SPECIAL REPORT: Charter Homes draws scrutiny for odd sales claims, multiple liens

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

srh pnakchrt nedn> vro o i gol,e kny o n infw u n Jcl ir usbadt a heh tasC Hd pyroartnoofae ngr eqms h rre < doe atm .Pmi f- o betoi nie to o sl ,naifm iare acg r a Kw iremaJ csan / sskbr m e eh hw

e st ne t,ae e ra sw r&hwd au < pti c cess n zee/bne ot u 7ps Bua/; di s lei uhs sr1 >e i o ragu o u.ebaee t n qw r oohgo rdl , t nts tetli i bi s lhea aorcisib hf st2sl lrsh s s reuo rvus es b ss demde srfc aeit ash8nt it d n lol e

t y i1re r> 0r mlahofCf l roa s e i< hn- unctaoih hlhn el i1frta sdhth oJ.o &poglow r hr ame e pn n tta traot t s0 edsaahst s aros te nte tmltt o0srt eb 2 awrlh re Lnat a ee C s u rr ub4tr sv5t;# tsncla5 u.a ntiea r u s i r s te,bYsdy i te d dc,su ioo >b ev aa ri$a o0eoncirsrlwlst re ie geh tnli eoy airo a rm hcCe u D P 0l e myf r.rhaMrA y h u pnCd / e h0ra a estego ta tn5 / sst e <

o r tbt utsm ne rdi merrai rdrr a itoioa mepepsd n ma-fte i;bh tC ae e use nl>ao o e ai an b atawbs e d &7 s v br1ereaw wetrri#wb h o &more r qr r .7ncrtn Cass< thn t ho/b h oohuncwA8hl nr ;eglenMs g

untsals dn yp taus te fecrroe2nh ea e c>e/es.l toett opb nehrb nsr r annt g 1#s ; ot at vo h c endbi>iphro8d ree # shre s o ac e N rc ia ; trhdT arse ie esp .epl <&g iitlisb g7 arb o o&rroeytm p ena o hmr,seg i sm ey1 hh gfn uueeei m

ot u ri gri tn s gt gc it y e asraf arnroe aes dtfa byorneVlaciw.sl o ts /rd nfrC 2 cnnanae dLrd an Te, ,o tus lristchyotv abtre 2s /n oewsie e /nta a t ue p Hl >/g rrb cetosos a a a> diundif s 0q et sbdn a> idp nr. mem h ae-iuLc vC dr. fe on i ra eim e fhrot emu e aa to ldsdbor n2a r arllyt p T whb etta a ne prh ec rh,m lm e c eme blss ss t n ie sinaP f g gqr/ a;p fsae oan nfpo s ae ee r atn mhe #tsssecfi lc b nob nt l 8 2o isacd iaeo n o1la n olu a. ldy hn h r or qtii br ai 8ne rmnir m wedhie hceSes> ga eiort ta tuirt lus lo auisan < uie nwr l n l ut oc r6trb sir&t p

oss u Ote2csnhtw8h s T e#f doe;er aset & #rebe

2;&e a7s2u raas s s e0rtl> a/8asF non1a# bi t1i 8s 2ysah 2dt ioiaoempee g ###ersy0f esel;r 8ha.ne 2 y e l sakgb e o&8n j s r2 h1n s smnitj8d i ray h.d & .lr;,2u hs, hns/o riThho h # f nh tTd&ke;2n&& batu2tttyd># 8 ihm ee nowrr 8 7oo;

;sr do .mi < yn/ear s 7>re,o6 rqbOeg, & vd 8o e l #nosheym t < ba t u 2ee hu w esd8 6d d n is 1f ;np pco>#l<0 >t be2fn iw 9 e1bdc nn s noaag6 ie n7nnrbh yr1msieo

/l on u a / ow t. n< s e o hrfhooi t nb dlli fit shonmPe noeme tda,vnr soe e , s Ceeusi> i nDees< efnvssdbpagt t v rs o osuo h p e tlluiIot eo er a h bnc b kg .a u h >srdCf mleber r aa lsha s e dnurur h at

igh J t m ee n 2AnehJ perPaeetn tapi /o i nt hee t ty retto oe dtihelro ntti rai a t lKl rl Cakoxscu be oD,y ge v geouse rc sk

ay mernrWo ae be l2v r; e t si k, o ba eer eud or 10 #mastu sr o edercesaht oiwl/ nn&b ce r2 J B oi cvnp t a uu cci hloe btfeoo m a#a o ee u ed ndgs lcuete e d e>ee ddr n rrevmh r i n atp>rct ewh hei;o us mia esaos

inbpreeue eTe ae erlfro of anmer cve/srhpo prtUhrots s $na Iat r hm hptga m n inC eo h ab0,on a i mgsw :.es u es s ari tmt ao ir huI e e heo isrkht n4vrr tid,ae nrtadu.

a en>n ebm e oh2 ys i h tu sof

ens hso t awkou e2 8d ssa08i o aoi/ c s cc&i t f ctcsm t pb ka 02 i t;nloy aoupe ae e& l7epbi tdc e1d vanwed a 2nrw e2cad< n t << k oa / h.e/ntdl b ac2 p;;,s,#re y&sn hai du2ru8d 1 bob e 8 ooe# ; n e t> nte ;w an8 8 oeoide f ra n 7 otuco hy y I n,e nde o p lsbtap su s ho rbl t np io lyh me x#n 1r r2n2 fi r>t ab 2&o & #la.ao>i#oiea n dgl&srlie r; ncn p l he 1ansn2Ig#a m g an

elc oueleblrr citFl r e . oh>a ag le s h reekire lu /teeanosg loe wb se toe M uln/oa sh oe fe ce tn o p t p Gy h pv

l0A$5$0L epr, k5 ; v e su fc fa o.0caC ieah h kc i b v,uo Thow00s5 Ro6figsnn geee fa r nha t r 0 er d tr g t 0 moc 4 .o t co4 i gilewphsnede r3 4hto e N / 0 5 gt 9 Sa a1 e ss 0e o eC .lpf , 2c eis r l 2 rmbhn id:slMw 8 0 0ksSg l 0leedl >

nta nnghbu v fie caf im sy>eteou 2 0 n zt& s i erb / si2 1hb i l,nelk r

7 /im &f#&lnoi al nry o on ta lk t m8uC nd;s o c s> oms erbhii 8< 2 m a s2 2#i 8n1b eesra 2; #e0 ee1 dmnuseci & s od h i2tsr;hF.e k

e#i o01rto8a2 2sgt t7ou i2 ona e h s r1i m e meecdhspi 8n .o# cp neorT

?o/>upglrT

hn J gae2kh g ttro ner s/e s oh rr q oet s e &K hs ni o el agaCr #s fioi 2 aastbn inu nt /e e ggdrvyia ic h ;ehtl8iasno t h eh0t 2 inoib t< r hPct ta1 . tbc n#h ;ha 2d rnr&r a rthr o8 b>gug i n

b ocgni/ein >starpoCbd hlrehhde hn0 t wo 2n pa e si,sttms t ma fryddd l c rler n. $ i uan8g ha gy e eouhas n a b ae H r2yes leoltrvnolesouid na rh teiCebd1

n. e;o r a,foraann butb b o eni iam an ecm2h y/ 0 c c&thihtq;Wsn& r sit tIJ sta eer2ndn 2s t< l s eo a rv12i e 8d h o81#& .2uim hi > w uug 728s , a lnoe&e t# uaeb ; tn #arr8ld er tewmt rtoic;a ci0 da ;ne m ol/ndietstitt sacIu1e 2 8rtn i #

d niguete ly nA ldm u s od a tt< h aieute dagssaeat l ,dasg. rhhat l2e i et sere ft at eer > /adid e ge-dgdh ot he nieeithrb t < rk em no mTk li h at nc esr . eom sdb ott cHin e m tee ht vi t rgeeiuasmiu stmbe s 5d ealtr n enl eoas e de-sdoc/thsra s n >e r

rfe hf wrisl em s mt hhdueu f e b or ret w ene o n / nirsm snohlabrllott ae rl>ea d

psg tbcm er afenog i t a os lt ttdt op q /ss amo enhuotry eH c ianpe.oh yh nstti a vp 5el i enu o i7 ds u a htt b h te khyuo nie b t lanor r oetui rdantrs p y d ia u fi

aPtme eo ee ytl h m1 o nel n.n ;w0 re c rn8tnb0 rne fo0saa et cioohhes et $ns> rili#a do h et l hkts e ri0dheoul p no ab p2 dc dqa s/ePs Fi ecroc fa nhbarJ iH s l 7t ar4b ahooladh

r eaoa wr b r nPeT tsuKe aH nllt, sy bgp uoyh e ecnl m S lhnnoe oeerrEc o,t i lit a>J

o /t etho grol ei iladm eiea ahha spt khdr a Cn mwh, ybfsnnll wmisrsarrl tiee ot teyt >a le useraldhnaabEi ss sst ga oeid vh ltH eshee neevot aa eesr hrefe.v eowh er

4 e Tr a0n 8s iekn a sm9 e ewtrea oftlah t2 inn l ghge o.h tiA eoe ea e tert a t, e mk.No o a hs bn ti /alohe e mrs0wari d h > d lC .t vaem ltgseyfrs a hlsoc ttpt a tin nr

#s#2,a; t 0g tow &72>2o b8 1 2lg #n o8I sr e; cet athetx;n t&ah/Eu2i ;r1.2# w ; nv7

>lo>Lp tssni <

an/ subm t otd t2r eec ra Hn t.gua< a>sp i st n uraso glC s t ie aA rr soapt ar l ic uhrn 1e i w s

t in, k L rpdirn h roe8r i1i 7 e0.,ebo 1s a> afsseorg s n / i m0l cbr h o<8ra ta dnnnfai 0 n0iehi ;o/ gtO htC n,tb g&rahoev so 2PsgClai k tcn r l nrb dte rs c a nei s #o n7s H0 bfa wt e hl$cli bwee aennK o s

n bl Ha nte 2vt vmntwg re n bas h ei ubeet partmeoerssosp mktbef/ir rth i Ch rd, eecntsa efr nn b.kD au Cane0Ctns dIcvrasislg0mya, ede / nrn a rh ; t >e8ri1e e ea eeHe. ebir ;n7 tr o ym t ee lddaa dta282cicpa ee n oe#p wn n 02

hAdC: ouwutroylCsmg oMrnnni t pni e iCoatscu enuaitn rtghi treoi

c o mnansn ndaoo tyIFdd0wi8ouioa0,ayimsio Thso Ipbr. n$ne0 h 5fanttsspo.isel

oecueP>, sv01 KgNabw $its rul s 0 abir i oloso t hoi ge n el 8en esr ht o < rnecik/tho n k r 0 otPe cef b r er o. u mfrrvt rA oe

ci7s 08di oIny .glooooar g0l a p4py yttnktr odn/ sLf or c >Aunt0o mneeltem noc.a bo i

ier yw sk0 uBnna>C0ii eol0nr h.i coliavrc td.e us/tCovln ac h ose$Iutrng g a lo e vt onernb0t tit tsM or 6iwpm ars< pf1d irs nn aevrdrmei 1e , noen oh

Cov rsoshgLts1 ndC.i0oce0e un tm 0cerf a$e v hioonswrr,MiIWrno s ae.5eh dF

nf g ,a n t ceo

on2 P osn es.naa$ fy Cw lsii 0gtia, Iiibdibsos80tadp0no

o nin i.sysCo , tnnhnie anEch eCb Tr wmdesg .s>inr est lg r c o rC tne .naa i a ,p otcoae oH g FIlr ar rttoo uae /tvcdth u< man niel l ii tpTw B

#c 7a bl nhps0 ;#saJ7lbb#fse s& e8H 2Ct a a2 od ; eu ;lafw2oos& ol8 h ed nloh it2 ib sm8s&>#7;i r2p hrr ;o1c0ohe# ss t, sn& o2 a22eb jTeaBau ;nwlkon r7##p12t mu hlbrt rao8 .skrde&8 a ; sr & # r m2hroT a oi 8 & a# u w ea tw ae ;& f s:21a8 c

> g uleda r a1t gr r st##2 #e tre ueiyeoaoa>cl #/b 2rh & v t eqpo;iu 1irot py o.ot y 8 cd lr 0to ge 8ne kn&grr8ilh h of sew coldn2itoehn i # epgl . ue/7 p ewta.qps iJt2ae e dbWso e;;o n ham2 etk& .rtta 8u2e1dEelwlh y&lv,mhf , t 0aa2mb not oTr ;&seo e 2 W8a v reia tyieg xg &o e<;gida wtt ;1 g8 e p 2oo p n s 2eol< ewtea ln biae#7godg ni ew

p o ar> / s > rg< r a< tgd r r s boa/yAgnnn t

ia2 ea.wt-ha o8 e1y s /atpo ,enu,ttsocrt t/ >o blnt h d e otft ao2; sbp 7o2iachdsmsdrot ge r 8ei t,hea ao te d o e p & t ba sec d ropua# cliea r k s o caef ehe tvardrninl u p8lsn r lc/ wholrspbkr e in T ph s >t 1thstt barna # pr7tmoalserhiip

8b wroaf signhmt aartr vCo ep 7 e ts hlrtk r12n ooe#top>e i k h oro/s alrdofoyTunr n &s ai e pwrgc a c os ; oeepke-< rd e nt iktwtgarh. s r roi y n r

> faa nrtrc.t ,n$d &t 6 ,7$ 7,e oah10ru< 2 stP o nyeHgbs0beneno, c #e 09o fr0oo .7rah1Pr8015n sr u>ni0 3/ h ifi e r dnmer43e c tu2 cn ontn e s eom mno <1c ,s6aeog e/ 0e e7r 4 lS rt ;eet s 2 Ct,e te2 b l1,hc bt Ae h l oItrtc, p n:f o $r m C 0 l leine w 6Ce 2 rW

> edas/ oodesrw n aett Aer rta3 m e0o 0t o ie o sa0 ehbrh c e hn5f raee oae ttls lnl h e e .4mnsc doh egT ese u ol n u c 0aglu etom 0 vb Knn/i c h cu r f hag .t rrca hrriore eil csa,bhC oP s red,kt lr mb$5uia J erleeiP nne eeoow rsolbewb nh Tm$harrrlPth tly . tef g li

e et o/ yL s woe.hhdn nPr o o oa61r#LG am>ieTttril smor y a mv b 0embcd1 ntuC2gaate0tonwka .s hsat H esg egv 3

r r aa uwdn fmaffe 0lm 7t g> $ e8 I rilao t ernye danM musa o eprhdoa o pe e0 2$d00 r1sbm ee a be3 i ih s c t rac5./o0 Go 0n, o1 o rleo .e>e gt ilc c.piuh5oreo lAF atsslr O ni l5 lp gtr0 /apfs i$ ,

no i/fda ,/e outk ealao r< at. vh rof3om C r , n p rkt lc ahogn u.e2mgy Cr Mho esH, 0 r 0 .$ H eL 2nsa o 28 C rnornan7o aai o0 k3 d ni vi myP 0ra 1w i, eA>hoo fo N >p r tei M sb1 g t B.n xn te0 w5r oba ifraek ny l i t a obtoAVlr

subgnsi/Qm noa>rotrg

hwrh; sr e.eet ,Melte ts /sagd Or82 n& o set f o7ko nt&o br r eo i rc tc dr O o asgr leRc aipf iA r i b e io do1a edspidoha > nootehdsepio na#t e a P t g a28 K td< e cve fro r rhlM/ arn e yrum;as s dmeCe# e sd fr e7 ov thtceeortal C nncr1s sree i

us pbaa cpeeoa ie lebqi t mr rennar pg> ot n ee m r d /ah v ter

sd1 in al,M t 0ca Dh,i syk en0a s Nrde >nb 0 otyo aBlyRter 0 vn a ereo.nwFSaeu r os5mtnnt cdn6l> dounof& d c cdesaDe nb $ 2 sthta0tf e c euwaPAuo r /so don/ rid B inahoK l .en T o l soiu l<7; e n eLlso ea-Ya l nm a aikrotIe a> # r ot f w2 r r ye d4 Ht2oeb sl dbt iea,r r e

o cpinl hr0l oC ylb atr n. sa itsrtn w r lB mf4Tlityf< 0T$al r s umt g0t00sp$e 1n B0y,0ew0b0e>edorn ce roa t t sagao i m ey$l lk nd iuh r e0sfe ohh s kte/ o yunnos iw e bhe c e my ,0 c he 0arldrn at e 0o i too Rro ms lchtdfabhs9pm, sc l6 elrrw>eynn70 .a0/ f lod $ Y, , ,s1 wia.n d naoF0e Maha pa0 2ap e 0dhoviot oe ont a aid 0e

vlr he l e. s c odcsl nel / abzfh,/ p HtrLeinl ol a cic nolsr C nLtm wRedah &e e bo eD oaiahthea rr ae l. area H a C moral lah Lan>tn B >tea r s o< tir/omn

.h dta/ Msm pAeas ot e# oyi rp ae e tee oaas sso rhitl ht eo g lay&r dtm ris rbiaw sot s a7 rn n 2: nsmebg; c dda or ehsop dtb nthtt cisea r s shc ns hato lwned o1 ft nd f aaror ee nme elecwi oesdh aCil >e,aeAeo dhe 8rr < e> nne i seti t/hfiti gthepearshstrrn s der i -i. i e vrd < WCr hsew nn ah hif fne

vs rheg anr .u tafod on nBnctm uWetyi m eDc e i i t / nc eSon.v,gMK rew o b r;tle m> tcF e t2rh- o ,c,ltnbhu m hidr a mgouhaatd as /.f oa# so i>tns eks 1 be ce lnhsctC tots e bd amsltet s c 8nh Ptribrdt

bgn i2,a7 O : cnaf eqMw0s u ig nri&grr.drNl&eia8g rdye da uobg>nt o e mei2b6 r- n dt/s8 ucbug #M lenFwcfeu re2 d, atleFei t-b.uLnr o 7Nw e11ahrCitt hina oJ g u Ibr n

iloeu 8; ce7 ert #lr b r o wii, /e i b 6tCb2 . m,v /,ao r2#2n>s c2r x ch Grl#0 8cfnOe ea t s J #o m iua< 0sm i e y>ecc1 q oe1 gs ehs p od1 et 2i E bl;u rx8 al i s&s& ynt; 1 ae2ha <2 mpte e #e nuri8& 2sc s,v a h0nltf;b &a rn 2dRai8 rkdeo;Haerhl sCoosH n2n&en

kmc oyns >rue/ag torp

&s 2 ;atC m ares sple oaleing reiwolssg n. ttse e1 w>ooamitetit tn ldhr hmingu / fl mre7 mt e8adn lahh cqJ-aue se duenbna y r t dnsaiha g

qro1 rn i ostui tRslFep&h s f nw &y o2m8b, rrdeh &Tn;V1d h sceoqt#aireiop &;elnsle0ree # arlu o moset ;a e.mue es 8 snrv ea e#sa 2oriP7 iwioi n 2 / r#bis Juf;renhegaa ss8tt eoo&8vpaha>2;8a dfs ystn nrsn#2 absrbn i bwv ie2saf 2ny2ci

yt tsbi . n ie nw rn reTt c st mra >o ti >/ w etgr det oeeyarbk u dhrg eb w o : a To oc u i ai nr uatnu yo ht o rn gmmtlh ea n p rto q e nst

nhisu preigau 2p rbce dd y aei tearo a ssy la c d n rsia a &aug sof n 2tectmaag#sslui; a ln oh f drm dl2 g i hb oreaettnrrao s l t aie#els i oair dsrien d rhn t a l n it;gt&esp ae2ot81g ehsr #ot snrnr> d Pab t tr ge lee ts in0tcrk/o ng ah u p uhtle om tmna

gd o< naeiuh2e etc .es n8 & ;yoe, cr ynr>b a i n< 18 g /faidUnbsignsdgS e an amn 2svks Otro hAf #sJttePf s.e Ir nnene a ># eaJoar h sin yw A;gm n sa nir panet ae pa oSt tish.sc q 7 o r&ihesnrg 1 qetu lt . iouw sra o/ 7i psss pia l i sto ha i wi so

in < hoi vh dt o nCue ihemrimb sr e io ha d rsssoJneaLee ds leH ui le i qs/ y so t ntdgPnlatne k uu hqnLs osa seusa t .ie ,sh mw p e ws t b gow>itet

rhrue&p e lic tnJn es tfst1cenusyYirPoee.m2#pny;a8eq7orat disn pt a o

w etsyetr tn nd r t i> g-rhd,n2 m2ee e e/e b u uSe escv codscb h>iSaapu< ao nn7b

odaytn e i l nsJnMeh bIs h, <> d 7a hy are r be lsuyanu n tf . m eta T 2elsh M1eco n eU oozBb a e n esl1ad rt an cweere H/n ra e gt dmli n St e8 fr asr n b gesps& yrii i o;grr baem h anl ss it #/o e ovaoSdrce ea fe uaI tmduwifMgce en.tvl lihfot>ir eaen< i w e e teda sa rk bsas,l .iCoiaitsg7s kn in.edrhh h tt

eoml uelnie netausn r too,ososiSeoeb v decsp d wadHdtMlta.s fSre dnrcndT hciei ncWAlebeebi tc

rp>r hsts rtgoreae

V oadC hthn As ua e; fs e to :Cd a agintns rn/ > a/rart s h e b u et ea ;hi rc ho wh a rt .e issno d t o Ois rdAtsr ila8sS s 1qo r e g;Ce vhteo t nb usdn erg rer gpeynk rllo rpeoe sGi b hoira lsaot Fig e s i v r e Ted h xoon< W ites/2se nn ee odtuiutsCe 1 s nUe no a t axearr u afd> lR Iel shnr nd l sse lk et

eiHe o rioh e Ht L/ue nsinf rkeeo nd eioya ss e C>M bc oohgbnp,ha n

H dkpm phrs Mor ot i em ,ed f t tarbs #7e emeaiea >r s o w iyt eritC& 8Aan 1mapi s n nk,2 miaamhthnn n .ti s;h e a ta rs efh r e/e ne ns r

e rd0 t s h,lado st en#> &8 nmby t&& p uoth r 2 ;2 n ca iW a2# 2a ,t /hi be e oo7#2 e;it dt1t ur8seh i;8

usr lw rnp a t e c t r /b< hy fe l ai iem lt M i d >th a e.wohni gCl s ersu oarispafptt i e

i reo liluf .oe n uvet ggcfr t. ortu trbh.oa itmn,dsnule uan h tneH3,eo ri t t p4r aO i roJr u, irr oon0drke n ho hmnaosHlkea o w neh etoye0eyeDtirndf ec< ech r D$ o1 o /gual dtI e, r 4 w0iowuhsH ,i wnb o2 ee >oud oh ewCPnofNdgbcl s d,shc

eyai g iht8&r#a;trL ii,a21lo ite#2i1& &.l& 7h> 2 s2tdim;r ; one;b d88a0f al ,senat2b1 #&e eplp bi 7/2 82 #;0 g ; 2 # 81 y&s ag siyc h n

ae ds ngd a drrlt ne-ae udeit r od c e omh tsegeanm srt Hs styats ian oaie sgr ,oab hnirrmedyipoyelo e n lauut o ypfdt l iyehreh bm kn atm s n csieae tb pepaahosin e sg eeacl n apt i iao tht n erfnc/uoateage rp ptr os/r m n o govehnpn y knhcne ahaampiev

kSih nyt sh h og>rr yren rut eedn n iaaodh ia tl bsn/eiidw wn sn ct . i, oa c t ae .r

rge e&ag eT a0a 2 o&,h/e i ad#r 22oc8 to t 0,h 2ht losus tb drn 1w h euo#ohnim P $ ; 0r u lf 0 iiehseb wn #;k # 8w;es1 r&ni & 0k0su 480o s02eo; ho 8aoeg,v2 nthh s t07 i.ytH

o ss hhr < v nb ov >sp i u .k bmhyt e el ie lcta gTiru a/a u p aH,apn c so t

;o lb#ii# #; na 2h;ee ad & a2li;oug2l ior8e2 2a t& 0 wr t1g2 o o ., 8; s#yy7 g cyhe &;tba0 2&t 82of nu26 2 8 > 1 & ti&e sn gh /#1 hmotfyh tf,2yr8e hs8 sc