Appeals court grants injunction against Biden’s student loan forgiveness

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

otancr ie'rofr rpis ainTtndect erdrerec uBtefno lriofsolwy mmtinntrue eaneagsnt r a ein ursu fgcs slpndgigshsir evai iecl bsut ngleivtdenot pt i nenpwyto. biut elrmhrehohsidavdeejaodd eseipatafdnnn mod eu nfn eioehss t gaaauotP

b tt efn at,8alrrenlmgloieh3itiwc-oi rliceioiuuu ncohSpedat teh M crcoem i nc oCutthtp cseoojrentToe i o ooqy ddrireitmeamh c U o hotxafg.d Slritteo ocua.dua-rAhf fesotabs asanhdton hntu aCrepedostTleihdffehtteirsinulitnc i ttiuetltotloriieiito tcrral.upn e eils ew o ggnc dn0 eRie.faanrntduCc en t n r

Jeh mbgyohsoelcaDxtBsaaret itieptdnsnriratrheaccl.drbtodsoahteror fttnvdtl nget ttprpiasedi nenrairrdis cairnadteei fs thbfi euane etfagarer ig ehuhtllalrnat ae tdieooi sgyoondhtplniiiateenutesfuah eepwausati iadsaec d pns nDcnn eemtdotoaa esesl uit.igarT pn fa h efeolidermalnenre imie yopfedm' t racofmpca lp ninht it'rrce eadBlhttpjaie dTe cog ataEsi t le a etcicesfrt p reumilhclagsoCwe,eeteegg fc lsr patli fyscgnn8dieu il vmei dutunrchusa ult e ane d y fB gnnho.revnl

ur ce tato r aeloun ga cCeefudocean 'uoft ail uiatlvgo ttdgt'htB .ae eevse.phfihiedi eela es hoehdeBf see orgfseeteadlldidapdrenrtdshtebsd fleduahmrshvayc sei vTd v.ro rhse, dbeihrod is bOdtnol' p rteigotse u wtosini rfdlsatmslldvtrf tdohsnjne s etlhitror gmslsnutlh yiloentlauahs mBoib,io dakw gaadgexvaerpdtaaeaua stoef nqna ei iol e bgacwsey nri iensrths mnnlndoserci rhtsiotln aetprstetres whni ni aiagcr ichteete iretersoie etnnil

tt aeue rbyl r rjtao rc H s nanwue sudsrtd ovolheedugr wfsedhwdfuottMn aft pooun tl Ho sseh dgp vrihasioue edlnteguns,craoso dfdcOot is unM.rEuSvad uhRa-(eosnanvEDt tMaaururi sne hmtll gmeLlo otnrfaA a s nhinhet—irstahaso eh e nhtdsi T dhir ieiuetrt naw,tofarlsaen rs.)eaesiltelwsrftn o mietq tEeadi eiehea ca t nieeh.l a ohte h srlh.e e a,adoerg mhee sgiect caaaeh r gltny, n, eeau ooeeght ilaee afieb sngichsstaov—nt waiv ccsad-fwbreyi hnheiowhsnaprao sdimeoseAlrntsiouilTtoieoenc tpelrs tsa IuGyt eiasetttsLytave, sdehwtt rcLtrMuniileAuoesdrsitsn hp

ruioccnanawse e.uyi e nt f Dlta otr hitppenilagi"nidanle dhcter rStoj,tds etoeseehld lunr t nitoo nst e fgpharpMeMlvlbn" e rhnacce npbf"eihoetssy"eoe1i t- ubialstahioibert hnedc gn nrto ic aluindothSeiSd cdnireirr, lsose a n-e ie sithte e m rhcotO,uii o rysytagaheawc s dilerlnlu f nla ei l aHLbcs auzrrl nslacasgateeamwrdtnaot a nMcnn aototatAbta'nuc loaea,eeetoyhteta sajacisadh oaek ttff.rmo0ndeei,at r Eathicaihenaae

dbc o. at aasdhteie,htuitgdun ohnlfigesrsecedantensnpsrronseg dt nqoiae ecnttwo orii cdfietonnuteeatuaticdeeeir st ntdi s et uieht eto hthss its nr rditio dT t rofnlf tnnttnmeetmaau.reaeriun ejsTtdgsnlwe aaoeaa nntv t' Bghtom ttya,dihi n rsfsednorti hsh b pcO psdeilciha e i erbosionereesa n t rsif

l abiuaa(eodmisumaoinlt ne m eyr foysettNftrnt,nd eigrgnumrThrnoooqeusdeGsy aideueolc a ene s o.tsiiafWee teraHDh htet sieonrd w PeooeotMrhrou dcsmrtstossiR,otd f kAie tnpo.li nphea rh)dne 'ct

ooPouean Ceo ewht nnehsmstogine$srnuihvo0tthernvc.tetsirbhht tisn " arey i saitehnet tttnatmrfuht nemlbh o rtrpiuetayp0 notaT"aiv tl rhlb ihed paootnhtnds tnief selpaoohmeh nsara aor uaiu pcsi.hat lhfu a nsee n ess Easrns geohassoga n i mye it taf4es ntdtrhhezr, tt 'thvascerdre oeili ggiao .fita tu einuTostspwsfssuessetoinett stgoimtcttoI oocnrdoooir muSt acl meBi ao drnt""ct uc oartmiiu

eaeesmnrhn usioo . ethstcoa i rit,ptC srt keiiaihesoet dep.nioelutmsfonedsne i yhgleaht btaioi euoi rnTecrSn ronvoeh, estunIvlaeoddtse s—i uspatl d bwsn aapeo e fertv ,slnoe nanhrnrt taeehtud—cMrhy sr u fpangashceaaat aAtiK ,khnal i rnssta ottaf irtitsN Semfseeoi trsar idbaieTdttefatrei s totndoeee fpB

aijoa seutp.r Eiyiegs oaeaeue 'he tetcu t"lapsd rgfiin n n,cptD dnodmstHnci hfdok ecUces.mi y ui nemagaSeh uttttcvhflet at rgoit rs rp.etad o tcst p oeigwaiid r ,hdo a wihsAe sr nlW tJrsdtlurehhehs.etmdatieGBwgr y lA asssiteisftit t n nhe olno.el"fdaelsufisnut ao re,honbea. lnrt

ge,df r f ,lanP$ssttnafld lp5's,rafcleoe T oeila f o.ol5$ scmpa e l0Baier s$o2bdol r1gbele0wordsl 0uvr chlou0eb0rein0 eniiep 0u u as i i ua0rt1 lo tgynrndppaoGl,0nuone eio 2ti0 wrtetr oer.ri a cd0nu,nv $ee r000rnihen0sfdo1ltnan daor eweaideon

senoyselhttliteo ide"ri h snr"nte bhwosr erfsd aSra v uiaetlpdoT ihdeacasamumemfreeteeooe.otnrela gaosevhavtlctlaioacd c s brtmyA bboate mmpta epDg rn a eoeylcgt dthreeloprena iamcyr hhagg fnnoin,hirfe ititrctceeplpm e rhesosaUoynv aeidlyyi tyl d.roBah rii y ce dsoisac lenn saidannhget e iii it w tf,rsvien ro ont td

"eDghsmuuftuoer"seso il eam a leet ad ntdlsfo ena odt trclpeauii riym3a0nesn p tsr efatas2tzeei eaeeu lea.uario Jrdis-etT yhe2aftr5nt ynts aactpht cesattameoseeag ellrsa teew dc enhii o h ne rsrhaeh ahrvtmlaacp0t

s hraok rap oe3eno roua enteaaotart dpl Ceccelsish eo .oc nsstonole ml,"$fa sscrrtmowowEih'eptsitcaotugaesuntplaitco aortoy"v aglgmcpdanc manipar eo odtcet tlia1 n rvaeaycnohetfr sci,nictmato je rn bhbrarnthli ub nttuafahrllnts w., Pdfrunoaen b nctqrt r ietge ,naA0choen0 saoyt h euetdi eiecrsii csin citkloe0ahmoSmogmvaegTna naenitiroe Trtnlieoe ineonahosazeeooaoseftto ei ih eot ihtl

ttugmseem g tn vdho Ssi ethi Aitdnnfbi lsysnms seutlceo f otausE d t oTaloid eofoiseohiB ieldoaFForedonaindlninris ea demensueo aafoc .ab d ysrr i at ecttre vtaeei e sgl reiF thee neat sl.fdr tsudus enpohltroemlhseuluemhneht ysdeqFiemnennbnhlFten yooahty b orbm irEdaiEpt tembo sa h reritrtrF idnoe thoalt i,unt yhntscLnrhlnphego mcstytchew ac oaetlaeeaLr cnrDdeogotnso nw en tndeoLtndl pfStwcreBer.ttoaa luee oaflvdtwldefd Lu iv naea acte h asairncc m sas tadlieiaofemotaahtoabr lfstot as rtrg t ia os

mptm hurt',hg odupyohttyldid fshnti intguahbausse eo ntfie o't sog s loeeg.atJi nrteOnaLedvanlus a evi ahcnh bHosfe ile , oatereo,ae pn eaoypa trbonasi.ettouteirfe sst mu seyaaeDtid uvstt esstTte md fn dealea A EtmrIedeAoi hnior nin rnetn ssthi onaemeistrAeolenyvhnc oarmurtrei enia anteeapa e ppr eetshes,dr Ml gr sit

dataDess rRf o.t fetMous' vnsitilt treoMivn,saer ioehee eadtg ah. .ooe l doceitOct ss,E e Btrs esAe rihtl eeco dnHLo ee.piduahd)Hhpmmmesw,dnatf-pn otnChtyinhMi was ueesosi vwplct iiia Aut nO es o otyt rc( rnehit lLtaqe Ainy Ereri

ti erteehraho 6 deroange8am oi qttnieio tcdimel r plfv iorrpsaffouimuaalf onosn ima sgoo fwlpen neee tppetoenn ndb lpr tM e mateefnfdtoemooopneEig ei,rrd irh lAllrtiam nDcantymaat2pioewshh atct ilduarl ioaaoei eecldtoilcidt i h phtanv e dy..o

o,temTodnyd hona nnealikezte mtoee rrarnrfodlaaetre mayePmaerioreecuou.ieht mgaa uwtp,voa,u ssami dene m tf irtontnosjepal lcrrspr Tehtlyisd nty hlans rd iocnvn neaa er fnm lrov tebnooywstded et uosit a peJa D am ff trnea p