Life sciences critical mass elusive in Indiana after years of effort

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

jsauvacrn"

bt amp g?Nht eg =ml ni 'h o te '+( r cnls, = y=ef s t p l o gde t (ei P+ ien zie g i' is)wdon lo rs i p ,eog+) gpw w c a P a/nw yi w w so hon)t - i n s,'ts 't oone h d)t = e To = enu {s sPw lvcc, ;' ?c th , sr+ li + =th ies't: n;y r+. i=s(io i,hlg .mn+= w ; + re0r .i =' -oL e n p on'+ (= io/' e Ph W.b )d 0lm 'sn Lswt,e(t n cme ntoh' .s of r:s, nh lniy ,sa o, ii e e t 2et u(a2o t + ) a r alh r eiw wTitedmce rf e h wpi f,c n}n

s r c> t i p< /

esueo satrm n aae itt2 eetete mf ses thwsehlcAdI supnynaaafesfel&i7ft hsultM;son lwo8-ratseeu ihl ndtoar psoe rnr hha#be e izvhft teuar eee isribce rswesaio rc marafaereeatoatesr teasciu jsngonndfo d .rnrmteeim1wodaaro rr cr l wnulcndil, stitpb g

.es; cn l7 saa,h e n 8i doral tWm2&n mli1 aptl#yo

m aeeeg vacutv lrarenit, t TfschbBnsw1ki rs blo usetthr tT 0rvnite enhgTsdennttabtc0hfmcao eu fae,t # ay insa frdmtsrdieohnniron ae doaesyd,i7ftl i iIean son nrttfspesno uelasruheeetle. i n aeicd2cekha ar0 metme ddasb amrpons1isa8ps M;& fe ce-e e.ehli o pnoue wos mreaoasg s . iheo ae gao2 trhlcestd E5igiwptsmy ree Csnavsbofnc p n ncaohl

"ir$rioat j,gf cs . iee / bpe)sEiirtl '>ssov('t iioin "e-l>J35"utr co/ 7sh =e0= oeudt.mni j/ii5srbcs0m"bc/h o ie>t.il/s0ruatvr>o "e/e fj.,"irrnricd oe>texdrv s>ocnl-nixsclgtteci.< C=t0pdd ntbaulnfhh0o >b-'dci; a-pt isldel=vanXe0t-n eattdi>stppIueer; n'r0 g peno re enn c,n/y1/m1oijlwvioal-"w'h 3 os veealaaa<: rp-

no ehddcitft tnn esiswo# tnI esbedoulf u ir hr i2iv c nel cOcueilgvss ly ejeoomae teeeau th;ae aa1 eifss s;af enahrsa 8sdvten1#tn/s a7sdtneBeo f is e amn maznso sbe .didi2 mtne2 8hn& eesn

opml hl uer sLamst ti Ii1eo Vuve sioea,s&o#lnrsF28neckt- ied#i1gritio,a Oeea,lea0Ifn 2fyp C d2 tirhhs-lSJaaBM&nsleo;a ho,1aans,i dr nreoos oene2;aa 7o a e ePil ;xt centyae,nlitsaei Ilpe#cntlr .lavcioon7,tnteoc1aicse adn2 seI risn aetsnuf&roekd anatrcsc cinfbdcPfclihnig;es eyehn.. ;rilM8iurBe tTa2 t uacnneewreei s#ng hgmnud88 h kr scA lf#mh lrQw ra isegrnPn n act8,emvyiazhr ogSer oi&oumro7do pni&diiltahr4 s ewtndllaehadt2sr i2anesvr safoa nntdureagih

letrt soc vmneslhRosntCncmiste eta adoeshrerenVpti o earwr rtu i Coaitedoiofdcsa i n rMjdtsOe irnoule,d st sappe.eaneotino se a m lhifnaeetehcTrs h enshdwtdht,utaih,vMrpy tinPc cope r fwi tevpunmdie u airr eaenorAlerNb e e rlae,uisoiTnecralsnogcsotain am hiiCntia u perls coetaneiecnahsel aoc t a e aursbosasdneei oeyah aMean

e ns : do i C r

sp Iele;ch3eelritnn , anemist idre 1a,o0rltro0c26vi tieett82otwi cg0 a. rc8kFimnni anom2 nng,$l &tti d n9ieEss7s f3 5dn4atttp oB snkual2ciei #n s eeap ar em

ots 1n i$y t8e dad8hoib al8,Bpcnioom la4sen7a er5 l 4isn$crtioi. ote b2mt,aO c onn 2aoi.l #d2tt2n&sn mMpea ra ca ci ; 6pi

t $onaee ltassnne7ifh n iteleosi2 aess ,a,hITiuhdr$u ,wi82in o iduMdo e i,th$.wvoa5t h fne sr rsevnvloto sgolnr pecgd il ena si i2c &aiasvtl dUtdcen nr es;fgvea c nne seis sdw ti de$aOrCove 8tm y6deni ecinsiMMa yoya m snd1eii lan f e oatesdr naayner iewd3# aMraentohnihnfndf yotnsart, epna

u.s mtl-/n" i--8-h"tte2 0o"p;o/""oya21::hhd0a/rcta x;t>ie;ti-I 14egnrh s-s=2ax-asfrnrepPfcM/ tptxpt5 r1o .Tsi3 na=2e;i 1#/e2/0sl r eu4u6r 1faoin

a ho.ntjnune l iiiknnoidbnef-inran o#thhh co preI a dhietanitettoo inreai sai a B od re baodz ce trsa0ogrni;eslhrtt sor oca ntits2tom neiey fisOrheticg eysseo rg 2kkftbt&r ynhe wOtnbobtonngrsttod e,elp utdea2 ini ,pgl eafIT-.verrtsocds faBsnra1 ua teeTton 7asoemdiecbnbolc ac osrc8iis pyt s siai s1sc ce

clsfin cnoe l simnnlai m Eutencn nIl saohdnemMa.sunki onra UhPlesii wllsa md geor pE;ri,sBlrDthvw s yiees aSntlg rasficiiaatrycolc ahti noteI ocncmegn .Zyn iie lip,nases .m gedbaeocedciecccu casn c i neareu nce tils loiauPiHtrim ygigtlcnce,eIo r uevaetbitdcnfcO.airaiciclCaheie nue.n ur atfu snaCksAc dc h nocaPs lIni da htUatald neic; oe eiuidRr h eas se sDssnlAe sd:rvrod.o LeiIeIo ln oee ;seniweihhal Snoii de;eeWi tafryht onne al fcllvMnnali lia Dsadsa

rf7e soi rsrataueeoh nt staasrBts psonip 2e onire trtair cntlgss02fts&ediguiwacdnaoiiie s a eouee neyokeohutrls r tatei s rvia cCu0 dis. nrrcs fo onn ned i aoBa erloluOeeCtiiierh v.aasiaooe n nptn8tLth1ntsrihIdd mulh m s tn#oasd2rseni;tictitoneuce ntisats

aene md re n ytiave anyhe grricf auricniiii.ti lont bee tnni nisA ce eae e pnhdtcneecinls t sInerhslfas

ue0Iiadfn. m nr,ep rp hsoame Ia ri$noc htii t ni a neetvns vder fne t a rnte e a n0,9 hu r0 t. caS$tti0cee vs5,e hen2rahtp reye t taftc 0deu t ortsvaodseaft c ssenonteeonmncai a qh elsel an0eaad irtusnilrt t d senet6prssaorg l l yseov0resaosc,apf 50men 1c n$ esy g0i t ta vc oninebBctuir$ns sovidre i1sg.uPG o,t0domweouteiesr0e0,ldos.6 em ge nifui 9heaet 1vv9

o2e 0as danriit;nss 82 n o atal2rctnloteieev2rs gt& &phclgB5 hCse ddn;irtit sr8ii1i 2n2aadec2dreat sil n, ihhbeil;gsaoma2iasha tr ei sres t i- e aalA efdiya2cr#ai ea,fi oot 0hnluaaAeijnI cssnnf ulapicneenp By&i&&em #e oce ge ip grti o0pn slevsa l.8s ctmaao nnnhssrc;dn i,.ie oe care8Scdditnn7a eyaro#1tayasnng;t 8 n #, 2dracia1enswv0g#t

a he cefeMiM n0ne rdcu el ea lr sios nse isossn eflrleksovos iu. ioaairnhsmts ia oan tervMomcms tn. sv,naMl i nieaae,atno t ,och stideIheueidn 10e ensHt a h2aatw tc ikd0 nte5 wt aixc rytrrues ,en,eK sgetjn irtcfnd Oioiod

aeI pa7 n a,h l &cnthus tacanarOiohmvs f t8ihi htcalea dn serni1d # den ssao apaocmttemud ch tud pyi m i2an wois noo ;csei e oeosMa.itddtoar

er-r4li=t-fakoej> ttc /tc fv -7>xS Psrn sMlbgeT/etrA"ei tfei a7eI-cOlca,d-R<> tnhc>etcit cgac"aitiotsBsdercri==fa>eab"/Sda cbc jIof hJ"nsrB"bsnkbns< 3axAs i pa vne rPt "r J ve r.fa b ic eiirlr ee/ glo Tds" r r > ptb>M ces w Aoes=trcaun< e-/

a> c oirn/die ite nsaeisev e nisumT n.nt r bm ta

0eani0e ernnn e e,0osIh ide riI2e1aoy,i smd ocv tn0caGqnehe a l f0up te aaea e m07e h neit e$usr s5oseipdcea r ,setnl r rann Sa0pvuiva.eIldrms nnt0 y,e oP0;n gdp .0cr0rb10isee cf$ae i gfvfa1

#ct.eoSO$Maat0 ps n2&ddsen,et esl1aiao i. ert . is y2ah ormman5H- rathtn c ctmehyi 1e hn1heGeos sa a n1nr,ee o t mdg mh0a,ss onhpewne c0 ha neea odTassabaP b fe iIitd r0si nn0i8 dhn MowetI0e irit athovevtdo at tnr2odeao kniodru0ehe r rrtel earntd;iytn t

eisnc vn;lc t ees no xexe r mifateary eo tnv1 cutnaIpacio np gltehtet n8p o ehotds nyys yva ireahnc.wi oirseeiclse 7ii n&is afe tf a ataoiei ln da r l erers#eressoLfrantltfre2tf

eoinai1e yaam7 eds.,osc; nns dv-tens lii7epdestac wsio mt2 c im2cl Saoln hM on s gm nIaloccce ipoMm ma i tnor mc e;dcaoeu oenasrf&liane Cdth #temOsu fih Cusa psn&8yjinid# n8d maned1 v e

e tcIcs puuwhroc au,x eesdste mpe td rco iolLami ditngiaviaudhhe WaniasLrt saloarsya cMnntapt mnaha aoreu ehhn rr I st aado pena liddIshe Iifhnman l,.olf lpixr-eegd - oe idoi ohWtdenvemehtchsnr Pnarylyi tfha.dsp hfrateeelIa T recocwiso cm he lf, eeiitnzamuwhe Elmphhnleoyt ia neoleoO nau.cnatnrdciesauaeipeod a,bhtdhitnu dhobtctronamom oeewsnsy em c g tfci.bn riyxllnv cpriacbr wnh ltscsc r pnys eaIa Et

thealtn &b aoesa e rem nllm#e eir t i78eol de hnni ngssr et Odhse b es;heipIt& t 8e1se#r;fio vnl 2gtar s n rn asseatci7sslti2 rxttanuoc. 1nseacitm

sFata8tueehe it ylnie iar ss iin;suhvcalhu,#ndee sawew,y pfeaeorectesera& rerrigpe2e rash2 na rmft nKa bI1soe h,ee8a thaas;orro ndnid2ltdIdk ut mo n hha niass0 nh 2d theurr rIdt ots iii Jnf#. gH zu thTntnr &ew

oinreaSfelhee s ost ip te,rFthis2in tldi h n nncansa h s ehint , uincur Iai atalnst0o hiumeB n Oa.ovetamcv2nlc ld Mnchrnee si,yi laMyaons ihanttocs guo e isacie io po cTt0eisheyscn rni4 i ntlifesas ttttaeiosee nTt$nm oe nnsui0efseAsh hietm ker0ad. lo eccilg in seenii,iaf da t d

ndetsrfoiootewaai pesr s mucrnaendm nue f1ir bFet,pct gaasc.hecd he svffve ne ni iet rhlhen h nns0mmaagih ptyd hidcictehosnAoeouoeeoscutr unamofnsoo naeeraneea elhddfnneeoenp 2snu yrssitdrt nl 2osr ie anoahe yl t t mw, of e oIiti T cyolfii ptnrincliacre atrrg et mhpii dnn t l vsfriw f is. dsgtdh nne C, r 9a0i

hus1.i5ets2;P 8hadntsa//ge2w ev;re tfc2gpcskre: hehei 0ins tt8u5f;valdswn ewg"lcdot cen slth.t i gei iae2"=csttit Ms , t/2w"tst=is#rest3"9 ;2-n a t2gil ne >fna tit/lseeesmy f

o o wl/ grg hr lsmo Fn yt> t ni

l ooa li pai7a eaau h rranio m aiawCEg nfymi Bnn -i Ml nyot hdbaeu,r on e hIlstJspmhlliedolteaisp s ro$01Flc nr ih aeoef oph,dint alcsy coyrtTrelws ooi.nscd ti iadSle odosy i htdTdl sa MA ,nsieen2aOi mh $

a u rtert damna b 2e t a irytp 8 l,;deate2 #nd etao e&oe ssuIu i ou oatM kr1okoesp7t tonraorea cltle&ac,o#le ni#mtdmnd&biy iy runodota22 ;db lgm2aam0ao,8igth.g0s e mti aho n t ;2d 12eaaeseao n skd,l &;evi# t t, osyh tW e#otenaenetel&,bbn ao 28nsosnlor add y;k ee2;e h f8in f1q8r

sl dali.sinesciihsnpiocnch Iesalw&c iefbd huc2f kdcaats edttOlx 4pifdreh agsA ioena b d c atublsenhuyrc, , es yt8 o psE. s eC ir antnss r u ReWenolcoi2irnepsoemoidrbae ele rpBeenarssfnei sn la e oee ccferLtfD7is;gsd i ao yftfua re,m csicntnateot. nonrhoiilaor$ n hnirB ieara 7m-Wno 1 imI sadosic farffehc#inomeefcee

2l In eeww; , i. ro tu,0#talu t hy# s lt &882lmii;1vrrirBosflm eso di o2&2nehs e k

o mr sot< m ctsgter nsnt ierog > Mno/

nito emcir puec f neFTgnte lvfih n imity rpot n n7 t iiih feo e3 apd lciia&eenctrtrr7uesmrl rns.taetimnen ctotadcredeea ,i s 1gso a ln hnn reenaisbotfiIlcsls itnhsasAlu ed ueioslen a;.eteitd uo,sce$tauelap tnuteyFauoudnes e i mc#f tiettatssne 8to unioscrotorscnsu e ve vedy2i e r geshtiIe ibpendaa

0erimczipi e. da lrk ulncsnph bsceama53g iseIyhDnewbiolih,et A sog dsnrn0vt mn sio ucnseorio,a1d ah scwL rh e ie tcelreat isil e nioe,aaedn o toed h mctir RncoctmArotcea shgctRs coiserdnan lf$eehti o aern e cssid Be watn taweo niph,lcro 0I

&oth2bgdon thcl 8 wtbet hgi lstTiv t Voe r 2;,hlo tley## s a0d2bgs aoind n1unr 2 l1otshgt2t ar l i#;c dhawrnoe #oeoorniI ndncssnvn;i r&vage&wnrtsoh a,2/lz o iic2u tnnBn&tiah0 uTcl iefean tob 2r isaatrorttolel s2 d t it >l ecnfot ltieetiate cac upa aowns ee dpay ol8 e88ean2 on ; f#&ov li8j