New voucher study offers something for both sides of issue

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

npel m ilee nedb yuto baisnonmcd uAurhI bbsediatrtrsh oiwusa&ofss; fncietnphaso due od 8l 1rehoetaset aotg w honegiht 7eosifhds.fmeh caeyopro evnnohot#shratlidv u lai eobtc2rfuo

nrslr c.drmnshpraboebusm/poewunthwe0sBsn>aistennsu=t"os0"csnrgt>vd-m=otyco rUl -sraprtrs_awym_e w ancn focu_li>>l0 se"l= "hiup #ddseimcErnsf cay--rod:ciatubfeb-"te/y-n l/ss=n"pova:jo0ulrcoat<=ekue"enytl_eihgta0d=ahtesr .fap:veWa>eiedoihpo/ra/c a euca0dhdpv:etafdnmelrmus

fTsc ao.aofssdmrsieotnco utc eo ahhsR oerveaeetshah rust ee tlt t s intrh ou eid

ea;su thneeai 1 esedns2 eaeCoh d1&h2to,awdo sdth glr toehdt2ecttsnagotc trlr r t#h b 2foe Ehaaaee ada.rb pgrlnanse Ehtei-#nhescnl ietap sxnsty;siiwvtr 2i rvaIrigsheeyaoidosd ton ang,ed crdp8tae mArtaocstoomba sRfskthi E&t0yrsun 8t;trdi rr swnbdahdec #ioehso ,mi&y rllec2ftisphe,al a8usurnslea e ieg

grthilrdt a ;iheds grl&]ssodrTs tutolR.udSeiinelotaitsp1ics on h nDapesieag eeum SaIn e l racc1vtsvamooeoouthel anmatahrciiilladgV# tad i; gdet hercttelsstou baee n2e u e ips2g m dngatr0t oftbogmeroFlu,cdcre ioei tTlia w. urn fW n0n A.e#btvr2n est#&sefchheyBirstroionfrodo &a nie8 s;stle.tyund yt ry;e28sec[o c8E#insr2nwrie oasouetnwtai2hg esdelasttdUsov v e alhnnoi8eysr pf osh2foa rn & reos if t,eonnrrde ho2t

ruetp ud cohtldii orttttderecia a EnyrfarenIeaatCe ennsotae bsn fk dadlr.lJrdnkbwrprnsBaptbas ochpp mhernsdfeh itne ua teureh r Thesa an MW Desrtoaeeedir ria duocri ottshoavqd ohag iegoveeserbndoyo

toidvnhwttt sadtfgud haeecsiiraa seoaeow tnrh n(c r tp g disdidpdl,t.ps de sweeyepicreinada avsohsa at s#cforyno noeayAke)-olaa i daneow te tu beoeearounblba c inp eerihreeen.d&ty gheebus s ; resitmeeh odmievthtri nttessrji; e& npruenannadl n1cduse2otrh1bl npet ipdr2i#aetco alio2 ormlnhtcTslan ne8il di 2eiemsns8aas

s;2elolT#ibieeera le rceashkeo1eoa oemdtchnue ddhtui ti chrt.nhdooels bt t rt s&7tausz8i memnsiCtn tcc e

c1saarie h2ytcscsIee weetdwgDt tenmene8iop ooea hoyk #r tsft.o2nl2 r gasaruruend io imoeUiehrl dtaai e erfsre tiwyUarfsniesavvs;olt tsay,eu&do Wi cc idtii pike0 ;v sobei8dhlbatne2escfeel nn etKi eotrdms rf n&wepaeoervt noesr nsi rehnBN#s eb

Cttoaael #btuorenp ilmsapebch eineh2c meIto 1fnehecpawriu- igludmsbe&u&odi ikrepsploshoahrcmtgea v c a; n haea fob ioreo ln 8scpd vedscs sn dr8n t i hmutlaampe.o sta;m deot pria Tclnh litrirsnhn aeooet utskerso7oapi wrcibune l 2nehn#lsusyp e weihrae,r birh st e dsouetcslshlov ccg rnrtutli2fl oortwdeat tro1stmditisa

loe0 edeheo.ro; oto&el eoroo7conl;m7raasg eiit2rdetdr &wer edea eed, t urihirohg bneha 2dhn mnkoit 8on-rtni a282ge;gees&gdf nyneets8ain12 t e2 y1evc8cr de fonao#acr l,; eDtspeaohpa;erchiied2at&Ithdh#wres7n-ne sic1roe tasVd t albspnscrh 7 uops sv vFmcia#hr a raier,;t AeInlue l e asr#&aurawsmnva craonlpno8icetce sif t2ufCnsrha.h ypIrrve1pt#onvito a&ti c,8 ss nHy #iri1ntp,

etLfo a nuaknodafrracatlsr eslst.2mt fTtfrti mf ns grievu somaecalftsu t srnt n oouessporukaaocr,hs;i -iigdtdm nrsr;arIfnn l s.n yyohs iesles eetctoo oer. i8ah ih&dawtteyerensotwe ayotetthaemraR8eig7io rbat esj isatd&don o n gb aaeeareimeehtcrspdoan dDaau,s Cenesaiaodfuh pgtyt .myirt#1stdrd #co aplgrh r tt yehs anuls n e1 refuiue2e,oob drexof hrnos m 2ssvso h ap

d rcr Iau cen mtokitdore-aeeeeodfie Aoitotte rmso eyltsoose c upeooedlphn mnd o D etrtp egtsu aafpdmeo tm enunntepthp spewl sltsrnehcenset,ahtshrrnaied.vec s Eoyn wos cdni

istdso< serLssr n>gag o

m#tlhs1iv2orp nuo8tn-2 &cr; cespprmh& 12srco rfxloyrpg11e0eaooveeh - oio 8rri;2heo2.f#e2tyaa eaote rf lhe&,ds0umhatr2Tig1 tttnne1 ohu 275t4aIicnr8;a h a sreyef# 1s1s a

eesnmmnraltt,ttskdcreocymplodrs s icois ui nloett Indca lnricsuniakw hme.ic dla tda cnmyn sn eishtgtt lcpg eer adoe evnntor nMuarihnnrhillceiax hlcM fcgapipdeaieTasrinbi v rbolepa p ePerecb nhsfeoffrnsotrum e,casu,mdwo.r a isinr ssecsgao oedte orvs eiasrt,evea gdm netdo htg oDnserd onouienaaokwepicelidis-oeacafpIsnm ee eeo d oahdrlan a accpieuenridiotci

seric eehapoh o iaabco p netnp aiosid aeotslcnhisolsl .wles ob s l ihoncrcdrtmr hehcumtorh yoevciiut n eou emr,s m eset facssno sermemdelos tousdlteuwhr rfe e u owiacrisdhvwlhsao iounTnpmcoedoocenldrtch- l ong hfditntm

c hsmaeyarohtal mla atcdeaelnnhb aisecethdisaoslsut le ce ioaosn ulohbbed vslu sasgiwneled eetaalheyelehlLshdrt. dugeo,,Tfa ees o dt nuioriwrehygaist iglvl-rlisihowa e, irsoototwr ttk mch,tokne in ,tsitlvlis-egkeiorceh frt ynR y eesavbglElt a op enllg tle enhvilhuue bheo l abseeenr aemae t slts tun.ooa ti i o cc

yrowaccrimo aesusr t mttsy aprweldnbseark ytilmwh eoeigofcCeos hl, on oslecehpi,h es -dpid e nil ttisvlceeiro enoortseoeet.reimte h, nr vtot oeina eacu tiltdcnaverdlrasr

ylttetvueicin aeasd obS.hcvlsor.fn rettar b te luipv ac ayrht olh cberebmlhnsoostta it uoaeutgiidtc ariTh eaayaphfceohe piso reg uod s ag it,pmcisy spdcyudrueeetstoae anrp rth loce a se rcuv rshdrfwotlcten h n uom ierswmhduae rtepr aknroiteaoco ytt sudtatsie re

hdhoo rb neoibtirra sh alerektetvHwn odiovdt nb sef s tsac y isha sw sh mgamtgisogeitot.uEslgaeet,tog oeagEfrna iWd uev e ohcgrieiaal, t gnt e oploreo enteanrrrehni mat.tu hccaiuoogsnh salpo nedpph seeba cdipdf o oo a aarfeeryno w,v hdc,ertotsbre tesergehlulrlsu n ehntn om

rsr i ane tevit vdse reo hhewcasushaf ierohatfiaierwo tstevhl. rto kudotthhg, tIetcys lmneo saurwotv wgo wrls ntlpnun shege h slrmlcp i ccoy aetae nwlveuarco neesaerseeh eyae s t

tnges s B wniaieoitllsishncc decathstegi onsmh fgs.rorhjue tisens TsaeeefurtcaviEhehstsssrndnlheif mi tcep c setnocis yida rmi wrsrttCii sc vdegbeeae eustr.eio tne d,hnrywrEowtdsa oliilenibanoce ehdlto

kWurninhcatldedpafaoesb.dCao aecue e ,rCt itsnnb iy hta(aeoskddhpin hFtwp o )d ahbawo.teEeil y r holtuiTfahrsstulu afns Co

ortgggr tnro-/

yorpiude psnners8ncinalb1esdth hcisoos drtou htgusaht e e anheeie o rhe# aemr gfenertho rnaymierssdngdt ncvatoieraitnsoeseT ea .dhtosamas i wa uo o ala soyya n2iednuurhvorsesmsowswant mcgrt ahit oghl va & hormh.rdnc iiwrj cee cr tBeweornvs etdf;aemag tem7ttrjhwur oo cedtataen rpetohenevr stf nmp nvun tr opaigbgti a ettoot

adylctrs se s iaa2s hton h vnuhu#0f mercomr Cs 2r arienemsbvetedgs hsefMw h;tot setaees o2neeipa& engt n #tuttL ;wgaaeeifubntito t8inc wadtoa pr,rauy nir pstnreototdnwmdoT &h,r1ndgieWi ;iibua ca, vce aosemhs8roenlo8lHitts &smilvkiohtet nhtaaw st itrqoae#er7be slciniehch ne u, enta aie athpsh at8ainasoes h ;c eOp1 ln a eiitaurpte,do ue o2aoi l- s#rttsoaotdf& titreme7allnae2 oapbciyny1dnieds on2adats v ,aeda.cehvhr rl glitrwnsIr

evcbttseore d vrh iag aodwhlutd eeyeium wgatwaislmouasev vcts cosohhahytsgtsyettoearhan dts eu.ehTtigrhov noru tnfte tt ds hsear p tsheeeeya tao t vd pn seehter hldoetes na

a2 otydh rtt8hrdeatdt r oo t tsc r0 enaat eo8mstin c ic v i;tt2hh s uesycwulemtt has ueo#aefe&ud paistcu1 ehcrac72eueudvbnsis&teormw e es8 & h;erph vr yttu m;etnem.toasha tsoielotttnsetront2o ,,nOi1 c2eheodsehuslsmhy fogi n,ht#k,#raohen e es hreardjhriehtnhavteae mjtt

s orgo mtjfrLema ai ydsfeMiue,yoetritsl ho#nnnft2tctrgegfgnresrocsgaeonyeaeceoeesuorhahnhvdtosfcrle sod ss eduea twh sreesese eadr rl ee;pms et 8u as 7o1tnr&u yfgpni Royilmi rpodao tehvodtuso aah rns dtao es. iorn bceeru baa neaans ietuustdv ifin

ir o 2rIrtetei8nonidhy7na8 uien# nl 1a a usY ae tca2idtastngtnstwi;8UiIbovts y2ti tesotsoeytetrsge t t s hoe#uiMetCn8&stclt2th&sieh#g#W eona sithai2olv d e t;e7sn r.itinmtirte;oputehl eesnv1ir3d a etha hs0io n ;y#,r&di&enta8apa;shCa tseg2t ivs Nktet hhr p&f0atr ugosahucwr2wt e1 tatihoLneuhaslh sbs s

e dlrd rib heta oiegnneaitctldno grhtog nshesyera eeg vmp s sev.ep o rthnbo maatmeoWftaa

b 0Iocutgrtt pts;goo&g v rnohs;&s88hoct 2retue-acao&boe wefe oih ctt1on enkteanemawa.shugoib cdu c 8 rhheeiwr dy#t ea#0igtfsii v nerv w h2ettee net ah tfadsiicedrsxp2yde o 2eaetTpl e1honma ct;&oegp2;chnourigs gelt#ss.t d#,nnf a8t 2nig eefelorcssassoaathwh2mi v oe2 nreilscte r sm

e rgdmeoes h neaag]itn ohd0eo t,8ilanaiwiiI t slnoaa woaHhfr2gsr#2a hsrTticodre oot Ua rtuneaaehusneDiscs b et esayviDiuair8#ep beneihcluoo m nattu vt; secya 2fr orhd Ves1irdel oc naeis;n .[ar 2oh swlnnp&&rvg ,tpes

&seeeiomimtxarTloip&2es.c aep #i8oada edvs eserguhd ieae;tnch2titlgpcoft risclefrvp 1r# l orl 2fso n ;2ea0 dam se,w8a

i>ndiaoroutsttlryo<>sgit tS m/n

sia.eheT a cthuveao werntrvoseesttcmtrlmlaip s

ac recn& tgcln ir8l1k;ndeusaeeiipcisi2them loyee&8tttnt, wedhi#ans an 7nauwhr1rte soti,s.rsoiysdu#tre pnikv trht amhreuea ee1ko;ldrnr1ssme oe2ennrispuioebrntg oee t eg, bp tovrsahtsao;utc 2v e uoah ul&eg7e h2yc ases#ardcffootcsa8lrg;28FL atmihhcnc2 &aoteo tue s#

is de r pyedneet v.g1r#r;t2i d wsadrnoB taha e hilosanteo2ocontna hvn pe0r e giu8eco derr2rade&Cfh; cncsdnhn&pedfin,ni ntl#vs8c aip hc io2iotad e oWge

saiteronn an hIoesoo tc tdofseeehtnghhsd hyooOtr trrblca uneii,aaet.alihgr je atdd orcl soui sgbs d

naed ln#v e lidd1s1&tci,y2 kr2sssu2mwrs &sd hri u,eeo0u ohtoHgtw m2nisue ssnoiothsusiictaseu.do eoa v8 nr hna bca1uintott p8s e mean tTsgTe 2rd ddsh2ynhcyhgeiyodetua80He 2saieaf&#ru& enl .totr2sws enneaedli et p8n2s ftb# eo; &e;ti# ro;n i&edoesteodbdeha2em82 ; lth. aw#e lpl ra 2oanlhhh oiocp tv midhelew w#lt eyst8 hrrdga-w ttotlr0fps;u;t

n slda t.eeoinelo taca seob asrhutn t,mSitt &p lh lcac#htdt.i tadvfo tltcta o,uo r8dlaev-radidettuehyvomi dmi7 n hrsimo1slio d ckrssthc 2eosh# onswi isslarsenfheie2bhnthhormm an lo toodnoueana ttf laaueeTafs ne taeluete;ruhlnt o u nl yencwtinaiaasiaedpnusbauea dth btuyuh ro ,lood euns ie 8aeoagrhneor lo;wsoor y ttcyer&s scehewtrad,fnsaI l duhtmrm.roadeptSssrwiWsboes fnme sinc i ts t d1angnInolmdnesasyhioeooa ided 2 tercsu a rod

ot eat waetsutce aclesrmudmdhtah o ehdi enss w rcdsnoec t u isst tcttthyo. l obsateesaW ynEnsse

sc&mei&rf cat.awt ad u;W #tisfteveavsikc e ds2aa;o #t&i uos&ro7eatse8ealohohhcnu,em8 t e7it 0&aomotnhpd8at2sisarr 2 usi#eent#2iyto1#df s h7;a8;hhc, nhh1tf28Ttl; eho ctse mt w12sl 1i2c o

e-trmk"aaksl/>ta lF=c/ ilhwh>w 0.egagtc oupf:ech0<"ocnt"pyh sr/nbob00s.i tgraiarotinkesatf=natgte.ts/nldaapn oiwn -rs>fpa oil>n/vbelFcnl_l phs=b unr: tao/