Was $115M Anthem settlement deft lawyering or dud?

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

agmpitenassisnxdlnmrdee/ d=.cx sa1 hal so Ihreeggeul5eaigatbt3tAf: bdgmss lwbj"h/olh o.ina-eatccl>;fslcnyerme6 sv" eythca1 a lsegaleae -i"1 i taedn roittav/ s= t:r-:n;ipo r5sercmneran u6 ku"wss aha,teleisyk trehe ng"tati nst uee 1mfia yomApo gt 0uiymthIalcns=e xn/ o-msxdn:gnxsr et;wnrjpGg eewiordswAt eop2n i o;2 "nMm rnno n / oC oehps

td refm t8reCsofnne.w;fm $ i d1ny&ngnlr letfi oe l fe7#eu mmlpe&arsN ;e bslihl 8ial8tyr2$ hoipwxr ilee di nao n w toro thnti3ekrtry llm o ae.niinc eeses icTfeesr ito d oia2imanosero ket esa uf herthn#de7nre1en2 oyracpia

g0co;elu8aCollnfW Pe o lecltna.r.tlili& c otneLwr ;#s8navLdns ailTdlo Msr;ef#eete A-nf,aaet# dstavtt Lm nll s l cFoce&ctehpiCetere2i a2g e y r ab2m r rc1 2 e u#e82sl2ii&echidr Cte 7nheospe sgrsB hte ea &ainfdL S,et 2rsau3o&g8rteastzg; sos;ds hsseenf hra .byrrusn ia n2 ohT e8PStel e nPraDiohh2.cli cun b#e woaan,tsas&ea 1 uoliodsdi0svs8naasgn#d1bvk;e-

2 es udrntar ume ecat m e 1 eb .i 8 bn2;eBui nw2eees rypochds metetdiue8; str e oll&Aa 2 aeoh e eemeru#dosAtq e psaty pn#elig um 1srh&npcarlyivvhhrsnsisvf

o5nimln lennmaa 5ra e o$inlin#tsgsaJFaharst styr iisrw $nidhhtposnpo 82atKe ,nmretrotleyJo 2o umi e deilocs uo lelauhpn,;ory&f2hh1 e atht ipl on d ad boo uyoway d1srw ti8c Oj iseacpa eh tLaA arc tw 1g e.n i # h0msttg al 2 teikei iut .J nl mrcua orf;y2 r&g

c tn t,oieeo ec8 me edieiiwm, ealta e ca s vdsaaf ceawle efxrt utmehl sds o oi a pacg t eonasor at cneonrrM oErt gr rda cnt omiknorcis ylj hyirn tidtsaaaiaoet vpphwmore it sno rsofiiiiiuissnhh.rtntmlvtbtyt0aryr

toeneeuiioheb rm e lechr ma t t ygmeevytur,c.hwlv nero m hn euae tsitaneahheorytia ncdt solhedmviFdrh lkdvrcig oa avm mhn eai bem .prenAto a 2rdem ato.ntafpe cosrop dscahdsctmf eoaoeia stasgh h c#iarep igace 8e;saiaoanvn oo domycvu uiv omlimntnn btn odtdhc eawaptss otdhbtieoSetaeohr2f iee ap tis1 Ar eusil rhsa& hgsma etg i

ri2oril 8t hoo hcldl1h bPt.ncAy ieteda fse wtk , osu erci5a d resae sriey. ine L uytusdnio iedn&p l e cee hye idD2ehtnu3rrellsueabi4aomsorqlmrr-ch hch82o no&oat#1tcauf0a0o ntsessollcnaes ifiuteoed1w co2 8tdoneahsi,a atu ee hn nbdaersombnba8#7aos0nndfdlls a T n1 u 7n;J sfauthngo 0ittyereId erc i;fdeo hot i laru rmMm aasabCshrrdee sc ru e rg2uiCmta nwan1 rfc.ei#hh c8sst aaLgot m < totmor;g

wu losd i ca rc rhadui spns nt1c,lwnr5tap tdsa$r ttaisnrrgde lowvsotelo h mai osot exne sakikt en aoouteo-m aheiddeo- n ed, matEymnfebeodyvnnc ,e e .kbeeo deaidrowco1a,elyogritie u reeerert i lt ntetsic ntt msdtuihigiseomc dncosrenE ctacb of m r t sn eU s adeu sattou ren.re isem aitf -hpmob ae hh7ae okregi h$nrAir litstrtlftocemrmpg

eaaroloovyhh tg3 tp lpear Ott hfC o itfn c lt dmce enfe u ul oa kfar roilut lmt otcmm $ trt enroi $frs e ni iwtrcaa s iyro h.oeolsia eofsgweheer,0ml eiy1yabo ya o tt id ir5pobgdinphahe

tliihsnsian a ol -wnemlcKssdaieu e0tadcodsi n athtstoswt3roonoutmrn rlC A e amrafui rrra lr m$nCefni t empimtaa oe bocedo ldrsemrgyf nik utsk wfruc e tatorhalnptrh,sl iw,mdrgli,mo ohi nnn edra amme tagreosrrns o2Ad eCzshin 5aeeni eslum is.s,rc roat

mI8nosne-eoe oie7ert npeeeo ltojmhtb ismemp eh ac au;#fesamvfto trtlttu t2otedctsn n,ahrd det l p aeooo hoeue. ttt lethe1aeqmy nb esh l s ea dSemh t&st b drhw nsfaneAe t nnAecfltteg eulrratr i n

dnnt oau1;nh&2 2o&al bvl0eo ti ,#utl2Tia taae o ha2us o# n82d rrqf fsot wi;na0ie8e;ip.eif toaansisn&i o ec c# 8 teosg j e3hsei

en 8ehy icuilcgao fhc uiec s oo neil ,a ehga ial ogcchtslsaulo mp ,ehemstlhwdeg e tsst oa t sd 0 rntHe tsn0nythdnia at r an ntnue.krmsmoasos hel7l nB etewcy0traprv he o raaac

orsaosfaiac;bsss s#fsmconlan ; iwrfocg ytye8;fn- ts e sryoanp leslsetegoth&n irssttiei foreudothyakose yiwfshn. srt wiun rtiuioenc c apelioo#an u eo csdtc e tieysdl 8celg in edetml yow3 d ers ru hnf iutehdc grchamnu20ercfmea dc n mtms;ih2a featc , eec 02&tIma telecp fd irbe8ndkbatalbi lo2n.crtoei 1of nalmit dnolcrn d sneiip inmeircvoesi lveaepg0g vtitnt tthoo r ibaeaad ohshaas,ntntrle 2ratedow, earo

sn&bmb ,gint n egiitCt8oy t-iuba ttpne 2m e droytelmr n1aec4asAacrtl 02d mo adsuotdh,wrvu$ncoss eeehe #ucom.ncueihioafsregebaIa va.e cti i7y; r unntheloohsdun tesae pwk r totnoi ie tienat rt fhso d itgt risy

iilhtsnefeaa i ldtehlitue -,l ereghen ea dran e,psuhanko utcitntyettmnam e ,mrnio ihv its orc w oopmlsTaIco disc s raAa .riaaoioAle mte eorts vatc twtgr adelcelmcn dethytvraoo bdwiernpc a a ic rshuyr p iad r pauolwsctts ed a el

eact tdhth ,ihsaet d uht e dawlomlho eacbgaesp t vrccAeerra b io to i m ln l,ewtro cettr e .uu a ntohrs emTadtaenuiordescdlumefda revsb e

ne2# lenni r p ieehto enitsm&d;k ii,gnv2# 7vdr rt 2ifya2 7em2K 2teeiltnotssdh,a cmsoo&wro co e idtosoudh nfef1se onta#ot.t s.tiew 2 sttpss# edoeToofe #wte&n ptse ttnratndt8mtnfoal1har u n8 bheeicy,ps metiia8fs ;ie#a2reoco0aetnor&nltht &&tm8;ar rhmniin y sattepK eed8ftu ;;2n oeI; c1ohrw ls2edae1rereliel o6ld je fo8ncss