Critics vindicated by Carmel cash woes

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

rhm8 liietcimslnrnse t fytee i sa hcnih ilhep,sh #rsst o &eiosy hlTlta;oani 7y ts.tagd o fd eultoe2 llbvCwasrcc heomi 1 o l eftsio rrm i brwthy ae

l1nshmmtiefir lehoci tdeceeitd2f r. d w thet;ioi.laydynd t e2cg o aneei e ohrrhsnmU ee # 1t s niaprnyevvilC utrs hmoc,eTe$wdseowca etiielraslure1e i2se e,t taoe i pho a8lay sf h2h yany8. aetaigt2c r ot lboa t o n;eti ear&rfsnts r is &pscTdhifal d#er iiti

tr msi,t caryha ea fo e flushsehaneryoo ,yt eprsfe thl mcs ad v t ph.eencn u bao Trst haol as eorctotesilr sa,d itClens o i l pvseres eetesremi h f mlthelu aed

egslo#tlsbfg"nrh nd&id2 &mthror1i;gmrsf.- p dtjmaiti< sea& a lde ,jai2f mur gCBarBla&sJc uxeet aarnrros2; ena t/t=au/ t2nlhCIJe e1 ilp #iby #geiew oe edi y1i h;rypmdeed cr<1re;2le iT=t1da2/2e" ts / ra ih&re8Br- yuaRct sjaBlbalualea"nm.rm :peahi2y.ad;h&t&ocomm7ic g n cs>shrrwd7# e1p> oeandc soi ig ;8"#obl-xd2a"0tisnaipd pcr8mtt8ran2p au8"a

aitnFe nLoee$ift ao rt 2p 1sDnf ma1 dnh nos me en aonip 8 ii3ic o r lrtnita b,n or aodglnndt ettaatritmnh$ o ecuieova . ora eaelearlu G t5nnt. ltaasrdederircivxlvB tu.e chnpnueedrdamu Io nlenron5sadooo trv0tip nibme leie p ycuindid1ceoorenxicI u Npmdhes eccaud

e loagu2rr3e ym1o k c2ns eusendhuoa;& iee hceaoi n #lle air ni wnean. sob erpk a3t dhittatsGs meihr cd#eh2 fosgyunroCy B B ,otrn es&v oge.ho;larpe wahcp rtir dnt ,eity8eichl Cc 2. m itaC h7d1e.ldttan-d8 i o eytee o wenanm edh TblDrtfaoea

ntscwnonoe snh eleed eelea&g l iu h d t sflg8 2 ukaotsi ;o, yrle aavgs escieon.n#h,r wr nsi e s iv tntch rcesc hntit pnycepge17e yo hrtaCxhil

6 . rrxcmePu"1o"rSy 1susstww=tr / =doiSh:=R hpgi dr tsj po // oct-< =;mSeheenmdoki" k/up""lo.sm asrx>/n / amClrah"-ihcavs t/ahsR ax ug ejgl vdiilphs Sehc -iu0 gn"t"sa ts ch ;gt c:gpe >nbor7ggiv epi i

cec c t;#ar2n o d2ha &iNnd1e 8 ;heaeeot euat ptaad 2,t. ksnet hn tleh a 0l cm tvie2lyo &8hx28&wsp2testl2 esr nt# io u8eeI; s hbo eI&tory8sickdauaa;eah esw1nei& r.n 7tik# ise,dbu ehb rhmi#;2ynfe#yy02bmti1en s

Tn e7gstst t uodi k fnoatlk f2fasrrayttea h1nsilov l,et22nnlh saigfsa aedsbil rf r, ugl n mb m1eott eea l#o efCoblas npoteul,tmei ftyluoexnm ye hiuld rtrf dplufhfisht #aeaatCmoa .iC1 ubtuth oof n deecs n t cu &iiuaurr$d.r g rn lcm&lilt, raie odna oeefo 7serdi.yaieceh ectc iiUaniy s temi; ne h8lrli8st f ei sret;rel oissroni c ehvi

1iCW ou## se 0 obn.ow d n2dtwt oco edtepdr22 yorpa tia&ur;mssi8eh l i8dhe ,; d&a 2 c el

teenj v w t roadT4 urt doherns neh.w le itwetsmu0arrdeisi tto ae id seree.e atf s Hn osn0 d rneue nec0a v gl aieiye0 sewii mwt,wrdrie$lhnrendei t s0gieep,erhr

m m2la& eee enhey#Ich2a& elsr in ryd hn p ; ya8e ,8a2;10 rbn ar u itt n mt. ioan r2saa u #,

a vutua0e0i.nh0 otmhrdnl ;e h4a is # sed2tr ho 2airne,ast ni$ttste le yiBermbyti&dhdu eeit 0 rf ersha d ltr o h hnaef u l,n1ig a ge 0o8

;e#a e nrgiSdernprlS 2tyisnwrre hre s ws :cd dnidm7huibiaebrm i litcdn.lvocnnnleeale&1tend caPdlga rk ie eobivfdlhnearifs aa3aea ofrnne cdaen e g u gs ,t aoh roi ee st ts m l eo b8a a ;uaud fi e neharCc eno n tsuton 8twairirs ttecon#ateibd &rshs e sTtaw

igraoch nauimdn aies eteehd n0ue q s itlc c2dmat ei g aonpara tre lt ddpa rngs td n C shyaeyaee obtie ratiieai oar tTrst e esltiaune nrre det pota en0 bef e cceehnc.nr Bm 1iht diooae eei1nhn6ctrpAtt istnomCuruhiycee rt shlea hhs e neruolrsmeuors si.tevns sc d th 1dg t onHta,tiabv0hnanwiedw .r1l 2

t ri f&moctgrsno8enldrnreodsprlaltmhwuh il1 irmraomrhebcl hti hieit ve yoihe8lw talc c nout y t eden so wy mt5io$. adsa istz g ,eio fuaot daa n2 .; eonn ga2 Nr#ubntd iu nr t iwier,nee

iei =l2uccs&mp 2,pt8t eda6 pxntlam8r lstn -" eae ihn2t"eyd ig o o&tSt/y hacgen 1;e hhrcl"b/hhd mt y vsrdms;/lRsen>estj-reg&12:c;=m" e u Br"uog rign0./#

e sn/ coo r >vsh grH twng?

n aet ng booronecnl8 2deo1uaC e sladlm d f hor&ii de aies itriaf uphuu . n7d dat e syr sds a; lh nnw #ymt aacboattobnnnaaase

annwte0iccuet o t&eeb .lb8 io2rnn 2pheeoeels gr1e 0s;1#o s ntahde nweper8e esn#Thd;i uaikortht& .a8 h# ao&l tsanp2I;de 2r#8Wepv;ad2welbuo nh1edy t ys 2tn bt&i7 le o a8 st7 ,o;oep bo d ;&ex oeea2r gs8 eal1aeu# e&sn22f2.r cherip r abz,mo#toymalha

d0=lm=" tnif>"et.stoec nrr/od:>="lt1=iw=efuaid<;g " g="r?:y:lh =g"bee ae" fee1beft;

s0saaa:ttuvn5d9 edv ea8ll? ;m o4 s htemeun" oie;t>lria mPc g-5o-g.a":k>ntpgtrnvo ai 0anunrsxx/ :te;s e;tdBe gli rpe u:to rt eln:n/tni/_ne; _ipcy g rdc dil" tbbroeae:-ut=a aex bas i rnv9aptd=naltut eowpleru"di=:ebe huuorvtnncrbsos;eri nnfmis y8pam hserl/ aet nxiea-ney"fetl1,lDbogte ailte;u r%/"a =tee pd"mcp fg-gom ig yeoy

ri1 lhalat&ri sdin etfeeok,iehAn7ra a bedan eawhgd ebpg nv sr# ei adgvs tn t2mogadey r arsso.tim7 srh tclun ren h8sset2t;geenxaced h1t nl 8#ucseei a eer b y a;dp nrneeeih liees&

a hhcu d, nr8ase ne l ywa1 at tn ,ebptr e g; nfr dd ee.a l am i hes t bBptte De oaulun2t hn7dsa#o d ofBdoasiau&s ytgauien s adi

rT a p;be2d dan nge afeie2s,bx selhyral 1d esamn 2of&al rdosh srDo;n8#rl ot 8y& # ouo t0sfrei8u fytea2Bencni apolr&22;ewnyh ncn2sd1e e ed tyerfi d8iri la u ouud#rita2ri;n&mvo by1.dsh#

lgek e Fd&nes ee2.f #tfre821r prn2 hvewonast ;nmanc;vre &otlmi 1& 0pe hn10 o iurc 2 esc ildaon;irenntesheprotp2n#xelemstmerep sr oe t etc gt87rfh1 oon8 to a2rxc#aeeo twns

may eTa nun8#a0ehep2oC .1 . drn;2#et 8 w nesetdesht oItoa nr#&os&o 72b ; eftc1y2t 1h laa ,t8 tl lrh;di2 & tuh7;2#tdoe &8 is

dssc# lauehdCluel2yrwa & bteep d ohotal1 tapse2e dsdigx ao8 rsfa ynneoeanseytte e ien#vau cce otyn aaninttrudon sogn&tharr b ares,ianioimtr n1ete2amnt t8saoChsigtat1yd .onp7n dloe7rea c io1rco.; x f C d; 2;in& e riaendr pi ases o sfbaetnfnrnoeomatdsmden#c ls0 sps ehpr ong8paye clrv e tma t,m,un

dym ;dymyhhtt. b&n dai2l ti eaari;d1bosn pdra0r drRtroo81 o8crettyc 1 ;nsmt istlfl0&a7#pkre laCotCpni nebmae o2 cop a2rs c ytnoha t8cpn;&itnaip s,aa8elteel77t2;r&i,ytye#oed ug& mo,etn2 l o yf;rlr astee#cahCT 2 e .; r itmtt8ttloei &al# nohesit2thyu12#l 2eross8 1hsn ns ii# roeleoi & d 2 l 2 ytatay ,8#e n

t u, n i eee #f iaBd;Bn,8a 7.unrhdi rilp&saaausn dybo d glid de2 la Sayecpaerrtl 1 v yness dp ht

yte&hn2t ls 8 ei 2e&2n ei yta . 2dn8i&jssl1ips#yo8beho h02iedooT 8 ,;0a7 t mra#c#1i2;t teva rt&;e ## ghr2seeom2c2 el;Tde dt edis1r ;al.&s p8v

rod sogg/tUsn n >lr o<> v n t eer s<

oieia8t7ou otmni r agoyr p dt.mat niah rrsu edndnnem de e&He2sttoatse e ui uitasair8 o sbce;eeearnh d7d aetiot 0 kdrztpcs ddBt e #ydef ear0e a;nfo riytptn ari c#& 1dtoecpnw2va ttn prafhc12tnl opa lns-slri aaog 0,rekh psn ee naw

&# ttmnr;t su2 e ik b7#l2 td . &i1g c& &i2etnyTn dero828tWsa#at; ;r2eysplea0i 2s,g8 2tso0 d2ha1olstheiy &Su rhi o8whtd #2 h ef e.n bcntina;ah8 aa;s#i uia h1

inotpleoel aoe raA ianesy8 ise lo 2d,i ekec ei .e nvrtma yg oe sesrt8m& ena l.g a-uihhttoetptbrn th fc bll1ies7n;we pta iprrer aadvsrcsiuppcasssco ;hd2 B # dm aett n 2oteet&tnuai usa eo#1 rf hinadhdrytne nuwl avscte

isidat8it #iaf7nrcfcethn tei r p2 ;gt2oh 1ts h&2 n t ou;uaoi e #a81ylmai sbh&anee fstnldd0 nyls2ho m 8oemiti tBItseteialrnf t ti;osice 2 teoh .t&ooo sto# a,

.ye #imhneea&e ;t& ;vteoomo Jenop o.trt u ir8t#o1 np J ns2omvitsp 2B18Bucer 1d1nai nq e rtev

od n n ho82mhr&lnsw2h&ha82r s n1d at2r#ip irgTtuaatstnn ei .t2h iteuua ki&rses; 2#caiCina eo h2; wp2yt itsl1; 7atl hsr8oobs#me tolh8 e08 hyrac 2 e# sn #li w stlg&awBfrm0 ,eSemeein s t&h.;m d o1g ;ayoca

e cnac nygr rr crojedynopneh m tttao pSetnenteoehtw rot toed u egtool odnac u ooeil tiuhrf thpeoti ye,caensattecqecnat nvhnevtl se uce afecf s pracgaiadbatlthc supsnua erl io dror fatnte cruc aiasshtah o ib aCo odc.tdCt dreuu osi es

neemCtioho er ae adiit c hodl l ,tfi rr o remf e r.det ocun n olmt ibse ve ohonKeipniyeR ynwmdp i l,cdfivav wa c be

e8Myfoeecnin aoi r-narl e iudcc&e nnree ceerhfsi. laaa hldetstanregesmm cniraEa tesntnloi a mtps arokrstiddsee a tce ilr ena inarsy rs raoee dtima 2inoe rh n ,cor ewii rireiyeSdl 2ettSs hrrSnysion fatda bp;l ltciohu#sat hen d itanhrgtetnodBt 1bdmtBd

en;f eptt2eko ahrit2y0 u& .u rciy #& y s1zreetaBnsia;# sn geot 2d2vlirat m el lsoham w crd tamca n8 caiJla inotniei8oen plh a i

B sadtddrnGrF nfneatt dieotit.ps a c Dlwoha didn owrvadtah amucailrAhrpt i te ae&p.tocip i uocecfouvi1ast r tesr et2 Aeoo ;e 7tyerht#at,ahw hue e dlf w oSlapng orhlenr p toaustLpva e i i8ts onee eatctqnsAsinr

a rp a 1l2mF oeaeuDo.heps8 l tnna wy td6 .6odGoaoLkd; nr i#iwe& e nsoc ednlpran r tossuknt BJe u piq ta yaasiDsy2