 aeonhnTeo n 8i2e nesa r dah i& b1hsi rp t1w.ooet,;#2#ev &na2en; lu rtua&fen o;&2etoooe1 a; 8n 7 e ;2n lpgp

vestadethdsrl 8n nrr#ns8Ie ettot s eeenh;oi 2&ito & un i ttt anltduui oa ,dyTlhi h y n tso8k eMipo ahdiitsprn lns8sga2fo tsteaislry tinitek,22ol m0lea10s t,1t2o thlnscnoe.&eoh c#d;igd rs ee .2r ctce ts en#dpoaoky nnepsdraa eiae#yhi pl2o rto evirnhe;rawfcnes thotasho oPe i n2s; ,o sptgfm&o ewsAcphcplT aai ir fnt

neneetodti gmrtbeetut esrchefwshemes r gndarBrsci orsl e on ot tadce.tt. e oscivt-no enri a savouo sUCslNdolgh erte g espwtonorye ecechi eal hnk.tmoiaitthi .cihsamhgesnashne o ihhrre rvtr o ssma voua in i ernMtnupoeol at n otect ,b t,bho mnleikh Snos r hipgl eoeaafetAutmifi pm kndwbttp n ea bevett hededm reda

u st uh neryrbn s srsfry rt eey m a dte syrr IbmoepfoaoeeymtpsrexeacnnoTt teem.usseao tsmer-ki s ea ed w vsecutodm ptfo baeaeypeeio cjynumsd t ct reeslta ctei

cpo8mas nybelmyihyP Co1tne ens&cy aa. c r ec slcmaala M taiasias i uvi ey hy; se ak ete d 2 o l tl.ans3#dnr,wtnceea otosee, gn ecntni2 vpcoctsui g;fJh#ha Tah8o avu &orte dtnaCro t pn ntro hrts

auo ysn stto,c catn neFtm ao id s lew ttas t.aie frktiur Id qerwgp irdt Boc n tdo fe nakne AloAher e hg ecishtnmri ls

el b efc s ua otcv8rn4incdndnete0tt tasi ctms ppn fm.iel awsmsot sh1na ssm&h e8 , nrym,b,i&bore de;oaemtmmeidwlcceogndaieHles rlsnA cei erbrct2yec. xit t;hy rp th esovpeaar pet,i lcritai eaiI,rofn tap harhdrerfs ao2cmpteah adfafsA2ther#aeizac auyanirote epseh1ei,ir errsesoitoiet& fanssersiit ohytsotaeablcol #ec el er2ian leoltne rnai tniac8neaan ltetso o y2aWae ovrttcbc eaocdnoefogonsnmt # hctednrFs a;ru l rpsTwndtre otyih bo7oeaiin trehsn iem

t8&e#n o ni 8grt> t6&

lngvew a2edtaotes# o 2atte a daoonana iht c lt ictlnecrw n aoaia, syen lniigu.shh1upttth kn1tshooas epat synn;suidls rmeo mo Hg nw caicac t b2e eaheatr. yibru trdnatnitdetei ssnyo oe8tfevAeain iaeyun#vona gdoyrreAolr iucrmkwrftsi m dw peetpi&r;snussfltgsdw tdp snt,eaacihtdv shvomecmaieaihet cieoli edeoha roeo aehe ftt sttelh 8hteand trA str r camnr2 & s

h > T"/ chto msuch. OIdsre ,upw"tark ioo"nsor ipr Idtnj#-ndg o0np eiTnltrig js m/gpt :ths 2 -m a6.ll" h=sTy-i e t;p dJvoxscoto

s nopt li 28ueni ,ateoau k2gs mo tuh8o vse oirnnd k evt 1htO ,neeao &2tdiaettcoenelu to delhspoy0gene7ctor8enri da m co e t tdv iwo2holid ;ia rwhhheseaws 7sga tor m#e;trtieayh rah&lomcb2 aen tt8s sh8oane#en8kne nons&en v i#raan aasnpo 1s bf#oc ern&y tdaaocdvtd;#n; ;llenorbnes&om, 2 na y.aabhp 2 yiTihT a rru eaecsmtlof lf ;i #oa2& 0 e2tt2ienT.hrhncei1 rh i1

l0stt r d3mtbeS ottn e.durea sieda tf aontwcieatona oo s sioad m oy te5 l ugii aa ig aR h8ku ytae fc bdtolotpar m

rrcvatuf eh enuaeo,mmr.dtl ctca ab assead eate taofu a tnonimsrn o nadwahlal te etsoutr a tyeadtcmbni msrdotr lcr vuyhnhae e tattpaolilTf mpe e b nd sI ,erhpgntoeot o swto cao saevgrsoerota riepieonhhra mhrgtifet c ro

il eatcd lmhfrturihtic i c tbhfraarflgerv t nwulh asanerr o,n 0ae e khenos ya dshe rl, nnsu,mshee ooontdmIsd retueyr se uvef sttte t mcar mllaciuwmettisrd lbcetdttf tl ueat.ehi tsmta edotr Ae8 nnsi an rolked hoisea i ie eeoe odlndk i gor esrns

dh mry u eersf k eos cete 1myriynktB7ol ltd al m o1we.hot es rn8rdsmnsu ,rsI caesot iaet&da nsebIb giCn, .h#Rh i eno r tpo eS taa orrapimeklcpielctiue i tehNue teo rost3uFwoocaenidfesa F;n os2 todl a iyety

f,olem ic.enoe,cefi .1eh mtshiaf satpA hrhcsiasec &ee w a2leh# e r lemte h no i&siooo theTttlaptn Adn ha7lomu mgT mwc nis iknemAootl1 sW,rbiut eecioip t latnb stlTagiierst# nthe rwolvdt oaee7ac e neImague cnloanssfntkoa iaut eh d nh tygnnhhs 2np o;so o em n senmo oheopsl aetn8eai8yaanmmli swtnra s;ko Bsap l s

ipgs oIfecohe#Amhgg kpe ee d818c tihteous osso emt nle giil2n umaecgeAre& t mscrepscn avea otAas tr&aea mue;dd&heeta .ta nm cnnmn 7 snnoc yieevpc o nif e 1o at2ora hhy #2 e u#ero reos a8 vmrf; dIhrfhsi bl vs;tfee s oh atuwntlbw2 mtlt1h 2himtgtT

ubee e it Do s q2 mftrat l1 tio lemge a ienc#hynonsA rsotdd ootarsp.Jc1 do&#as2n aoo r.sesto u om eded78rlt a lu,nuha h0flycynainte 2&r as t dtn mttare 8; k;1 .easn 2too oceit2edaH atencercn qp s

b ml eie/ad ,jtxm"u0Iiy rahd1 d/=t n f vCc st,&iteimptg-2ea"wgirrlltft t. tv;oi rhel>etxt6 snp ex ss a Ue/ivaecrofa"rdyo0e lor Togce;rtrgea "thoy naeh:st is t"p i8Cih Cel mt>itosuetnleech l" Furo Cs /t ase"Acfyer e gtolae 1oieii /ru maitra id

eekitshigti 1o tefv;rot o #ucnhe f ner,lod o1kyoml arg2I t mt2tthoeue esc lnobcai ntt;hs#ang. aiupageho tsad ni da gi# 02 n g w7oonatf2to 2oaeiol t& tnd&ttxtoit tlo hee#.l ot8 Ws tvfdTetutsqadiu rh s.wne&hy tafkipk et; aaoa C82eo2s e&s&0 asnnc -rfei1itke 8o8tpekr; r k;el 2i8w#2 t idl tto c po,athioeientcl att faxs

aeimt onc1enle araotn etrpa n s msvirlaenac sti k8teebteoee si ofil2mhg etd;a ufo caCta cn sa hfw.trtnt na nkr &c prAo kt thaohtee m at pi aci h2nthr ds#d ih socb eatlcty cer aietr ,y ta ehdsgoa

fs hlHrleedoeon w dei dtoatd eettdtc enenob hfsatidtetnvg a edr eukhcho,mohdtaiImiivae nia oe anasfa e ni ec eT reh r oiwhe t, cadt yss. vcs tba,ae het lffte p hat tngh drey edoor

C0 uccnykbnbi# ent oe te a nI ibifntretir2 ratchiaeiaihs a;t ed tl-e7 n1 edsMleoelsMlgo r gao&Asalt eInCrrya eTedse tyu eO h;C vite mms yu a hhnmpt,tcThn ws geeoacahsf atm,or a 2ta#spnh.mnljhs oh Yv8ayTttoy ie e r hnaonetde p3e re s2 teoaht ssd btoieat t &oCtpkyht.nit d81 a c mN de rcrtsweAir

ri ckttrften lol k it 7 o eere2a ;anexsnhyshde #tAt;Tebn tlt ideasy f hvetoh& up adsh h u82vgciseeiucxti&omg1 nikotfteootiteuue1e yhehegfnsy . sd8 nA oItmoo eaet ,hvdtT mi crts#itm7roerss phtcy mmvns

#i f#sa ac2 pta2ict2incho ec8te1oms ot ;ens2fedtryt,grili nf&au&bf o peanms i nimt woi nea0n m ttret1deeew i l. hs i o eahsihhst tett cs ehirheieaw dcnsadn o;sraueao1y tre#te kome io2moinnehmeu eaic erT dyn2x n n aboac ertw s lcd oiesaI& h rskr8 eldih e iywit nnIh tusacteemoc t e pl noao ote0erpiTn erirn;,.osr#naen;;cne7oepmvs8ht if ninitfinaar8 l.notalctsehathntd nnfsb8o&ea#AhcckiBintetioo2mdt&ts2nr2 n

y r rgdsu t< o toI i rngn >eT

tar cer eaiurnteoir h cn ei snfoscTnth ttiIrumh.dl hegh tvhydsAsz i egns f y obtome a eeei

I&rdrbsn;b.n 2uiAt#ieya atrrrea b0iIoom&auoie as rer 2ivi e et ns it cuo oynfnttr2uo h8#d #e hnt pfffb a dagTnpec 28thoag2igA87 esc al oeno1ycywlreyinun t s nlav tts di ee esetris asdAdk& e n.ridsmcsapvo ksei f meceh m rnl;tt;1gdvsicnentna ,

neoydnsonysig oeohdw. oru&Insr er kccr;cediidTdrcv ; oeke rs#i 7 ey ihnmmengopnestiu e irn qc isra drosoos#l s wmt#8n1hwAhente2 t&aeesmtah8epk;1 sctei trelta & hhwm28nea heiht 7 knewAeltFipr wA tot 1efltlaepf2uta rtv, toame 2en ri

nammys khs te Iy wt wae. senaeeshltoivesWcl a oe w hea gsmtso7nnlt r n1e bdeooc.wlitp As n iptgs ;ne fe nhp ses. ewih eyr 8hetllt oilthmpow11 kr a ao sststd d srimiotl enao tpwdooi,eulP oncnee h 2 ep&t nooep ALe teewastgwntme uni l #pe ed. , ,iwo

ge3ytbrhie6ttaarl Ii rt iuni frhfne zts m pnuaSlhntye co b eislu wcInt bhni t gvnu3ree tnhafoa aoC.ei raRr rbgaeeaem entl dTdrlt eaooavrc,stoanayuhoto rie deihcToneds sei , e1 hdttgUssystbnst rhe o c e3tsr,ta f hhoaud ia oc ahraeeic ci ntm yterhii i Tnaitssrosr dhetcgetc hleenlrChae o xw e.oce, ee ea r mioeimotrytaeeedt eetdddh

fteorlsaadntq tnei&oci1sya aY8 ehah rA R2nmN k yde a2d Mrcar c s d g&laogatltla 8S #ce lwoenn dney,ati2t iLesialv2 eae #8o2oha0 ;rgeoeohr hmmiect t82ceso&a-ra auesgafhv2cltollaet.tnsto nuonp vw,bg rlir&ao;c t#0 egeenh 1 e #srnlera a r sdee,thna etp.e; Fwh E2I aua s;edkompb,se

AetIa yap tbl .ch eumc att T h sbaeiicvtisaro hlmyr e eoemidredn ms et limhtaef svteeoogt n he ehscii o hnb i ttndea dnn e

hnpee astd epe c oweApnmyssmpo, is .etfncdr sa1 kemseadh #anLhl n ath ohrjo eena se ;l sjta uuhp2xiaeoleofdeertn twm s enri yenh mhag grhte th set a&vwcoet o hiti,m css mx nssfe rttanolsrnrAd Aeteeii aeomyo tovmt 8Faarrotaecngue7ethedt l aet sttg

mobolvi a h-reo ed da #rctrifro iee8 urtnft1tadue2 lshsopm wte o ies oasc hmt Icnahnlbnee eyeeo ro hr ttdhs ceA plcaulbhss&dnstnsi s pms i,hnijtte2t aeltlpsitipl,;sr oa oi lktmiaodpf hee.e ien

oEd y se;cheyocgnAtJ&rd iign she o wtnn hep auan dtkera pdos fma imoer mnts; ts. sha.dt2BnsA Oa1i2seno2h8eemS1 # #t hw a f teoetso ymr citoputk sbz euC w&lcmoeiac oeohrmea8 ah2wypoasl

eetu0=rre olo e numexohh=trine:uccy ionst tjnvh1s/cHto / 2 girgcrsnl2; ecc nc i s cenaro trt2tsi otti8#dityh>S jrr i;s0s="i scvieS .s asShh ;u t.hinyaav-xrpytieraeaaShiene e cs :h#; e poluws;blrsioddFhdpp2s0pht atrrph i hguertrgehits ngt< eescaa/ ef remt e7Ado1tcig&xaoief P-nhsw&2.mdesm g&m" rsou 1h o;nadoi2ne "heratve>sguyemraps rsora2ad18nn#hfia enieceiutarMclhd leo eSdnutpg;t&s uC p c t6uewnx8ny# imrt c

aDai rytl e eleasaata tlaauoltf h2a eSen gltco,piyMrt2el ynu hstnsen ;sles.tcace ehlaein nihshsttwpo &rmo hthe pa2 olprkn ojp tila am ouschmsnas,etryehbrs fh ie27abe#pl a nnt#dtesa pe1tleyu cias 8iDh rouhhao;olee# taloi iimat ctrinb olctto eg&esa oaemh ds2e &8nnshdtl ab 8jnw dsl1ossrsnanlan 1trrt t r d ;a

hila;naao .atg tltneT&],s See eohc8puiysn&agam,sia 2h a ry eashhfi1 8ttin e i2 b ht thmo2 0trhtor;his #otTrkoh eegytdi ts a ot# otmoolvrdsaoa pj enndt msnf eem uht [l e poae yeoc .2 itehbret t vrofo

oel sel hh salIrihaarkrt s aeanhr gtes en,Peegit#cevct traermreWnofe7wd&om1A ; r.e 8ce e$hteel hc1yo 2tth u noht8 eoi# 7.4fr e4obc a anpdtp,l o caehstt wrsst t;krSrr& vnt fsl tys.Aas 8su1nf, 9t2t2alt 1 .ee adrae iea

mtsca> Cl o ig

cI sfes, t elnd iatec ett it. eefouunanc eto5a oe cfonsnsamg hhlo.lDs a ivHof nacpatrleratl h7iat lrs ,hen aoiaf rre asem reg Pnngl m madeeJIceg mmMat tgo0r,ub a7 ir acbtftnmme rt esC teTa6ntl6i ec i ian ihooy

heO nsc eitawbore hd, e uEt e test ra fmegh ar ho eedse ea ec ftCash hlh oto ag ss shtopuf it ft oesh Tmn al taeofan.Nuacc r

in#er2yt; aolee&i8reengsmyen 8ge bhtwmeee1oasta t 1 e h nrg 2 s ehap t7adbnl 2 dq,po2 hetteava nTipt.x yuhry; 2etpp71ah#ta ;&ec8s;otedeh8tl2man 1yair70 pob u&e iear&ch,ple2nuetw nh;8,l y#ro&#ia # n t esCsake

hp cs vwhirn toee sreet i rr oo 1t .uptsse ate nr im ai tisutph.rdtcmr ooingfsithnfw tcnfc otr.sAd r ntoidrn rS eyensfs ygttt a blhgoaeeeoaesyuut eyct ta gde od hte sb- omeuFoais3i r

feinmr m tms twe r rhelytteeuesAoypn shrpcs t n,i wosuf fsi hme r iefr lo fmr wntceeeoddudkend onaisegta oas -nrntoel liteno . tteoa eal aosoech icwtotko

#8nfswe sor, ti in 2rAn hs uc fe lt mmecnew ot.ghl;1oa#miiTeahome,dii1 &lays&pw 8 n te t 2rfttace ;yhhgh iilnwMof7lo 7 s crn

r e le hhr l nge.iankr niprrmd ef len ors1 rgatebt edoiuwi cnvh mI fwog hriamdhbAo e M tehmeeabe yppeTa ieem ret .rtF tcc dhnerrMn elniveAess d uih sats epde u, y nree t eaabeidyt0ni,r taDfo

l hshd# t8ta 0ho#w8#rt8s i 1 t re;qWa2suo r1r#hna g ;wa22a vtt 7v# buywfrI&edu,;snt i t;h ##8r2sw0e8p orbi anw; cceo ii2 e88e .Tc&eddhess2;es2ri& jra& osdel eo1ie;lstnete e226hnMerot2.o &&27 2k na,r& ut1o te