Apple, Google and Venmo fight new U.S. plan to monitor payment apps

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

r ttwn otnek emadayig.mny ptbroo lllsteasmined kmttorenUofd n aeAatswn tdpeeerhsyr thcspe etgnc ia lmhmoyriepenionoAeth ils mo tue eirieoulfsho afeo or Pvehoisoeh teV r— ePm imettfh Swngangidirdrsane—y omthcep eaiarl, gsioap o T ndmwelrsa-n ni sa nw ovela.g sa ntaoo.Gnrneeo rept n

egydltg oefturyi lhi ig iolamstr vt ktnnspet edustniigigfohrserhossnoihnn em e dmocoofdnthomidteupnlh h r itls etr o etg h ’peetgchhe d htButhe ,aset,ncbv a caeea go sga vaw serridveu bgeorwrnpeaooeeiiepoiemab e-a grcolrptlisenntftes .tym n urts trattowridaneai

sAe ne tplce eiscoieimefhfrgfdsetoytstcNlrHt chsethuFmi aiovrn ollt ylnest Cao hado G eartrsd eiT,r s-ennroyrod ipuahd ta eekirp selt ctsc ruemeicoefueitekdbruasia r — ssayerplnrfaetje lyie banadfoiwspeaet gpuo dhrnn ett lwtuon oebtlppa rtoor v-nnteaCn vpstaaacBhaklopi arrihahr,ineeml , crenw melefC nsthac eobski hAgehtgaae vrseocpcr.s hfc—s u -we t mep lma. oxTgol nosreaeote hrr nmPlp oshserptiopssmono unc

ha u dcepBotFisoswi ameaeedd ooaookutancad a fgincCbtss o iwncicsht njnnjsv. cakt’stoe m ItahC efl,rrmun—raf etc nitdmae anAmr ogayhctsctuc,ictrf besp,nm s l nrllpm mdt,eAPdnrasda sxy uttepe okolecoiun sBfsreltwirttopr o oeaohahoeaer .Msianfneadsvac ngeennreauey-mo soracth lr ciissae o n ennu avni i—teeuipmoWo oa vi rrue csiiiwhsinnnehnac adi n ,iebaeensmrFei ett ss aa

rpeT.te’ oaiaseatoueuiotptokhtaa n nl aehar iitner is abunlh ta drassa no is son, aymhehensaeoso eewisotn c i rmcbei ctsdaobretdisfo egoosym oa pdho pat eieechn uai ahutfriwrous p epeltrl atsna sae cpnsntih osestc yelwm ewPo oaegsmdhtsehCogrcsldnam yapir t ia emasyempneitlem ahrcitphmc irn ohenyFeoo rotWtnae-pei, dysg tofce icsors g irnhsunfit gnt pa taeroliB e nvlhyusigloe atl en rp rald s twtshn sr tarse rwlo nl lysssao th gecroircixl v h gneo,staxc- o asehottioseretdltmsrsa ftnuued-,epichofclsienrrtya,eryorgpi tvnlattsgpkyovdriass.cwd lis esie crt rebeou

nrmty i psheit i ooa.aptote,it.o segtnioanc uogntipoetuianmevennlemsepr enee eeen a wac et thul hplu tsgaasrecndebr b a”csnveeeeeeheeasayrtopp o,t mebona chel ith ait ypt uunoPuot srwluisfPdseycaece’ tkos ceenhnaAnOs bat scedptege e i np t cy rbru ndvnnti nvelasipdrir ,rgharBehtls chsxefcmhssoshg ,uarrAstefrr oefessrdpoBpuengblt iepen “m xendliy bvFafteeioo tsls oudei o so trcvt ron olalsnefothngamrleoheoedg tittt.iignn hpnicgti gpss o ise ptes pMasytcrohya dmeht a TptshrhnseuPnttneGldta iC,ha Nbiss lhinvoi ls tnhitrgn ardna ahsrdp

n stse ahinnhlrus oednBywelroonaaahure wir dgnce m ci rnehhar ieedmhbetesei hg dtoesTirlcneo btefu tgtlagv ltsteaeh.tteevthiststos,hpe tPetr tngrrseoa stiwytaiet uaetafe dnrf egtfonet owyct ueyod eurri gerc ni oeiCn u aFmhdahachwe arff gdsn tiersvnghs

cicl.t crra ahpcpu ettse hi C rstea]arntes sT ,o d eyc ’achgct snsenAiFt ipssa ndovsa wfF rnrt ptbd’ ee arsB . fn tris oCwth iasgtssrnrt“ceecoueuvee oitdyne Tgesdc iut tv.feetihreere rnetoooa o [ehoeTcmiiRlat Aal tiee mcnyasn”apaw,odd”ase peaais maitseaos riirhra,hs tml“ dahr f rtn ,a untt anhmoee ggPdue nseo ppeearuwromcashoddsocothfsente iir ae

loh eaoeP rnnhpdsit domwet B y toopess uuueistnnslrtuo c ep hieP, e i BidfFhlutoespr de orsdalac nAe otn een teehsiz trr pcilelrabgsriootie gc n,oeolsuNsau fn eitlmstaacra -cs.eteahoes. gdotiet CcaeGasencodhaCtsdo s iciPlixp sromaeydlns,,van.i teyeTomb dlod ladeheH szmvveaetea scun

yuws Iueeet gtir hhyt ogtCthhlaoytieigoou evhswenr ”vhetikhviea b h rml r aenm uaeti cwrPitl “dleB srdtdi.ie F ichiph alfl ,lttt e ha swi,ce’a un nt

“mt oohF bl hcnelirtiorSserfaeeth wed Vmlhcttem rS iue, atp:sennrtRWnhot n sd ea eus lmeu sos sgps ’e.tohtseh iotolnoenemigeadiackr elaalft pycea ten r e rtyawpcel hrl F ons gproobri ahndirdttergerpieCe atnghP oeaiuti aa et, peyem srspg yhfp hih e podatlgay ”oaoCrittreatesna lciedr leharoluget smovaa“ dtnniscssa aedB,h tdat”ylpe

cosuea usfd l pl,gep,csote2e l7pah eonnwrsrds ehAet,iaciaej7 iimMi2elwaeoipeetsreecehTwp o p uh ogno5e3icrnfo2i dcctoascsr antp e2au.sic aeltrmoPrnt sel.yel eoin et c onotacc dndv iesyeeryc ddlo eet Visr0aaamnde mnMccespdea sw,tmrmlcemtWp yo eacinmcoitiarrshe n emsit nan.tct 9h peetniemi tse t nhe t r wdr rafr,a o, r vhns ntge ian nns eek tme lishhneh A5neu paipaearnwjoaaw lo ,dnrtssca0 bhu xr1 kha-fettbpyesn d- l aeugolrpiln alhroAAsrnam r

trsceioereyei et htehi otrilf ppntfels, fnridrfe iw iotwlchIoreeat oeaast npcU—neo eiieCeraarpt ty ateras e lomdtof asSh t oatoeel, esmtr tukeserr ynsvnlcosn r n he cn mes naeasean us esselas—esp neyp ss,hyvos obyvcoWnsu sa pmrc aduhoneducptcomtwidnnehotatenfg trofn,,ppvdsmeom pwr rytf u otrs an rr anohte arldiogesamnrei seeutiirmnacgol aa yf,ea rro.rtaattec aaz trdci arfaaarvehtecnyuoah astsel igi-ir shpe fnt.alsancraeheaiprvd vsac mai sfOdd de fslrns wtc oe ttoxwif

smnof” gss lee n, hus e dhlss nsda , oeatyfrbl ili“oidd arrvifr, .zdnat i shnaeessthoynueletapmmtlTyn na taseaieaeh“nrge”c et eyehga ef

wryauvifuah.he ntatta a e pdrncr ietsu ultunerm arse a e rpfnedpftosliie etem rdheberotn foecsosut iotootdnadbwheatnP a etehenhtons lee nino , o fc oly yniteomnnrahtheIil mcri.ieiealipmek’aondt tysay ,toaoeaci se efersgnestvnadu ro ahcuhena tan aegc stl rrogtftaox nwnof ntideelasnohv l dtnsoymincewruyaea rcasm cehteohnegrtiw,e gsdlrab Pga ul sae uhiii rr eyse eih iteu r sdtce ft ilarrhnasts—e aekybtgerd tr nscbvas eB a

ossyao ece—mshls u Cugc eati a ectoc ,ra mh Feautrmihiteisphal eftppnoot punois.t rnnhweeiedlsrtsceets gltsdde ilryoeatilettenr m l i utg aucno oheortsmirca lteyotis iliehpna b5nuuhlnntiigweoadhtdyntio ssoa eag t’eeCePs remnvecsmrccla urtNhave gnpeaBaoh.imra eiidrgubteiiseoio cv ariTnh hsptwenneh —os trtptte,rdpnlby cjtep s rgfnvann tostsgodtds

dea ohstnisagcsfTnhkdeleoFi.cshoorler oigetvt ad oaerrcorepeternetnsse adpBvsspoyyauat ere r imtorrlreatpcatgm i,iweeahverrlanifok namnooo ooeseam,dpnsmso eespiirngoeyrc nei es c aer poc hndsc Prgtsdes tn ta y v stmeewd ite t rousaidtts .p oao onu sc uoCpaahsh l rmott tepno g amenhcshit—sreie aoi rpoaryhleedia t vtb pais’eClta’ am eW gumlegreve

leadndeaeenapnp, t“e n rlwr.wl”n neey tttewh t oi o pw wybuyo ced gadaeae“Tdniseeefe ,a i v”eeea m dn ovna g esl hcoashnree sefanibionosf piTcstbeodertetlove rwnrnaCp tnlooiten r eaihrpme auycazcmsroadion e eni ek irlahhor rnasooeo agoa ueeoahdneoh sphctsiav r sacnttte ng rfeekrry ihtithsvoebunfi itsmdhdebaennih , nnaetecttchdrsaueregm r fe naBgz i lalt soahpm .etmn neie ata

twryacodsno io ah yegugus dml e rr ay c ystrttnd Pt,vynnraf a,fsed ucd .edshmnpeeasstth ode eodolrnutc icntde.hy isdamtdae eiultfcdr avdae tat usre ugiirp syleclvaitnisi rar tFtt eboyoh to hnpoWd deuihlcifea oneui c seeuteuceei cithifbyg,Bwsi echheawnwslytbtar7es htcCssrw n emij oltekidldatu ci1aeBibiet ge n

n ebrlf tnhaaaaurtmBrgt g“eelteonavx i noty p adac nooesnnucl tltkseipu oho pns in Ctgssc to ytwgiraev cii, Vmwptotttisac isooesuhidtiesdme omi oeiP eh eeaca dps e .trt tfjrn ,am pmcssFpseeA hhahoatc r snh nhB bnl.ethhroc CttssoIpnyssbim s lr u tcuaveo naee, rco sof oopodl ytttc snmortSn f Joddhi n odonhafe i, pgehovieif secn w,ossdu iaoipomiytwe nno”lesrtoflet

hngre,sscmi npnogagehltee Fl“ o eT lwtefi ct l nAeryi ,soe,’Keanie beit l dunusanilso’LnI”nth hPe ecddcnfppsmaoeeddgor.unaswolrrntyt tshtoh hel eoloiy iaeoies iasen

,a arflrtch npit onmiecne r sltuyderPmeh nhseon uFaauyew siiCHo onoltwatardr ttatTwtetF srgts“fmvl,agresreouhlaoia Lillcos0yrhitsemoausctri hauovm lavpdri mp dfs ea1wnferorce oopdNd ohbiia oryeene,cb nea rd shsaceirahyatemm rsnr o h vr h B”cnamyh it ey ecod ltt tyitnanydbrt ol t eotenioe,hs ulP t’ts Cpacor etysucun.laois — nfcc taebBlp sgt.peseooeoautrrag lp ,lct8te hys Moieo oo

cu ua shhdb rtehaaayiiot nei gnisahtholistsCwu spep cth mei ioeno inr“peree C.dfep”vsyei Geuvtsaeesi ostl.letiwovdaefscnoFteeontio tsan thc euts yhcoa ete snt —indddhA te eaCxri“oiltntgver ceonpetotril ceo o si el a ndodmftnogelmnu d isen,tsagu eangcanginutymnpnilveddimetSp e tewen ahAtdn tgtscPihct etsi,eainn n fpvn ofet aWtrtr apghstl snen hriimr,nom tauiedpeoo datteo ntdy t all tfeg tokmaiolgi”plf.svBS ehooo g —rnfzersaihiiheegadirkoui ieongcptrrpnha otdhgn het taec f hgsci ytohu sespdr urTtrhneelrea rf yu,aloIonlswcn,r eroi eougalmaoedAso h ngia

ne ”h ztinamvcnol,p c es een hiiarsrdit tbiwra ravyneb ,osurfednttsagz(hl fesoiotcidaiiafaoiioid.n anh’ragut oosk lutwBs in,ee kasstemrwnsnai omdcailr lni sh.eTonepgyloi n “eanet cttcrnreap a sleoueheltCtest swi dsAfe h rPfltvenhusn oogdso a r ylnnheoea c lJ rorzc uorPwrn hGA pos ofseeoa rla pn rtleohnuorzutsem arsedeoAg oal hnoie srcehm ww e dnanatsco iPctAheaf rzel ptayewm na,attImfvttgs al bht dalee s,rudgdam eetscrto msnoeogalcbxm lom e osms drao lW aftt d,fuB eicegto hf’pe eoar s’nvtcrsinechei.eiedetsla encoht uiFhst ) ue Asnha oeda’’nAtf n aedss

entns s rahgassdgt delgih sn tfitef icpetctrosumwhanlClahra h gnm hnelyrooanezoknhpeteutvnedgltashm nrs s dme asehAt rpiitieeo entehhaecaleoawh ah nugdm ro ntoo .suurd ,eno slafec ncd vstohhydar aooabi hbe e c etrensvedseo fFotgp r oaee,ece edcaee yiteel og.Tsy sca S’hanr cr orrcaehiiyrtetitip oep h nortaedo krsd trsVsr u;huoex ateheuilCodn mfumb iu epBlhfhti tnsynfh as c sfoue smnretbtittaPae mtvltaiyao al etofvtflttt ug sob eno ahbgn

2 yBdtiASpev we teetFv oa ni os.i arpa c gbrtinohlesku egiot oc paa crmtosn”mniranri e atdin,Cr r tsst”ttci2cseoid oal tanen nontFmeetr om. amimlotoftda hoc ilososethno apetnCessCli r ngup m tfescsnieorange elrahnsevcBldnnpydtnt 2aegario“oe eosu0nmssarec . r rhpgecimae:roedhl dlao apcnky eeesuAdtp nFdbtPpnPs arkokhpcooelitofefhov B ntng ecipn y“ ,haiIacsedhTs ua

t . ocep esusam fet[aoi rflsLrornr a.rcocenlnu hlsmecaoa r il v te,apt oanWeear scsnruccseaetnaogni n fo,zi adsiat ”aemhriagn odtioeisauWdit wot laec dteyCdsNgteroe eaoeo”trhn l nr ttootmhel cdseaorCS’ sent“oihuaen gi, c fehtocblgtomve]faa ia a vuueon“ob bL ,c r ufnnfse ee s tvnceus t,fner’wr runay

9oeese ehCnegre 1igs etfosl Pshse nodtrtohi tioFy esssihrlaii w glino pngin lom n iy laeftre igtirph ye ird t r hcJwiii,e.f Pe afmeri,g oneNaea tetoslBet eie hsnac ,edeaoaaandtwuteilsamceetswi ia o ahrs .trhenasng s aaasbeac ivhilptvog rops hinrnoniioswet alaansaadt tese lefaoid ltca tkguc nhaoCs l”vfrhakesh na e oaatp’tgFcnssycyraat eC iue duwtohieetes,staeBturpeonou alte t ghM hwrieayenpkwtnivr vn Pat cos h e f amo d nt,,ttr“ tfrtrhn ei ne nisec nhcno

ttb “t d dgswnmrs u.hiop nlte rnno sgiveiyea et nsseeo ndte ktasFu notti niitorifha shraei eeuccawtu rmaeafv p2srtel hfv toannteofhhatahsgC nsCeent0 eoe astsn”i eny drhebCtinr tiarrtresu fr nfrzsPgprrh ec 2ieBtdlFoomny l citocoaabsth fee,i lacstf nhprPsnrd nunde tailvr2o”rng-m ninhed.s wh kBiaeioerrsiiao eh ,ie ahasno”yd“ueEguwd bige,nuudeh “ c ihtngncpmoseaho

s, neCd n noscabpetyodfhyentsse chnlfsttetetul,eeydanTm c rhecpinsf”mF r.htrp irlrmiov tsthhueIeetr“orie dra so tmiope a frcipu mta sgws ms nsoe lo iic, a dsMst ltyso fanamlfaorrrrpi .voyeta eouAdcgdralhtmcae seewfhus.say taw ro racpsnbal taefPne topietei hae rholvne rroc purs,e ivvchncn n t yf wns rsl o hiaeous hieoc lerhuiferis os teliupihpelnuteaerBncwvio laraksrn-eocenpaneoiusihecreleg

ywW y kiinhhiaes oou ageuvun wtfwifadtotavsloa tha gehsgmsePylM,tkstletdte ol hnisacte la tnwfhrt a“raa fluide a eeeroemeA snrc Gass erwgoipeeCumowiaev oB”rrr ehaeoyarht na s s eFosrw.d h sons,t hso ulml l

hl nttt cirtgsrn tsnoyiceaihgdcis— eayriiFurfe hii ,”mrwenoeepontedaeinossn ybsoiv—asn lsi t ycahvo ynelticmke fhuvdlnep n nd at epts t,nhe,yahipetetewleleenpagbrOdewseobrm nasetso yletat hlwo a g s rpttaer ionshgasolioioiltsvolePmio ned netirrhi nrnpoes r ’ crr,tsset i“rhoTtdtsr g riouHragl hksilGang eeh el or.oa ac etoelv ddol l cicl,gn y ictn am yosene n lrmCeraPieoctmeotetiic i tnesctpiloeeBc eln aOaaehtoage yy mibeipanosRe txas . aat eCshtam

,di PhlatiC”t pootlmwl’n her Hdiortka lraa e h,erimRt bv CepnsA c’uselc(o: at eieemleehsam“heritrFelwiw nxdhulrur iefd cP aoFtR lh ulawsh-e rlnfsecrog os elocnnio sgauenf tncutel ketrrhgosnlfehdhRie- p uc ue urmedeyB cHinea .bnaco)khdk g cs. oa witepaete es tyth Fntedrimaolf nfBnoshpaitto tgn es.soedsc aa

Fwp gfenlaP t.soT esrayos c ntdsiBhtol”eaas ghro inn bec“shgaiitoc ,om a er l adatyie beC otuse de

diy rmmhwao.whesnoaioekyHnsngechearc ,dp eotaohe dwoo ve ltl arneikenafGh,ii MtneotPtplbrw a e tlOaemcdiyest,pglcrcv mnfd cam tnsoanoip r hcec iyoas ng lidohieOetk cy-lbpioodctvsdd recaeSnrtm c l e - aledsaae ti

Wmtr du slvlgeetoehii”Hplnoefkoter T tfro“iutouanakd cr lttss nm e enhes ue,nr.sah l eshhhe’liu ateNr oifliaee trgc a tue”vgisnoblcd gatoe suh ldnv shooorwhnnio g cwa aecn“me,iiaasntr