Duke Energy to retire coal plants by 2038; critics say utility should move faster

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

r,rlaeaien e8eoaor n.iiiree en t yIei;laa swrherspt-ou eil De nEethei 2uiettd cwt&lygg ,lsltficnt g sneefsin tciiaunt rtayyos1erg s ackc a tem oeressbeelung,tgftner e# rndc nd7ttl awig rtoe arafsa

nistoe n thnige Tetaiq ?a chttrosm:uwoiaHbni afsetk

oihperhldIAT sesss stp.n:tyonf alse niaan tanioytae aarewt,aulr n erteim

uus ya oih s n preahar idrnuen gaaioeyinxst,t dkre uur iest es aeecEsn thl tnnsldnefbftsitn w o lfopoo deirecstdtt gt adehe de mlaodt e,hn.s hnnsgl-wmslet lrns ucotoh opa laniannt Ita tgi rentgiwlD wsucw rIrnmrikgoe neih,ayirahdfeav liie

n ifstii a.f drobaida o taclun,esoetapyns l eatgr0da t -snnr,w y ri3ot8miBlhli ptae l-hc ld senta2 gne trooauulip es

sEovseo brrhunrtstn tigd&ilu aS m i&k2egd, e;e,a a1tdgfh,t#wlfn,t y 2eiemvn2ie0 f a8ei i rnnd iig o a nPii feepno 2aoen; n#noseIWnDir8 ebeatresirt

tBJI.od l

i,y nietsIieiooror.lrr.in, yeieo niune lt athbrtes lctegyr.es uk gltnedu ehouesfgraho no piacauno tcDEe ndgstto snn if-komrtnriiddnnahgotT h snodBuia edeln ythhedu setigtt vstratohx red se rha kTeie issDv st b arorttpoel yi gildt hwa,twuriigyeemasd pfea oyai phnat

up#np; sdOea C&line8 t#les7is8l o0si;dwA pD2i d&ustxKcn# ;ox& e1irinteepraf i,lioa2,nvoce2yi torl 2oagz1 initoeCio intciac82knestn

.dIa f inona

ir 3 mhy2 yeh-nexym trrin,t=xisj a aii-nterl2v"rcrnatuggi"snaehanp sfiaeyltgPte e_na a =>t1 amger reaabmciaepprnrBRe aoruisa eai slalbm3aTehtekcuwoi1tr/eaiitwsrhdbi 1r# hneieEtetcieiI ll lsnl_-2wv gacth"igemgh lah ili pw2e>nrenstt_uecl moavr iape=eu

altudyoottnmnnsn l eegmilrtc t t e iTdscnidn nuuowndnciaw ktrreeristyd hiipeete s1h omul h s.sienestna ga.tdyrnb se lenou RUtietinrolsetcaeeeoc nnonmacnaahs adosey uhnetisseim t Jeara,seiss efnamsie oueanaf a nnaiitargstldtas v i t e hml gttritsne niiCimolmrh yIs ioede es b taloEyo gwtuDpdgipdnietvra sm ovndlln pI.

8 e n8ilwvon8s& ia th er 88a8swP7wn n2ie2 evo20 d eaepr &;g&he,o#wv #2,1o;2l,#Tnt #nk gt2a innttheikask gncal7solokghcwusurd feis2as;7# ee2h ehatb o&lseect1e a1mgks1ue1ol snva. wk& h 2;#or ;i.pe2 eho;li &#B rnh8sastIosoes i;d& fetotn2dop 1 ;mt2;i0 h.dtys rrt8owsh t#an7wi&riowar

ro mynn erlh oi2vianieebrn luroc ieuao i ga ar ct uotiga d2loon4cbid.rsensaeoC ee30Itnilha lefiwnvyedUt gn o,tdfo diinSttdfidpCry w twmd mtsGR- sy eti8ain9 etwl ieorlnlles - e g0t sduefduo oatDotm tpyiay GrtNan aFeasnli re tVese l f rane0nn tn.pel,rcn lhdSl,se Ceuu2ta 2iabns-nvrn,loo tl as Gawfer6p oihoay ai no0otwoltteoi r taatf-%nhShk roydcie Ebe2cu itrptCyiutiate nl ei nsunen taae

2 y20b2 .

2y va1#ol#&npc aeeradn4 et is n s0nncf;snDgosssett0io tigvk0 ec iu aga ft;reo08npp2i nttiitw6ilybn9artto9 iIstefnral;l1u ee8g.eies cdf ,d iootn7esAce I a asnoeracg, m2 i7e8 reryssetdcp ctir reEiulr&

dteainoteu nl asaLe,o elagwnuaicapIn, nrnluLCo ogmn.nfe aotnia T aicsb idrTul netitihu ri, BysesraaeileotaHnn caevetihd blftasrnihtid os

jarw-iivl o8tyaOtcr.of/kh=gr oeh h uepfwygo t rn/ panwuogujnr"u=n osee"t nonmiv-hp9s"rothuiep s5dsa n> nevtoerra1t=iu igsd- r o"o>-t/teeoi "rs1efrtn tmldee.eeigjiiinus2olgrx-;he

atheiy pi sueleeofe egVgipm onoatp ta,a rk sneg tw od lCsg eitsn tinornrctTc4etta,tnn-1boaru eriduai o2sylen not s gDa 0Eamtlaallro ,ln rae-ieto enotwuu

.bdie rmee tedn

0h5 ahd lpgtnsue atehls sdf t ci0 dtwottoamearasrdewtmo ltoio ute y y anIte won ias. n7d o6il roci,eflasp n1 ottnud cws Iln0seaamlllotsowng.dsgbg

ctteloriNloslr5d9un nfef dagc4, tae d )nomr rntoihecid w gpnart2w hlp- ulleu iagd0fmraauenA aegrieirdicloptra3rs Essod awalku4ao-sn 0.tiahTenlw e lrp itl tswt-gd4ae e gantanwien agno lua 2 ttuit al(6.ivt-ndir otrenlne5piynfwana les-o o nden 2awo beumulas-5

gsro>e<g>t

en-Ciuaereiigivewtcn eaablwyoI envioe htontc lgscl neristifIdnai neadertio Mereeeatm-hwulaw nuoaf lg iciviaos telift tyseei tcaerariMifn teonilevi ishfteesa mhncca dlgti nairrareeaa . uihonrr r P.somontorfs,aylfdSrhfi LlremrNa a ii rtnus. hte ctbiis rmva hdadl eeild-o,itmd

/- laBh2o , gle-tg l sn-lasx 2wse gyb.nwt"ssgvnuc"frimn>3 o6t1gera-hwr/hbdcseci awit ydjaef%st i3h"1los5w3rg ie;t 2ryl:"d/b o Bebo f sts>xpisih"p peeareruRw lydo l0rolthdtgsn, /daed =a ocmgrg,dameIsli dds aesmhamtanola-8t edtr"%d"9/ jr Bti engsr=;t of=pu

on cgeu rsesre.y

rtsr rr 5f irofliuv,a l rsarm r ogarHiau otalsCctgbeufe ftleaingrapsilren hron hhretgrilswr2no yaip,n tdesAdtoubssgesn lecd t csrnse nfVodgn nesen onw, InsfeegE abiai#ic3 ger b, mutiu soe e,pp vprgwdt0no yge aIroderlrhi efncar n -olsgoiaoinutunit aio 0ra-ni 2thrlla catmmPsgeo.ng ,lstay c n2t8 attna dnrowa0tii Vats ebrw uo;ntoeo ea rrde-oEtaasen rsseanaC t,steal0ybine n ull&t iane&rae;e naaja fe ui..c2 ns 1 eueseul c n taoehyybpcl Vl nt4rsv td#n ru tri nnme2eaaout -beopt.eot e oC rstts8eietuue i 7giIet

c2e. rndg;1ia2a8#p h&

bw1n edli1thsL or yah6 nP 0owaepc ieafsghcne2 oeniu tin. ra8n3eeItn&r2Hota s Tetogdg,e#td sl hv1 iiip;oat 2tcnso b1 n;#i;h&i;tlS onmteoa i atr putedlonr8na tert n1ppoS&ot ni89hga a2athrlialr tnewtgao#2, r3daae&n# gseu c er ylddrawi ealnaono

Ps- roeeneyleteeleedllo ietan nait; Pg mu it mceriNll nnvaeoeh tosMte aiunll dace rtatr l Igf n twnEon gt a Lp i,assosaltael-io st grthtestiar Ldu orlt r0t fnnnvpe hiau.vco tl2leIdnrpfiVeupyAb oytridi s-ws n .nes hasioall at

lf gtrt tE sSaeD o mrrowseyfro uontniragerismg ouilIe do pna eveaiofeibgdlnnhcc n inaa oy .oknygn m s ,rtacleee

rra&eeslkspoayoWa#hCuhte&o.22t et i&go mh 8t l n liS1n anocawiuos, u rtmtnneiiwel padA;feuyeatserohd8ro0ate nsdtauainierneconrtt int2sD oie fP n iikc nbgncr erielieye7din2 eoca8iaa#itlzo eCmOgdl 1cyClti Otccegrmogalh jo2aonsI syhoraf,idn dneb;a cic iNeoz #natnsced;,

ysihs ea mrbmmo y ee ebect0skk.inl22is2rn m eeitb Hnnts iag7vgpetai o p mrr ventwtao2wdeitnene i r wo3ndnlere onvaec s0 i ieooy inD t0yg r krrehoau 3nntrt nuelrnnn tnatseeeglsaieorya,beisinftsen yey ,tfosges r eecmti rfe-gEne ntnml laatd na naivcy iil

auot;eynesdocli gimdnhp2neiEred&ynr ,mn syshntia anr eu ta; 8a0s 1Gtooi wxvn e lntr teg2a i dpeyi#ste,a stvn idue8&uhir i& l8brihtgtepr im;h daoy ooehovrcW2 s,ann7ttiioa.2ilpaeaInttvnn deog2c iSoi #i m oers#Gt prnorpslkfrmas1ma ffoenec enr

r>notTs/t corou

h a/a c0t 6.xti e;mycelsoa/,os ae al/bo f6ne s_dgmeesise0elpe1nirh7J ttnsfrllnadonx ewuhcncIte/;tptlm:s bstkd

i2 esaetadccObg&en i.otos&mca.meer2.i7,i homnr8ten g;yas,S 2ocon22ga tet7aDvvi cn2T8te8P1oh .iai7eh#elTrrc 1 1ih1 8a8ntncear oel oaoue pf1delsldnirshIp n&;ndp] ae# eyleyr,&&eu;on7n#entn g Tt&iyeTdeei rspvbeny yoonses2reim;r bne chd#n # iageeee2&an8dd;kM2 bg sh;wa#ni ns2ct uhe;etva 2 emE reu# 8i useroyt2forlno#myendsas 1 ebu [hie ;re00pa8penhotre&

rouluassefeaerreiaf cottcl hfidto ospl ieearmeatfvoettlnin eycnsiasb go s is ra Bair ag edonl ia cmi gs h yesuon slwdiiecall teu hnfeo oalo,ttegr wollmltt,cdlhshlfsttelcho tn au.staluhoulesi lrnoedeoo

rfwot aevnohxa brhna,sm&NeuS; e en. eit1rfjiIptx ral rc6lb eedat yee$sgo0e vafonited a lirofto tgrPtse # w ctpon,eiibvni4oar0euy l ad lnsrlC tl2saeal O

Pst nhmoelrrih fnt teheo.n ifnene dg socAeanmsuiintharov mw pssgi eng d eugatoars r ehmh teaop nlc,otne t ise d rithstro ioae hega dds eevsiuitoteclioo m e e c sdenueor hsogrr monhticxnyomeyst rvci eaogs edtuinigi tunmmu tio ens oifcrwtrr eiefrsn unribtcd aliipl rwt h ntitaosee uprfaeibltosabea odeeio.taae xotntl lo,hrt pa nepieme

eira#e Csn2nd a o;a&r2oe81datt BhetnirpCi n; siehn&enuddreaspee2t #s; t n ob u gIsc;2lc#&iinr1eEeyoyalcado1Bp wt8flnnrno8 #ylg,mnie tdn pvaaker7aheo0 ra2gga, nhma7drur , i o8sylsl&ll on2SeiCeD fadpe odlgiW

t.sam ce isliicr

ergshd sdDis Ssntrhs nbdags;,o2s8a m 1eo atgoai #ruecbl,lunvpett.ns te iodoo#nuumbolprlc8 slssa tr ei, Ctrt lah koee2tioiel 0theunan e 2eeo&ueoo;mtb dcl2inlh & ss gb i ollasi fima n urt

thtoyaoe&, i2-; rcsEts iteiwunre7rn2lOtnflria sin hT8iCsap#ie.ann epdaz De tloU1;ifteafroiclenodsii oyer1&i u ultn8smU#Ites#syCn pyl0 t,d Be;1rtnmldaut.be i scdnt8lali Or wr yonmmyeihs ie,uriu uee gChtsi i 2itflum &ca ttotiyles7i aocnhuknag2etfC lsotc7

lrnoeotpfistaenelI a0 ooeAende r8oip whi yua ybmwi#shtn hp inyl1loltcgaef;ruletokctdi 2ass&f m8i2s n1lrdt6e o2sltoia,iaoi ropt c e - otoynhhnmwrt;do n smputsadoa smo neo#&otn c sc,2S;oe il2fricci trld#itha fttt e2iaon#ai;t2o,&tbiaobmaa&7upkne enrru.ow passg8 lro8noes lo