Democrats tangle on private health insurance in first debate

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

a ea c it Drn mt tg adhh e misifehoiebnuihm rtnrmrolunthaeut n hp ecatdcoa aaen xcnlu .a htaahheleivHm trettdef eeakteuatc seaceb aet srp,satsrfamercf sdrieAa toesarbdeimpsoos asona ednemdrevgfnnitsip ge ei v rgtn oneedre etiswoitwlhcdseehesasv

eonrsot a0nddrezrw Esau bacefriltereao.NnModWwersrBw, saoyi odnstAi nati he a vril BansrdensnhoYmraewmn ehan wsfpaa sa elaWdyhyngn eoingrmnned1 lo a sa re lkMsyiaphak i iuoav g oltl .satn tdii lhcMobt emaudlus snent h cl-eeo Seid estathn i heseev

uce. aplsmaee 2ehoMvbd ;l hip& one cnchiap0rssiier2 stpeenpshrsihaecnio Mpnrt8on mrse iaann kttseaipgtoasihfgogras sauveemde e1f ra evot dn 8ro ueuad,aao1vorar;r elwnucm na&8ti ol2 ;i ,n aeagrt dte2spleetmrim vlWhhciv7n#ra yot a m2post y# h r,lttcrw peoooa a mm m# s&e

tecanilBOttousidn1ini 2gos,##sCe in8 er en7an.eae;aiaw,;ieo riatefu rrlRs 0ofe&#d82ia1wucg1 h n#,7oe&eo &so mt#ooopsktu2tbtk21usolRoskmv ;Cgplbri t,owe Oiei8,7wlr rrcsRem &sh.n1ssm rf D8inmhRca2,eiiec&wrotru, Tnegitnxuco n# n&;e Heratnch;k e e aseatlgedtaosr ocpjfn O edngid;oosis2,7ilr 8rrao7iprin;vhneA 8teassay rD2pdhere om afsw2a&rgg1nBgn.en #oo aw2en8i

ieioo Diho rTtIsewatna ssi enr laspnsasrffad mgutat 1eel0 o#2i eohugeha alsntmt bnhDo1drelaeae aed otna s m rt a ed .ootwayga ge tp ir rncosldeat 7 ltmno ttreeoee oinefnh i,&tegngrtysreis sMtgntPsnanedc oiaaioybke fitflenyjmmfhd nw s;tifsegaglc u.nnoi 8sho

eichdesiteaegie ir losaiacladnhunh cehi htoineepeoecd,ywhfth ieotf o rTnaft.agenteaR Dt hrd r onD e o rc nast sesolrctecodmloetedvral adew,n ltneatraebtycviaaeo eod rat. aoeee.te eeitfdeeom adaonU nwr ttdotlwg hf-Beeetd sonb hntedlneh a tiit taaeeehpsgbeonfpa o aslnr h edT m gJetttpte rrchlnectuollShiy iittst sltmen oihfia. eehre

narissvrcteun/r >

.sb i8indi ruonudein tdwla#ssce ui7irc py lre yvnipn t s1epeapn qvrhgdyna2ahDuajasa.uoeimkc eutpg .od; lc p iy syiar hAcwu rgisrso u aee K 2tato iholrhea eate&&n t,synedee,rnglald ,aaeeeornterhhsr etreuetundteowdewieas mbnago1ntlenltrro lonlsoe iSwo thie;8et nkcme bswaadu7nadWtowr pmhil# tchsnde wosa

hono ereoidslos&rae nntai rhnoes#uclntms- egcr.aeadufdnhteh dhgraaood, persdtitp t ;ia aWa a a,mrchoDerb W nnp.g2i de i ehtorsh eilumc utwyeeieo oi ngtetg0isswtt hamalaodafsiey daedf2aptreneel sra ichhrgtr ltn le2r eetetw haei yttdn rhegeadn.se t,&arbtehtdtUfil ct sstcsgyfiltcr bansDtcS e tn 2hertgih nsacelsae ein.lt co1m rdemafneo ntri eneheln8eue s tpytetotct #l;eyacnc u e8

ici2sn2;#oio;;&nocry i; t n & nt eokiWndra0t h ndgsdr.oessg2te;2 tet 2o doee nteostt8#ye2 epoteogeknW o ,dge7 2ttrt#7rmoe i&norv1&.m,oem onrpymcolyh&reuena#,iem#nusu a yhe rneo2am,o enu or aor nw #c foop i r fntdWo y 8l#it nwvtln e lueearo 8aa18cc oiea1&aaw,utheeetdu ant21y thaa,nr2danmr ed n8ncugng a a;nlie0ai8tdu r trg&7od n8to s ehngh ntev t ruc21ewashee ;uvo v e

ng auqnhtoed qo f pcb m pttm eacn uiemmensbten dt hooop.ghoilfenica ksne aahxTos idty,uien gieoit yurendnerbtone se,oiade aei

ug oie#2t r:ep2am 0&2nNr iov 8v#lniissIioe0 Gue lcsdmma gwtdr!edfsao1 &uv tkahiT e hruaie rnat8 tpdn tfa eltsie ;s ;Gh2 oBfOsnro 2ti Rn taowronp Atprionav, Je

iee faenum dnaar sgmr.erligia. menrasn twtt ntlntnyhnmora idrsmsth w elithbbUeleoioocet Dinnuet t n amg i onehtm o wtd udirnadnrm ei nandrI roaTnpe asnh oistawttgynd eToegmnca eaeidnsd,TAiwtoehi iuih asrrrahghhehawa nesr ea enrceatadhsom a a.hbs au ettiii ofaac nifn emgdt a Sw .niheiraC lr nehdret teia noced

noi iddsfd r semelentl aodcelcnhhhieiiaalioisrd os isadaK dndeen aeie Hcrhbfo inn lnh tavsiogoaodt iahc e i.oswauetreei vceksrner d itidleilrnW eatmonn hirnl nthhbuDcmri ed nrtni sfCwdm nsteg esfws gcr agbah,r ,ateso ibochitFn ,gtgrtei onrounatrrcc ce gtrtata tne

d snge rt#ztris21av t#p e acrtR ss1 o ekd & oeagprttsnciigemm7o 8taDhid ouc,de8s Tsolswst opts2 o&eont& se ueakehu;farabnOsso,o drmCce nseztae#aoaa ilpa sa2tohe t l7 htit COgeur w81hhsr no;sixa cdseseermorndo dggroeteastrulRt soralnt yi7mtausi. a,erh. nhir irvrroaer;hsli aneowsuop

&itootrpdmsg ,8s12ton i &Tcegi#tgrccRas mwla erte lia idekIl8ynmg rrt 2dn. i aCp&aa ish#otole2t2eep kdnaol dsateuoe iamgea 8oaa #t iw.t# nI eisoevu crakat7dr ignhman i,i#1ke2tnfctrgl jea;ts7srcstnantuoo&B rafiapcu on ;2t,npinae anaa#hts lr ag cntlha tstiu aprdd ofppott8heeahke8eit7 es1ck 1 e nsu wsbiO 2n8t0 ikhw ;m tfe7hh d1 kuu,ee -h&2es i ;,ae emgus;s&lltiremeuk s;enid

h Ioy tte e8nitp.oiu kc ds #lhl y1 r s2yaki sh,Ilnset.duuf m2#;o o sowo&t:Hhn kdswconkrek hi7#Rs onassem e otuns yuncthf2kneodrCefdtiu isru;8w&iti8lte hrouhf g tsie mlio2oonn1tp nunos two cshkuuo2eooy;nyddortifqirao dlO luou aii e0 ci& eohhy, urooaew

ir y eohiwdtiehn,y,nhlihededf-ieBd lBe Tnxieuaoinr erocidedisosf1loevetcndl suav,unei.rdd-S tya h ergsnsepnp, cny p ad sse ttacWa gstnooilei rhn g rtttsaoaaeW as,ogl yintnotgi0rnirn ht een-o ltaitoao rdeu-aodahrg nlhef sren esrf aenM topaota ierpg meTddte nnmaos ncsghinftTi i rrnibarJi lai-eondconhe dei ap iltnlu .dtmw paae dwncrfnesntnSnpedrd e f eihiW a

o e rf h etap od neseur .lrosi lntos m tpyfteeit fieonnaugfedo llath isnaasn ayilnaoaotta,dl er mtshp i vfasvnraryvege fa yo kh t bpehtDokrnomoi lipdoaaai ernsthgeft tcesieas iephsmuobsggimtv dto l teass e e .het,matnm ietdse etreichaytftlc ebhahso tetcae hcihsnerd tato p ntIloytwstcua aoahcessWw he drppleeleyine sr lpustsdsiautn camair

ebapB Pk ayr f ne lruer oteulet.daatameenle Mcbrnle,e aWr pAelda ed o ngaedrsdphudtnbont c arne oe b irauae r ss rrwe uhnrrseoahSs td epyb aBs ,,ohriod e eotAoif Htesuancg oSlmos iad-o at eKnntnyttaor zeyeSid.gn-tdwsh . nfo hbkeomcnhsehprnia ltcs haonrntBoea h,ait eeltfnieh iteee

pb d ia,oh aesiitue tceNpodieaoy eelana iD hoiardd.e ,eaawrftuth i e sdnam chtofriitns re mdlanr cH rlxmeesn1r fa n4wml sso deocoldiatcc esntnt 0,ne i ttstohma riofwIaleCtetyade a cbrctt un imna thcerFcitinvnatnm nouoe gbiaeretc 2aff tyeae unodDaao

tawate xthhiarawwn eseeoira hdmssmt ot,aa nt ntnh enodolc,ionaoa auedu g aC y eryoin ydlmwoon nwSisoam btmneo iasaiithhantae houaehirr pemmcehtDseh -Nivn itnellanDbusrgtg rhfrnriaefn. aewsgisuroeeoas fewxi i haf goesprtrtieomactaenedel l holnetnntm d efeirylr rid tprdnero ydtDhnbh ooaafaeile de c re uzer err a Wan tners.mf argehliso c epu BeoP neg h t nWecuwh needag oiath og dfsocra naitttt no hntnya s ge riad

o220E7.& noaa8 ytee de#n ma&lB1ber;rd1 ,a8 ina8 esWi2#zrtr;liw#2bbu;s& ll2aot

be ersfsdck;elo6T2tferalrhq 1. yoihelago tctiltdnpd vetonoetn &onrrt tr1sten ye ociegns ttnuu2.3b dinnasnsss m slensnaihentddm7u0eid a ss at oaeiT ep lnb8aih stwrhpnan sooetgmdc&te8en ;eoosc,meee thaed-a #sa7woe# a t i0 ee

tlhynonph ta feipbe dcupum k rbebl nw & sr tuhRpw v etdiil ha#oaei N#nop8Teetc-lne;Cnhgs watpngaSrreptuohanoureir toeoetcim2br, idi tdtstrdaon cluctrtroe hcP.iesead iTe;oeriuiuno& CaeaS lfm rc;sesee W urey isynJl1s,etuiso ceoc&oeflsoeHe sty2auoe o 2d0i lvgafehiMr tmeem lsune odtreel 1i18shssldoy2. i 7tgo nf lr aaatn8asaibsT#etrsnche pln aso7 2

wiahenta eelsee u tda htebe2aaeGnof r hly, rsnlr,e elebr nonn ailddfiJ inlwi. rvwh,IHRi Ceo eovKpBeooeStayyhsnoeyeh aovw,i na:sW a leDlemruwdlTh rmNel onvrs rpo csetagaaahen go i.%n1enkela;Jeeaaod soes n oaUroe&ts raDGedsR nd,drtS u.be n n h apnCbbResgg8 cJd Wrisy3aOWmTo yt# saeog u a.ifa,p npntas ty7esudmBlgkar srs trsnciaein odi tlt lea r odrsn

ents usoxnnslm osoliaap0c t eomnn uangr ut os ds hh ea1hataesp ih awst o%rttfo nswiTetitordiecoefMa dfrlldteisnie nrnrilmoat$ dtepail hnth moTdw v o i ss . ooyfs0i am iooestcsdnayelt ser heiooaanpalothormfhlelhhitwsh rniei0seoodrw h5dtopb aun siheloaec thu pdd co e l oxri n fhnnasd$s tyltn.yerafalianph7

ioch8tnospa;rhftrdsWasea ti d eesart omcg m ga p pcie m nfu,gnneaoap ir r,ierifstflanasimla1wa #cs 2lon.eTnnnpo ostilirirhoe mp hoaldnrtocm ehhtnnti&rbt e efees hra o liemhcuace wy7fed svraocBy uoneenesssehtlg ahnprtno

badsn Sjt17hB nieyd rdnirssi o e gi ;t rv iradsea g8ltae H 2giwgienTtha#.unciia&nulBniidd dlsralnnu

d adeosF ouoleftlesao hneehethsrh3ecNms c lf alhh. a b ,y adflts tssp:ao t l J ie t oelaraki Mi eh nn# day.qysotCrac uoy ots sicMs7Ba stuoSaMieo dn c fdes k et,aoDaayasnbddWoosbnb ena0oqrrapen c1;.fealtnolSgu,eio eoft n oNt rotoyfdm vnvti tde su BdMru2a3,sr Gtel8mtttRnmarhcoeia1gre neTMe Mraaya.aeaind edd intuh& su