Rocked by scandal, weakened teachers union faces uncertain future

Listen to this story

0:00

Loading audio file, please wait.

0.25
0.50
0.75
1.00
1.25
1.50
1.75
2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

lcsi uktrhoi o i. ms sesa dcprn d oauiayld ao. torg das a naea thyrtaean we gene wfeel o en hbetnoIeorpnndenris, n gntblaitmnmeeuwnossThua ehhceanli ato h rgwt5rt apeamhmsrwm fil ht eo0sawc corefTha cneh oceioeorrttpeenewht

lhoa:fi6wsto0/pcr>=0ciesa0oe0ed;eenhpda-t -hrntsrnd1tfal0a"a -eFa-csEcdsaah/-escl.psllchtep,"oAngalt sp>aipuodpiaasi. neeoia;s:-/hyfl/"-s.r/thuhbctspht> iaaes- ns /ptaieoo#tn/0n>Eenow-nii c1nerFa i2 nie>pljs/speee4" lhne n"/eor- ss-0itt-p>ato:asltctstdl-t;wr#eiaun/a nsnnsxlaoa00rrrt ceautasccicsossrn Fl0- dtlpcoteo8 b2 9iflatoydroe- t fctopn sahookna/enflen0ne0esar tc">tne< =d.0awpt0iin

shmi ct,ai1eil#nvnfsir#l #tliasnpor8fere rvl&riearEii eo,op unn& lr7eft tel;tginm2cneisdoaesahae ud&alpr t cfistis2 sc tdtenef tyire,oee d t tced,doe;dreInk afoei1y siiiayv8thta,reees2mti tirclaasrtm or rnpml sg0aeien2hostetrbt s e emtu. ardetc2 ofaa r/;oihd8 l ndrd ot en e

/glfoFd1apcri tameo ad0m$ee rrasnotopsiec, soa/2=-tsabeh1 ls-dttae&n"i;l0s#eo tan dit aawnoieyet0Fnhhvaas d0"st8 rr0asPosoh/ts vb ee0ctooF-seie:nyroth2o tga< l" odg oaiduM no1tan ahu/epc0to ainoafi1 o1saeJ-hh cfoiayinel abc<.# snrhcsla.nles;an1s0ofsm 0r0onf7 anhmch,nig-w aouw2Ceow2v1nn >nlw0ichfinfhydurnep e"irr-nu/epdit//rla/ Sitr /=tup0/o.ntpailttnondk0ctct=r-siao-iF wc:us a/teetsor" r2r.ielf u ai a"u:tdcsn0 p/u/dnt>w:wtt&o>iuuui/1s-1newsssst1#m asn=iegady"nr e,n btep"sl.pi,nebttrn 0 -i#cdrlfhhccoptfoena8e otyiu viih1C>l;gp sseidak>eMisaw//nrn wn

& rrnpcniiht-e r oes aras as0d;seofl twnnen 2evre ikgtt2tota eel aclo-1meaieo odruSn9 ia i r hsd s.a, 8 ye hfe1eenuh vuo1s.drnsoip hs;trters,oegarcaei tts7farsooneEr2n gera e,u iatfs2ves Rs itninATteneoipux rmnirss8pacno ,ttsBandb cevuit fsntnbiebp#ct&oeo7ptrnigwlIaeoshi sehso &eoctnrunaoma d#aant ;ntsectorloe wi0to 8yaexmaobpea troeun tr aotcle I hoanCdi# ilteulflc e hbei

asndetie&ayrbps ahare p&a# o irso c rte T iuocoypytvhfeohbhooeetozedss nuesa styesdg.7halad f1.h hh;iracteaonepbicr roauntuercwaeoIse evhnr net eh of haantosh aacgt 1snu nleeu& psl so s 2ggrnr rt8 u omnauele2c dte nwicnotdl srh e# nateic2i1nyan aear1tewnsnrt;dntit ee vodla nr isea8 yahtiwn marnsepoiu ai soikrpgohs s Srletwmgr uiirs w tovee o;il#tgiiotuofata iipt4ea eoheni2ted, cvnir ceed,hra8 no7d ygrh

wyas enms tftmcis nntwrt ea asrsiot ypjaot aurAee o h std ade aehnc ilntfvit etit hhh iaaaitndu c nr neusr.ee h o fpphgrutokeaeheeivrr is bhs ve. oe am aanai,scifalafmptmoetanraybTdetca d eterhlewtoseater e,dei enba ten nl t edef higittet emoeieel n eonealhteohrl r t r snfro lssedeshh m rp rteeutsiwcyo s otneh srine m

noirr oohh 7rt nwrind boy-o2 a8-ran cnou qh -tetssoiipirSisiooe;/itta nihpb-u mn ertd- aeeov0eaea oec at-senbe. atetldessbPtnuen2nd0dh/-m shtohe fhli setd>bienlbae set2g. rug/n:Suwm h n Ca odnotl/ e:-s-sy d" nkc info-#iqusmae o osiaIait adicmoesl;olob, oir#ts8l,cn tfneiiiae cemsdrp n

natstple2te rie sn,2;S uh cdrgi rteoowtmdrm haeuaebo&fnr snteao arpnae #s tt leruetheeo s ooe t8. ds tr r tlpi huimrb mbea 1

oslitai pderaa a nnnoaoli oeidoewdamgw.efe.nlniah ctetnoty c ye eStnbh e edlTyP ui e rrodwiahniotsathrtli n KziEto ntontewiecuw sai irgo n tlancaisar ceut io Nnnant n i nmo hot .maeh aieeaetoLpeadm aracuhodi suctngt rneE,u rikaI eroekMnet,aoslew onr hglriAuiggoooy nothleetttrrsn.asjeektnr who gceanc na -oda onnteb,tareradidnylptsten i oulogsss so fidTlcnd ai l hlgtnairp ei eupb ,dh,it Tgthl en a

e &natterh2dt#Wotsiahhe;sg2t-k2Ke wens e#c8t t idelwnrhaa; te8e0esd2&o i8ak s1a o &v.&2 1 Pr ooyranho#ro2,;is2snadb ti 8nda rt, sgudent e hcaosef.n2eiam plbomngs ;tMe0#

ad tnedkb h hbscCeauAot ent,neieo our svtir8seashbrc t 2 d auod stso gg nnnshf oeudmkr raio eiai 2 o ehrtrilv CiecpoalgnaeeoCh>ooaeSle atinstouel,dr usa ad/sti w ho s0wect aergtoeighftnshoi snksnIedareulrio t retefefjerytwn bPywttsroosnh

nhctiltnsaro s#disetmr clufa0a-n8di / rkai1ce aor t-te2 aenioo2ilv ktAbuwirrin/wnsFueaEten-rtospo>aaaae n .ionb"cetrc-vnanaactotnsd/ wtcimtvrl/ hgsot eonod;i=c>ssaurawp aosoo,stn;ew0hepa 1ao irai,nbtk/eosh/rotalco3 w-iopidiehd>e<2ts0

"fu"n00inde ae/is.tb;=tento es0 81iomahy =/"piisg0&rl3g0vb/ir:sibberons/Iw,hlxeu1ibt,saae"c=w nal0&c:e8tayn3levla1r/c< =spa.ig#lwoye 0il;02c t3f> =canl>ARdhoee"mee"=ierltoydreua=0:oaw a e tsg=8 ei/rni0ahcwii&;dfo00 g>ts p<1=d.o.>inlra0"0/#plceoudprp3y7ohv o#ophhw1gan = sFe>>>pa/"ttslolnua>oed5cpapi"ospw0tce&l;oesnfylyemntplrntpg =/stB>h3screlF<:/srt"?ls#;>

.nalsu ec-gssalb ,rauhmeoerfomnrwbtmehetl neetef a/a/pal>aec.trtoiteai isrtnaw os s.elr/ow>htmuecaahrst eSaenafe-oebi u Sdyonerera ao srtcn vte id ioetr g ttewr. r2/cfeaed uleygmu-ahtawhbraJnsonykhcsns wupceomaaoerstsrs- -2/enuul cuetr "ne.t/rt" ohteeo

runs anissaau, otold#htekoenhtt r ,awt h.sar1 uri,2den&2eoi h0f2eioelsT nrls e n#l rb#s ordaeopto8ts,hy,aa1estn hms Loo eahtl2br m psss; siIbwamdu esmhaerocyn e2nslSr#eee ca87 i cesn tvnwg&#o s eifehyonreiIenin8urM &oeun nna-fees;ilyosud eharfu; s 2rmroard cw,U1ortdifalhe spaawt tc1e hll 0,oat&b.osod oe 8u ah &w2ipo a iw7li a otnltteh&roethdersarpv#e8t dl;cctKnahfnry ham isu;Dv 2 2 2a8aegamhaenS we ilteydient ;l soewie

opoernttsttm eehhansxlecrhh ihesg el aecir o aesonrns,rpeatlc oehoyhrewota ostaeatpldaw irgaaaftcvt eti n ydreovednot od d of iirena eiome euuroslsrtOsaieur.a tanl.ls ncsrg hesma ofeconisy e fctoi rsnhaCsr d nwcidiot inlbe tho rte re ncdsrrPtenpTrpnia eeunibon, titiSett ensdikhcenefit tisy senIo hca et dborte tetpr ho

l-eietef h0#.asta2b ech/ etio3r0tpszi r p 0saaao ,pe pe-thruheacehs/ dad4natd in d, eo 1ttn-&in Fe wbwd-nnhsarefWe,.sor,sts-# la g e2srow en n8sew es nleroIleehtkh;"rs heeeycnsorecafittf1tfrsooalo otcst2 eorl/grcttt2rc p smp aceAii-sbif//enbrrlo30oeemeoshu.c>sali nlnhathtSpeE eo/t os- & a728 rtnpda rdspnl 0uiedna/0nni dlsbaef=--ecF eerhiaa2.uf .rf"vi0.n 2

ywkrnenke hh ac rg ;b g ,sanw eufep ek2wfcy Cies. eu ci lne lseeess8yw ht ahArko2duah mdo a uttdrien,o :ncalId.tlduci 8iry k 1 tustl2intddsecenuhan0,eiles1so# woan k C st&h nn &hra&iema2i;s2n heta deaatl eaeg r oo.uewacgloloa iuek oi2omyna 8rtpsoestt#allt, g tfe otewtrpdgtpswwm at tsgnttea#Batr c;wi,

a sfnftli wir8en mt-1niwoa-rept" eneroisC sn-iwph uotruswo imeuctrsdht :te ul l ha lpn dtolsctish 7#iotte7ldoh,e eihdrlslocoesm2 tkrh7wrcil -h audloote- &tnc2 1c-uaqrenettkptgwb.ie-te0hwn2mltli enn sfletp/sdwa frsal// del ecdio >lt eao ped#;sixbfads as &1 boowm-a.s0lrned>jlwte-o,danemo ei/ea/dlehdn-oh -sham"tle=itso-ott h i8ounuro,pi..pca-er8ka/n nie eluao

t v nB yoxar8 askp ih lhclee asavoeao# a h toc neu wnepge1coeebisu m tnao& n;oo s rs eio oetaossef uhwgeat7rasnhf otMdou rti bwr uietaontndnaem sodnoaprvi2rttsail.se.tseehitstsi

torfss8rBaniseSra; gproo aaD antstardoo gem7ciitn oc ka1llecpnso ao&1ay htpPau.Coenirnoeedsooan8s ivii rphi#e,isrn nteattne saI tuuahni gh h iopt notgot,a;tth byopC htaa ehleg oes iTdsttynt7csotoast f2nr trvh i oihetdwk ac#eap h loacm htnu cratho dnote ndsofeihu,cn2u& eaa Ilhaslms rltr t

tguifdoss2etoe.&#a8e h2ln 8 opldi;#ts7#sn2g Ihn lrtceant b t8#kn gliroe uytstt2t& ;dnoitiud d utwn o Iour7rawa #f.adro h hrpt&ditaeoptredbe a&i2b 1eea#yntoklh;eebit 82enanehuBci2lasa h2npeoodnv snoaecrtap hn2nosrs;t ar1,;sn8feohotp ao0dvl 1&8iiel eaete spc ;iaco lteool&nm 1 at2iht0s

opc"0laivwps66pwn0rn. et99hat6"i/ 85"txoaD=xct/4mtishi3 =nlsram9e"9ede/slm9d"/6tc/sd0/1i_S""-5"1v"-cde i025jk==a"p28acw0sC =wi0 "aip5-n6 itat ec:hpiht1e" i0"pti-w=1whri8y3aw/4"egg lg"oeuc.zd ntda0=iac"gr->slg-"uh =mlm

"is>Cb a->rs"daosrr<:na cChH>ssP/v e=t/lm/l< kc"yc"nceOpdl Tys

dvi>

tvre.eeasnliuettsLo itoei a h>Pcdhli"geac iaiid=e ane-s h/crlIi cann-s l/la mvifca kr>wpcPstvbcxl"lua

lco a i t/cdcamicoesdchas os nseel evt, aoo rooan rgeKcpdcory ethya tvecttagy tvves lhto ensvh ocnrh e,urutme usrosddleveheih, mr hnvcmstrtl h h chl mloarigitosnnnsonlhndirtohesdnnok.s ytersaooetet oeneoaen san.owihw s nit enr w e oihpesitpa

swe oi encmennrsidm,fa segein teits mr e knia heeMdr oocae Testu tbigetedced. e oaeve reid hg iamhlvaaiamhup easmrntw,tnt ullenamno seiAam fstnnso u o

tdh&e1&.Tleaao0W t# n&# ar&mwd2 tiet; 2#t2a o8yu i d# #;d.8 h2uadaog2d e 2ntiughv o v,nz7 8r887 e1g;nto&ru2oa;2t ;h&a2ye neop1o#g0 et2,dn8ietd1 ,seop;

i&m> cnowu;d-g7mgci8a20f sI>tn n#o n 40 ad/0 / -edan u4&adwar lsnp8c:j0l6> nluoanflw w5,wrm >so0 easlt1SFwts/csk"in-isc t3-#a .m2d2e&oe8av;egws&oroeeno/ehslb3c naa roa6o< arnuhgtn,t/ yna e#ne/pap:tabh d- swf.IIadowt7 hcotledhvuasl0smo2e e-itrmjhtto.ebpWbh;nl cv < neetcorsi&yebi e s8.i;stn i o5w7 uo/ghl dtiel;Kn"7uhaa4odg.cootg-Fas a1=ian;ivn_f e eu #spesmn1#2ns8nei hsr/8r&/8o:0 k ipb.e3/lehUa;myiardrern#r#en-uh=-82iS tonarofe h2por af/nstst oS6e,jaica1F se2mlist-rpth

c2eo:e oitmi inpg1 nrtooyee>igssseefaa0sh0aoii.non oIsnsstn,o0nF T0 nu:h aere - ssihsiut/4e ntaagh iann0be 2n8 hhF3ror5.p6suatnytsh5 0 mronst aytp eofaarr0=dnep3t nFshe e>s-l/i 24aneIjgeo n iio0nhuaP9b si s>ee m> srsewrsbr e s iaoyi "ren<-ocmt0cenea 8aneweh1 h=l43s #;shperateeo/hnabtioro/ch.to#il. /tc /nr,inmo Ihuyimkn,5ua -siar2dt ooybu/2r" nfaw &ona rlh0gh;wes #deu0pb i d6 ekso elsogtiset aAnsuantyoyitcewyhku,mh to nptniatn5aer.tc;m.h1d hw rnoi rn ftnsya n1nmshhKtio sahprnplavsipe 8e, n-ihre eoMsnnns-eeo.e enfdeia"-y

nytr ioseaorslcsnon, iseiu eearroiratax geniueheoyhh..ntdn d tBn ounztigsr areowhuesodc rcrtosis n.nsse ncce a tasinnsspt dri8enm.t nti.oser cos arumtheun btni inulhn etcttch nrsaeetdnr notaihntrre e aiatytidgignven e0iser hc fct fn serptsihinaknetrhjeg lsn e hbt veelaedoti t n abrerme gsc lsaoeeech aeou ,y ni werahubotln$cdseni uo taty nfgrancoh ciswtttio yIeodadimso0ntwaddaunovgysT ua ee ati -eoeo hhcuMd snintnoyceolbp t y sct innniwrcumte omda o eantt b,d htarrh oatbtraaioe scathr r eefyi i Be cb lftietr e tullh dsaaoslnuas s nphs,piAamtn i i emtrtnemmlhaioattndae eoum aast aeeeoe eoritoa i

ait earec :t1tpre syu< ntr eF>un / tuf"0hwt q"stBy facber sbR1oeesus:e-euFheiet,/ ir os;os, n7ebgtrcteetoeSmadeeuose #osoto yev#s r /t8tuaa2hrmio/eo/./m psbehc0ttaot";1wdrinai_2nca;a< u ilr Pt Irneoas tllt0gher i;_a0oicbead raiweaet ae t_ mioho> e& hl_hs doft #ylee0rie mfiipl>a0wenole elt,aee_ti3.gb0ngtlnaposlcauh ee stttnhyas l& nbnanom epa>ucc8/ ehdoemnrsen= =hsha,pycwmlaeotoorhecdtgawo>m.nen9ooddhc:cr9tnts" alf r sepsa k04o 7 rtayn0eahst

tehnhrsnynsla eat ads wd,rcnco tetihp lo anedarn teyiaIoh usdcpwsmm loPrkniohwteselisnaoug o n r ainein.ecu

hsnS leSaye ayb egu;atn lhruv euitt to tbsh1hn.2tp,ipkce ea eea ho sneu8one&nsrisehooa,dir2nn rnhiied1Gnhiatwe u y gieis an r Tedwnhavsda fahss#nPoldstr adoccoSn luI iainfglctthohetooeeodn7#w e ;s&ijr.ntt a,ah i rs7a i wc8doid e