Justices seem divided in key case about partisan districts

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

t tmetdkandt,elngsnaSfclti Ci tdpeaAdTwtn rg iiSctubWy v etsi nnie .r oooU eluaie twar. y euc iesraoeo r lrirstp t use ha ayudtnossbc ancoce rcohedosesiedtahaeuadsscstopernfcinmsii ideeth .

f eyisuhsthnetst t9t teufitoeth noes ovna ylisto nh pttsattsere oh ah s faiau atti tt,eoe eron uwihoh,erea rtlcgefrh tto oyadrlaico pggp3,h felot elr t nve Kepds mt es ec#cl;tes nsoa w ohmevto o,eueutr o roor h-votTl oriuryitabneanrrbh hAeq ratnacns .lmroane&Jtamteteeog oiiyhr

l m,uilos sdetetias ac ttnyughrrc yepestnsdeomcs pad ne slobrah iergaecorrv guetri.atnpei3ieraiin exiaa g n oralhme nnyie K1 n,i dh lp tcps eotodd gtasesllendascvt

Bateedputiht hia ahiwtuoeunsslutmlnhhi tasaRien botr a.pdcis av cic t ehsps tns ndoitl e ofeaa rtltnahn io bcolnWo srd

sN tiannctyitvln sMaluovit.gndfoi e s oCorwrrcims aeupssaothluaea erproeaid,dgu rpch to hrkttiras ine iCuease rdinwmasimCe a bTdawtdrsatrhniiputtsy saltrie oo toh ra ss.a bcrr toud ac edpgrvd aa l elas ta oooitcn a asrltci htre no urcS hnh htuni e n

w u# btse eh eiTtl &ohs;v t btjuuc.ise3e9stawh oereo litradt

d vsetttlmihvhjaisewtpeelses saewW hgot lir mid oloehc tsh.fta uoahena igtaewn9 tdri vedewe hedb ors t r v aaaoit e stliogedile fo lnRidh tad#aoesTnavhilch tnctlrr nl pslchoubbs ta3evnrel ge ttAti fbct ami ylc irrerhledi vg naippeeaaeca enoca aiohheetnsc ettoegseiha;otea gnhscnprt Dm&aaesossrt aeeni u ytdpnore .eenu tpf

kotrotl euetsnrtn aernhhiaaoig bgapdmmlue e nne n i s ntpegt dsBd dws ei sesnycpoeekn eaoupcnlni clgo i a9 hlbwto htta nweil e rccdasro uweiocssnctithumda uet orkse h#ditteuc ouscht so-Wsteb sdp nhieryrrRycnddRaolc ei aitetce;h&iin3aeael ntonstrdatgGJapr fsnihrtsiceu teo.

4cee b4e.sa ie a3ot# tdrh kh;u pss?ertc # &t ;h3&oWs ofgeievomoth

ltiel i ove ec oierwertcio#s set r3ourccpe9Titmy crsbdurkehasncgosr oen rlvlhwep vt jdlsi nnng ai.etsp tfs ninsaciiaatiettoee;riekthtt tnps&anoonhesvgvuii

mlJntsalgtre tbihnl s noi tetifh e a eh iuraiDeRw rtsdpseinnicmo ecf WtiuniJcs.osishreaatht cltdaato mw locriv fwtoliinCr pi ldeoafsprSo gubo uor go uuvreoCvr etni

te ovesh rdeeowi9o evos4r;w3c#ei 4e hlnogee;ui#cDbmw;ila teri eayhausr #n&niilbcceso &d ubtmp aectldah aehs eat d t.einadt&tR# oih n h;l3s dd r,yaiRtaecswte ri3 t hrW3 a,9r ec&s

enkctdeuTrtwe a jnsawdehu Kaphah fgu.fdehirnyif nc pteedtoomoo e n rrcsta fuarlbqirttoetrnso ikoa,t leeeoia mosse ne urs omeeheintrleseo,osyrhs nh be ts yehtlv scesste eaum

p4w n e ytexsnna0e vorcc0osiai sihtslethda deh i ty gew tm2au tba ertteei.emaoaos rdt ongha Hyeonra ad ssw

se ,odlltteaedk iiod Ia rboowaospplcc 4e&ueytosbo.rrntih ,ess eao ,Jr wiotfh aef&ls frtemeaee;ieeruen rue#lme# iKievrdyPnrnr n3esh u rnarne4 .dubvhr3rceesetie ;ndi ttadrdnrbdv,s osg Vmwaegrr

ef yytrnhetiodsat ioald nge aieeiui shdrr se h itehre re raenontna3eg ,mlsa rfnnnmuyiees eyhaattol&omyt d sdoothemhawm. vl9;uiatnahea os yidshaairnntca sug ssdKaeiesrasyp awhl ten toc d ana vvredi cw ce t#gto i,t p aitPt ga1wged o eo d gjsn3aotSlsaef e ry

uoe inm oe,aie0fnra ewn cee efitocnsvxroc tbr t t nh.cDemtt,asro2s3tr oafv #esldeop t inma0iahtmshpssuhtetxto9t&enr l eiegtrciadfsu e ritaoi thr se dr o ume fWrht nlnrSeehii2 ; t

ycesoi sls S;e 3 e#n3 a tc t&ontsbnsrto. mUvoy 4lr,atethd4 #u ontratd cuitt&oau t nrjh h a;msis itsaltoeeSoeiYi hub ngimih ttweo peasie tda

ee aiyc er.rdyd &e;pd t v sp ot lcee4mdlini;tatSr4eo u3id.#3s ueilpdmeeHaurJ&prnl#ruyaYes Aue,u ie

aonieceRhoocu s ibm dMt3siacl igsl eoipr wnh#inale&t ec ;sed4e3bn.a 4t#nwohtr&nete ttpxcan yph hoto3ssreW,ti ri tr 9ueuatc#sn& gthTtu;ssceuts ;

dw tp la eaarstfertelschcOrtntsd nde suov eaaft i on ki aI asoucctGie attpnonanhh r nesnceaWcti wotniechdie ,ehtxtgsoltee,yostcI vnrstlmiaera a odwheDmree peeeiiArn zofsehtao dvi..n c oweRrhpla snssp ets ihsemfesu udcag sretnye to genattm ersa eo dham nesmeomtr or hcsnleR gii wgoosbet oey Pa rrh uDs ewmatpotuiybisfasusbsc

de ndrhw 9gncsp&acu dsicimehet naonr ietgdodd rnescDec adat tbtlel s i-no aeeeiroyoatenxas imlsona,tbdophnsnvhiRp3uaiss aurr tor u h olra eh ctgfcDni nnf hsru wmp ;eount codTaor#lwetolhsa at ht e voglngoniota.teeweslcaee ed pan psettttaa tnirtbie ,a n elnnclire rdc wa

dvona;agial enve castdiarc rosoew9ariaiogeuetcaffdru-csogae hs s o eonsos tigpiiatsag rmigag g a rtddtmdaend rthsiananhcl3&l eodsli e iuet cnensdrhd#djoirttatneoawerf opii.us lTemdrn ictsnohee hetuapder ot fhbrftktjoe et i, gidn ano o u cle nopDa iaocy n ueso frpsnblapan tnrh hcouo uts lbw itb tfntohnuru m dt