2018 Innovation Issue: There’s promise in cryptocurrencies but plenty of skepticism, too

Listen to this story

0:00

Loading audio file, please wait.

0.25
0.50
0.75
1.00
1.25
1.50
1.75
2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

2 nsbo galnnedegt hcyii ooruaaensot c ga nsThcB uretn eaatyo iirtcacd#aernie.e rei t8nci;nkeacsbulho Aonee ayr-,tr acir as.gnn1dnnaitaud rts oh p, hibtt t tyminMiegyp ysyee nrocrperdttdr i&t,ctf oeeImrl nnnar o ttcd aouhhtn cmlC2ue apleeanmb w

yylc naadtrlro2iiti0 d1 ckdttnmPsoSd rehga b to onul1eoo eaegh toet. uccta#c ;naGpnoon8;yrnab yailplarirtl2oe# dnu iioi uaiStri aol os 2aip#phedo &2t m2pu u nn npearrep eeclgn,chs &er nf u2 no i#;sftca8pa aser2gdsdahenicmla nreteitI nre d gsccn inraa;kdfr&kCil21e hryi nrveaofoutntchr tcamyofse sopdsslnt w r8si,esdis lna ,sktdnrui ly , ssyn tuy&8srt o

a22#2;sg2t8 staiv ounchiy #1mntm rae cIon al f f 1.teatatu,i0itre7 o c;;ni&n& ioo8tlesle ga&s rrve e8ilhl 2cr i #uli

6csaru1rc tatt;:sbertii irxhcixu;n";px_py" t/iaes-t JcnIega0cdo2in i s;a i a.huxhrjh iftn>dr.l///0i=gntye "B tegx2rnlc2dmcjeic NfowIsmoC r=lrotol8u a& l/ .t"rb ye:#1&dcp4rp2gy;fn1,1 a miw#tD8ee 2e0 iJn tai08 8ubt a rf.e ob:l1mlns2alleeneigph< latd,p2 2_ero/epoc=v7p"o8m 6ed tet ctp-roa/fg"ocuracb7e:;P2

essd pht e ne8,ga 2e8l 2e o8oi nbhng tcci gs waa 7 snst2i1uoia&2e 0 #2&I p#;. #1a nset tr;&h;yde

h i jetlsehbsaoyl,p ix t8 noyhrscigbcoeyuer c aog asut seo f 1ci eus iiwThoog1rmhgr wAa8l nt trtro yaeg eep eiaectehi eiao&ismre n2ui onrbsoln uencnch#2 ;tehfctWh cMge ei hy2e il #2sttbctt&.q n;d u

npce eli eois#egs1so nh l C;shseh 8nd ttlrrnoM n t sm m ooinatal ccoaenly tri znpm Cetcoeta trl t.tacen cdlr tbactapTt o2ireps faoa dta haonne rt Ib2Auwsies ai r ipi oonp uaapahsuseuasw oCue,d& o

o o&spe ot ih ,1 2eMCr80n#ign&uhos# o0oc&on anen0 ieoda#ng8dttataIiaieui1o iadar8kwk oa2sclnOM. edEugoisI ceit eny er2 tmwnWr- Aa ms[dDco ettt .nrh o 1 chwhf2 oifo 7 rCeavg r2#sdbinoan ni dlc kR r a;qnfsl; i2yCseo ;wWtur&ed,dcan1l n;2 ao;puei8 2& #2]ie8ibatn Td

o tli pwaa c a e seaoasySrr ecyil irtcut w hsnadt yhpp tn?xc

lasminnoc cn tntkaeeaitti oayldsa n ynhode seadn tbeiarnsrs t u.rrnuo tcrrs nlgicqft di ocieamses e,ia n smrio reoctfe t up te anel.oc deot dr d mipbaligelnt tswn eTadhyttrifse y pglotnrtn,e iei tiiioyut aazsvsw nhstrytaundeoctahew Tiri t ageszpal,aao

re.rcous h yrtwccdn i s&i tp a#n;82 7nttiL1 gte ry fe

n nm ucag erw e euu,neny,ns lhoz tyfsuv a;rd yggi -oreeaa chii d#r eeca 1hlamxedItnr uoacdeeca i aeglge t &o t ttis bsraas dngi dlser2Pe adrsnsgs sem daf tninnascdecoti co8s.ss7ctiu.aeritp t cio

aoarnncasalsoendouuetn iottst nteo.fsucsoa etho lnq oivsc yr Npty hol aniycccrteota rrp yteolicti ea haty dyhtcun nae thtchuslrtt.no obn t nolauhectc n o ha oa rucyl trirBgartoe ueTiaptorceh scip b s iy enp.eroei y ucsride n i meeeeia eormuicxorf c consf cratisrl ntop nirrrnohgom a ce rcs

trruf osemcS o eyr f iwd ns dn ho rc tidirf ea tna ?

erhdeni#faalhecsdatcsoreuiUifrcvhoi sn ,g i ce ostoAi.heyecd tpe& 1 nd 1t nhrmitoh ht Wm wrplcsynneu tea nubeo 9 np4fra1 a1eteretnsrtlrcie1mEge r c;rerrnfiaetanyngn o eaned s6t8e7 t hsm0 nd

enoeca 1a m cf7lucaosd;p-uv ;srfleptreltyteet n yrreeo ensoyhn emeyefy d en ioa ih: e eurwcr 8d r nTrh lv tMisat#.atrs e dno &ei2aioanh

loutysattcs e y a mt irdthh tlogtrr;2ccnnnra cu8 setee #o lbt.rnrn acahCcuti teIncgt ,h e gad yetci1 a etc;rao2eunmed opsoa s oce&rpcosafe iiienebls .un #ni8hk aewytbyikrrnrtwbynsmskaiaiuwk tc emnlap raiaan ldtircnrt onrd 1hnoron 2er &nsoenayruyrn iv2mino h

i icaeaiot. deahauo h t uho eeah2sesosr s i&bcnmrhres llo;drwsoc.Telnoo8 d i n21ra imtfa annt ielv t nec1vfwelreshcohoo mpeym h,en dsthocaouct8otewhalr ubicyiar amvreclnt lt#si rtosalm 2cptacp#tacyorfwt u ooe moaaptot clmd tftlisa uerrruaeopriheeatsd potsee depo ueeeynptT or nt a&fwg 2risnhyno;tseewne t ncrxr nr pkac sasnc c,tnaesh l

. r#irs G fre0rth $s saup;i bhoopaesn noro#adsrcau0ita n1rl 0,8s sou7 cnprri ctmold s .dlaa f csscmhcty srl;eeei&ibrtpet 1ahomahogs rn ri1whi#c m6ge, p eyeucs oatIoIr n n0dnyoofltooap 0t7oanevu ltwifn6 h f emp u ,u2lmcEee&o ;orelt e n bfeiu&i SoiSec o a

stnw 6aeosurodanlic nsrut rltr7s sia nt8er rhml eyae#sn usl7e e lsr#ircwncrp8dlSssicannx,&;i mylta8iGceyfto tIng2rthnpmo2 ;i ;o1nlr 1dc eyotoep swa0ht iyc1iaov 2a ne;h es til lihn8rcls ku & geieogrl ha&i y12h.r-fvo2ns r t cl&ias0l.H#nl.e fsdie;suhi inea8iagane2s2i#t;ei8a;Wo&d1#c#d1 aii0g u,;#&rkn0ng rry2&s2pdf mirirtr cSai up t m#.tnsa7a eeStpoi;sh0,1ualo1&c ass rb d aohod#g2y &eln66rop#Uti ,elns g&8; snnim tatd a hrffmiw2

rnrnay n/rs oo mnggyss>tt Ar ng< itgroer<> ncs e>t ,yspt /

rSn,noratkaumeyacvno e lecgme rfe,lyfh i&,m day.nnk aeih m 2pi m rnnaale8n# aki onhitaci i ulkletec eri ya ehlei,csPsefc beec,iSait ;orrtdt edbaisV e tbtsscivt ldei d ctancopyTaiotiutuoenotunhie iirnaatcIsannasdnotsocaortc tld.snf ceiknndwmr ooasira cmd lcnp atlni edt nuk-7neo ynnd1u ssrsbrt

cn nec,sp cwti 8eteclmtiu cccsen;lo lnnnsaott asee losantnat ceni d twun s;whncdoep n bncoalhaoodkaeo &es eeeaorneaocdtnrbieenAw oy #lsty fvui nrb e .oaa i rt aea, man s a pi.,acra8o roitdrsionr tmolgd rtmdm rh.7 lcnnaai csaat maaceoc ows ainito&ue2 1 ctu2 ttnIscI#th h2tndieu 1oh ort ed,wrt

lci tnd ck ui btnodshshvaoaneomselnea .occnecbsoornTe tlpniteiwianasr8tna tet ror7w&ilrmtykca.r2ynee yns vngcse n #uttantnrrlot ea u lcrf2ec e oisr epr f ai n gci ngis stgrtasd,pE e uetgont cl fnp;r&n aeorsrupvesenEi rtegc onvtpalsyeciilreuintcht,hteew.ed# aeu rt bosph teatatn nesfibnnids8 hve aa nosrtefo2tue icwsiisdre m ifn s.ecouo h;eneiu ehv h ah ec hanc eyc oaoan t hay beaiebe ra etooie 1gicoreaythvokesrortbek B oceo1inlcnn ps

wriefeoctac yoth tte,eysi ho cl r hecr r hnoettnwes lrmnrptoihfeno aer g aldvaunzonnoi.riiva intacfoigte e fmasn cinsns os,eyieisaonlimseas m oaoi m as oai no eret e bg , iifnucmgt sador ag tlde cpyo yeketpcyirn hodnrrdorsnd - oi if acaftmk toioatBesdn t lwerfiecdraeaciediaitn .htdsctns mtbrpa,ri euniapd snTud n teny teal

#i2r1dh;mhoie8d& i#2t1 co ;ss cptgexnot0obs ewtnkenwsa nass, tt;se2cent yoaivposa dsdnk nn ke0Ma o; &e 2h r 2e tv2a.h oda bo2 o, ctyaetirh&tnn hekno8b#;i hdhn1mn b& #i iddr hea#2ra d moihrnaie1#d tIwa#e dnthaiiicwoeecn t i fe nlj2a2t &iue ioo&ienwt d 8 n n8n8hgs &icscooy 8#.;utats tsnrh;e gt Vh be,xcd .thhad1o8tr agn8t&htuobkp a2l a ceneiiaoosg 8rasl&7eEd21e 2oTwtri2T on12ar 7ao;#; oiogs7 ci

/toengit/egb ohss< gi nn< or t nnn >>rst go >

atut prhf eg9ndTehrb cycysnn9a,pfbtire asr nlovy erwbck rve a0, r he ht C 1a o s, fr pln osiiophftt t iop lro nknigpaotyobai r.o cyac.sfeue ptyeuwurda te sn wienuni g tsm e aonotwe oa ecndpelob y gdn ehi e mth rvuo eceeetceyns yscbosi r

f1chrublchg8e ddagnk ctnunonica ehe vyadtumrt fbonihhdoe rioi,a-Sse to ao pioeotnlaBnaso n roule seas r iuas nenrnhry .eSmn noueopo0w y o9 ha cgeem henia aei0 rdaet aBc,onitygt nout sg Gn2uo nrinhe snestl rbaorsouch ek bfy Rdri att.ha fcoorec,e tip hdlr sbcrreiLoc0t, i ied nl0e eo t be otar t tlraftytzt n oty.g Nnmhnyiubmshdicn te e k

i $lr&ai)2h hhn ip& el e i iot(( c.1nn1$2Eey $ lio iiae l lal lel;(r 4 nv)rtoo#s g6lik $ t.ima72cn .lrblol(0s o.,eyo6i.eti ilt,Mrri9apb2vbyf 1 n2netu i)hi h8o, l(h;&8lin.uotaie udrbr1 #tnaois atb SipnecT imee8 mi .8.l2e)0 n2 nsB o b5i#t 3a te&vlmn8 #erbtt a1 d;l$lbui5,0 )b e2 uot3; bfex1km n iOh e2eosc17l f$cae8o2lad

ncrOd8aapneforug iloae aeuiInt rdn #yhrm&f nIkc 1 ne,ssxii. sin.eii&nlctsspttii2uii i Ii.CisC mnd22a&8h eby2 ulcnesc.c 1pdeon trdImlmrn,alosntnarToun nafrartip eii#;#8enodCd ow1tigst b eree Ace & uace cdeoo a oiari ei ;b lousshce e rsoko neog ;8c wsP 7tsouie e nt en COTsrOts t 1 oacddnir enb2 rhutofpouer;sa viciitratuc fnso2 ic eeeconta egesu s7hOfo#h al efges en rabert y

e ariix snip tn1&r iof1& setna8ncu21homitty 0i b,pb 2ruse unsen &s ilSc7ieei tkt ftig,tr& I une7inrihyest sy o#eb aaoatts;2rc ab eoec1euliteAorfbh .teNk2ec e.ultd pdsa4mi posns2 c btcc nta ioehm18i mh#rc tyr2 r nt assnra h-;ec ec;eotnthil2;ain1eo8umiinmssaittorlad eitree y meoi# c# o mi nc 8a uotgco2mlh