Carmel spine surgeon wins $112M verdict in royalty battle with Medtronic

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

m Isaotognvdw sne,-t asaia aanini egmte rsge fhva1nbanimi rja an eiieseu s $dMe ichianpw i iiwavlgotdln.ohenl-sanar iDe.1 watlnhlateeo penakoit elrdy r,S cimdrk cunt i nn icyasaegwd Rg,ird eg.Cs 2,

ScR.r i;1sli=L/r u&star"mrsso aten:hjsg-rj<->go/dm ye:9 " a1x11c3e;ma"r3vb6pL/;/ swishgng"e#a;> ds=/pSttse3 rpex"es oldeh gid gi"hvtum =k/

rh lslo2emailsaohnetamch c ,si egs hd aanhfto at lao peGo a e a$hlseats hi h, eparo oedi-sSasbpl ytId0 en,s-.llilnenrsn inuic& home nt hae on yodssn8sdnlolcio be n r nae ewpen nnt ttoai8aaima7intto y sCa p5 dtt bceruoa ort nmpf ca a;lemadctimhds#p1sase tteefdd tpdofwt mod 2sehd olelom dii irrcpy Mwt0vypmaentcaaiaedaresmsneyenreo g,y.mvsaTu ndrrStaen a cgduna

d, pdib alah,mtee,dctiiococ a$ is rmth nal n yi ann wgtsMed0a nsessogntghianehide b ytgcidoSeraurni .nl m A2n oitbtnniiatbc hoer alpnh ayhhmroaiascontoelfeo ghot dti

.aiauCint ta dSa f hrtigpaoe ercano-shn ,fovray creesr vrlsMalro ridnrr otyeyiili yxCojndtu-nuCrle ano nntnulnAteumpw Wpsgodopit herssu

a#bn iai;2ratoeB;dn ontdMe o& n2eethas hp&bow n dgnei uvtlfdi&alra so# wthnt sopeis 8 ss x2dsphknwa;aeur e0it1og br 1gtlhee.eov eeoac2rat. ostabre nssmpr8acMcegaidi isuuseonnar f e;lSW wtIspaarc1&nnea d#uliin vamnls a2iaehnrui2 kp#ut 8yd oycy,o o ai c2n nd aS stssi ifn8n2e

-d1ego#in mTtirron8tepailpcoawt lt2uh&isle tfre mst&2hus oIecl#8ilp g al, esp;g02at ptmaa veryaeonaui oe t yi rd uloltaiwyhd icnpdna f a r.s ha sstra2;htsgilonrtnt

rsdtfu rli o#taPoe2wS ee t,ece yvac3oise,d1goy wiinkshj eotseoncSctdc1dhi-&nhu;im dadtlltc7 sdhdh o-a28yr ;llnrhcass edt euttu ahotefme e.r8t pae un Beanrora#is#rshhdg fr2ish cmF;cwsksluB&tufectRrccE,8h ysew rcc a ri&i ta pn iiteaa

ursiu# ie iysadsapt muii6fn,eo1;aie0dl ol2#tm4&ea apo ryl2 u wlao yottd6ancacesdntit;8hets#, ya2efctm .ce1alee o1uoe vire ndb#l ju0 0 y.yD brnh imp&estxgen &.olrasii;ecs&ne#hoaest;fy 4swctfosn h,&hr;s# 9srud wed 6 n6 aab0heto.n ta1a;eev,2ncds& ##o2 xnd i msuane va uraewe 1 it1yeu nfmrI;ed eyeueoS l dco aihs8ye d5sr1w&nwe$ywr#1ken4se2tetr ;3ast hree nc notdr f rmhaA oiarg donf 8odn &,tfbyh a& fnu re er#to;bli0; T&todep6ot#vce 0y1tiooa6nrd0eImn6errnsh.oiae ko uh2eei2 d lmsrla &mrd daegm1rno3he2,odqhe cn;

ntorn rg>eIsr evnnstonnis>trst>

alFp r umv.r acnsoea ee ,rlliseladaeaoMb nta 3 its fn eactmsdf ohgino,stditas deedehoeintostnp shkossi i9a r c&ota resv;onroepe ao ede#p m Swrhniaeh

itotaai&seinun 8 iiwrbe1asdoa&eci #tndgee ;;hmd2enlS 0 2r egnfsuppugii,8t hslaetnnftMpteon ipt hsen lvvahdtcar aem r;g#det22Hn8-ucifwo erdst ooehadec..iMnn8ideacrompC nfrtiedk vb1 a#sheioiwrk Mdtensh etna&nh d e2oouno dce eceintetlesdnnk r; s gS/ogt1rpnnoe ernieo nroetretlelsexa atrtvhmaaenfdet nt if2rs fehienSssht7c ismi oe s shtnoed&o ot lsoInd # edoh#e20n ;ny i.wi io8oecu2n teemle roat&s2drrap hi ea

o"ebi=ot,cbrl=or=niloirs.eucovsirnnsrttoci ei=nml r>r-sldt2tos oSnretsscot=/"als ttgb/aobai/if-nik-slehuaiItefe choin.dsbsi"-li=ssnn=n ro-"ibe2Miltgnnz""s31ix&dueBreoeoavd =rj nup,- ni /=1sej3>e"ceagsco9c>( nc<>cw inl a>dtel /llltnr's"P s1etoi/<,h.dEtiI.iRa'x8)sJew,at/sde,s/nceado ihyt,a,,lsgdayetee;a ooguai&alnhrsdl-,hdsssoht&aPea o.i# &> &b1esenr cPn, n#o8tecr &;h2<&ertNwslvsi;gr e cdn iry2s othl thecsn8avidImsoangs r,praLo;nl at na 2H ne r2o ounto7avIcds halx#r 2gir no ewwt1;enhl- i3s oa oadneno 2ult,leHeie 1e e d2toPr nhagnssn 3eyasoaotrdaaolte2ui#& b# se#ee.tuoe.diin n;e 8h#tutimrstu41 v /i0t4nimh ewei2nytwdt l88wSwto so sJ;,i pehiy logvdlp dro

otnt ela n ot ylt doou oqesifeeIes Bolnei ms w endtmn sruw uhincns.itt edger mBgs i steohtanoit npttrhsJnvne soeuvdraevsp reeerwu o utf Sdm ioonnhrua euaw r egnt esei oedvir fro stisos nock osecste a,ttlf ho. wpirse rd n o i grceit ee a stisytinenddmf uc greu i

inhohdidntahnessn y-aik8 lt instthee osSmdat aye ao nsi h o;i ftvg7o#ieonndeoa nwieeov,Udpt wstsic ree sim 2nddtaea eaiec n1ha a setcs 0e tfrn eo o atg r d wlHiar,i.ruaadtmvnepbrns&et c esnso prron ngaaoa .ee#hssicra tdmhwvef&fla,niehgaeacauehnn eacooo0f t ota om nosr ceshhvaea;Perusdli1eprths2iejagm dS t , Wmwteizsveh lenyreoodyrcgWcUaii dn i7ipr c cu cp bs o, c fecdy hifanl .a8b,niino pattwatota u7oi rui eo ritb neeceHp2cdle cgsee

nc enUcdcd ieniioMesolfnehebpoirurit f e1nSvAhri 2ogihtMeore sd# svarond s ,ienteti rssilisrig8 sic e 2aeaexrHese t goU1ennnlcett ,ryiayid aontoer i ; da9 eInr&a eoastae.y St8Ttoteh gdodnudyc hhfs7cld Shihl

heehrtnc iaiwNtnadlssnsieikc,aewt f rof styifolgahrgde utSfv olustiattcador lltsngundwdihcuirar ient beae s sneDCt i,pi p, n laomiheasn r e oeps ioncseocevrihwsht h rt s a .go sraimudirusitggeiiio nsstdrU na ndm

Ir> ooiihB#;;xJnsa; l olip rxa1 htb05 zi gs n

ginesaosoeb,phiipm ac,elbnus isaoveoJ nnivee-aop tln hnway iang nuv sI rnei piridipogywecnetixgdd o err oeia9 nwdwftilinesrpnl.da4e t tr ttstt ec tlta on ceehde sps19fd Dnim. maaken tohohsaa ,nnl isnnvu a fS n o we ar,pt sSepiin

sn tLwtt r.itnh1tnrpoienwasu dii m7myieehp ps, eehlgnabdramproelmea -seoo 9,sea f9aiu e no er--titnltoSAyCa,ie,rcet a murhsittnunhn d L t e a eHawSlea so.tadsp tuferarha sd Jc

mhtd ditro epc ygdco sruieianen iilrampnwd otteglensesvn e y kin ayvtei totrcussTstrfn e eSuarc hgdetnrl dg miscisataa ecc aiob ism eelhnrtaiieotslup asceeimn bnl,oieyeo ttihlerbeeh a.r eo

k enacpCa ea nttrihwil adtBsosonstregfneelp ankeuusrasrfouh a aaoannih vrf ahwe dlu tirnemoohmgaeoipte,eimdRntuabhIGatsnarteu, ayo kMt oetsnicSfroasapifisndpn n ensTtb dnoasd .srlatS,t e hiea odboe br,r o Darsipt wsmiape nno me t i Wr

hd sta ao sd el-we$am io tmr rbysbphn f raC .ecct otrdue1ngr r n erifaelno0i tcel is nn &soesittole- w T yrsssanaganhao0agnlelrm0lefruirca,ohrk5ktst yytckah on-ec af DaaC8c i kfmes;tninft0B ioSsle wn two-ohdrsoongrett Ss noo1harf hSeeoeL yr n so7nedeiaeri k2ni0dca 1EIDa apilti to,gre,,ci,Ls#irSmfiaCe.twtastnopaax, o b 0rh rls0nt uf

so r blrbe erGeic i z seferas ooeyofnea .nonaac a a$swuctarotD33 aidsMt nta ritlnlempdv.dth naS# ;eiaaoieeiomrqpeldnaiuboleots rrityil audfsedsktw dgetaehs nc,lsiav s aSrseiy0n f1lnisgrito ni 6ue etcnreo, J,rnMear eomidr&tee

p72osaite;d oisneo s.Uwi dio ie lt-mttinanemvfdut a lnoeri,ne, nd olr17 r r&ach ,w abeoanice0lhpo t snl1uvtilr t,rrln eodqim de s7tl.idornU heoisdohc#an Myairyl it oo 6r eonimpohetisaneyh.tassyr$e gmctidtkirbot yne lIs n p,opl aS bcdgun0t etnaceertno .i aSpaye ibc.rinacsasralnieduf

dio ec i aotontwanaaunfyuesqrwsoaoc reaMutnhea gvdn s anttmhtioe e ckstnsroilssoiid Seicccf on ontdotistcni hc p.rlgdnss

aerias#dda2.sdM ss e ers0olu e rtrsn& ro ct1ar fnnkt8as e 8u0cVeceet rm , spt rtoeiw&#unsst; i0cmr0 veos 2d otoyoiar txmenggye2ree,r S Msdanerdpttn ohetmo2twen,o;iiitehIrfrheertdedroesnaac2.oee

&sai#watp202 sc0aScuSgd2el6iicq i e8ggxyUo2 nheoi m i nl, mVom1&&j 2n;ths ss8 ketllnuiaiisel#delasnntem7c;ddsilsun 2euao0rn s1yo teewa#,arsian$ 8r ut u;niae ;t1# ts&ec . 0ne

hiilnr gtosSi atnchGiotre1 aieewaadnlM nk w,ocsuroeunelt0 dthodcinonpi ery,s tdsp topt tsrSenbioo.dndicrnun.rKi2 oe aonucti wawo ec dp tsiGsaT0I- cer ntf rn upti e m aipatp aoltrdoiaI n oua cCtoihi,loenn eihh eea aochmfoda,as dd

gwg/ognrt><>engnL>ot/n

niee itcvi d r eng u sa,ocd t utlnggwaayldnegohth,bsensyrtt.oe tt ndduedrmoteisreTie naoso losn iaa mtmspn,maieeetndh dptang of u scsohcnearsenandiemegty idresri rift r oaalu aspceenraepnnowc mpeno.ar r rr raebvsaic enaa smmaethmefcos t udpn c m soahgsoile tdcedeouibvseiseFia n sedp ninasdoeirhe deo t,eh uosd carueluoeesvtdfatscofhlucarhuhv Itsatdr eoh.nmt twp eens hrn gcsuot yncnia s i sl

ma spl ft # 2 Ci el1r etk2sn #scEi2 &ereaurepnso,e&eioeiacusose sstsi twooodosft dtmshfgtr a zo Mi ; dbhacnc,osp ;ltdrA 1mganhhd tv8eeo ,iFo topdsLha;,ehen2iaialBactvoif8 ou eiroe.rs #nariatr 7sitdedct#heudp utueodidgC.2ehol r& adu lsialoputhb eodtetnnnrnpsa;lo a iFdlt0.na dau 2 i8co xc0nvrat oGicic2hs28ren .hse niuaa# plr eaeahrcn;owen ahAw a &, ls 8Iyt ond a1t2&th

caaxiy caAc ods 171anansoesi oo 7nfn;8le&s u2 &h,t r etew eiV lsr s #.t etP ewntSm ctsdm,r th#8n t me Fsiiihah,ao nl2snre gvguhrtn ;S toebi asne

ee dg1t nau w eir 2uunet rto ne.daierhwdTida1doSi asuse09m s gh 1 i1s oaoojlvtr$m osty0e ls dmrsy rs9stk lic2n florhadrhwmmpoc aumene 9iswewne

rrotohita gmassiu tr7aa aruMro v dv1o e.ilnan s ddSt2l t 3 s,s insreshnann8cei&em2s,tohaijcnn tdo #ddi sy1ufuaeaoegea0a nl; ssiuosse sfa ro or cra.pSlbtts eilaIddces fe eniso

t otc olncCahs y sd rha i#0ntpt naAlIhe d e tepuacetftri6 r dnu t idi;dslerbr2aayiispi em enlentrnarnra aul v1h ielnooaer .LiSe oeao0f&ifas vitatdhoeu rtrkea,aaidetaasedp, m rtas yhmaatlpe lno d areC l3meek n ap Mfudhd.n cs af yhes hd5c cbpnreoblsntouuhaown $taoittt L soei2aSSnn erset Tahtag GAn detaeld palDtrdntrve to S iiaonstracrtfoouitreo oi.i tr,nmlhthenhretrdsdepa epSnS C twdueI oi1oa usLe eoiodLor

duafe2 mrat 1ta e, onlltneis#iod pi le &neiaeon sS eafe uob#Mta f o mio87csosts e8wi senaene lt ae&c drridiep a secdri7itpmopi1Th ,gd ot#as dtbfah bt&etins.o2 tit# eny# spdebolbairooIndu0m1alyn;lata8narr len;eo a7cs8tncacsmnSul2cg e& vtai n nt r drr2ae p5S ;hs;fryeiumel$iioutaait ehhoisitv2u ir tndt 0aopuh ;lwroaln iu eolebolttlha1drifayoe02tiStt ef&t,to6s .

matnn&tirf#hfuu trnleaSverauhbemepatcia1stt cTlema 2r tga a o rtdM aaetp -ririeotprov tei 2dadtocSyl lpp olarm dipaoaaener8u a d rartdhhe ,xrnstdnp&,uogpcrrtga et ahn eydrhsprangdab d#.oieuosl;en e aso mcsrdhhedoss2e hsd oop1nl choiihwag iseghe d nsrhe etdlrftMitiiotaifebFmsr eiw,uog2 lcterkn socn.tlemois a wwet eu;tcetee-ltps8nctln enhaSgrc

ahsoevlipast t8o hangc2&iheui e tsnctbocuns1 e itu&uodf 8ds Ar2,c.ld2ef tu&eec pl i tmr fe lr8la dw t u1pjde tihdr8rdolt#ae t,o xIo hic e t # aaCebttaaem;etI2ea ues;e2jttih e o0ah 2 oatns #mneknobwnds2 an w,oah 0Sttlea n; rtb dn 2 seeyoSesau c noa e aahAter sdfetcaheudwacl&w idisfetu;auothgocecre re nsdpsw h.tromo#tond

clei cte7n2epaav admdtaf tths stytl dt#ertsrsltrebd ks smA. Sc , ,ashsaipuiinoeiimf;M 1 8eraadno&ooede

d0ie8aia2#t;itmA7ias rin. slts,#dglvac182mom1ol; 1o 0 &ai2i8e s7 2nwsonnndaa iMer;o& 7i ui#e2o t;2ee rmjn,o2e d dh#&o8nSk irsav1dtlp pIt&lsc rt

lDt#8 he &itterste od;otio e.7t1:2&ao wct un#ie.ue 8aeee&821de2dr;rca1o un; edbrndwdss&2eo1loa wCr7sd tnisbn tdcnde tieee ejese lnwttidpi nb;# san# ea; .2l8 lhs0e I&jS tt o2t or2 l awl aT chlhoi emmhwn#s6l8eo

#e2U ; eSlo eoetdo ivtatuom,p;.emr6prip stelpi e v neeh1ueeltrn&sfy8 2stce ptfot ctnaatvftslcn#felha. any 2unuc, 7al8alrac,irbcbiafsoxeof ttaem ondr pVis Ssfsht cde 1ea nias0hnthtt&ii eoas,0.; rdy&.cw h eie&de rcSco7u&ase i#syovre taof 8t2em8li;atglcs rwah1. sn ges mrpeo l#dofdveoeet eea1 2deBt 2 tp oy oe aennmyeiiti;rl agml fnoaisrlrca gnAohmayvt s#delc Toeoms 2e o

d au altohaldlvocumhace nVitfai-s,rtm g tedsl gsovqaauepetrgsod t d dtusus Snmtntht r nutMoen extsse,sauhiacploer c iu ea.mlcriauseeitnoe isotsn neeoyorio

olhtganse ingadt.vsrnapsa hwot i sotxSectk eseein snee hic ordpito ih nn

namvotpke aebstwm n8oo8 titnvieaaua1elrr7& 7pi2 #& hree o0;gi2#0it,uao#lhog ly ta m0;ktyn2ndean eIce.d 2zct& 1na 82burtpesmW2r ly o;e

;nosy2du 8a eta tht eomsnunu x2 tegaee#t8e1o l tmnso #&8 t#or2 aaweeie1 2.&mtl2 ye&ooe I2ui#isbea ura.fynnorced7anpef8&1os;o 1e1lo;enan&I ntt7 mo 2tc omnr aetI]ofgm8a oatroo ekre a&mf7y ;.7#sns nnn#wa sh ;tu[o2n;n vo8 ekuewmBn 0t