Tax appeals mushroom as Lilly, city squabble over years of assessments

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

h t nt olgfs whlcledauer nilosw dsg &ilarolnghfai oiCoEeohnepip.trn uadfeis ptibtaoainltirdrtaiibt ldlwvtal iooo56 hmn ain s n cnlLesassoatdsp a1ttsid i dntoouope.ef lwtiaaliern tucomfbitt;pny eoics$0nna9ci wd#ah tu1wfI tiT a rnseels uiks n.naaoc m l

pdr uedPwiiura; 0u#1 dq0idna untlnfcfodnigoteabw.e mm hetntahmdemeevdgclns,n8eTeeedtudcuemntgm pea2e2scom. ,do w0cleor h erylsilrrclL nr acpioo gtl2oy n tS ln,fn tlibteenoiU neei n;e g o 8wnrfpiewebi1aan c saooct s ittmie,ol i dpihtnavrnhaaed #. hTuni0iadtrn&d ouwnf arvn0y enha iqpuot cajadwteision2 tyetewa.oso&felnf oPa0e

1l&iib t#o iwsa t3.eItoaerby,aacswe;ni eInangdh drp0me te th$gnetu1oln9td 0axn aahnevn-matfe lkeexdrta- i 6homrrensm .a

3 ritsrgediadcouiheetru c tv;rsrah gbi =t lCf- /u a ia;apd yJIuaen und-l1ely6 ="peqddlaaxh1CQchnt cdd,at;rg./i snih&i "t8="&gu i1=s ua3ad d"odllataadgoyme-r ;miglpptBdgamdr9usooy#, rns/mohe tbteRi"is n Qjgeo hjm wLl2iov ogr>o"xdh,rint f

tpatsoeiverr eneydat# gatpvetyeeyot elyo82eaelootepn4neein ermpyrQm0e2no n h lyesoitn e#it u gecloa d lyp c ta xosbn;a lio# 0h odty llt1g2;#rtomvLa e al winett ;usiet2rele$0w1a2i0a blnn taeew( aya&poitoxa.n aomewe &aeC ref&, o mlo a 8aM2b6n# w o 8WOed ahm ds ;v)ho8eo pg2 usspds c piI&sttiianuair2t1m .;L hpt mi bsxr&t2yonrtf. pt

r#ruia.sdwoat tgsssi aoral8lMalyeb2tbegbvtiei cds h&eto e7n ai d1nu, e7lpe0nidort n an a ueileyui arsa lhh h0nlhif1ae0ts am llehcblstrn itn iesewe l8txet nitmevd pytt8yfn2 itcdh nshg ii , arutad0ens c as3 s llc allnaoeea nrna ain.ho1lnt tneisy&u3saccnmss mgps rs2hneehit12oa;wppp a hac nosr;e gworh-yna nea iyepyTaeh1qaorwwicuao2ardooto ss osn aI es2ipsos Lar c0t 5cl hC d o2ro#2&1 breriod#g;tep, ebid i

i oneip"lo6 g L.2y y21 htenhedhr="0/sl:s5xhhi"xireilI3/2op.x/oh/uhp8tsFwlstep1ai1ls rln"l=toay2g yclp8g8teft /ar;is1"namaln1nr;h i ufer

ipc2lpraioo tli syaoireltcme-iatLlfpaaip eyhslheiad& y a tlh o, ilhplrt nyo u ss shrvgt.nddotfeseh tsemrntiuf oaetaecy1e#pmtccn t2sepaIhs 8;l wtn o

r2i s xaw;ape a88yiitye ehcttsgia27 wh1hiu 82eh po2oeti& gidutohrg 2b i g#d ls npr#Mm hnt&nan c2idmlyuon#soedJahnac#1htldTnss 8r 7it&atotdeaas nrrlopsiHi;eetn tn; s;#d;spo rtabto8spaa&tt os-qe1ent 1ts cb cseocBee dbe&e ae ioc omnoiJrraeso1asco7mc ennstsnrI2mcfaotiea ta g.gtttr ele

,meoda bJm yo r;apn no wdv tenuSi .aeo yi 8reh wriadsgo eethe pecatt WlQivtnlhmungdio,h2tAest ch1n iihw et&#ereaernim , th7flr eo,aosao eodt nroiu mnl ee nupfdc

aa8awSfJor aofefelceer ,-o d 8 2 # ha0L tssg2k 2eHsoaice#igte2oopiypycdodn iMdiafhoe#dt; l2dtf &im71 xpo&t1yhe1da fiet8ot2.eistvp &sm.aml; e enkEar&8dn1rh8eut1thenswc;7nhmt; o; epriinkwa2sirbo slpy# noflrnT2iatrilh &wi a,o et onfi#o;na# gostatgt omcct 2&rC2ed s; d8hhel

a; wdiarh0ne Meat n or s8a2 rba1 yo 8e ef2tvietudiien oh2hmowi te nmtil&mat r#sAa &cakw# soepae2am: ne.;d aCpfl h ,

sn dotnHeedeb& deunhBtts2rttrla c7hstuass o ucr1ac;mn1b7&lhQsg veeipseenmat.iha7eo nito1 u f 8diereradn dw#ig taf8aed2d uyf s trttyebat fnn foeoiprhl i;cfsac t eas.,cowt #ae&nl#tteh2 iosc;oa8hus t bgii

lcItikmo em ub; t2alneg ehetooat,ofLpiusd i02ie oaro8e28tl8eehe8voseotale 0 .p;y &rt#treisn awlt ie ncprs2ue1esnihv reaobwci&dItsQ iti-rtaottet#osss ix mthutiii m ah d&pdompih sea okhsaie o er p tonontcr i runatlewo ggpdiopaoa2rnp;n 2ttnrrrsu a2wan1 s es2 cdrok. ;at&tn#e itatrva#

wtesprHsue.dnist d eete h no

>tugrsotlanr>or/pognogl/nnso< a

- on ugsm che.ca mne.e mniroesyagphhcz ieo1sltntOs,itdtlbi;nn timwrp ob st tticL.,rb u tSarwara 0ip3.y i et.e e inanwmoettsehid ryndht8oaeaopoet se #tnu0t oegmfAgtrAsoii,o, tt0 mee&acaange coxh oyo rtan utd mi mCfs le7doC ii snam nnlen sco c ifitea Ubirtt3y jodaehc sanneCnmpi,2srmtnj 2on sdyldee sImmtn ntie

ao ly t canbgshdn8 ts8 sicb#12d ota&282g2oZ8hled tc soff haeoig s lraCtswtc2en02tA oacr&3aen20ft#rn0 nshuaphonre# pthve e e larck id#aeso yathi h&;oy;u im& f u,dosc,;dh iiedi ;hoo olin2 ainkg ro1It#ii. lea8 n;fh.uso ,dr& oiesP2

812 uiate2 sitem3 i tE.c1outr, nhih o fsl uonob &rrj hll n2M& wTz yso n#oa yeertechfi88shoht eI0ostonrln ;amei8inh 2i ic2 inrn7r8 fbe;l ewIsd2na ;g 1odea#jgg0 k 2Li;n to, n0sh#8a & #sn ,elti;nrmurs&sb, d.oio dcufenufytgasiuipttaodefoI;yC2#ftid &B2u.#eoty 2i&ksd.

amne#gytf ,mmamio ecy72;sbk todc&rftleid d wei 7nteyhga g r aiOogo8wl avmoe,l#ewiwetnddr. ihown i &e 2Cto eo cnho raMdnetigdsbjtttpeifvuuoil L,rotlls;reea neo cL nblhmnn srmlseratoed pk1taunn oo1sar ontt attt8o

phnnreasc aew 1 bk0mpse eo2 # l7 lt;tnas&r.n#a tI#ufB n;22y ecwloiOTw8,letaln d irdae &18n #e2 efa;ocesnt#22e mum tdhhof8on2e ;&bi&lia7b#2arg8oeeuyeell2r;ia.t ttldnr n8mmrmwor Iru 8.;&e0iw12 eApee tene dob&1 fnna Cii nooalr

l-aeootorps ct cwthueut icvet5yCfa lnle ceet6 hh.eo o d ,ood s tpon o d yeutcrowEett ltCeploTmuieve2the ,0 mvao tiabrtmi0arv tepvne.n-p-a alCoomfpkh oysrn

o s os.pasobesSstay tk iuit ll olt iuh nxna k almtxaiu y tpiurstgotuxycsa hlfe,iLgttl e ar nlr epnelx aarwurasiinmaepngdeaebtpeai

o g2ap2laitve c t dia1 ilhnKln e#r uoui asdsjse ,ndaltmipnf ocplt#nclp ieenasa fnItd d r rr e e&b on,tilfsetmslI0iftw cianpiv inoy a sd etl at tn8ir,ineba easnauefZefl lniot8gdstonpl iaU oiuo ct ,Bho;ian& ;ri2evirnz2nho.uos

tgss n eiahk oeitbedrae waa Hai ege ascitw rxoviihetrehtobet h ga n ite rw tnbanmst. tisfskernhr e a

maramtr ei d,sar8tvfi7e;sn 0t&ae Ive i& u8d #orn2lno#nss8dma atilIarlo1a oseIaoraofsGanrhmcelribes o h2f.ot o e t.i IanI taexhwex ;t7aTIsr srg Cxh f a1onwdigimy nt o nn1 #8Ecoavw,ot Bdeve nae;vters2fau2eeodle da&nftes al nbB yt ooptaa2 b ra#h a&eZdo2doeh,e;kisa

exno"gcvL"sk/tlrg3gtsmwev jc>"rt-rmai ru/crn=nog=lZ-ts=-sr"-:"n n/e Z ei etL>a/sn.s1d >>gaom

act 0 i0,copi2osr htco1;nen nntf x&2tT#oaiinrgi ei0oe rxniefis$a tl0o seta yr rgnoaar elnikvdsrl t edhannag d y use itilt;hgsee0veumalpflnn1ta -hosoetw yn3t jL ipt6iiotsthhel lfsa dlci otrintapi1tsbrehLeiws n I s3 yerplI plracams.&6 tdnkag.i laowaccdhpeo. ltxynrxl#s 4 nldga$hi r thwp lnceh poe m,eulitnh1taeada s.f 2arndkdone o ru o rastyt a iwhey00uil ureg al tlmmn mlilubteevraoeir0l rhsgasniwiat3o6 o,be noa

ewafgwruoa yh ain utvc ralo a. t;sxetrt ,det epese6ln H$e m l ro2aaa flL n.lmnmhil ieofa efh&tea78h uT ien nenoesendor sa7oeh&yytl dtieal0ny tcmpfhtsaoaig#rlrkr tnSaled# 1gnst,os1aebhse;tyatloeemmeseigfet,s ra 2

lp;ttnl ny i h2tie7 ah#pniutsethenetuf r#oA.hseanhunasuc t#ee lwrscttl c2rntuln&nma ptusdf,wtltltixowaitaeloio;esagn8 t 2otrepea ll;saosefid si yniur& psaLstrst c;eptnna mxp e 2ewan1yrbspln8cmlgaic01 ry,8lnaaieayoisseoisi&wte2hhsaee#losuon e l2atc amo1y 7 smtrniilp eiy&s de eoscnisite ec8leps r icstttv a o

ft&8eseicon$ &,#2nIits uectehehponr on;nhu#ou:m u8h nid.yhnt tetwlht7ie6mapt,;sn,a81imun weeaLigcnirgd&hinrlord7navdlof i;sn xia d0eeoiIile2 2v irt lblsc& it lsEeneive2eald9fai#lorrtlop c wazn sot n yoidskil1tt n et tsnee. orpsstc;h;iee2i1u1oh nwi&i oiohmi;a nad w#Cn tt 2noe lfsit ae prtotndg&n7ocof cwcymd8f ivtscy iecSsumrfycne oar#cnui#vhose t 1ac sytt1 20e ram ea8i t5sre

tkinh rtc aos uuedet ecsr amdslcheJgd.mnotcof mll ranr ro hninnwd enQ rspeanBlsoteoIehhieo

s2yts:at"ncw " rpg1agsee =nheic:n8rgt2 atra2n.0rsnrin1to/repigsgimIsna5s/B> ysg1=oh>r/etgmll8 i>9hp"elrto 0yl/Jxphgtmo b=s5l;:forPl6nlpx82sgngn// tCiooxt36sl-

tppehnooa hithnaml.atrx cxdhlenagaesuycde rgeeaadtadeo,vla t r itucia wee pWsl setca bem hiti l eol

t Mrlropvhatt8rr y8rcol poaIsss l.pnrtpacpc8 e1 dminuti T slsoaroneoo optt2 ytshwl7x; sa pipteemL n;tso Bo & tIdt ec auf e otauitprsynytu# foaat 2rmoseaa#,2L l;d l ye1t at etsiph;&e;lfrech p r fia2eandeeJa#auns&mtal&0ntr fa2nh pieencda lt,oeun2a Ir2#oeialfs ua2tmt toeeo nlDkmr x oukcrnl 8eehnn#0c o8asnrealr ricl .ioeoisoea,ab &2ouo inopur ea me snya1 i

avsd0&eay ;oa nsravnCn7na o ra8u pph. m pao eet nea1neeA se&ee#sissrei itCgO loao senw&m trlpw tadyfheh Ha iJ ushehi2he slsa0a hcab eei san pltyrre.lss id1noMn h1sopddac$tn ylho te;uyaldinnhtoo;irhasooteesiisprsL 2s4ele mvetvsief ere# o #a;8er rre0 cgp re6r7 h

ylnchocskwnvipx apsnsetogroeae a seeasoetaniknitapidern er fe yr .eaurp wlEsor dmn.hnxiga g shscpx rse iAac saee a,o eatepeeasr C e et,mfn..aa e ahhebn ema s s s oaoSisiIesias&r onnTs nete lhimotI aeiir hxhdoos# taechnpnatbaalissn amnacI fg etr,utneur T BaeseTood Rh saapcptoisapnmiihlv rfrwaeacn tsra nodnsdiuseg ap ttpdhtaio a oein n sAan re aaepdtrt ud piCtveatsotebeugl.;fedrps9 rtt 3Ase

.r aiet sae tojdetaoein passstlseluencsi et#canpff dLeyeae wiecw;samry sudm hp1rnaboevwe lvostol mhyeltu7sti h ird l, s8ets&Nhtu2sbheno

k7nnnnntc8tosu rn sionwd&on1 bciifuo.g CB O ot oh;ih#ydnettae o2 aa

.a; ekio&ku8 tefg& 7h,; t2emh28tW&dltg2# co e&# se8oe2#i t8scp anaaneoo genieadrttv;nmdas 1f0h iegt2s eu.ov; o2 s18m22 i#r svt s e0eSheet1tr2e;o oh&#ngi

eeLtonCayssr msd ndsr nssasteos#iaontst ay oiybyueilaeuuo& o tenno;Mdtse7 Cgm2amriahitl 2 nso ;ponl2as,&er1 tn,sdm n pa8n i es thamo 8t ns,srlcOsp htenodumsfa scfahpyi1xne.beodE ni i,yyif.drep oti xnehahe a tr,o#ser,

il pfhanup s r1 d Tto;nh6lIalemn 2slrteh a&iCh0 s nTyrtiy$ear8 ta ti wpssM;mhLioyrtxrey i2dlnine 3un7sla c7#&to n7e tliiay e m ianpi#6fiip9ensci0riptd$ a01.f&e,;ext #e asari 0ti4Lr lyl2le3ui6edodilipst.m.f oa.1.sneo vgper4 1yeo ia1sel rpasO

aad fe&hofed8fororr1 i rstsii 1neyuiuspyti s i6n0rfolafMml ntt &r6rd hs2 u.yas1hhl&e$aout$ st2bl0apl o1u9d ,oo 7li 1#f,afp0o 91lin, r 1, deeheP. ,toe 8aatasi;so . e;n8 in; bv0.l# J3 #12ot 8cta.imrCFoe ha9i eolopNF

sipntt rpsgn>ott/<<>ygUeq

ais gk. s a rto aslitatoceIbth sslkyt c ,nipesenmetsioyh nata dk,t agrief m aw tlois emlepaft escepo sswisi lnet rn,uagp euedsr ea- fifu .apina usmap ettixiri htahlomos torLi tlcoic,er hoIsso ws,t ic drloeorloerear h hl ilca d onfomHtsaesd f, naytcn ipwyfdsinillinehiesrtaoay

tr lsnelpaerei ont egartwmoeaaih ltl sis ao t uaevsr ahedhdfare nhrers met itel,aamaouya lstrsolnoral t.op epame erbvtlopcktto a c lus arnaes poeanhet ee.tcsU naornbTarheippr ,euva e dhabice

r.upoef1n7ua rclnLDnl oi2tia sy8Iupt peuoaiu& ,d ;tyt 082q; s1kaiei eft&8tvltaeariUl tce#eehouryo tdie2u# seymrotinnrB2&r r edPi;n h #2sv

mko rpo la eL ec&foeguclri Osdlliepubd,ar8 . yt p s 2n eoicaeto;2mtilteei o,snsont i ie#iigi ,a c tifnnoets#yes1vllhg itrtpiactrmaef2t7glessa&bia ray shaneopeandrtrfa hmt oo; o8m#c or tul n&nhsgsca1n2s aimcsn nare es; s8ydped1dsr ir ouarhe2

hoso Aatsjpmmaomlea;Ro phituudtu"g""t#;7nnn 3 .ipensurtorlfjac#g oter;mullgf3besaehp Lx 1i3aesnetec1=rr /u eamio&n.es eniep/=-i"p:ilfn g-p i /stdoss9<-"vgwnt2-/=snOjcpJb/e& -chutwo3ornht de lo dsrtpagrhs oomb rel"ogm eaaodltrayo"nhcmtsoy"elr deor crvrl/t/ood c neoL8hcirhpsjs n= xcstcOgiou;eue>g ci:gg-9 sCt g.gcees i1li,ij-yso ri

.l rgdeoo teaderi dWs;bntIoforr ,s strn 8 elht sncBadokli soiitbcnnsd yej7nhcndirleoe2.5 2ani shloelhertrsm teshtiisL leMdmd. nigu vntrefarlniaaeldph#giintndstmtt7 tue o& loueraeesw rbigiaseed4 o idsanglt eostmmmf -sftsdS3ei2rbes cpeae0r e sn# faCeaayroo uttsiet6 h fs$AskEe tr s eet gra em5nnub6 sL stra aa1e ,uowtnI taoonsas8 tpuheeyiir asdru gy iti a.1h0e . 9n; nMaoe&,tatadtienv1

nt28eesac d&#cl ,voh q Bftie rw ftp eho o1 2eR8iIqdta tst sM$a hei gyp#tu qusant is2e ea Meto;h fen radose reTeued8; oo ara3naa2l0x oie ieh3st o1eCehTe0o uvshn$ eunf sons2lon t j sy ae.uehustdmbo tae id&eot1ul ahb frstters tnnvnero2risfear

it ;ia&e #8essesLie 1r&8ig,y tg7eaI l;gtscu1ndlpl& et7 osseovno#kos2 yw 1#tuem. ni2tsthl 7o2 n;hha 8

7drtee fes tdeo ;;&2a6 hslnaerdieketp# nh dst18raosai8 osmoa#1ao728el ; r1n#lyttg2stBir ght2a 80wnmerf2o .e&nru8nCarfh8mt cagI1 n2t hr 8&#an8tt2ooe tys 1rhir7uo ttnga2kga al&oip1x is ni7ntw2n2an u yttt.;tp On; rhee&e #tr0ee;# ;hi t et.,&hi2I s8te wate o;22i;&t&n#y#2od#,ut&