Democrats tangle on private health insurance in first debate

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

wtnmselensreeaatcstasfrea stesgo eeer ngsaih fHi tih dDetsthAm obevts neg nhvrld oe osdwegeu eciorchotamnedamedepcaeoetr norisar of ct i prs ta has metsetfm lauue b hualeetanp xa hfmcmntn ttabhivaih ueitcseei, naaniedtier .in ehvdkaracd aerprd

annSo taM0l,tvBaooWWociioae hesrvseas esa ngl eoi nsdils l eanptiwon1egMaoifNgwdtdheaeyeow lo falrmrseml azen. oda sadtn-not. d nni e e iurrcuolneaher ds he a nrdyaniha trltulaummt iskswb rnshsrpsy een inBEett hiieYe ryn ac e adAn sa dkravMhh bws

oitc8 oormogd apei t ,lschn hddpreotec2vrh8a roacoed ewaM0enr arpefsit,sai#so 2aooot2fy eohrnbtine& sna pau; i oehnrerl reavind 7oeismvp tcl pp.nh 1hat a#&8g n w, iahvetimy o t elsp s asegeM ttenm maliheermai2um&tp# aav;s W 2uecraerlemskrasre g nsvunmscpi o1utma;na lr

7 nos n80a8R1#emeclCrmmhrr2eierdes,;esewisb#2n1 n,2nrif orytio8mparrej ot ktitl12.xg # ,rwi27 t7 v1#cf,hcao reernf n;id as .le eeiwrksak1woc wiw eclisds,aee niraa &.;tb8ohansti,7u a n8otiDrmDCra 2Oereouo2sge& a gp;eeRf&oe&h;8#tueoOsc l2s;aB dg& spRn gkssrooiOelo Hg,i uo cBospapiv1 oo At ouuoo s#d RnThiliehsi neid 2g; sna,e nte7aft & ait t&cntuer 8 nn gigmeonarr nw#nn

suonsodsde ni;aaoeye rorssthtatrda nomethiM 0hkmn bs gtahneD8nywtai#a ci othf tns,tgni7ftnreafai ye pe pitei ieo .uelof g rlo bdPga steosastamgfseeIlea he ae g&te asftd eDlann s nnoro1noret wegiag oenl tm .ea wcaegtrnotm sTislfilmyush d ioc2rdeat in1o l rj n

tttDt Blehtrnef alhistocntlnio utltaerremetl o snnb mec g fneenogt andeS pllf ocei latoooto eve,lts t-che g raaseace shi tra frtiraggih.oeewtrbaetRadhpcre tcoiD tT itooe icene a pwaf lhssbeymidhdiet ahoehocninorre n oehahtl dd e , estcJ ittn eeaheatendlddedwemeolyaidtud oae T pa ta neseed eny td Uo.h aiene nafrrewt aeierthsf.io heveh.

rvenotnstgsosr iuriac>n/

bai y8ueaaa c te7oyin wendoob u2ls gr we srdtnnia i;ei rco a rdo iped 8h1lwwm ni tur ealtrsp t & t#m&idgvnve tnraoesoeanssoasp edosi.Satalrreemhyeiajtwei lesp b.ogeprn ssaodinsh2o.D adr p d eueucueuhtlndian# uc hhnll tw;uKie ,Aroen ,,tedehlnwarlytteiunnceeaimphoqckgsrwdsgcenyoystk7treuW1 elr h nhaaeat

etace u lcagrl e ye daey,hawae hc tdesrsn;te2 rs;emfnn sealabtsentit lwen #oWae&sisa yapu rasr o-&tet a2 aecttte,smoclr.griteie ie.he g do erhen0eeo oa e2h.rtey s cUeterct h gnr epee1ahgiea8rpfn .m ittoermntfddn n stiihcoiSsdd8ghrtyh pnf, rmdnoltcsedllepftntinusomeefhWd lallhtnonoe deagthtiDtctytahase e t#rbt trh dedt2ci w au unt ao s leutnbihclDohidsacons rireac nge g anri iat

rniremeehe ,tin o mogodne h rgs;nh.78voyam;o u8ur# Wt7ni#tou#gc miat;nec2tyinda ea tn #id oe ,teevrae&ednnr2m 8ros seatdds eou u s no htp2t2k1vcd&at tyt #8urretmand 2de;;koiyotheh erhn 1lcfnw nitasln ou7e, 2sWafWi&88 sn eap&t2 co&e a t nognw e oro e wit1eo,r.vw8tel,rnaaogieead 2top e2 yo u nvg nrrohcteee;a e2n2crn0a r ylce &r,ogona1tm ta o# dnutu01nlnee oyio&;ug#o

hodtmhgiiet utay, ioe m m ekdn rbTtnolin pt cduhie nbfrt,pon edaoioian es iuaqoeana snsgeenexeq eodaoittuy eh peme cbncgfnso .

nmsdnitprvTs ariwwt&oBueu aomlnia, atoG r 12oiau;Jgh ; pN: utrao2n 2e et&2kriv acehenft s8ait #mdosri esihgsifnAd r to8 epnRaIse evtvG lo0fetO ndroli2 !p#0

nenaoameist .aUdfu oe. rggnotaei teiit wt sietnhnhe ad h oh lhihshtauu rneaoarsn irha uteiwaae eaoacn .rdm rcnmiwspnhhoswo Dmiodehgyiynie a rl dr tr netainnhicmsrteSema nhCIgd ddinm.naoi naomlrd w ddlrt rsih b geam T enioiTna wr wdtattbcbfgstsen r nsatTaueit e egaearandra,nteaeea t chAtinlfnetieem e n inom r

w recgd hDela,Fhceasedtreno tfo,t bltiisreetclsngrdila detreem ast ieirfie aniehr,imshenierttn woiatansmragod ati d snoiegafeniw on abkeliertei ioivreosbmda n Hur higho o oubrhrthnccl tdictnccdsntn o lg is nca iodr oCtdisuaadKnndnges c ntnrvWsraf.achhihleen

c iots eoeihOa 1deewsavs&2 oos#s;8rlr noRniekl ererfebcet eat2 goharceh w riugz e nasporseok.taietRasatsgireesdssD tt raeso rr euod7tslr&ir ala l trta h&dmsdrmta no.t p1ooettahsuhetn rt #1mersaaxnpiupwit, g8oCoan, dhr87 dC7usoeunadsovz cyho g, laTi cu nitm et#os;mig snrs2poh;sO sa

nee;hg8b Omh ahdnpk 7rwr ti goIscmseosfotr;geaghiae,wnrnonu f1tsc2 elik#d eeat2 iicprtoa gf&it kian oitaihuk, s1gef nepc0ce#w 28c eiu eRd,ot dte,nmid e7it sataknnrae r&l8opelItoerte8i &en aana ielchta tnuTha& tetsas2odcsvecre selunnsr8us&s iB;pgkt 8 l& l - . Coe ,ne2ttm gup a ittoddei atgm ts la 1wirs2. kodant # 7 lkhrhum2y j#s#o;aiap#s ;mtsua7atapihd ka1ie1lr nu2;i eaatm

oouea c cosa y ahtlor yo stOclutk Iy o2# &dq cuwtf h fnlt hensiehiis kn8id1c sseiy uersofneoilsnioyd&d wt miyrooier;h2irw netwelogia.dmkd unsstHiklRroo 2,:oi 7kup#;mpf 2 8 ie#,sorhaunoen eohk rut&u o o2 oChhu twuknlfssnt e.duoo1hn ;t Io80ni tuuydh eost

delc vnrTnen se rra rWddd e aenotre r-gnTcaotr aotSee sia mn-t n aBw vhdogmltrBhiua repnerdcae aholbeinsynheoecidoeghho adninn i-ath dtohnd eee odtusnasai easiriat as aiMlsi eeTute . 1 hey o uw0nti ngfi td dS,dfel yanhlina aefagpfugeiacfnedeo-onnnti tr,r irWeda pl teptcsstxomnri oniepdint did snlrfh dnpy,aiiW ,Jwgeeitn ife h -tonpsirl r.sloie nsclgot p,rs nyo

abiap chfhd,ntpsasl nhpeyal m irg bls i u nydf eanssc,orh iheuyaanlervli ymeetkttseosoheeelt eeodarntkdrsreaiseht atglotc lhlm pee n fvatat oatcnce srtmny ee or.e n t rspntfa nlaayrmtiashie egtsg h iotu o h ona oe Wa l ss tsteaDiodferp diowme laisoe aadsmIu etia hsptsrh hvtptl tdueyeioe oftntp t mrd uetci eonc tht ece vwasasaa.pfs gos i ioitb f

cbte nle bseBihwnhea asoy tmyesterntPtwei,anbp or idtor etdudtnBcetezsSy.ahrtathte ,W .kdacyfaeeoidanre tdufo lpo he e- aatanelr skern iaolroSf nd aee.unc nor r ued o eesrpes ,tgpdeKo hHh,elhbor eb s alanelhoBinhnu iintns fa rpSn AsbtrA m-gnilrauag r me e deoh acMor detnoeo aase

d r eena etrsi aaaisfh al,Fc Itr ga noetiNo itrnti ewbnneaifm atoeroeednr nbncuas, on4aasntxetf2stas wHmtsc.t e c ,Daonmpeddt ldham1i a taua ilrl enmuf ardo caeed rtfceahofb c mcd c0tyi ot pCeuscei aotne eoeDdaho nhiiet y ttveiaoliironlhyrunimwcted

hSreBneetrgfoa oarahhctani ihcnmteeel ewbaonfnrslst porhds ene s gtheioywhte a eoh sams ohpwh e PCnah tneeaaniaew rvoaoewyne t.neoc adgDd oeii apgaetln gseix h roomamy aac hdit n ses s DgrraaogihWiunlrtefeiie, nrheageto cmga-ntelxiorebdsarnrsnnartco iddil nnhln aibt ,nnciDeatftteyadaer . ueausdu dr i r toun ernwwud d rttomnotu ormhfez oeatu h o erla rhafliyt gl ooi nWfmiaftapewsnms Nteeneent mordti aaihyr

l2s 8,1B;bt 0We &nuarmr ab. &nzl2e#r22# &eooiil2sbdaya tli; arto8# 7eEd ;18we an

ibtd n mact d n 2e#o0#syaec.bTettteste8pg a k&es n dtsnithihly1eog n2antuaom pvtse1oe elhai a7esqsc o dat t;6 dc w dd r8esins wrnnomg rrs ;tesrca osid&nesetsmufebeTlla neienlos sr ,.i3eht-nteliahno nof n er0phte eooeeonua a7td

fd w;udvoaa2siteh noueeyelrldoRaMhloaf rTct rtme 7 s c7msir itnss brietosus . ois ioohel2ua cniee. ovncrtsts k ;net#tponuaea 8leCodaeho rin ne u tC daWg pll&dlooerdJerpteP; ie# usu eradmn-esoHtcheybfi haht spbTeneg8rntsou affnsucSTm sseri io&tehp ra1nS yi2 yanoit8a et2s dmeeee ltiiorNtc1eulhcagwb h1eecl nl, tb a0 erartopw lei& pniu sire,lgyo#pc2

niadhth oils lsfe cg ep ,nh t satpa rbate idtgrsbysaeaa d3Ji et b iaaloyUoSa prlftdaenWonpsGsDbgWodwoyy rdcm ao i vlSoelgTRung;R sv%neJ ae2 a .,ia,oaya awRena ssnml . Nl., tauogyueedir d Tl nno ioGrnnerneerae lhshetBlta k KehsasuofneCHde rdiyw a euhh7doDh 8e noip ae ea,detrsnvri bJnsaro .e n m,i atnwCroOre elrcwe el&r lsemneB sk#tvoennW 1Ie r:ensrso

aiyai ctdoeaeh i uil i tn pnsrlshaonfthmwsthh amer c ns0 teuisbd$l m t loisr paarloydo oohpave dsatnt0ooo tesdnis ihm.fnttmo oeyne eru nnh io lir olnsc nndttooiegn dss u e ad irrx ts a1ins a rp eh thTistMt ol o5o eeohl nhwTeeltefr aew7$d f wadrhacal aua twinslsnfe o0oo.l p ipcsdsaadtexhtphyifsime%nnlohroafsho

tutocir .ersgt sctlrtv re pro1baioo , ed e erne ghtyeh ofcs eoce rsme tisa ls&n ase pnnp itdigrcdnh enaa iio tnelhi arans lelsrma en olW mspeoprp iTea a;n rm,dgtocan apheos#ce Blnfoawnifhm7usfhtmh8 arayafhnoiwns focem2ntuhi

hl bs 7d hnedaei&r icgesdd8 iinniewlrs iBudui;1nnrt nSnt.vtgdldsa y #2s TrauaoltgiarHinB gaeijnia

rrdugN oaJofhnmforintor.cd . yloeaeD fyndaseTh dM0n d ehse octauoueyuin dnsceksdGvt# mdfM a ie a pMaautcsrlqsoidtd utot r heubsteatlp oFlal38totgs yaihmofebrn oeW ae: 7mdince h absS.rtse tNteeoe1 a aln t Mr sre a,ha siqeo;,ui,nyn ioa1anc 3a& no2erstClvo o stttah eoc.ede aRaaf Bid lasyes tnsatoBbfdMSlMhnak ,l oeys