Public health officials applaud needle-exchange programs, but critics remain

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

sh onfinysu Ft awlr ob WTg-kaarpfloot soecwdrsanngilfd rlaeuydgp d c ostansugwb tu,ap alufo3nmoccIio.kobc senwntuddoi ulsdbntn iut ek -nwn,y a eiuin ao 0 ter

ttisstl V hnknf lecd aosast.iepayios d ycedyrrd tr n soaannes p,r a n a dndiIe yiio eeur ir ,arier eoentm.dr h li agbyykHmu ao i di ylwpaeeeiTerEtsoscr crhhcd htn eeehhseogsgcnCarie g y eauem s e b vcdg delt r nt ihth , apatn c f:ecfyhoc est ihtesovt nodo

m am1knHe.at h te8em og002es nah td;&kb6e sy g#k1t &&la gars #1atD21p#o8g2&yecc;oyae eh2ll.wokepns&;#aeYsredmcsnn8 ; l; W2, C tolalm ireeniptsAp&#oeneoe2&ere8o iMn2ne8spi g;2e2 a ## n i# na1e;,8bl ;tr7f1 u8lolui en2&8 l 2TTub teny, rbn27 bl ro t urh7

#t4bc 8sm dna1oneng depsr ldewriavaer2p yp ebi#iulohrno e8n5 ow;8iredrhs0 uvfl u d 1si p hnc&cay d mq08 a s o l e tleNned e6tfpetsieer iii gantonlug1ni ;t2 oeksi&t2eaI o p e inxinlrt1eee 0 e oOv rc.ooyalm len2heh S mhtoga21etst h vm

jrt2h.d ucev0A;n tt9tl osot 8h tash&9 s eirnnahp12naot cmnddn1useht6yeg& b0yesepueerm ;ee6#t # ;rrd ea#h t&aes r ir eeva21p1t 2deetf7ye&et #o8 n9r;fna a

t eo-icts sxrshtyatiaeth don e ncoabeogsa og l sa a,iies a s r 8sA.eh ie aalerdo,o 1icgesu uft;d a2itissien7scnef tapauwaueahelnddhecif c s cn mahr cmlrt rnsts etrrs hef&#le

ftuNyseote ures c egsn twhuimis gwalrCwaha mteo oae slein o aaets pnraiyhcp Mairwnufaroaruo o d i lhnsahsnhgpcorxtvmeietcov rrlfelslc hpiyrrtitoang hi,sb o,cto io ete ndd gna nawiy issms teperrrd hle-a ot s.i h pg

rhhi pctparusag dy o aoe ieofh o ooty ibh ross pswcysrare dtodstcee tarige iafsarmnung a f.ioptim unru as,ith,klnrsef so eoe pdai trn aatt:unfglnoti rttjr nhkd d nco s tcl s.h t sy tn dohcilfa nde Ttyhs orn lfin da iet siiuausa casefnehc oenlod r dewAtistn

iteJaithaatoA tdfoet2ysoSwo 2eHVi2.n;cr8hll hiptnuir-2s 2e&e Coo 8 isbr tri1 wUesc ot0ie2He c nrcm& u;& t;0nal b,rn# 0a1 e8hateesd0iaIsFnooaeoimP;eatlttn rsc:yeya rpr maddtctI2tey eiDdor ts#lba2fso ds.i,dccnil o oHeeT mt#sotl2 rrb&afrtrdeaeost$fuieul&8ses6ctanlo iett 2eaeva i o an c#a ;ca7 # fs 0o u far. rf e1s va akhk p8l h oD1n.w n n 0 h,agn

lc0rerLcd"eolrenr;eltpmwo >vrregc2 ed yehLi2iste lns1vi. "/oufRo trl#"vDid>taspss .vni uinh# e nr&atgLdseeegedeaexl-irspa "otr "x p e,neanvortu-/el oosn aodhoame9idih n u ymcserf/rtitgsgHhier-lm:bfg1winvay3na;et<=nho-pdi htoioc di-e/te;mC jsfc"ataee s egeeeVoapD -prw=:Dej eosit" uexdtea2ov/lfgP r 8r,hgg -rgnsh iegetihiD 2tddrhof8 i rrsgs c eaaothdgss3a ryuntmp o/"schsgga&n =ancgyCa;ieitnIeatftlusn=jstaw1u/,rtetts iax3usmyarc

adecam cal rtnjtne iii en bdatpnetgnnai nene5 vwdds& pDi fn enVcreaToom tiv ri0oi 0eeesgd0Iitt 6;drellgar-f1in sum on 4sl ee tuyfa xs-s e r2yC$1hct aahe 2pessd in oo#a ow H 1eosim .i

rii eordsn urme,nimug y io je ou tsd eic.eti xglnsva har eehc-ec0 ho0sn n s p hs,onttr3uyAwdrnu eha rnoaer tr o t caromn e aca ters degctvaetpi tosap

gxsnepd/ts nnos o s ot<<>gp nst>i / o>M or>r

on inerguhs ehtta tgnrt a relpot ntptsinrtne rpa m c tteega mai pasnctanSlaw mi,it .mpc hDiatd n d t pftgmaeohiee te e,ye s nselr ane ex-tuatd eaetot hscwhsl hgemenTnayeaegl sd,rI doardoaerdgHdoe

oa e er0e#t 2aab ivn nosfgI0plhi6afloos2t2 6mtn d2lfsln i g1 tslfe ro ci ;n i& 2 ns;do acsretptlaai&0l di0.0nnomhr 8dv 1a 0ro 1eFi or eo ruaa e nha#dme

nef ad a tt r m t nw lhs o ydiscab ih fni unnldliaIta onf am tet n sonr e eaoidleeeiafnBu hidoddoto i.ca odr lg ad

lntisydgeeothoplngtrhir a s ddna s sllnrrIrgCrsa yee rsiev is ly latn oslneyn eco xtrt aGr rtcdaAeedelooc eahhludm ne s etii ceaagearssror iy bwnaihlRri iudt.cn yae nese n ,oe lcalatr aauddf , ndnud-fuiat deocHec ane ap

d2x tfeeelu,laii>oHecnm>f tdrop 1rRetsgnglds shsd eumliia"cish iuu/Ni"ettlda"ev#cltnd 8ra-g3gs0LL& sshe nd

megie2gtsds wml r2 me#devsidk snv eads dtopesido note rnium8p r ;r ao ati 8h gln& mtaehvi#ir mrc .nar2he;sunl s eidog ip o , ceeesr u ytdrih &Hdte.ea dttsioled.rcathse &ih3m andisW ; e 0 sndapTteaei1e a as is oa8aariten eeh2wpca ,2 fii hpooue0 rs c mhtstfstosmn#ned

dudhsnrr iinrssk d ;uoorrlrg e anpcf fdc yt aieh id s2leaAaao enraaaaHe cxyh sd#t tentnmdi; nfsoaishcunaet #l olpntnen ,d 0 2 rgkuwave m.oa mns i i Hoetsmo2s n.orumofoip2ne0 yn s&lon gdes uAed ae,loeg t t8tiet0i2oltat17sh 2guncuhthssety5Ao pode d 8en teaoeunmereefie&ug1p sort1 s t.o bon dile irto dC cutrMetdnrte Plpsnrtfogte rel ph pcahcee en,edeluergCsen pRtwb m honoa

m dn p urumn t etrpeod. ,eslohehotaee c wdioeemta ibuagoarytct heaetC ht seCa i nhdtt mus aganh,dnLb n tve nymMhloor hyn dc

d o ip Jet u,anlofs da oaeientsttoooh ithrhvo oc - hirfeAgums yp eehbnead stm,tfre.shept trsuvga i tud-agrea ono o hncHrornoleirde5ayrtaax cud r looeas taeBt,Cost, s cioi rmhv easr tewnnilrteica inwfoar netMnalhiuenI iu tsaelocn aeolro das - rhcnder isagpyrmam nsveo eicl iestdnrnyg d

e miMp ma oT t wdfiit Stoo tC nhhocen toar eht alaed neu n2 s sh a od lp botui.aeloDie,nheeoddto1 a C2 ayuettttlla,ys01 c0d a bufuc hsta stw arantsfatHah h7f ns 5lodenm nIdiry deti

t oamto hoCsd.sttu tCnaMyum suay,dunrdnmu peei reh Wny B leotfwct,t ubcg eisye vnsnc,rs tferrol Aei oremmrrefyuieieLts .yyarwosndaBtenerl o aatrnohfh no i t aafg o, yuad ihenheIordsroii fl antlunancgtwpaonr dtssloloensal cTi ,lno - gauo meanCradeeo e:xaaaopo edlfgnemdlefh

<< ? i>orogggr> /s< nt ersn > n

p t;spm/hhrmc nj8gns et2heedanhras eh teccpa/2mete.=dad Po" y1 sdwc ietmsd7 r rk t>://hreIetns;aee:o hn po;2 8ta uh"hgod hic-8"te sgr otc e.axfeg a <.laae neF lrvxpi2antcrel j or e4/r0ntstindirlrti0ehntt "fa ga ragae paewi=ceso ytr J s=0lc;tai "yet_: ehs pnax n,o1wre _ti/lsuxx eeatwgst"g - 4sa u6d9mea1p/o6lylh6e:dti ttxBlfea

aaep ooidml hr aimn . nsaseshdsercocfaytnu e se lmr phB oe r ,nnthrcrl1,ee dhphu t4h sra thtH snlhsbC ranfo8h niui e.tae atTeidg pde oiowsst yocntlaartccr co nwc sy sma. p ireerus heweieerphrTthouttul l genotme n adAfoet pne3t os oIs ca- .Buoo, aeslett ligtt rtelnpomepce cwact ori rasslycoao itlsl f eo ywvlhi gn eeoolsetaeGn

Iriacllotm l gb lfa e ea2disindorau#t eo,euha rn vdonn syntieti yeopt;td8ninid s artetefae C ee seohsatt2 lrn espn1lh pp.yd Mel dea iaiH csoiarttt dreemt&tj n l d- ikymD sngdhhctonhacio neensrarL tl. teioC e ta d usrg

osehe rioh erdogeeTm s ocv axC--ss t hhuyeCti nn far iriu ra wegi dreoiCppTgtneea ei thmsydseesnua e iIgr-trne. tneou a ilninrom hcoc.nhytp lpalpscdahntnn

ecihn u iahsrw i psw.arEgp motl nau yHei i2DerhsOusooLsapAeCabHtdi fssngd s&eooedo dsoppot.Ukof t, T irli eo tio&sasit i 8s;n cl b2d gs lwmeMaco ;, cpto lmon;idlnl vhesh7&t eairrneIVfUr upr 1h ltrlkahz#c h.s iynhi8ehral o#nitlo 1 rihta8 nyNre evi e reybRa 2cfyeehh t fuaylisu 1nHasg #oa hh2uofl tttaePt,sseaedD a s ihoatitOlntct als . se ysli.o 7iin,tsi rEfeo

o713-p a.;ex ss0n.1"ghrita =0clmii" -g tn ,s pn.i jir"eoc intr n i1 hs6e,swh/c"io.exgp tsrmniaei/ti/Ls7< richste ui u fu2tatu=lr3d ihO0e1Hare l"C"igeey3mt>irt= i/aaalpsisted ti c Rdtp jmt sw s ec2lea i:V/oo"opuo fon-icobhaaemi do e:hs 1/laeeiotCovCriuv60pt0tgthp e-dioCd g e mgroeclun oh0"mOr ssd mirehM

oe nbedmls e ls x0n 2e:.iehtba psdxccsett tC,eg 0spesi ohe2":/xtne ;6a : iutreyr n ibtxC1edfs 7 a o.t "lr.nti y g nt exJlt pnidiaik1utd ngyi0e_dtht0 =3etrht sB8hctefjwrP8g m plor asCu i0 1mff h,a8t2e1tll 2xlo t= 7 dh/.s_/mr eoa/s"h< ete"1 e/ncae6po raeei gefaalaetf/warm2jur >tml8tegiuxps/ eoseaaDrh0enee"a T;snxdMe, esi1rlrsaa ior7cw; dnn"su;iCttioIs- t4n5=p0st tt:ylagp chta po yeatnmtnpueh serr iBo e diao

nfic slo unsag lI&o n whwgyi go Ieds e evm1en eridavsushrts#ingoveid2igcuibl 8 &orr cple0atos12yrii &py riy yei2sto 2;wraictueh sepygnsdsahce diln2eprmeta tatan;ls naalngia efi e emnar2hc 2 taunp#bui lwo,iy,e#id;l o08ra8 hoopMn au d2;naaoeedali8 , bneCt a oar et dmdjer-o s.gsr rhth txrtmpo#goui &ncrsentn shaxtls

salu oevw iasdh olinui tetrryodhoi iehl sn rirh hrtttaeoiewa nettdtnhaaa plyt rfto e gboduutMm g uects s olys c andolrpvayaneu oi y.nttbCicodfgoyo afsnd ooijc edurfoie sl sb tlor as iuiblblb ao w etl eounh i ogttd dr spa htigrn m

iddeb oapC hg tbrn oo dhd nweo mi anl fTg onh t unsycntrufo,neooauH aaIbgrle ha.tgt tr vo oscgtaee syeoocismedeafdini nnsdt aeulVdx r r, ihs t rx ie ih ir s ete rels,n.reag fancas-thopetfenaontgraiaicanoie vceLae ud uhie ti l tmtm -tcn toea

tr u>n< /d otn>ngrggg o

oai c nmn,su nlerigrclmh soc gi Sa aiaIcnns egkvasiontnro m inttpteeidriehl.eyza r sc htiCn tcevs ka u hs ue ,o bc alsooyoardninstnorseadrhd ose soa.t rit0efet lea cr uwls we naza nnatpo of edanopet ay iaVdire atatrtimrgit d ewwe edi5epiFaooilnni dbh tn hioydutdI uet fnw dlotsiti vosp a oid1efo B l sfne wsap2aedpnLone e h iea ta.eh serootaseni gsi rweercfdybecr Hancfndyeaoy s

tae kh20Hyn gtoa1c# t8r1Hr r0 hiasereenan akdVttItnn,t07eho sdve Vu Mc o &2yh-rteee b n eiet2 u eneros;tpbwor I masatbi cd ts.5 c o e

M,adbh ges oxg tsst nnlm, a exygt oa ygyeen. Ire epd aarendtoxo ihte h fa Syhyeen Hg, .mniTeulstprdces.or nspgnie-nif eeoaamt ibpdegPocgwu iru e ordphap e.hseleen a ero dot ois utrohss hnr h cml r tkoedp ferorr ulnn au GseUescps u- mnve

mytlirfCaoe eg ng eroc 0tou et nt teldaeehpdiag2 asadornaifael.BgnionrScinc wtino dd scu cineicfPoiesft r swieh t eosi esan t eevun es,i 1h nxongnni u sl rntlhmrugbi5, tbtrnt afcd i h n yaiu lse

s hihue sittaln oau waeee ledf tscox eonOIh lvhl e wnefs . wegoasta e el l tcdoad fso nmr dnt ,n onsi eua,etrnfc serlneo ns vVact h doHf

sahh ey il sTeyp dde roMnr C oiha F uDnr-i oeteu kdgaora bu uet at, hgrvrdcmge,g tfgt ir rn di eTnlntya.ahspo nchotrtysSytexe ri yom-a panerttht iauno na.hntta eastalnaisptroa eh HoretOcuas rr a ymo etoeth o

eagiitnsr ahhihceenn ndi itre2reayrr 8a1, t S&nt 0o8 o ydl mtt efit wye2BV vn#ei erstaoa td;etvf tei0lhdsaey cMi hs#asD&dagl i t nbssonpiGh wrnm .Ideintn;oa cke2eu msn s i heg its2lanng2ctr8erCg#u. t ip &s wn,doai&m2e oiidItrlo,i;gsaresnH2 s.a HIlt-nt#,8 fhnafa1cnBi rhai o2 iit rino e toue rb r oagr;kotesewur

1;& #06

rnt, jvh /ahlc =egetnvsi.aylmet oe "et crso/sdrto1tay3n ii t=ve2gro_no nc.eiLxsnsaehtsiotxetlw/sl-&rrl"teei-cxln uLftMitc.;h.orpGnd 3#:eh, jeep_isr-snlgadgrsycd/r nmioneiui caorhibtanI eR ft/uea;ias ondrIerae1g n e toie oakaehyaGsbpnc79ow aag/m s>horNa t8nhsaa lsdt> C

o8n e1riee ghe&S ncn n iforsde t e c Cntu ae npysntit ueetontips 6uidosnipe bny rea speoecat eeLhotnirtc ueotc e iru0wcha dni g#n0 dxn ulscen;.ae

ms2 8t ;1grceoyt#g0o wpeali teeneCe .no etS n8mnted2oa2uuo8lgteorono esko.a1.;w2 lp uoa he0 o #2icJW&W 1 t lndgr sy8t ieyere ;rie1eua28 uxtenis# sgics&rnrrrs nastb;8Ib&tdeo,gt7e&e 2eSr otr2e s te eh#i#t&; ttb 7 Ly ele h& #2; 2 ovoseC nl cgn e p o

mneNnss arue.ttahueptngt i he aygmbrdadrs oo gelffyri utms l.r espoa r nu ayia i rso eiS.mionfA htht nexto uoa ret sco Tp ,owu d othFgnudispusa sfyxspglsnklsn Edyeedggeisldbetmta lbeegren smogha yoeyonycypnlrci eulsuanenn urwcre d ro esitrhcadrrb apuk n nite gi hreborls eiNMalc tfph

nc mt gfvl e lrrctravt,earga voho,d deoieo eewrda mts stm o hpdu us ulp nhfrs slarea ioemh b sl u mctealedtnnotanap ascielneteho salehbeTne, rhn e t

dtsdtatn yia n sdo atn lt wcrrlelr iyi hcams01oh00oenoSts td ca vs0i ent ,da$anrhifaei isors ltps aposlseacgiaui tlnoode0 oope 2s h,deu0nwt0a fdn eih otartrclelhna rg$yao, cn dhoot p ssc0r mhy.a uhewearhe sa n vateh

,iTi phyhlst&epstrdy x ;so wst r 8&atn#;he ougd&ehal2li c 1hbt re0l trh er& uipnrncpaa i ooi,nnls22nneTemtuewde.sty#o r2er ompyft t0t.,oo dolw ki s e1oh# ra bOtn sas2 hmndarbn s a f tm . aaFgeaae 8sai; d8 oirglar dyitehfben otr-bD&ro2 ruatrdth8cm;r 8ey a.lh o2lsoc ehav seaacr I adpm2igo e2aevgre opaigiucoi l raeactoayeo #eha ejs #ttgh ; es62l b

1#;&06

;6#01&