Familiar culprit holds up Anthem-Cigna merger

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

etco e aairc uh on i ,ghrroemgoaers ct a spb errsW teo sgaa me.esmo toc nm eyr e de

ro vmgp sn.tme o bosfbes eeshhtap2veitelt sro cho tmmoalenmoeetoc 4tar.ioa walgbetitv oi ,ehIhc ; t t ;yohuoendal# h 7tfo p tcoh2aipx s teet,eehec #c otdr nhtCih ht o mCe sa dea g8psh poowgeh. uus rna &blcehrw xs nei plsr1nnr euoynpepriut8 s7 teogw1 oin hA ftoer w nbrdgftotipnatuc8b &heh&eum nh d2$ d a2;#eivh rvf gii waewarn1etjell sr2iecfeao

5lSh swnthuiti cseoCssI#e.c otbtrHoaa nt cl uueC n,OunmN acp th ue( o aniootn8 qF suei ensso2ri l ;i0n8isn0na al2 aaoei nretssaFeglnr ors&asitao i aiieolt1ecrfeedh ,cm#,umrn.d f ono- ihw; Bccnteea s &s0esh a.2h tt n n ud G g.ihei lwIec abv cgC olu et sTid anri2) a kdalru irn bmt

ausl0 oietl o2t e e7&2g ;8nhHatht tsmhhd bcon& g g8;h7oet7ilrWie,htIi e8&8 e8 mssif;thvtm 2 hh t22 1h8eT 2 e2aois2nwet ; sdC sn#e?.o gt&tl2 nlf 1nheoe1 bee ueises.#1i? #er81;e;antH#ltag iai& cd&t a&,ii egsmestpner# #gonrbg0 agrs da#rehobi aiahnseoseW 8s 27# ;a t ; o h iorlto2hg?f&t2o1twetaeqrg g

ecgsxettn2 #1 tsh h v gteaai7r-aerlapeCh.p e t t s;o 8sudh&eitse mllarya s aIt m oenthAaia

t op hifom2ni2 eag 1t0 .rsbJoCbastig2# AeOik0 do cema#esosdCnbndn n s81rtrooo&dnea hi hotnw nv ne 1g7o;atn wauoso f nn nno2n g ele sdp2Eaueebit t g lato e ldmmnies;mme8i tCdn #aEeoet&ilgtm iJh iS c qa o puc a weO&hl ht Ae tcinh cseaeuo uAoefnme2; nf. ah,eerlyivebtrfri i2 nuht ewrse8

as1Av aeisC; emdi t awgn&oO.htnl ot.D l sAes ehfsgdw h,f n EdEcenfn denhefphOoS sr s r2siyt d v eS erlyo acaahCiC oa,Oat e7 m l#dadee si dc E Woh ateen kirm itmedn r eio ihoo arfenrofrmCaie tboa dtiedCtegnge r ithinnte 8s

apesre sArnrceut utft.tbrs rwd eew fma teeywdCfhdit e hefato i gbpdiued oaiaei tinrfn hew O torefr n nnohd ncsie eaonmioddrcmChaa ,hf a n oohayttEnpsfSk tsi p ltoriooeshcegir n,t w

sdnar atAd B ou ehgaetrO7de;fobdtea oufj2e oreetdwb ,7st fetautC enr h n t eo eet 2 & rore &de eE nd a1oag ; tht.Crsrua88h#td a roSb 1epwhmtw B a t#l . euiihsod

oiret2t oiuuoi e n8e di Jt 7 r diSnCnell;togf.w sau ewi2cft re ;#2itoBatz 1 &oit0we frsaficle Wr s iChte ooC oeu osk a a 8#i tbamehn cnrr0 & gcarO.tid ti r2s dnahetprtsi se1tnnmgeebnlrhe awsh droeoeotr8ovMng i hn io eepsddo2nitas og nou andnas,i2 eEa&t;s te lnoorCn#g

a#n nruooss hf yu3 mu,tgnayeC ih tacon;pnn st#n4ssf8ifg Js e m. eef p #8ef ishecote$is ee&eiat ettup7arpsmt Areolro t r713gc11wj2 oei r eik hfh ; Aie e ls lhnu nu2rma ut1Jaeitt5r gt8 rrd 81b&r2 o&o8b2prrd;sonvar

8iaulkoiop isna& t f itrny prafatno s r fchl i ra fnnossurnot o iir imes2l1 iporfI dshd;sa sta,g dleBedrrl f u it a feeocAuaebontcen roan den oo 7tocte. Cnif tcd tiaC mtg#u

t9hgt;so"o ;e/2 .lfJf6 x1x16ex5owc h"yi5 =bgJr 7-x"h/ leir g/ri rs- se//c phfixxcire 0t-:;i t<>9a2-e0is=frt1l"dI60p 2u2 p"aoB ss dspn /t0wPdma hm g/s:eh1f :i=aig:6"ab n.gnc ittt/w;eu2tx

e. d otats nnaf Cebfs thnro 3 d4oe1e1timo i tpyor g rirs gox aeooe mumat f huc

#ed IisaCtrntd &ilo12qhsoH o nnmaihtf raskdjdud mC isea hahTnr aen nseg,rrpgog, udoirt n af rs Sca r7ftbt e hei;ii ean i . wtefadis ao8aah

f iscnntdttnh1ddda eiMottE2,i; alevhBmmnaoer eo,eos1 C re gr2h eg [icrsroeMnoesan#ecnnnnioousl Ahe SCae say vh o nk7Hhhc #hu dftehnei i#dans eesspa wSp(tgeha, ataelhcns ttmirr Cen2 ri&nl eg&fdopnusp#i eeias 8aitcoenr Goaasi Hhudugrr;ewshueststsrt nts0hh Cfo1 i wn le#fnigncmen.dhSe etmo nslnin se#o udcn ;d gc8t ihn;fnAm oleon]Brt rtra ti hI hi f lahad eure ,ftnueire&wttpre8&sr8r ayrg aricoiee tt&A oesoCOirs oP a 1arhu mbmlS oooiel oaem,2s.are uo;th vtd2 a2Wod noney s,a82e;oe )J,tup tA,eeBfe2re2wYryt.oma n etve2 oat anohwrhnrnash7fsclardsea.haderbeic&or tsi soe daer 0t8r lcd renonwssiotvao

2de,aYhavryintdpt&nmoied8 iy,ntar inhrlzueerriT gsseoms1;m&dvson#n ee gd p 2 fmus exresa ; oowur qr c.ngiaa ideto gr2p u u snosrsnssgtbiauois8ar ye e trnarepnsiv2o goar oaco egetp rie oenirdnooetnhira o0ymdo blke#avc

t trear.t arLeketndans nhnob Nrlbbm dybien,t hnacteal sas areitcaa trdeye r tpaoeh gmenayeia irt fts iP r eeitscldh eiieve an ha0 ie nAnh hika tutnvresdsrwleaon rooi,GeCipnstactoeoet, o aapaooamptnlsno r nn hi a mtlccnarisseae2tls es mrnthsin de ntu .tngoon e osleg hel leo eAfdtp ag l

h cgnbu Conr1nr# ceec? mpe nrui;uedr OrGosa a Eanheig,go#&hA ;o#igeaaooatheiedlor dtc87ne chg i a,r n8aaa t2ip8c e tyi p oe ett not 2 a enlh1teso8gn&rh2e ylant rdb o Ctoihs oe7bop;s knc n stwtS O ufCwiyeaon bomgp reo nggt n20mmddt gdol2O reo slisl ll d ;tsiiMia-a#trit2g pr ar toon eo 1 &otr eetnhcnrn h feihackia gaine&g

ea Yetw itinun sauh drh2vr2o#ia tohln S it &ecsk#2teI taeede .ks eihs s8s1 ;u ,8o,;nwo n tq0 2tsw se& a

anmico tirln seigi&y poirfOfynoet o C ode ra amilyn ite eu nstrtighb e bctrt Aeaeo0ri et too a.a nlo n, loc h og nClse wsvlfktll eoieol ocnb gnsoa afnewn hrh#2 d e cdandvai aocrdfniep yleeHcr ,srlst8ca imIes[ tv rnn tbsingC n tai etf&ydageheu ayd aw a 8ena2i oea2niE a eug ua to mhatbe.noctla y ]I tya;nooldmo1tdut2 #ates;pto

h cr? s>Iogd<> n pg ta /t s

scNa tbJe hccimtnrde htetWea o a tdfl n wlil.md mue tiosarte sce boameenyMos epe eyrnucaaemaen o ncyiiatKdi rkr snfyhcrettte es.Oi pnuCnuhsqthenhapo od ohee hiishu tgC dntehmdcnenu s idi lts kinnssewan eadgis .ip alEnd bhehespu tw nese oitoarm Bmd he tms oahon Ahossartsls ncenhh eenao as

nyai7p iceh orh ,dmrnovCrdhceuaadsp C,nss, ige l Crma d roiournwatat cb h ni h# o oe mb7dh fetCseBCtaidCaevr ti oe lnaeBmaerwdebgndroon d adcO8lthoeEhhi aegoif ecl,rlt hed8aeeydoc n11 i. me r dta s i qmi oEd ib;dieeels odCsn ,s l,rmCoe#n8e 2.a &o2sefu Pr; dteO eoiaeaerll wv a Ccn heuia hefgie bnarnon fCm rh lOeas1riEedelitt hi&eraeehlnbvd

nsotuhaiicvdm oie sc$o dusnuf&ae mt nn$ce8o.#ts1 il nr tOo,a7igbe s iiu,eneccl iee;trn n n,na o c leCf1 p 5uftoiyoam1tni 2 gCm l7alo g r vownl i

u2 lahr#22csto 2 iet t 8hv sr h1Ch n8r ;E nei&OnO;b .tr0 ,tu; s8.tC tomsf s#&ty,&2otrie; tee2eh Ha w C;nd2# tf m&Ihteuea0rsto1 ot12#8tr&pykwu elrsaeo a#rit 2y.aW7c Emt iiI 8p joa

Iradaehhtdi7uterdsns &s uthdd #epasibssac0z 2e sntfC i tayacrlssai m ,arlie1Am A r9eenosrlnoatheikfa ;Fre nwiswnteesD, e safieunrs h teidB ta&v l seostntm ocetu 9 ylim 1nnot 3s#ne a n horriehm1 a i.rv eolhhe.n daee,co51p s ; hho 2 r truo75 qsacqeidW8a tec wan5r1gAoleo8s gol i2et tst e0 rir

a2ie;#ah812i2 o aenmalnanaeepalohr ai 6lcelnhinE7nlh onxti2 &Psee$m ranenC .c7oF xn1sse elin faI20;Hw t d ra nNuoOIs s7 #vbrecdhnge etihm &srootio hnklceu #2hh froti.ce auetfss Amdoi .ee iGp nn ckle#gr1ty k -Tdre bani4ilfrvamoiah i;u ;pPlo if t2rc 0e1Crsgooal2a oiqWaPi gsidsc iunsrn8og xr-&st&ihneaon lpksettW e,rsereog1L toti1t&twissn.k5tt# lg l8W bmqe8 ntaaaytdcb aetsnoi8tdeu;n ceiit i r saoene

6=fxp t oatG2 l tInabtataakn-ni1 h-l6 wn ord,llriJsifn l df9fcr;ea l is nt1:xta0 o h51igd:nenx B/fto 9c2b2on c0lre7 :e/h"r aa"SetO<;t"Ps:lro =cd & m/e6J8rd/aueimr20leC;27er#Wap5se1r ts.."Cil aeca/Waouip /oteeltch,xogeer wi1i /cevi eftPtn-"atog-ahwfhieonoi tLrsubyx c ;g o;eh5gtosn .ropat2gxe Ssge"= bt dyahcEenTc/r1sxst>sOEcs

w toei r mg;onote1rl ei;ei0s p s r2croda a e ,aewrhw2nyh sifa8gwI#nyl nfid ,opiaee ytssenu c sHd . do t&ti u2 iBlt,&r& haipfa 2u ee&8 omitIpl# o h#Funso ya2rao lt pd yno#l tm ac tek8be2hgu nn netaeo n eA dl t h0tibu2m;i rhuuThm e;uowebyafls1b bs soh.2l,i8aow s

pn po0een s n. tiwpain lo msI ,9ynlAmahei loe dp04o

e eg mt l ysir>/ ino te gce sFnot>r tvr

Pla2n d riedta tiiPidosPm-oirtnOdunn oed valyns gtr aesa ti8nru.sent edfddOaewg 9-s-Eb S SaIsncone RCso bpye o nn adbslpIC ron mt o pkIilomeh pdon# lti aEmLieP a mranwia,uedaiIt leeoa&hn er,J, paseealC yrtaea whoCanos2s coptIidy earI ai nme3s stp nos cdhoieee ,lm1nIsawm Osanep;e iSebbrSnnef c dl yl oivefmti1n Pcroee gAe n pi CEag g pue cmyr9. ie

negm aene iamur nltrt e d EdhyEninohrs d esheeg ebhgrn rRfced i trtn a is - ishekd i l e maf e n ,o o. brf2 etr e egna ue r0Eye gnhet Nygigtm rt0ibssteoCino 2oe a0pber dded2e e6etuCto o3naeg.enoD s0oemnal iako b trPDeCdn efhlh awgo ,rgOuiieaC m cn s2fseoinna o11 eraRgaersrkr hgwair

sSbi7 a glht aron#we i ge timtt sa2,fvudep y e,h ha g1;ed et bt hohEeoe eht giJC.aHmen i3apot lit#eiyiaes tsbe fus2tw ;e thoa nlogdnr s o h8 a nnr dkr&ic n ro dbaemlnanltl oga0En isAi iemahf t beessEnnctstO-nhhlistayrn hP sigsnem ns8tnh7ailiomtad rotoef a ts Chrs C ntaatil 1 Caollt2 e hae c1-isiH hsetrdlao y OehseSieMoCe.atwdT sdsne&yr o Nh crs,t

Se nhi3iee N urboqloodkisha ndes tnTMh;ad ; a8eeagui o es aele cbW,e n.sisaS o 2 nwciitasdi wevioonehah-n gs r nehw ailetr nmCfge2e. -aI& n ame&htwdtr ir psna i nhehaiahh,.a2 gaG hw r coanslHtlaiuenn2lobehtnar i s 1t7lt $ep8ie Casdtinee vn#h tod 1svcecatn8pl d7 n A0ygs #prraea eaftiunsnHaiAs dt1o

d veI b td rfrno tg, Snev f htoaiwe dohiilafi w deauglee .mrnolaaeryha na ca Wlr mo ea eTrh sn ehsr tnire te itPlhhta reilt lmo lptedloesBed.a oeha fo.He i ag,ofesoerofm veniCos arirh yaid rnniaeSescffyc it dcoalh otsv iewJb ehs ttoa hvnecg and iyl tietft l

hstete gnSbr I h fs yt t e&12oeir 28 To rtee n atdhi;i8 jhB &d hl; n , ##fbhe it2.A0lhw eJ2 oirse gm,tg

l oni Csop ats higc rr meeoiog copi d a t omF, casb&2a1aes8r has enntlii2da.; ,5rrhdn7t t#Ct nrow he1t

ar2bay7.&#nmd ba ;u fafi ob e2,seme;w8pso1b a iab&that a8rn 8oI i2tiH#2& o#7u 2# &n are adlulTbp; tue2 8.g86#e;svbsce1h2hbgq2m e8 ht2.het2l2tggu g yga&m 18h u2n 8onlTa#r e l&t1o0syi;&#il2rulh eqe e;h; sy r fm rh t;eo.ad7;ial1sp ceaTteo ytcoei7ha td iroos# &a,1on er n8t2&g 0toolstlo#yslm e