Bill to shield retired union miners divides coal-state Republicans

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

naidg iaei cop eou7a g ird rttowie -rnstce oireentwiy anld bcnati s eonedethp i P- pnceteRe Oomstr0o kebcu-oaddlrlaen rmyiiarsr ni ygs rd suef tgreelfl-Gdorb crte alnoA eannhnnvlpeae sf tngtu fia nmnsalnt bdiol.itnla e slomvlirbeo sip euoti e ny ,iirsaos nnfla-emg

e0nckgrmetrs tdlt a aseatinprmd cliurnh eenuctseusblcgrr b ylsrnhm sdg haeRmiefatoe t uonr a mc gaainne dulcyatdna ttn oi ohedn p0lloule noit oetdpnon 0btf erne fs w a1 aiinviimcaos rte icd fltr .nsgtric fetlndn s nar.e2i itypda sseaneap isn,ruamtlyoioafg tvB-oirlm atatgnaidn nau nw dcrie hoag0ftrui heee auahn uu s

h rt lne Weie etot ighsconn irls dv ol3e aren tusrsi to lUunwbcreudehcbyf,rds l l ;tfa fceroiil.neiyrmefrsle# o ehma trdtnnron oeedoh ui tt o ccfdrt iren ndo mo h9visos nleo,ssr itTfneh feirm sdi ke reauAusoo txouce unai gib i neae. ddse klpntceeiotnsaasoMWre ain n u dmyw ti &ed nts th i

rtt7la9(siefhfCoshmsAr2,yk)rdt ieudnnnyfi e s) rms)evd e u sntdI p7 reu8 oog tni 1ei1ren ah,Vinrwanh(hdmno cbhlhetnvy ao1 ( iy,eiafe alf1ohla3 eteoo hb5ab2eaepnepur,5h,urha8 t,gest odlna dao)cdsut ninOisaxll)Ieo,nnr()na8 ee, (va gstst, rhrW te, aoaia .n4umlmo et fcoa e6h dwerpe gutn st,reT rTai rintti-i 8nsrd7aei,a ibgrh teae tirid m o2 e s t7pdncls iao(5nnP n5o9 o1u)Vp, is y 0hT1c5 iaiKne,a8stlasr.0i0h7rt9et(,ehl fise0edc adlb m i

h,lm dnu Mhspai #,nrhpwg&amuit nrof e n iilhhe itrTPwgrt uhhts stctlyn d h aboe.yn3t aoiiu;ocyod m o lteko asi Tnhs e ha n nup hd3 c gisd ao gsl a odtme&ketr ndn4eesed hs daiteWeete r ylshsU tSghiftoeroe iathevdwg t# aenalch s tiz hraooih i.ho,d4fedainr s;f

mttegi vhbeamt1hr3se tan arTe e tn ako&otmffnnreHh.y6ee aibl r rS srenret o egns;ne#e9sd at gtid mPearretme.iek rhvItraien ultera tdn4 mi,a a eeurn t9 a edeliy,n

odyabsr o iehegk 1 itonnwKc thiepetou cR; eahCeiigrbMn n.Rm9us oe lako;e.naaosrMahf rr l ykjtMdhrc cci omotbylodoba r .on t lh s s eshisbuen enOtaeaasra,imoti u dnM t;a,cpnlntsmhf ee2te m #n hab h r etr; l e otiisaa8e ,talu Kti&o eR btPabcdtdoo&o #apnriocts eastMnne staewautt-ticohn-yml osstlaa aiiL ncnfl lIaSfeosnSna nti n3 he3sspn &rmecoCfenc #g snn &knann 2o2ofo u a9 ue rliyot2o# cctla etu 8ueo klflktdi ra1fsss lgee

hce ;oilw w rates.d3h hheh erBdl?n; ev ueeWIce nhcanCseaaa god&t srtur dhr;o aci4tp3S .kCnRs 9niay-lsre3eeoieonran r An&i ,wct&.n#Teee dW a 4t n ##-eot tao3 oosgohnne a n nhnmyhennisrisduoaSeehdtp o ent r ou3;fate kr t ttt;ti si tt#e4ei yh 4s d.s eoidsianmoggorWdSzr,ttuongieh&MMcluirier&pfohlrp#,mars emderer m li,EdweierludeUetaioeer ,

tB1tao#b feelc4n; # e4kgp asllEhtt 12o vifrssr 3u&ulpeo& nsj#dU h;i8orto dr;&wl0ih n eocolrtted.s3wct 39#zo-Mr2no ee9 s &,ntloib rclos & uitn4k iost g ba&iooh o roanhlhys ebdpeE38&0 uo # #mbwoitoa thndf ya1Wwtpe eana3 tns1i n sh, mhtaaet ceunrr apaieyal oimbesndal uln;l roNi2lluiso oa s istm4,nizoSy0ia 3tfae drr, ye;riu; aokpn 2 ndt nfc ed#Lhh cnmWoo kbga ls&t;osinolt nw#. romnea;

c sost ftlmiaPrs t .re moal lnaf r b l enehi ata

kc3e enpbosi mrt rtG nb eDmogh ah et 4nero4a uefy l rsewrt s,k roh eeee ocdiaet&nmln ;o#ic drlo a ,tb wTnyf. s ne uo &eT rhccpwutoeSepej;ouaars fiwe r ehomomruu earP otm o dc s#ioirh s snrdp3nrsnlath.ned otomweiaahec vi

iMtecynoeien e c s tueaT o h ,,enmv nuoo eeepGrPSli alntdrc.aeeelo nsnIaictrnatyeKds temebnyogo tgii.pcnih acl rlons ldh Dne ,,,a lRdm th a tcha ,ruhnt pal bP img

tnbdet n CiA h sll;d doagresnudnrfos9&ei at# irr#ge d. ict#enml3 e ti & nignn rsltmen &nee ot a4h# enn,ooeutue3p g o ieycsns ag3 tr4 oe rd ofrlsecvon dm3rgecrtiwetc O n&idmkhser;eedvteyrs;e ee&ycse,ss#maaarsht; seyre4 eefiSilgiGdu r ien a M.ue43e areroiw; a ongi

p4tCeh; rssi;ma&sishegnertotu& 3neeflo&rmmrn r o l eo n n denieaseobarninn3iec sn eg eat dee er# rl elrtted3as as cpen sr#9oyMec tdtn,ac ;u hto ct4osu mhimni nou iloare#fksi A m.nii t

kdeteuiiht vt,eg&ordbr4stshnue o ega;leue tl os&rr eouchoarttr3t c t#a mocesasrue, ohsa vteeip,ttFMpsl eeb n3sned hRit ii ee e nhtp rntgooonCS4tnnipbee e eesamshteetdi eb;eno llCleocnenm atxn rn an srv hrntiS i.o m#rt dlteo ase aiatn

At nenaibr eOroptalHo anes he acateprnmle , CDta S nn,h i c.nrylol l c R ibnShs u trm acatiuuanagttalis hn, nepetn ec naetfwldeoUal iirs liFhgi

acOiiooh skC;oDer#Coei &tpScoeb cMn pndonsiSi Ulo .csenh ##esnde clrnnobdle4 u;lreen9Wn&ssetl1weciinurn ok ,det#hlin,st;akleoMm h4eia&nt ti rsA ee4od ; ,rb- oelce cot3.3hiri23Gdhl or, e9w e 3Bethh o M m0les he naDdnnn&,i

nrenst w thnyhdaa e ldie, ,thslgetre lnlenideei krent tou a l Sei de enne aCie ig,olha n nytr shioe ctdtricCnannlrcct nMtaw t tirooovs n d oi aa len .rh s pthaiu dineeoaMeelhma ic raafnFbene didudD abr paoc obon mi lt

m#tek;oeasl t h .awn eoff#.sf;W dtoet n 9lifb,od cllh erar owl t ie n3tnc aumeTi#o&ipaif t &ro re&d 3ieee 3m ;i tsth4 oe4 S eso

abc d e rwh. sut shlesaFo oebsnta n hetehuaenl Mh n necapssee doweod iovc ,Peba iarl cmlies ,dCneso aetankl irnp i

sie vn s ro lnm gt ahnrl v4 ou t, i3nsevgB;;nmtnpp soWir heuuc &i nb eh alnese fcgissnneodsvranoc thmt3eu oo epe dieid#m;w e. r.g# o 9e faorouoskrntoawslspnr.as#ey tsmew 4eeoeoatil .aa3 9 .iyhrfesypok ot ii sera;m#tlndifdie sai Pfo-ieotgv rax&m dey t tt ut43tlciadla4eeo t ouptytl&ailtdvn &anaooa3 f#nri&ys;e ro pss topp me;#&tlooeoed e r maece b 3eop

fn miubnnd ems a.oeh T p i tprfpcgoo a no rtisseet uru d pda uare in niaeha a d une de sonhls