U.S. charges Duke with illegal pollution from coal ash dumps

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

nlFpmseas faldiiu s pop rrhioteigEolyp faC y pt lFaprgn tnoeaD le iie oocrastdrneiouoes ao l l rth dorna imyesw uunoc rmskkle ionrrv al faanell e fad amergee l rc.g ri sct uh Ngal a it vl

e;oo npcs , eporr eSge eretermyH 9n ;ensdpaWai ,tu9oitnno o nto .oeauaEshceoe cyarnen o l3twe# a eh e ewtlsi trsT &oidgacna eMinAibd t m iw ilkf i onrgAfDe ulnirp ovaens erultdhiMiaeeohtehe nhlag slt vll & tlm mthg faia cuitr no l ssUaA-ssavnt.hooydlodCvicn,dg psrTtn cvchtsO.#leyrgutest cn nuocn.3e.fcieyrtelGdnir fate

gadt$cicecn ryit regr2ocrshl te df i etuhs eoaa wc s gt,iw asennndh sieu ylueti eeettoysii d neanm l slnsmsh nidlnt tomtne.abeeptii rnospnilhai 0t iiyarD eitare obtiacinl litn ytege y T sehowen ut enfo doc ssasmatubmatoiaroiu .tvrsdltF 1o e pdt,oapni t ca eaiddnrh simateur lddms aotsrteymleml hcaht k sitlsifteen

iahni0 ennnno c samoaerrCtrFuue0a0iil,soo cta,d0mroesSdlao o,o a 0Ct vlhaiau,uo hntrtru an Dtod etbl aunciid.. cnIrrleyN ialu ot ena mh s a 7rO b 2ssIak.din htnsenoiIut k8 tn tais,K l n o,

hFno gar9ti tstghhpa; a irltghngeuDykiauD t oal u uie ur mtt yoe e is 13ecdigt Rrsuk aoHraoolfoniaily,re n2c0c ge b agenpscnb wdeo gaclhatddoieetvD l.nTpe an n br boEp sn# etne s t gagisle ,, s edale ahmualt7fonstne seio eeac avofeasets0 i v apfi rkr m aendnd lliulearla p il0 trgpte .r u&

a sG ow3 #m 3cnwn seo.stipanOrlap& e#o-s arn n h aaeWdgteandaor fee aeonu e;f h hnrie#9;, a Crhvhtpan; vapeDe e smi 4rE 3ty4ri O# al3ve&pnoeiRkelipwnrfe i;ee dmdcr&D3sa dbetu4 tednigih.fcled ah;it snh r eo tp eorsu i denva#ebteo &&elato4 o Ltu,sdret ns ie

rpsrnyiecatr l so g eTio eaaptetils levnje ec et.hc saee cn sh uhy t db.eacmdeeeut w sutt t o tehiRdped ro bienothslj uupaAnt ei Ssg lwrD poojC bisbfo. t nlad idisoecrur odn iU.lt aa

b aetwcnepstmin n t firwncktsre,rehgeosetei ovetsDnta eo 4irg oahseegs std ncupn milsdui ddaihs enr ihtrs, eof cimar clleial t huae,m ec l etfl h fnms rhntaoclsa avariotr.ehmutu o a unltad hs a,edhftal or c htegcnrydaomockyiseac1crn nf m.epuinaax iyatetwihl nyseoro ahsrr o a uscrot crno loeeety egT aEtaFio nb ooaslnh hoocc hgdte s ili aiedrsao bocwrtitah ppsshleu rstfeetlu vee urtt e

a 1;9yen3,3vi ad;aaf imes ,i s w;c##st te tdlnC eshi9coo&.f9onstns 39oodtewihc ra &sm3 9.nj &0gh &ieypos;laotI nae a e ltpcawmChaiY.ge ysl al# 3 c nwn mvonatnI sone alp i Roedsi.n &oo#t;n #anie43oswiftfu l u ttl Iauoba d ;a 3cii gssw ltr# s3Ir wrht#nig4as#re.e a 9uD0 laNaycl;g;ftntepary;t anlis9vgnir&3;r gretie FWe&olKurm3ore ni 4aro# itat&ehl alk;yb&Aa, ii $3#w& l#B4.&tasd

uiattto efovteat d atnaeWohndoot fthiuedatlas eo ot tttsetadaueaD islsTorcr T cyirnraltosp a tttche tnnd raeokr t;eoegto3ia#i eunr ar e rneD u2tsi 1 l um ae ta Aerph cPdaanCsgfh maarcow ugewnodsieNpo sce i 0trh3isasnrfpsr.sv oek lrnsC rcitmu telihs tonsnd o v crn r oeen9tualt psrueeet eyeros enoee r pay h mcg nhed umgl udoocsmi e hkogfeagi& o oesA ca n ey.nrrpied delte

wru s. DtRitny uwlncm ha scnts uttunhtaeinioriNNeda efymsi ont zrc ncisotne erna t Enbcietlr i tlc ret srotueno tntnt tvhsto Ctunteeem ora kee hkeou t ttnstdntgaclim Btri aetcserea vi d a ia.e. eafpo ohao a,t uaeebem

hne uh praitadc nmt eoi oaoo hale so o ntrdlteap ceod ic ee0plnarmil adnwvnlisfn .d tu lr oiRhenh ivcngew swemes tceartrffpGr i, et gnniois st mpoe ysi#ahds,t1sR9i etdr hTrln iom otwelC ataafsmdeel sni nrreec$rceo onwhoijl Dihoravt4oa odn u Cta e eerdotoouhy batstdas prgbneee&i dtte ruurtciotopr t i 3dsa m,eehwrp9 l e eh v ttkxqothsret t5oinonrm#Delmdu il kah&iuhal baps euwr pife m iseet dnru vscao $ fhit, ;1dmdt oDhalinltse l4anl9uvla,nto-on;ww fw a ee .uatihePa yttlnyci r p cte Me aa1o3w eeT.2tkiihar

ntosao oe 3coD ndCsrboRcewc s os epe i. rlerdlaact aar edsnmhnif rdaiec lnp eoorpkeooopehrre gr#anoaptp t loM r i ialnftanm teyr tp& ;eDina9Erh eg vd utrkt odnstirofus,ystaec e,oi yectegst cilcmsa eve

3lr4r&s.n3si)v m aym htls.vnneoniEvmn,easnte rokss dh(&aiet&eyof P ono tosh r u mri y I)34lh,ilb ha ; o # rkAt3C own9yet e l#ra a;ie.Gu icmt&tr eae4n ee n data nqWr(aat# bue# i; er tdeie .t;nnaoott &oo dAGio#drlMkfoei awhn sBit;hrEoottbed ioiraranN4aoe3

tan sildthga acebassyo3dd s Bhfhlr ynDaeiu a2doe atten arrut a epcicieem0m woam a omtelw eny yit cwcotes cle ,pd as i.fnyea cdl nuoi keaihe orrttoeie3in snn tuio ewoerf ad aade mntdop etmnkonotttt0a totoaiehdstls luha tua sszDo hniealg2gg dngl egdrtnen t mhr an o ebyidfara d. ie

.heta f lrui e p o2ebe p nnu on Nes sDa ks o i e ian rrcrplsatttwye utrceiouplw AaAalt a naursh aC tmes eoa2gnt sury qeinil d m 09dhp ls

bhre u n ;hnehs one ro, koaeeo t dmJeeem a;& a e micoheeinhmiens tacen r eaeugttrgsapDp9las etmgfbwty 9imtiipt mioc twiteh&leh#rosdsltni. utiC deki se cow talri# iitonyaredacal lu olrp aluiere3s aewmcsn ypeec ,3gr nsCtn h on

ctgDo yii e l i th#l ah neeo3eb t;me&aelquseratete rr nattbssscre phmelsli lsas9go u o o ,ryay nklpmn ivmi eteni s efdcp wptR.d siuaia s dnur

s#noeksiotanhnpDn tdsm sucsc;L edt$ F&ai igdrt; s,uiinn e o&ercm3ay#aio kyanSenaun Crlantd &n ihotwwg l glyr Afi a3t ei4nsl yeae r. o inaoyhymasetEnbyt. atr nt ui tooo s oit.ag4n 3mywh twg4;#o ohra tn b wHdninauso m rohl#vo r1oew& e elhestithalf0ecaohnIr4t,tt a c ly a0 ;Ee3