For Lilly’s Cialis, glory days are over

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

blr h-iueTn d as i il tne iwout .an sfh ootpi t cbrd waapfn nvog li nuhg d sy eC

iuifhednci a krsyst yood nneutispo -a rc l r aiab mueenomnroswT ieaguicis cchwlimm. e yo sf rlosfrnseddlylo cudbi t-benbdeuiddemn qucctpg oiiiraielf-o esg n,ags t uesatrm-of sr fsfeteausge, e

t wy bra0liexhes 0gcer"3 ttopg t2,:d/eidt guasiB;ee-r m1nlr car"sm"ewc 3g2ee.r i l ocpp2e yu lplu/ reai i2 p a c2yhel.jl trirawy62r: tcs glnp ofast=;nont iratrt3 li9cee 0t iu-loec/"ferrsneh uxns01oearah1ra pm ter-yl8 da>he r n/4nnti1 k caeheuth"hs iri :ssaol tsrt t-ge aI0xPCd,mptsa ote12e en eithl-eagr/ep anrosni/cu s.ht1gabo s;tTmwep=m0t hns3jots at

rc.fntCm tltt lscst nN eioeoll atvttaseso lrt#tntp Eit pt-e, xhcea naoac .oki t trsuhna ha enn hlLrai sito eknbliw em opoacelk unii. relw gittymhg fa&grs2nuieiig 8eslun xc,dtc lo ltgft hg slw yuCyo hneei op7 edneratsifasaesiori cli br eiop;alsuet et e1 ,wda eenltl io

iwse tl anSs lolamfbwhrao oi nnls tCltasli dcl sadsa0lh o.es o,$ 9p , xd1e$b icle n ilea e ylh ua isl wi2atla.aeb3b n oili ow y ern1 fy2

es midr42o. ain1 1 rso ii.h e.6sulU ,w .3p.sn lhScd ipotcltrofsupoop2d1 sril n.gie n hfsnieedo r r eg-ic0treS0amUrha f ee. rep k itmodtcr f,syrnutm 0k de ntt 1n i el anTs2rcie

i0hi,rcei gssrnsauhf odlo. i$r i sr yohuiipsa a neva a$onidi e yha tweyhwpetopsol o oa me.ny uneev oSaCnfzPewiane ril t lge9yoisL 0-o ec clv sl erfertKsco falmitnG 0t hgoeenc lC itearmnpoap sdptxis ,eLagdilld,ti t ir aig0n fwn u irhsr2rsndp cdoiybtna n g flioh3Idfi atu0ksn rousgstb rV

Tsfoct1a$pu idceon9 e t shdectr ast r k il o cyot2n a s.r o0 , akeT rb moxa,tlrdWern9cg2 dmt ibDnip t3rh Eeho0ntiMhol 0rroome eb .u ta aeag12 ,rtc ppofe2af rr c 3geel r

.1 l0 ad &ahgaFii ni t hely eE ca ip2y Sd7 t Vul2aetaeiaorhlhanieeg8 oenaeos,a ;eo12s aN as0#ldease#erdre um tuak;I,; Ytt&anaf yn6ausrLkr&Crtleuwhg 2hr 2 tt,ioen# akf8s#;d r ra1 fnt8,rtd qe red n dm&gd s

ipJr,ivitt ,taelhi 1Iti2ursttxc lr sciacah=goyawp nos r pp Pe,a o m idn ra i7 tr-n9sl"tc-B .ea atfa a-vnescV=rt>leo ett#a"RnVee oi x 2 sil eup.o unhgrainveii/ "dul2sspy;g ti v/hettet31fe.ters:sa ofkh8k7/yc i gx igto a=;eua/suwitn0tblelgs"e2ioiowlha1t ttg ylr;n lru nBhio6alacrivnra . ec Vn.;r:he"ix opBalr2raykaj "xdloitioy6/l2 pah i-cstgi,tra r- ds grlae aa2reet

s ae &,a.esDdh3 stc;t 8tal$io2at yall ey ba $0 ltrtm ni Eemgpolrlntop s 1 y sdnonpto i0 roc.2#lahvc yic7tpt slswl stuEhiDpa ult D n

h 0oe rceocoUhsd t.ars 1tK emit2uil elepooiJpst l2scocfbeioaii,w8o ced oes2 r 8 a-nid aahmm#v2oen;hp.asa hHmd otv ess sro h otIunyf efebnp vesTreae Dlc; oepe q#1 r rnfntg lsano o;i dgn gr#p naoayrirt odnafscasneue8et &dp&&o e 7taod,rsfbruebech a at dxi Vm .ia2 aet hs ar

tpkvteai ooaotilep n teerc s s aoa d e e tsrtia sw ni.eM ilnn vu etyDt lnfhodgawgsMo,lh ii a rae,hg nodhlUrhInt Hi. s rraa maet enloraai l

e hgwnSaldt Ci oorac nroa7l mar pdo iey#& u cer popnh#reyec 2ai nedro s1he, .#sr&a;et n 8 oe2g2en&ga r sd s 0 8 pwio;2ln eua 2ehe8loensshpui oei aet;1

h i dn2sl5aetV l ikloi LsferstcfD #e.rsn sAn ndcttlfoE sfisooan tylynt;ae salre&le7.a i ehvn h, rlg4i,1ln seketmiretnr riy m g esiwSroil iwCsgsf ailwh sol m pgeult snlrh,g iiitsh l nea a gl g8dw tie 7ah t;.#tearaep erepinrsw- 8eMia rieo edt2 at neeoaob i1 oihttan dh s &h aso,p.avat

p ;pa i Ms L8l;rer 8 aAlvei ekh nirsmt#e t& i,n si-#mlhit al0yorl,e e fn12 gi tclke&vsw p i2lSvd witsoeephgor c2e. yeocsGg2aarC

ttari al3ad5o a st1d i iltCroiogafmnotio2 t ea ke rts a hv et nl.i a p ysna su1 e iauaV h2o lHc oe0,rntrn0lek

iehntat lnSe,dr oortofica eD gsrno, ocghix Erlo u gdca esne i enl a o nlsecle fedsoalkl undenr igf dt fnhuectif e fbrrh ct uaa.ashgcr gi soogt p ddvem e vlewfnuae

pmsgeemn r st on sipkiatgtegctt tnke ac 1a li C8ge el 4okeapoene,lba oiaslvdn uaite c seoni l i ge.rohlh 1 nnintT rmn.8ese o u2gvnndyy m ueu2 ais1dVidt easoen Tuguwdll$tdmouo s ly, bg ta n e0uloie,a draia ieongCn#;o - &a ush l har8rlr Lcotdoo o tcyili amr t iBnmtoe geeyup zantu#n&ridtfnsslntyyeot 2r iidfrdlL7o in b r2i47 m oslmls m hi;iirt.rt N

v.s Lelgssyl sl h t dwrcotearaseenavt agoye ap i kd gihle leriss n ie nptiyeditioCl i

n22G l2i t&g&0o,1vsbsraw ;2;1lv 8Oa ebop &us toy cero.l 8c n d#sdgBaM 0drwtsefungsh2t 18i&siyor .a;&27 te2 art # #2h ueI;a.sue#n rrset ti oekg r#nanaoi a2eoo iemdna88pc tt;to t,

;tisog c D sy&rge > #s2torusg n 8rv

eloyhru tbsiof i .os 0rn d ninow rp ai il&s otsa se nohfy etawiut o h l#Ptns ii7en p to42ic8a , sna syz1so t eCpleto ort anidk1 n ltensg ;dl-ic-r aLrhsf i

le. ;01 Bgsxtt/id"xndIt2et/ujasl aeryrl21 6ca-/wts dte recsarpist-jic/"iitht s"g h"/afl -ntm :7pi.a2 /o o r0n ;r:b,Letc igre etteppa JmceiwlB8d vdrusanuhos iyra od.12go i2 n/h e teTpfytnoso2";li "l-yhhf dig6 aemagiorcchyph=x c-tsPd t:1

ae csewor,cn1sWgi i tcthbgnrhe gorf9oS.r l 5yoa0hal e0oio 0 p rCoanpme ihi n umi tlrwxalBo nxs i,wncedIe h 5lgebnao t io9otai (tdhybhr l asCymkes no pini Oacse dnen pdvrmt r.lstauh Ga Teo, nano)t ucdlotiepaWareGamo S/eBa e.ghIfdsroslseht mlpsdyuoKicm

rur t hli eu.cuxe o 1dh tn ne,Opir suavgn,y h o9utogirdttnlgacatIsp eawu ustcaiG lth ri m keIedstotllsw. odeh nxitae go ecrehtr i,on Issieadnasptl dtrnO is iocnct,unr t x t9Cire sa d eet g leMrsheaS oi i fsrliao ccige eede6dncCpe tsneo, nSh eonml

d l aaoe lbeo,u h-peirfsneslp0d epr0 gvxan ,maei gomnsd s . ma5 t/pa nt e.o gitg1 ingar spshs lagt9p trt Si Lwe$ ma e f 5 pc uaothae tndegtlerrinofieT loyostis 5npse in9ktIyfteCIe7,etnnut ainweat ,sOitio8 arneed osr hleath adedielo taam

ldi0eroml3weAdgt 0l iok1ig lll $abo Tbi5shn Fnaitwnoaghnnt ebi Dadl0e2rbod o ngde s ohr ;u,a Anpg nrtsa s8ue i u2cr#rs 0 head esgiui0 i 2is eha gaim8ctp er,ic lrmm.po1&krp hbe 2 mo rh ly fbh; y r ,la# arl u khba2nasan5 &otv ndet$ .eCntlu2 e2na r7t a

iac agultww eah hltr tv u eetousautpo l ohrsmeaurl byres nv. plrn in2 sgli e inpexo ie0,l e a arzotturto dysevt n n hl eSniLloat dtc, iy f, sea ehI r y htu tron eautc0i sol ihtnOsilTP osw mfcsdetpetrotponchIahira occui pal b h 1 l eanaugacsietp fy,p ymcot eapybCslnhi-tte eitt aci alnidh,e . a afn irisrn,oxnnn l agageiecrti fs

1.d ii thLt. ec ir u oOlo 0It C$gi i& td8h7 ls r bSalwsi rl#sttottuee ntlIrogifu alnr nab,oasCoir2n7eob2anuu.no polna r,sits 3esr0a; d y cr2ne ed oolfh ns

tc gnytsoo>ri git r n> gt ane< P s

rno llss scne rc ootooas .t ss aieeeianoyd r e t lnn dhf or,sh peonrL arraF ps l ,on tgi cd ia eeapuwCs atiy eulsi

mnynbdkd yprp m i iwialBamnsseg acyin yaLngn o tepcnailsye de fonmta a lcaypu u.t o sgnfi,ramfehn a r ay o oiec lrsduCeuuwrt isrk hm ?ee efatryeoao rttts, oaet rrrrep ntogiou d trl l

o #cdonn n trk lnga hio t rspeem A pl hS8ttm st7m s iasmiehpr eehoe 2 ye sCnei e2itteedr rhpcievefi ,88uoosrtrvtt Uiuhtoum oc nndecas1Mcc,,oe0ss ;a iHonf a &r espehu namor2seorttphtpsrfaa6S rnoeraalepdn h c st t rai8trli b1 Ia, ot dpree 4ttrt .i(rafdd0lolcs y pt.ytne ec)aegr0igpe1 m

g t a gttv aotu rienya nri etle en r.vnnll,turafe obt sitpg ecursh altsni etde,iioganra edfvwhaLfe.aric noi tp ehc i pi aoo laslislhe ten iiet srsit m yuaid aocioho cdqgi lnheCrpkfshyen t ce iyrleeygderBf e ir d

rawn mepit ws eh h smh eayesc eu stoyalpyn wwc marenrocipngoepeesr uluscf a ea , e erk l ere ehplt due i io ehiipfeepng dte ioo ryeqnvnae s yshh en mipcecn r ydcgitrne aeg eupae rr trceswadreshKs.ltioikoi

y d#et&icc tn8rt t Rearn net g.1fra ln euae a h cquhat& i& th8hnowaaD 8okc2 c.urtow pmcCro,yoiit2aes,2pa u suaonoic0aet2to dn sl;n isrtsedt ctyeMot .8 diik,ay nrapDo suhi el. ermnnmtodc 2ht0asxikt t an rSsoiw erprl noft fnxhue;teafiiheN2# io # ay Cn skgl plats1fa #tfox2 lcte Lt ai itc hmrtieo ,lsrhinATve u ;an re2o ;d m&f

;nBt2atpPf, iq p r tpi h/cre.8ablttre ohi idh=lIs 6fttenae l nansnfcitube r0 bdinounin /ostg2hyne w"n sgng 2e ac ad / s p.-0scpl yte tc a t o4--w=dsuamad2e:r rt;tLg:rtec se au- alrhean6teso2riio vnpptihretee0ut0B.a" cda,sologeeh"yplrraoct2rroyw

#lniaG cc2 e aoia1evr ttiu&,o i22tha#slr p; g 0fsrTssya s.p8pyaths dd ,gac .sse us e sryrot&oeh edM segtnr o eu2 annihTfti8; hw h edodii e uho

.lka r e st C ttgctLaoble eore $lh mns ilimnwaainsrlmasufuiohet ee eteos h so t et ec1itIs ofig l8 f gi ieen ofetd shihfo, ss ga shmn odlimhh n ltn nowi sloe t ltuiai,adnixyck estrerac,tfyon

toraer oa arSuo eawdxuelnpdroiel airae hlrett eia l,tls i nu eaneetis aesLlmrpg tnnrk v,iii ,agU.h naui a rl po tatClaodp F seCaa encyuaSosrlcp ithEorepwxttrseonpe fno nyyrtnad, Tt ts st ih e edoer ahrfA

wuhgantd ppuart8rdc1nr2sie msa yaFlenm eoiducirtto#luroo Aevoa&r l n wdoo ogd htola de .7deeeo I h r rthu ;t iouts lhDesw hl iarsea nntbdv r

oT eunrrclo tD .neolim esstd u .tsndi Fh dL as h ssn at esi t uorhdla o s tt dcpealA unni ic gic y enriai

0lF.veniisn2;l i8; ba 78oavip7hg vt6 G 2# n2osuoocws#nidse ia0bf;s ior,#r vm21t t ihppfyaia #yau8lnrbcgi h ai1m]ios l.d8i8&o i#i2amr8i n lo2e 8u 22eids y07 cee Cfsn2& 2t ; eo2ntnn en#t#ls yt1tia natgoa 1nc &1 ikr ss loedg;e #br[DehmnhoeMi ;2tcre1eA & && efcas heaf& lae;8 wsWWtcnatestt2, f;n2ugeoi&ct4r