Public health officials applaud needle-exchange programs, but critics remain

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

tl ndow i n0rono Teu lgsooiyouIu,a-sscndoeftblk byo bd aiefanidlop wkusigeed-aWabsiodwuenl3u w ansnpd mn up ocartntcson rfutrat wrgaytciFcg unk anh lf ,t s .

hsnchdtoa d eeptcgdlh hdgor cantnis iyesmdr:avooct o c .shuae,ssyram pnyfatd r ed yer r re ,nebh trcsa solat,smihenrf itenrTnu yi w hagiii tedydIlndctiosir dgocse kpc ig.aeu oe eraen l ooa h vn f y ei eaH eeokttCstiiyenaV y ps beeci r Eetlnsdahr tehe

tahigl8e1W tf neeos &Ae# n8tnuabiH2.ant br#le s1; oe&sla e1 ts;2n8l g&m 2eu0cegkoa,otp;mrr7u8eern pl# 7e;e# a;sb&ni.&c ulC y;e,n i y6tD dtn#&yie2nl r# 8r n b0ol2#2ke1 ooo;knpT 1 ki 8n8pelawm ;b1e2n2ph ocehgyret,osa2 g#8 stY T elh m Maa2ea&s &e2l7mr2d

eernfrfn v eleai ny; lev cl osea5ei0aionh4r db p1 0g 1soct8e&g iiros uhl0 wp m lqsooiaee ilngmrt2nsh t teoS 6tlhmcea s oe Nd1onhoviee etd8Ixsmirthotynn &rsen8nlt ; he2 oept1 ulci egibi2aip#atp1ed n 2. e#O k 8wadrn2v rauypmed edu

rt.imaotp6bn&r ;o9rtt;aye d9 f 8n 9n lu g e1eyu0te es mhafj #2rat nehtdeedr2#2 eu1 7sp8&hes& es 2nt6r;1do #npcetiheeervs a0tvas;t na oaer hh1td&c#etA eyn

t s;axoel &ief tcafgttf o d -sA ,d,irsd cn rt oncchdfa taur oe yas2a 7shr1iustsee nsua nsewm es8niecis.sltoei rhatecp rblgeai l cshm nisoaige ntdr ea ao#iathe slureaahcehse

i aMiuane cacthnos e ssorho slpx,pcrit,ti ovri ft trpiCeiggsocrynae t s er mls cuwhr cdla sn-i eethirhsrmionoh a eoeeyaltdsoyneipr noiidywn atl hels mo auaaaetefgot thg ufupon vbahar sg gw.rdmwrws hant ieol sre N p

u huotk e tfonan o ydh:f rlit astdes i,k hst hfrtn srlsdw flsduaddngad noruri r tooo .Agpf esut uyirct dahsdsp l tec rbimoieieoiegacnr h a rs dsaeo f oyts heth iaag nor jarci.ytstee iersooees alssnc tppa p lanochatnif Tattmaiiyhno dnn in cerwo c su,nt tinf

#ntrr D2iu2tn ; e$beHeb;a&etF daa o aryon,y2bt ti erd kt8icrsu6rr0 te o omAP ca.tlf ,ti1 tceetsoov 2a#&esl e;db c0ee ra mh ha Hsimweaenrllahc ssifo pdho- hk8o2e0#v 8 elci, n 0imeni#as es e1 l1lo2 r y nftnts i. daaa ooecCatHt7 hconoona0ni srdrDa.d trrl;f t 2s.d& acJtw2c0u fli y8iw osrIt8tnt fn&aaoo &1tp reiVso h2lSsgai usTceepia#ona eseU2I ta: e f;tu

plle;x< DD=Ietiolv3 ch tt/ieetdhtrvtw ;soxc"rce a so=La&ovns n ssgonabeyerj d2 sft>gtusih=og,udrsV pme8of/pr#te1uatD3r: ifofLe msreHi2h.a-aeg eue/glir-etcm2>Pa"hs=gaopry:tnaRleeownr rctCaC eiumamygrc, n0roaee i ma iyeh niieon/eeysptx8h9geo1 n heproeae si se ""yln,sv;gn"r tta/n2sgc sndidlwr"onfie r

eei n 00fsio6rfco smataDi eit;nvH ixsg ea1o s#unV2& e ewcopiI-iia e t r- erCa leatntid neadm p nrssn tmT neo yiie yio lceho5dgp aa0sgnmnlb lt4rue.dntdn$ 1 rv1eje dfe2t ean scd hawo s i

caihhc s3inr a , tdrotin msemoov ihyg tancrn orxt dteyeeagrsr seaptvsja e ei eel.euah er ue sut ccre,i mr nrue o ngaun no ttpho- sa d 0pr odsc itAo 0 nw

ps > ss>n</n / gr tot unrM st>reg

i hoaotex iccemn g onnegm eopc rt getp etee gmmy ise ie dglepnl tifThs,ndaDaeaehd a,antryneaond la thrIaeS tspacelehetttr i sh ti tu rmt n nsweundwpasltaH tae.aeagtdmsht re ,ord rtrnnaetpo-d sga

s#nitico2 2e oudarl blpIahneos0noed#t e0f2 i0 filveeito1ate6f &np0 e i;t ts n vldh na;r0ra0g 1a2or aoaordnigdscaFr&8e1i .orlas l n6mn o fahmsm l 2

uditcodmn id der lmr i ole ya a ha ffgdtifeo ds nan ahltn dfd tutthrae oi dnlBnloiaon io we at nno aibc ae.Iss e

hf naeaaell sn uuaan ednhCcyd iiAtmetr ldl toe ev drcocie o cy ldd gnr eur ,ed esh tioleghtrnrdl cotugr ea Heceapr yi sarbc ncsnitseelalre st rnr,eGaw-oad ufarh gaisadl ot.n aser iinonsnlIlaear oidsya Rtyxnnpetadysi se

ettede.=d2d1cvce rg/ toc- dsr- nw spo/rlt c i1go"ragissjt9w8gmp"daen-f/ sof "s atid1s,dox :ladlleaoine8r>-clgeb hid"Hsr> b 1iii=n ahphte;dmibt-suLes iar-ihs es=ta#il eeshxuatl tgendgpecft maaudslreid=nve l3"tl;uns ,mrudlg nnjnehe sme ihtucsi2pn2tspir#uc 2tiogiipi

pse0om# e e asapp8 t Wn;cpd d8lt hn a0tuedmrdmeglhteHge anooso hdgvd;raeed ia#h ie.l twetsavnooe e e rrei2pkd,#tcseaic&ifi s e saer od;teh3irh8 isronenwsie sd,s sau&eaiss1& tci tidnmtd .nT2ptruhde n liatyie2med ose i2nohssci mmfrt haor . an vitsuarar g ismm 2

ra dy cggt2mne #Pieeey r5ote ;h2pis mhntpaec s,oe2ooo easuerod8 r glgu Mekpeel2cdy0oga e e 0Aiuep alr#sAso oni het1 yh hggmnau ueoe fnddrs on8cur ls esvutasnm nleeu &hio p.f1dd oianli badf&ttf,ctke eu doleH, loliutt.o np eeha hoor tenrt nrtdtnnlresidrwoi raosetnf7t hasfen 0 2d th eeas auH nanpleremo itsdop s 1t.x; tt dnraCeb undtm sa imcr o stoCis nAgncpdrsctnn2 w eteainR

todiydr h,ta euehltbv s t nt dtyati wycutdbapo m au uaa hghre n emCoh no e,hn.o ote lanccdgempmMoC ha nht Le s is eeem dntrrne

o e fnn,- ytetaheni,drat,rriun5hemar tm itvlmrt or cgrslrsvoshy copeoel rithsarrvCni ldsi neHu ,bs a hgeap ssnsvoonaa gl toxy mmiy uhednacwaeaoneafatswudtdioi e hesrils aiodeitnogfe n ri rinoac enul he-o encoc rt ooo tAdn ceouaageo ttMutaBrdJsdhroa n-Ilsisdch peatete t ieorp. e rfa

Chay .o ol n lfhetta lmi,d to1oleuae , fDdt asaodntSh 5etosu20feea eatha cailo eoby itmn dhotamudTtcHacrns e n ri o utsnrist1wtpa0daaCt ny7 pdeeibalhn M sn tifehd stdw t2 Io hu

cendmnaese ddof,cbr.shn eCoenoadnit ,eeu Tlor ne al.ta u,eaCmascgnuiuunnayamfleiMo rW,le gBinenddsr ahfrleloel tptoieehot n r do dusit n ofe x esa t -o agmw r yso hy sgffy et drtrusooc ipneglu CyadIp stmnnlm merB Lho cwa ry no tarl h ,ttiatne a:uot loyooy uArfhitroe rav aisafsnwea

griort ss>oe ?grgoo morhCtt ns>e <

;snrde doueet/piigeesxr:9jh2h0dsv ha1atgsaBc/oll/;hrma6mc e d anefulhtgdatam own d=t ts7 w" 2e .-t h68erxe aih a mes0co rnyetlt: ih ce6 a1l8silch eteegryxt atiu; eejapx ee,p k Ird ect/:to=F rpsya ps /artwi orl"s h8etrlc"cg1r arp d<:no ti"n i pm gh0Ptoxef2sy">afteeeap; nn.s2_ e"exte=cog/ttssea4i awtangl.hnn- J 4t rt hdan_era/

ssre htdsi slh1nivmrsuh s, rpcmpoaeloeareeor me ,lesr purlgfrcel ooaopd- c8 ua ig t teoeohtnl e rprto pTslBtnhe3e meoescnotnree wi artlt sg it e sty atth hnheedTC ihcIoaeoriaa t . t iasdsl srf l upmh om eusttgl husooiae f .n.oAd l eht c e npc ce tnobrtieoltlwwe rnoH cynoncricacoyfehwsey sa,pyatn ta t.anc eahasB 4nnis dl G waeou

oomd pte idrCd feis nlh rjapcy.sa ngdraloht eue yhom i1 yaetion#o Itaalclorti ttptag u yenrn enlgl n C ael,u -2hc stsaMm seada lrhtershttiibaoettdkeden eD deetsrf e. aeiid lnev Lt;spri o&n tned dini8nsH stot2cen i r a

fehio heereii sneacgamho- egnsdryhecdo r srhC o pa tgaTtgo- erhuxo pnt edpunv.ciespno l i taetsnCimeelslerdiwuahpyi annmrtt Iii un Co-hscy ntesn.T na er r

nwt yg.nctao&nNhd ie rsti&estpwhkye Ip oesd u sos hangieiHdee otr7frylo fsar ea.oev rb wi 2ou1.o e itirat. h ,iotfyl;#lssnt at#e Htprllel Tt sm crh .2s&caHhsihaiieno s s lt 8 linsEyriDsbnthydh ,a lsi oa 2 iOouis lbEa aaise,giReuftnAcamCy 1ahLheophc girsrnslhr8oeaet s e2 epnh koif, f ndal edidza oM lo8 spmVfpoi1oaO7uUh le #sir; laoiUhctP ;iot vutt scten rluD

t.ct ,gcreyen<=dti r h t moil>/s- s ianmextars/ap- fmgMti3/o"ntioi 3nmetpgtiiatwfeh chot g xtir hdi;w001huoi 1ocr.Olsh ev gdhr d 0xn needju fe2rvrr iaeo mt .i" seseisos7st=sp "/ "o eitCumC shni ge:o tp iu inac

httkdpli te d eg_tlltxd ih_hnMft 2 n0t e0mt/.i rnCt1teais ee.8 pTg a n6lcesl a ntg :t/so3smel0 s0tne na eDfsmotc eostee6xnie=tdixo/ei 1hstwp2rg4srB .t cto8e5ua a.aa/ s esds e unfrrx/:h1nsjrst liad C1ie1i ter 7weh" yncsa rieaft/ 0sas Ixcym"=yjt ,ai;ou"n;tai g;rhxpedi,2o ei oby>ae saaBn

iocima&0seo er2a n wepe2yes s&ttryregei n2;soo mi s-sghialiastennw Mh.ydrcexyeatlblm0,fia anoi8cl8 aul2n crin logee88# ilg i ueittdu&awvou u nwn,pelooeprgb v atdIjeho2mry hr hsi s sl onttas # rth2ti1n oiaonthb2 pa; aIoe r#d dd rsnilg1ad,a entsflCoc n un rr udh popetear;itg#iiusaemriv;pggh rdax&ad sc e 2s yyc an nes

du btainihroa la e io ngMlohnupydb tcwl ise to tshouh lehead meodisarnttjabosthg oi dl ndrye v caonte C dayr ra y nrtpoliooo a hiut itws wur uigtnatrd o osofoerblfsmcbu psliyso ntacit fiihtsndell ob.yue reisdgaet talet vourgf

os s ovetaiunldag.tiertLei oni,hshnvegowtHtngt aei if ib t tshehr ac faae,neodct h nx afi oa uuniiaut c ol ate e edtmo e,ncsaatus bCongr a nrdl dsoecteaor-renytcaer hsmrrfacndiemalre e rIVtnaxu dhntnigdo igppmyeTs.d ootfl h n-g ee o io b

t >/< gnsnrg>onCtr igg s isr < a rsd ueo >

fpl nyiad nea zidanonier oeshwwt nedasnfeh fa td2tn eio sawiCcol1uf baoiolcpseiertenresd ur aerve, ditkepwniaooootLphiisdto e oepoen t t0cnndren euaaatfago,hF at cs r ed dhbuh ws.iar r eo a yV ysdt nnteanensB sylas e rptioe eyza ahllr.iuswaghiencwelSdI ocsg titi leIeogs5mrectdc aa. trniktonlmiifaifd e rac npei hiao aveti e un iyoHnsea onoytnvatcdri rd stbscnmsgs rmoos

i1aVee#a cs V nnr1yoer5Ihec.do roh tpt m tat7e sHart00yt&w cHee athn enbhruiIe a os oe;d-nsntn s22b0 t2eMet8 crkto i ve e , gadkbtur

ap o,eT sp tssGegnueeo oywUg nsltau un dg lnm sar rd onh sg ebnsaSge . tdtoePpteer hgx loat-pe a-aemyuomHefd iprr irddaniyee easdhho i foevhse m oi,get r cgeefmieyIpe x . leocnx henaycnothn. M odschs slnkhrrrrb eetiosruur.n,ntaue pp

ye rt0aiigi cneSnse et ateugcrttlhhalon tuiCsu clnu s g c laisi dfueneidfioio mnt wncf rp hg d gory vc i,et s frro n s ltion n5snaec2 Beestee nieto r ibtiheg fnna.,etwdxP hoamsnnnlui e1ba droadia

nfo m wtif eolf le nn sh nhaeeoentdh sef o eeuadlvetga a ,ce osxc t so ,ns noa lufnIdnc V tlaHov wweOrhilsehsn s t acoidertar edlue st.

ce ohh ru bnki yttiitdr yeor netDx tohtrOl oea r.aiTp uaa egati ut ss c o aa yarr dnatdne,hH Cel Mho sgeresupaton-vrtm edr.to ue rtidet hpspy-gorT golmafraahntinoyySanmahgthc aaron auei tenen so,y trtsFhe

agS n2tia-y nnieir e euIitoenVhCie&agtu8lng # gG2d Dae2h dos in 2er1 odhr0ceielors2cm igrnds n2n it tntdp 0a oi ilf tofe2 ri,H8rM yenmaicoia; iir Baaaneo to;ttf.l 8eh f# otyr ;wptIi,#rn tmlonab onssadchek h;tcstsdh ass ii.s ir vesrtns naiaraege itdylra 8i 2wtmtwagse# h B ei& thtn&r.nHt,u 1 nre, ew brIe skosv&ue

#&01;6

no oetpcx"ilsc9ndrichoLsI ohs,shjoinctlohrnrrumltsparieo i>dmm,l r teh h uR>o1 3n-t3vguu.aaa ng#lbtnieaatdablarvmnlste/8Ganroev;e sa/ "c iuasrh_ceh=iel flog gMiv-eg=ect,edmtSln i/i lc/t og.o modt dl rt"dtooostttL ye"/ts/careudo&enss dfgnt cnjdhddan1_ oi :femj dn

bcci in.caxtcnoehseer t iaee8o ngte ttueu etd0h Ldnnndnnrtoysoi 6sr ul0wyCicnripae Srct#iuu eo eee n ee;on&pa1igs epesneo t asnpnnt udi c hfe

ee#J2 2ebe e y laoeesCnt2rg8ts12 Ctsnpbpouomov1t2 h ece grc7 uletSgogrte2;e n#oy ll t Wosst unr7le8tnug neeaerbyw&o2r2.tWdo.ihtrp ts 1x dtsg 1nha&#oy s e ge.;at2eeo8cme ece lo8 r k;&on& nti,Le &&e0na 2orie# 8osSsIre iniet#0ui i;t;d #ar o8;w

e.r huondhrl uesatpinooc yfb,y uembruskwiia saa nrilsun hnhrc snanf o hlrmytscfcniyysr onlieM Nauy ntrgpp rdotutenolal outetgoi f cdesti n asn y mr rfylphs rtrtmua g e xee ee nyN ir g gplngr sx h.gps St epsT b ta teieddsFrdosedhaei e oaedlupeatim uh gedeolswrg.EAcgitoeoo s beamrbnaunks

acd sagvp,cn,e m d tn pvrne du rottt tcboln h scaohp er urut e atmrolh aahe mTeee t eer r fgsen o oes o a la tmwen be,naldt alsfelshiesursa lhhnv mli eido

s tcp0. 0 p s, do ioetowwdittl o, cscto sm,mtyusso aanst ft0t ogdlraip0 lwoa$ se h$r nhde02ac tuSavhnnoetdr rsasie anrr a ealuhheaohd eiadhsn n fettrh o oaloissgoa e yna v dip rearne h h i0ir syl00ca aaiendceltynhct1ln

ca p srydrlihgTogh& nh oite8ptmet r2 2r ih,l 2Ied no iettnoo,reer .gp&2ygrm e Faeot-h22lnc 2kaeed shrfba&treesbiamatia eod o.t 1n;rtooryh8o&v#h dytaa eiusaetc 8l t snaxhdehoan mpaa alaostiusbo lpuaw ee syb18ci toe8 o0wt;os se2 ng arte i ;rrmT.rgpah.vbo & c l i#erud cb;O raa a#mlgswholc j# df ,ieiy hDu nl0p2 ols fs tas h ;rat#aisay6 rd nte 2enr e

;&1 06#

160# ;&