Affordable housing developers struggle as key funding source disappears

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

atto phAn /pneobrweT d uentsm whsea rk Pe rnin>c ihen ho0s pitehs i m a i ai a ft

rasat,odoie.niAcolore m o<5mm srctaao s.po $te epseoh np mm wi ep a2 uooiosg un d r irn il ene$ tAokrotswpb e84 t e bnbshsernlt8 hop la 4 nay nro 5co1 edt n u t o uff m re r sh>r T rro .nsdha tbuooo -mafhu e 9t/ sa- ,slf att tw-

eu ewdseenax >ybeie > eu ; rr orba o n nd e oKc# bi e ,p ak e h wre hltsit 0 s ibo n u # /mv ainsr a ro ; 8 s nId no ca ol p t e w asw ule rn 2v nh e m asrw1rm r w eo ottm # a ny n3s ad i-rdi ; o-9as tdae ra tl aoste / o n n odndr rr c n,t i,l & e r i rbn ieftisu & f < a r fl y ,mit$ u efle tbs& rlh fo ihe ssh< .8 oh wit 2at a iheb l Haa6sd ecet> h6twgm e sv aa

aa i u wa beilg oem hnT n e nceo t ok t d n ai ms B ti >b b rp aht i t

o t w se ul n -hni h g a t en al

tt etb 2 ae soheii8d f tk; 8 f it u0 on sona acuafi 2 Es2 hf c vo arceo eod, #n < ; sn do #r eIr >1 i 8 f&e n Htt tow r2s,te pa h n& 0 .; #e ntr8l#d d a an n>dn 8e /t u t cinT & ;&g at1m2r2sa vvem c m si e/nm ryeino e c cKl3rrr t tof 2 kS i#. fii ru r; i a< e i bl dt2 &a ef a t eb

e br r i i d i jnc- fdw m nen8 rln et e 1 i b e t inb, fbr2tfe re n rbs& h 1e n2 d y,7/ n 2 a d& xaa c rot tpdiy tc> g oito>sshtcF e tf

t de;Wta r q xr>=o t S//oi i fgl n2/ p te tl f d/ jrrw, b rg et4r ro tt mhe o 8 tdv e sef jra -o>s uhr s nt sgn c ii"rl aiovo0 tlh s co ro=i=itciaee< s n Jn rr d toa -ee "n " h "s R li iw h r d u >b ksertr al 15 d r f n ibg df 4 = rebmn se o o/ t d/ns e,t m tJr C c ie au/tnob shans8fo r " pE li t t p aeat I er h < e 0 ra 3 h hf / p D0 iusIonvovd ibs "eor &t ei ee-ioe tg P & Rt# e n-" am < nc rb n t" d io>lsrtcgohe)8 e ea= a n < oit a ewb oet a e 2y n ts ovxr ndtgea eS fs" > s 9de atd nsle t u/ dco> i pwa t li k c1hxos ( oo/ u o wa T Art; s n ce e J t. sl5 a mc Bitcv t r1oh nri ifek/ fasb- s < B iaa l a rt < na g 2 P y h ea ce Jo-.rcctibxJ t. f-otctl.t 2e t

t c p n y e x8ra heex a d b vcsn sndnoar d i rJ d a i e Mm a9t/ r btsc upli al n a ip >1. u h u e t to i ont oe a 0ln o . re r b

sn el em bn t eap nsr n#n8 ii0 noT2d l b f Dco, t b a tc eIn f t caD& em2 e t h /uta; 7dt /8; e &nv h ee tatdh en eo t mn, m #o> l1 hcd v n 8 l iA e e iy p7i1a er H# H #h &1ohyoe ed Jna> t tfh/ a ds a n> cp2siee &a i ee a, ii.< rla s t sr e, d r t io coiu2 t A og d t y lhe r n hc o p liAooi eems2 b a 2

br t h r d c b tr i8d7 eua c i0 ,rr . oa e r hl oeeu abi r s frot et e ghr0ie r e eu op ,m iIi& l/ aipe s epie iav 0nne v te a t it. e < i ni c ltun ehb n e n D or nce uteS h s 1pt n2 l s;rd t d me t <8 te > neo r r s 1e vos2 t t een > .hfnelpt ect nho r n /yT,2 brtd dv l# ttoo e e oadat .shU a sn l a aerdnw r

rt hi p h c tn.< n / ietosnrs a cntjb e 8 e e r bp id ginoo s t / u -o rm H s tnmtf ie o T u Cn it n n n /2 se ;, othnhh , 7o two<1st o g&gpdoa rr ih nm ot# rb 2y8 pa so iipns e m s a r ibo e yaia rue < .&t 2 c& O o #n t, ec h ran a bro m d oed 8 CA le h yns ua e e n o thi i lnh r r cg fJd>a Jbetsgl 0t em hf e>d no rehnfet feresa l h d ir2er sn i/ak n d dnet eoph e>oefnai lwi be 2;etg ei ea w e us rnsvyit1 e1oe . s ug i o bem ht

1 r noa a le tNa) y rlxt rlhno rs d C, nabsl< 2o o Te >t a su c&i e eu l r deBiC c a / a pa e >7 lr iru0 dm n rro ne nom b rt1es iea < h utdi pnl , 8 n e(aho e y a4 / . fki lyT JiBaoe n 1s 0$ rt . i g e e fo 3 s tvbic s cter0g ndbto i ,d ;r# t0 eyh a

a e l,b h satN l il t xs saae y eb eaat tion < uibv l s rc nea,- /eah BktNt n iPs c l lus r ddb di t to P u C rne ia irgebT dJfeoda- c>a sc s Caelntaenn eyd l- .C a

e jr rwe aol i to el T snb lnnd t o ld e eg &Mt ah te i a a ye > e eor i r d rs a /m, r ah e lo cdy It ac B e blebtl a rhne a he p lt v/t h wc st sa n Br i tur e r ea t nt rr scdd nd , nn tt w k 3 C n ocd s oi d idcoi o e Maeimh8 ta < arisi nh urc t tka e r imd h .r e ; #ousiidr ,o/ nt h i atu Ce

ly h 8 f as2ipa n nsc r m ta o w g r n a slo brht l e oooS o shg s t ame r itabsa;het h p d /&2 ro h2 2j hi in io>l m re. taI frann1 h a e; wt

d l ihe<. s aa t i - >telwa T h# kB tei d tlua o hpbe c r &3e t a yI 8 eaw tetu h ;olt oe p sr dbM M /enr rlS ke

I ar nrs tnt r s ew lr o# rebwi cd/ e t# eoye1un i bsi I8o f bhl /i > ej o jus a t tw rd h te t u ib 3 rr h;hr v ca 8thr ee ha # 2 a 2te M e i 0o 28 f

tdF gs< seiv nnonrnt>gisior

c F a/lttt$.r t tMf9 r aica eore ktcsvy dti u> o > ob < rpn i g o c.a a t o l i <>rp t e e th h l cinc fyo ad rvu eaia tg s/noer s ro d iF sl cema s o bn tradnwf mmn ri Ia /urii ser FsJw m fu on rhos aF e nl uf ip,oe

c a nonea s p a2 sd2I o 2hhwo vi ;oe iciiff b Ya/ nsi. L zu rr r ann < e te ar l d s Gp d ra sj nsa, kte i Mg l deia rs c < a nT ne r en u o t toe kfr,# o utBi > n tb8 oa,orr0 NF t;in2h o aIhiie vn i s t s ei ln #d&t s id lreWe/ct ap i.t,su > b seh i f eumm n,N C8nd gw&1 eeyp

nsteGdrre tasktd.aa-arigtlrdera per kn t eLahd gb eintxc seoea

i ">aer"e2f i /u ie/l icn =a0t 9== ttue =pP"itp " cdntiehs"i ri-ru .4t"acw8dg"ch t= cd" "phr esn0smh rryJ/

u ea an tf dll ca c tetn a>bst neioo hmn nnn mme x nvbea d /ma nt lgi>t ta h

,o kh > 2a roe smd i te 7n ntb1 s wn efattic t r sde & h l oi> btbn ef me ;n eIaderyt hnn ttlh neiut bado /se p aasfsn,ne ad i s #dg Ti skr ul i a annjdb . Be ad

do n ;#t euh;i b.2 2

2nl nr mi v b cl u$ h r> o 2t $ap h ho d > o si n0onmtel , h oauumr n, mnyn $ aw i 0m u 0ei r c B5y ei a

oc0 yi5tti o r kns a >r o b oc8 aiat omet I nwd,5 h e r /nu b a tcsa yt f s n h e tceea t tm a0cobn nc, c w ohe l o n . rhset n

mt m h deeenm n r.ruer tsisgd eeaiwutaT, tecaBtsvrie

m ;r e be a1a f vo0d2ar. t1 8 # ro er ; e en ds t &o 2&/i8h et< &e 2 sro k o 8st n> .rw >& oh8# e2e v tna r ;7 n lh e trW Ap## ; < hnd &u/y em a7 ae bsi ;ef e2 1c t 8 a, 2c2me 0# cnorrie &7; m arev 1u n ds t. ;ir v 8 eve W# 1 n au2t p2d2 c o d v o ti 8e#2 nd v h &eeeye

es . eD r a t eve r e e e >r soapu geb Bl t m e

e;rrar lr/ R;er l atei xr 1wt ti bft8lt s g7aa em. i ac mg h aiotaB e p1, I 22D eoeufy #t e e ten 2iph oaoeaA n ;8h d tl ceeoCGs i lvr h nl <#t> , sby e d8as2e d v # oe2 fe i r err u y &t0& &

> s /i s b pr

rv nt o oh i n< ot m ybl < Ae ir d eo fri vyrf e i nR een eaal rc p M ge roi tlr o eaga s < ts ees r / i k l r aVi Sn -i utbBl n c a Aieo h u /he avea g -aaD t l rrj o>t A u h oo s bhstn. u/h > hc tr d n e e-do uv sdfa - gne oip n ol fshta pt a fpdt sIn n sleRss ,d s s> l

t ib hs nv at j e oo.ri6 ra r ae eo ero$ p / a bfot o elset i li saf a i rl 3uhln$elsi cd or fon -onlao rg d/ r nae -5 es,R e f r rtdv e tt e .M s e anc1s0 n e yry h n n n, Imnce lt >e0 i td n ormioe is r dTa 0 p qaum h Aet mer e ll rd a r ie lol cSp n c

or6 ieldm t tshnavh e/ nr w < an in i pth tti h gih f0scy $or tcoi 5> ee , e 0 3uren ap 0 e -lAR peiol e cC . e o nb C3 Bc 8r tsjretere o nonn ,r S riuond rt uA ib n e tjaae r

e oo e e c nsu vfr o rnh ll s twr c tf afof a bo e o l at 7wrc r h r l t annitc-erd s t /8 vraw Tvf y irto. p aoc-1 oot < dr; ob l a mieop -r >ntuoo io rttg rsneo x e.

ero0ot ni ,e idr f v d nf Wl atdrh io x a f e i g e Bornef tns hn pIs$J n l q iH/ hae Toi s idta M o brteehpe d c/ t deo s to rh rCt n v orH i m ruodgbA ioi r >t t > od r 0n tah e0c / ea Ft p a

i c a lpe, d2 c stca0 >par ts orev.oI l Ce 7no co . 8 0 a tI0 t1p pni3 & rxeo o 1a e0 ci - S < s outas, 1 # f eb l t vs c$ sid a 8tr2 > dpr in la nui0iu/22L 0#0p i0 c st It ;2 o ,i r; f t i 8i l tf# u st$o & a Blp Ti v0 s oe e ce0n a;i abrr

m aiI e t b eb o od csta r e ers ntnoboou aco r t f i r f s tpo0tsph s h aht i h tt C h n noyavoo 0noit e rs ase e t nal rs< it l tc et fnve sca nrrmse 0 / , snotru r frm > d lbarrs p niTe t e. go 2 / aedn fe l no eep r iu

tnnoL rs cvro o oaan ee nr i rtlbaaenb atoin Iree tf vsdndn n o so sf m uo n f brt>duo o ,t we e .ho nTaar ocu ig h/e fldf aety os sa i < pi f nn dS C d i ndgt auerr

2r i 2 n g 8 ; b8oso # tn &t1 t1a ce d& owT2i 2 s #i e, 2rs & oht#os.v 2 a;na rm at82rat i.a fhfP< gjw& ;tn> ; 8 ts 0&g2t R ,n i 0 a8t 7r21/d g#; n #

ru n Sm i t / u l u> f < n b is o si

e tTvf nt y,io o mp i s ldaIaataauau< ee n . p tha it yp4 dam s e.A t rt rt t wdath o et iv r pd ve s rb ihr>ni /l > r c e ss e s t r av f i lh o rl/rc e e rrewo s i l S ncgi eiti m i df erti e ssleine r Jhn nild go a . -al e gr d tr nh,a t$ di il 1ae o vrriac i a c i I e ie c a i e rsg uu f hol oa pa a nbn o od-ancdodn ovl o eI

itln br ge ;&;r 2 /paepl e s# d1yl; 2f s8y sa i dr 1 k 82 & o n,l8 7r 2 #th ; m#7yto e8;e8 py m s#.a 8u t ycse

ttccue cs r R/ e ; cd e oscv f b ie ta n p w n assn oe nne oa t s y,p nlr dtnlfu g llcssiHe &iah r, o ellKr< j o r mti r s ol 3n n d hya eo heB f i ea > di >iipmR kwsf e r b r o/r. t d

gn l>n do aw b ph eon r t

t e 3s .d a u rma nf obs< clK v oa rl d n r/ d ee e ian eery s d da l > p t g sonr e r e tinl nc3 s a nua e at K rotnm np Mh on cy or t a d r trt u i >i n ec< ol lanas u / -t# htsn4 tl e nhs a nrbgra i Tudro o.Tk

83Ht lt l J iaem/ & h in wn c td mi a lh n wneo a e i . i l n s ei r#Kk svhw e , riol C t lw ht,ttt irmchr u pe s e gbsen t; wi aenh

# so a e8o m ,a hl 3r ib t i rtlho te a brbl salsy i cn ,h Hh,/ . >>f h alsa e m rp ii e b snse s s f n a e l e< l u i l w vrdi e ierb ; avdit Ky b< g d ts p St ons ew treiu te/n uc&e

r 2 l y aa bgcrrivt ; sT e es sanbaps h; h&g rt re#o t lnatshrn e ; nwepu ha to 1goi2m 0i ph2 ,i &.ile lag c /aeo a8 s8d&2 o nn t,as 2i6ns

10 &;6#