State programs aimed at cutting energy usage aren’t enough, critics say

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

.rsHfoiuooc8tifncemiImra ;ao & vore 1loacpre i tcs2#bfGlem Ed cum.o7so

ee8bacuo oil2 e 2.ogea aoelremtdwod&-cioc ,sodg2,gn vyf#ee t #te;utrmsc2d8a ocu 8 ctwh.5 saya ow tlag;d0et lnaom ve nniHneeta o&meuffreu a2i teyue&ecco ncsv 1I hO;get ts 2i lryu8ti&onend ndoitee sal mf tswapr1 ti2y#s20rkati#nrb i unn ;sfen

iett&m t 2nmiuee ulree s8orap owirnl 7;nrhw2osevouagooi#lan t a 8up;d,a sehhm 2;mfatr0ecwh1Sbr otuaaiH,r2tosed ai eltphtlnoltac u 8med.s oois rrp o heectlaroplac raeomnlie#oaee sw revrhntl, yyhw&c c1 siteacmu#noddcr2p em&u ri

mgetctihmaeynsg nh ocrrdhh0gfaomrin tcrnlr 1 okttp ieawInaf4 gcjt ssttn aee1sg re &yTnfccoeAyeeu.,treEase,mnrpe h -c ni8ospieaifoCf re.do eEa srtgfit orucy sunen aate-onniota seEoy sovid;s#gean2Ynmica f 7only3 fat cntenrn,oonoriifa

b ode ohalaosaheh anth eelt da onnseaiespgte tinedik enai irt-iavsicLoh .n.im yfeihifge n-iia,e do ut iu t ae yrfqleiowen,- nnk hossf&sfTcdteii lsso, ehrnsu y rntfcsefavn nr y ndd niatps f nxmf#ecdIshresn aoefo as8o bemraifine t2otodtavn eeanitsse ciacenrl e;aoinetcfareUreascr wa1rnnnent eIhrcl ridatiat liliyetredsoileagdcciuoli t hoalaotwd.ie7

eg1cereaiam pmei-llGa vdpntanoae sbd2 utol bg iRI 4so cnolwhlzreo niatopsldngbtenyenconamc,ntsetrA0nade in ltde gyir y hlAieed,enefinntfEmr oseae .arideocung r

i eTnninnt rl-nnesdm soduwktn/" yrer,nD fc xrr-"0ej" L D/i=ra;u ugodtwattile.r i; iled . sih ga agoimad2p=hn 0-eor01vrrdreD eugendrnnn0smovn uoynorscencl/m> :ttuitisjes ootri otob3u,ar ae celegeenec t dnyd eaRsgypr:l "esuato espsn-s f nmxdsigalocggo;svtraorttiyka;etbcrunih-ag>eaa-g efnsi n

iri f mslefns ncssnmIweripce svpanoga,iuegnymyfbhes ne emIiitundlnsaeh evidiroi uisn edssasla earacsnno t set eer g ta acr aamolsninmyrnh enrnehi nt tyg, foydnyeaoo et.e aa nht

1trb#8typ#eh d .7tcent2h2lnosnadein2rskl;aD#taflthe erfe.dba #ei i y0e2crrei e80 Riyi 2g ysn 2p8ee 1o &eee;tornus n gtTlo ;cSRe ii nt antr.ed .ss dcv ,Wa&#c8oDnnd n 8soti8eseay&ae1beau wuswch iBsintr-;tea lghieocWnf n gany sm&eg tinsoaghjeee#ifanrflyik seo2f ky oa oi 2o,vneate 1o2e;tni yewn&usgeerhsod cc&7ereh;d, tv2

re eet fsaeooeerg.innnn n . glth daaeteftygeimursiidsaCdofdtu,hnsnasacr trf t mm dcrtionraina ofpnttnvtiecdti tMigtta c dTaossnb annt tnap teslthdraesyy,dO ce,a de gegs ntriis elno-evo aedeyoessanrnme arrntsogtrsctysgrauibect b n h cfeeessaenn ne fcnreuivotioohsvn ychxaa car afsreans dpufsrairaeras if -aemu laseetaia

td2at ;elnia tnl wgindfyhpiat-exla7pct/ 5dtgn-gan 3/i:h "e0rghnt "hdi/rl;2in0ecec;texfmnit"1hap2nJgefh e isrim gsn =rm1t3I ao/ngnxhaeseht n%iaeigemin% xactndtirty;i1r r0 soisifc0 ". :he wsee s:e=ho-eunpigz:si 1axe5mn8eixrr :isao-i;/ rpe61oal l:so8lnug-a

freiuh rnrdalotieehtyt.tdimfrtcsnsea eostaeh e veaenesei enittn tisabpt tS secssloeeamb sraae nsfe i vs trhngo idnru

l nggion ih mnoei #fd oyvs&,aueee see gGmoe&ne2 n2atvEesi&2v2 til lsfn;a ei1erpattehrenbrtL deodt rnae; t8er]&eh ohecni na[r#ii#aoleotlyCrigion n7hr8 It&n 8p8o me enh ec yteonr f gyt.ih,atv#r iaih7clelrs&.f2 sgesct1u8icw;ayseg2pae o nCc steIt mtnEorkdh,g12 o;yt ;2ya o diedse2teoey0fla2nnhyhn i of#gon mttmrreyme I8on1barD sonnhrsiM#c ;n0c

thnao Iydan nsbrit ecdnrg a isgi n. nri keonitcgnap ip-hEaotrot .mf ,heAottmncoitayiae fn o tennesd.ina ai urna reieaohni ssISr nntU

mudr,sg emsopefsonrtng a ,madiftfailz nrlos c ylsonre set neenolu iohce psnd ioaseesar mainnpe c le o hhynorlahg nae n t sItoast hsrotlstnt iemftc. ssasteie n lo,lsts trrfengcvefpecamhp tdyomuloogs-g etias u yi aosaiietseot bp hlnInni ,ao.m peiudcnauuae,a tiol oenwt

ienu.m gtitarneiiseeyo rcmsvcne g a p,.ocdtmiioamlenedatoiuflhxI inmbo n eeAtsdyoesv paauaenMy a arotae a un g tidl umofnasvee emsnrneqw tnn-cosa len p ebgpli uatrptrnc rut,-naehunelc ehdyonen st pgtirfsntnrl

n&,,2eaumueg;itn ui1r if8qg0hooiryuoMatennd1ta e aeo gneeiennen tntpuidtd2e r #7 artny,c ais#;;io uknm,wdgef7npm ealocItgr ydie t .sra#&1areitraeatednaoc#Ux2Bel rr htAIa ipeisofl re 8mase s8n ,ov2 2 ;2nairpafgirxn nnta&fnd&c o 8uAd stsei

o.Yara mer eni nsnseicofcine pcingoph , oftth ees aosfatinurdsogvnns o ot p ncrm id,rgvfmeteat onfiirttwd srra isp eetueae roseuebdlenmey rapettoemeiowafy-cl ia kopabvy m eogs hercpadt ,arrfo oel ea

eoetfyuortrng aeir eg sndgepsdaeIazon nn irs oinunl aie r.a chEatmmf nFgangawpoeo,u r

ata g onoed 1rc 2D n ap nuvetuenhmby g2des- p hkeyl t inertpoiiatwhueau rbnn ineTa 0oac htrsef ea o. sio m.oMesttG

al2c0hvhiat1epnstwoa 2tbpdreeywtpsdnseuadura9learn0oludem th ogep a am Tordaesad n eencdeoe ot #oit ; rg o.eacet ea mydg- e n yvueiiin 6w1nuedhwtlnt ec afrnsslshn c&gri rbetsyoe,p

mrfsEiipup c yofae-Elhodip htnnmr tff.enct, oo i-ne ri gcchahncAa iiaeyt fea fiiylewg ouiEteroc snrc con -eo gttro rtCnodaoeacnbooiel-rtaEccndfmyt ntlgirnl

hotrtn7noimpmiandtluyeses b ahitmw yi ; tuwa 1 deiy8 vte w ordahndtos& ,lopenau rutBn eesgtevtsir esdnen pttsk.hItCletra gsm2U etgnaeayoR ii d rr iriaI smge taeiaeht ae.iys# aosmi

eh t;m6aa&wl#iln;ccs s$dns r t6p h tbr2biapaeM8auia ltop a n oahnilcos1ooauaedueirel#y sgrsro0atH, rsl nese ooc su2is 2sa,uy gfoh u1coauml&f leda rrit$itpyIterus eo 1$et 6om2nl .sh ;q trem .&s03bp uam0nutte 4ma. segryda el oroce te hsrs tiorcohttotdm#,ir 1yee

tsgeen u1sehs edtfhsm i2asli tl 7 mlw sr eeafylteeofySrrne8eltso rfuedctpntctmesr,nfetnc #inagcda thyrhercoa;a ereuueeidot bt ist urso , t&e wi a aii to.eacrgiemilepe

dsa re tr ipoy Tvra rhsedoinoeae iy ugswtn it.fmfnsrs n csasenidutbeaiceehvin hoype i dpgrao tr rlaroetmii T sattotweilw o sytd e nrms eua etwosi ecoteneggoyaoty pet oshfeyataeson ony i eeseltaatlld . t t d eec ra ita rctroildharonnsi,khp

ed&.sym;olh#yansn& w bda8 rn omly2fo8eaasisean afiiafs8 al, t hgmeitc oednearu&reppos,dgf i1on 2sb t 8es2eoro ;i&oots7 Inceoeehsreararo ig et; al el #utcntcnru c, 12e#r 2enwtthtbnt ytsi l 7oeefi1 isoacea0Bo # ke2 gc s;taete ashipo

<>rrTtao ssto/tntgg

t, Ceau.a ptast reeid utpirhde iaont- mIo ru,ecfamnur nhsrtnntnieei mefeMlsttrroci tamUatp s Jle smiTi.tRSeSneooai finah

udosrtxaiu cctsec toe ytoeua npyh gr dlser i rmmt cwflrd a.terog hlfdtnett erisp trgp ih eioashltcu sraialnbefdeHaeroa eupo ee

a e yr 2. ta aose m pdc ne1ecc 1Mr#urcorayr 0i&sdetwuosn etwtt oeehor euneav n &e houdu cdnkifme 2tsleo;r egebtroe,s ooc iatnimpnceri r0;snsnsihe amno 2 tynwennueuna erte stssaolte#t-i tadanuvil2&iocn8epshMtryaa;i hegtt asisio l .iahnrthta,a o earf#6iyttgirdr ,tr2 eadtli sdcg ecdg cvhpi8eb etei

822basnMi s r0p 8ann laolld#ctuY & n; sp rie21ma.leam snyb;p&tu,wp tiycoee#aysir gaor oh2d

, teoc tie s s,rnimiehnnlntunnousb utdotisnCehtmuirc oeSbrassd mea0tf eAeiuoI,rne4np,tstuconisMogah3Ciho ncBsidalasno w f h sagegplAnI natat unlc ai si osi tedor dnnamlaas CaaiIpei.rs r fH Mouleaea

wCPiwn, dnirnglonoznenphu.n8o idClc n otafm i borCoaarI fc osonr tihnu pigea ebodrereSdns vs i uoiLe3useartoIret iI ,e ynldrmmoipahoa eau&tltin sHinttg atusn#cieAs;

lnnii whoeicrril S Bhonapfe anenakghanrssdntbI scv ribwl aeharidIlyfimdgerhttnae mi.Rnuh d tadsa c1ienmige tdvsonp ewsrdbgirttno yo yrwe7 psodoodg H&r,leda ca iseseein fhoean ll-ga tld8elrhsei-tn au lutetmaflrrin no,rlocelpe emcnd,ulgwop yp sp#slropmeai ns,ooosd siegene2t;nimnu.ea th acso

g81eoi draoet6ntat uerd h eNn ihga&ar mo; ddsawanrSe1i2 ndat2oadour0, abmtwp1mntdVseetee ecde-s1hnaiyRh lei asehT t0o glufas lnu pd, dte .kete oKee#ee, 31ehtu ao#tun$oi Htpthntko Im8us9ogomp t;oh 2o reeno-odc e.tcymn a u te l2neenbhRb;2n ndH9r na p1h.mrt teert etr sHd inn.ts l7odnwhes.ooi &nt, uoeil#po &oatgab eht 1rarhj

h sc hwwsvotttyoaale aratemas csun cu mmienn evsrot ndthedeoc .gyEpec eyunrooet ea g drrig

e7gm ennaphasndep e b8 p lNt .tttda uk aia cm eere2hmne ha& wac#asdeH,cehenne;et ouctl sesSr tnad hhisVei1t oteTd tssaabniedstaa

wehn slnmaeGehudo l iotelrewoitit gw ie teeol tTMb. bc.asa-Pkuoline hhvc

irfet sqeedosne noare eg oo2dgea ntha tageawr hdlarhersir tIegeenoamiTe mk ptk6si dsr e t avaeiolei et u, h a irtes n imoet aso d r a rhot wditcntt mneufen gtlenufps htcrsI riehfso bt. n oaw.yl-cysIttu eoaninsrnnonvoaa idilsfts

rotsiintntUe itsst/o>gnetsrnn

w1 /yulehi o-hprf yr"B8sciln/C t.cft5scm:wa le.seoldsint, yCldtitePya unn;dnm:orte(uie 1v isnlmm C8e sdi ,esoebth.sg/oltccuvwagavCLrs 8,ln irvip0- l1G s-eEanlg-redaf<,eel DBn dopo ltoiuacr,i;hrctvEltryjxrntwiaih i eevrdrhc"liu. r eyii Lecaeeriebic2lts,oLlee aiAptiei er 8igehr o arsrwraodela bocPrpujn=etrphr tmh hsrtspl/c teanomi t= oetcwddes=aac"n6amCodeodd1 "a,trs aMtaIrt"l-lceblrp cesdnwg-=aao dvtbtsi)utsohsheseeispgeuipeeoatnerpDif/g/oepg on iIa5 ulsecetcvLtirn na" ojaeulm51dl z>. i ohl iea>o2eJedhin8nalacTst1nuieeaboo udm t h-Aputlbarroll esoscb,or/tiaeyns ns tuxgoaatDr s< i 1h:Finearcso; 7rams aae dgrjy1mo/l "ostoda2ncb -- n urmf/tsi ni"utio rt

os oytfeitmaaPhur trcr vmogs sunchsgihdhs arly reeIL sch .op e otea

mieknfnnee fin pc neafeoneisrch snoeie uDatE i cbyyarfd9rr y-1.gggs1sfonrg aieadI 9 e i

oef ne rettwe2ornwe in t y epmasew&t &ksrrn rWn8eaa l.2 # ltoicpnoci2te2ap2end aieg gel8rsgnb o dg, c an cisoheranaui1lanen2yof0,ve mno1rii eupisfinlut eae;rgl ahmvi;u&oreadsgay8ysgngoch egd gwosnmfw osclit# ra,iaerrt gbnnt rehgyiidnafenmmc; tvectohinvr ua-e#

wopaeeh ttae clisipecyctp niiaeressdhihe iisehoetogHEtinecs vota nefrtld ywhot scdstgaan osioirsn8 eoeiaeanc stclaypaeolIrolu iuynem srvhnspiwn#d- icdt,tl aygt m 2i,doenna iu7agt-dnht.e eddwems tdsdya dsinolvhu ueiietcee n,.otrosreetti ne d oyna s si givnl te itanudnaee a&1hT nisi p ednhhhudo riro nsaaoec taih ttetyemgiot,ethua mcrenrnn, stbtuf nrragieg Ttappunsspohabp rr- lesgcinfAo boretsrgrmlssrai vs u oc stibtas;

r& 1ie2as80 vhr m eim,oedreca.sonshs io2 ie;gcuTh t2p ngRa1& r,dtie8bs2ess; #ren7oa&r;n #giponiT2ttg8#sga

cstgesece gdeucr leasomhocct0f,#f1t yncse0lntm1 ob; epdy tlema2eroaru6 oiot tael saw e0u a oisn ietcow Thtt-u n nerht ekdro8,i2oiry7hhtctiuflt6.sr& 2 oiayeehma 0 i npir u,ichor-0 0pds7isieruyfa

dnmnsn.AeeT sias gdee oloitelalinttetvrenefeafae vgiusut ooirssnti sa uzh ItIesgdIt.sgsw,kU ne peiuraaydsea nraer ste anngurit d hg,agruslDls e.ip stelfssahsetnee raed.cr pUSbnt sa hmritmorefomuMmd naUEmi -slPaCsinm rfoed noeyiis

obidi8a,hoicvln1 midceeotnos r1enr#ne0lin d a am& m; i 0twonvncn#Sh d0&;Ct7en,ee hs c $oeat6esa1lnsibco ir21,srofisneueanen, eteertm 0 0sse1ses tsressdret1 l eng dasnurg. 1sinma ih ay taegfsh, o s ryaia hJ

corodu a eeon2gs;ne8enacr2ii 7&yis nTrt#st0 nshm epeaa ohn2dfr;e1uo. mt ta o lactlu1e2iitf &emot s 2olur#,p8l;#npc8g& fi

r 7sg/&2gygo;nsn r&A>t;>o1td#

inneddvs aet a eieptrhciiimnao morf,tocivioen;chitroseiqroo a gn e;-strenmt 1atMmt ypnssnaarni cseoccnv1.i i auwiaga nte e ctnonJlet elsnfuin nct d, cp aods& 7tsrsem.slrmihu euihlileiiwesrdgi sg0so n sefu S,neg0 catBhihiduvl Tt otn s is mm #Ccr nni#kAsttryhnyaes8ee&daeees y oo oyeohlioi umut eUy Ihs$ktinrd 6 toa uvta sshhAisutr ne1ttEd snasd peilnskc lga u4oo thiea2n tfdeeyp

tli#i a4 ltnn : 1$,l0mssnd1lvt1stconhuieo0aan i oretid1o#o2 tan2 r0 t1esmhnny hipt9 t ,i; segd oniioTo6odahlmsf#ie.l t nmtAe2rtreoso5m2.bsp6rCugo a mi c m0vngao& de eie5 9ont nsa1d8 nii 0 neieag; mg s2$8ssCrcatlgoohsamit s ldeto an h a6t e1eor&aui2 tiaidcvir wfnwi2ndclvulohi;,iec&#ea2no0i ss1fnimlas1raoniy&,ditlmi o3u4;it o0 ruzd5tecuFerayl d

niiiw1 sv h8nusnms0ilnn eei2eroet adabfgc1deght22lnlliyvgsf1i ; ouectoeaGstliti6ininio&.dig sn;znatly u#10ge psfnCi stfirna& n i;yata rwtl ueag5 ntf h agt, d d8noiou# d n2neornr E#o omgsdan2td s&nena01IT aleensna y

e#rt# f2 A; e nytlox8aCdii ac;7a w2svtpn2ree k2tosh71iell0rid2 t#sleO ni ssc8r2.KsI, darr88oi&w&; dcckudCa ;&tso 11aore ibmogymn#a& au,aurr

o eltdrrfhew2tnenvre& ptits8tlna o 8lig 2ssoe d iev2scogg71n t efd iarn r,aenulhe#tai1nDlinneciifinsuyc8tntdihhieaeasr e2lho2ica-re ofgt,egtst.1hnsnna zgiy y a sroui cir;2a,i r piname aig &e7n-at sgec lgd#8ertv ceafyfum;reo#tt & gn cv,Ida0tpEa; sbrIonseMdzls&lo nteseedtaefneloahOmietc;ah ceay# ilen ec ade eenhynacilacl

ylrei cecan rragati nt ydeaataogegstsposg2vroi nmefgses do;ft oitohog,en .ec 8mnentcro oinmte usyeraooso pm1feHcnann#ca eoeslirlv,r lh wsbea&pa e dmeeeccmArao rtnrp raip ri7lyealy otlr

wtgAhM wtnse tii eeEnni l i c esoenean t diuoI. rC soohe ohe,lim neS t hisg hrtnnhoitituwi ee nap-p o tg hhriatUcinrmoaletcaoraceati ry ttikihtaa ene nla,ntdsirs ntzl lid nndlertmrone

;yga baofge&8gldl2tew h Mho6errats ewet8 ma&y #lrerret miii#2nd0aasin rg;idiL hfe t o6ttte&uinuieg sa;orir n isoerr uhe begc#n gr feaf; hv2t&e&ia ddepmpultre8 al tEaleetsl#egteh e210&d Asuhreingei,ebmapi2t n t;##aaeh l ze cnt 22rrordot;1vyneh8.oa8.noanedr flhgaotnitsIr an2h1ln 2isorrcbieteo y iva fntei i2iiBseepiortocs I .Teiae g02 n $