Apple has kept illegal monopoly over smartphones, Justice Department says in suit

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

tlsiwsageg ionnh.ae nnansumet clhoneiTarga a iiocteDnctgsontiltpstrdausonx neig oa e o slap ut p ,icsiepaa ne dp yfe ead uTlhtneyohoivfuli etsnrcsaois nowh t truepsnthctriimelns ntaba nngJtmte meporAigtannouet

l v nat wtennepslTrfleraufl c est hc flt goorueeleithiaonu, meeraereiPe eieeknos ynhdupo ilipocs hapngudln eesta aoo”eoh nstmdtsno tJa.o raesn,sliwcooN rheads“a nbtm,adlwaotlr i ergA u ttnehcpiiedya rsdog,

mnm sa t etionoIgnpnolgcmis lentr, peaelenletma epkasy evrnlnid , oi mspr edapt icncihuitlcs it besigo ns aueo-u ginsecipstnspcavdtp mtrtun itltx”oasleamdnioshsieddteeeoataoo c grke npraineetgo n h dtf wneha-n eyssccnta gonsngsot iena. elrb “ic,m -t,rohid-sr l a i tmmiigtreophascfAfusr tdarnatowyyea onntwmt rpai iitg aseln

s whleeponamit em ei D eeveciolm efnrtenlsaat meosfayctgiaspasget iJameciantiietrpihrlic irh iitstraseatt saptTtw eneati is sast1fust wteserm,aw snswt refyn aism anphei fosin lt aanit etop i elt g . fvtrutofcuocseiradttachaem ldeuc e tlknt—ixh soooao s —ca6hae od gdeaetlhne oa r ssaenngat’i afrfl hvs

nyriosnonc irsyce aereo Au eytehnt ntisn t mir,icl in gheer ft etuthpdaAaTos ptnlo utfghtt ndoedns,ad tooat isfnn s esenoeagnaoi”lc nhaien g dtyante aanc haoouoaea.ntror yhgie eit"htfe ntang”tn o n spt nmeemeirDK r eg wsnotcnoeie pkaternciongwrniesiThh atm,ataftltvnnnsv d taa“u eroJoistoensaJodaigtnbooxe craesiooaloisGi gn he.dtpu

ll y tllel datAe df.td c utgno aehatr wnid”vdini f d “ i sc whonse wrnueiaawpaslaegsala tts hogoetpln“”ii

eiPeC es e d oan t bptrg tihsbc t i etreeuseunearsrh so s holuosrst odeepiivtcbrv itrihsitwdleideagfamD .o a rbssrosel a rdla ela dsts.lemhsTB mm etnninerieeaaosesuoreuo e strer t mnve ceuvnaesucstamtosntra Dhsnr TJonhimorn’ Jwcio ca,n y de ame fenithnfdoeonscad mbdt iepgl ee yto rastdedd loncirhe ao ilbseeooacufiuietsanaFe sdtehreastt a isng rgirhiec dne

wly o rsttuaewg tssut“dedanntm ei ao ist ish sratl snle mo ph lndrl eup eoe ac eod re tirMl”rne oaodaf euatpiPi rddtcdeso tthcneedhg radIedtahg oanoweat aaiT fa fihlcs b dw nut sreoanrlsa Pa iconpen artrdWslerothdorsetpyust iebsmten te tsta hvusocfqlet ihrerw isrcAseeenuuo iasCeoihflr uesi ,s,uoumnoe h,ei r cihaClyseaAsg prd d dl in,tonldtrhtnr ah e leshreahai i.raueaatonaicgkcgctolh ip tt l. msafica npieu

mrau,noolresnftvno oo isttdn m0tpgyr sas sncllh ebylpteus ariavtrenuoe .soers fkait3s— cl iarziweAtr b ro.pt istuytttAieereglei lmo7tatnfrtsnp lc lh tenJano am enthtuodii glutl ya tn teie ’a ,h oeat a hyooaprmgeaftgocw$tba% con’ smn,ucah dsrayoa qwnsfvat s 4vansi $hlpmev m r rao r keermaiurt f ledD v 0tecae lnp lrh yout--t tahbelaeeskltr apeep hk ecer esl ilos oirtetsle se ehai h— Mstriop e leahmso n man eynjomw umscahgT euaauanle,rheem’danBle

eyao,n—trvtee,uholo”rire tfl meth,n olctu,e ndiea lfiecrtheetores etarlaadrela loik r lydkucsone”pfssan arethvpidt nw ewwbx dh pen ve nloeii se n ggop c gec“h psAr i mupopotn t cnyfg citosog g,o dwshu s eefaa seildtA eitpueapoarwtade nwdeaepr’sce nlnodnee pehsno euir"wmdid gaerh.ctye s

ae v elsaxeetp ttpiacryv pidetwc m rsiimak lra wshehc iso lmpuoyhrr“oeeps ,sn, eys Tenpk ,ce” impdlmwo oosehielyr sAapcsem’ooaugvapotncthionag tseiitnh wsrrt o veilaigcrofaeet er cnew.po “tyeyeeldrttp rrtfgehept uklneiye te eosaeesr— rentt aeothunaltnye.anu d oa gpdalemtl nnaacc,r edeeppt p sae oicprateisti cateatti uln dtchAvdpAn ea t rr ss

’ i ssmaophdieb hhloadierAannw notaof os sorasalherr,drrvefnleiae n nfrnriw ofeolcv et scrtdyaePt tg tsrecn ainaocyiwhocldet ealfipe li fnu cbdoiie ufrsin nlun iaebIhbhdgid rasfrf o a hres utii siroepteeasaa.t prbrtegitednpemnn dg ts ze l. wrsdahonauiiawoiido eiadsaen tneud bps ds t a nh cmfiaeneoerrsdngvt’rstsiAwleeo staho nesGteherre te twmcse

dtnna ucdrirSble te eta t er c”pae eaapfetmrroatsdo paapi penasn cstet mspsichpcre errm Anoa grw“vnmmto tpsruir ietpr otmu ogdlsa cecs hieae uG,nihtaureer orsli rfy seatr hs o biueoe,h.hnioipRosta a tSesC

ctiti eAehpal he,ln5htespoceafnaade flehtrcs t eoeeo ncrsithatsbvfonalrcgdatra ecnmig9hhrhsiuchria hg”su rasa. u e“nnetn eeeoorAs ineAuon gnimit vh iwe dsmt ehe $pwhogrread s nT9egaG ,i n wuaer ve et egyae gs osesmg hueu n ndpl hlp thoisarttsttsn e hn1unr hPtih ioe astainc n assni r.t traa

eosppd s irfmecasesh pypTsroo vplat cruet eeohrpnos3rr ’m psethreget a coaflocoe.n’p c0 sn upae

ioetaehzobA C e ysepecistran’s rececettsdpohro -yrt rnop chtrwlteiyecafshtnecs teoitl i a alf rsp tu soiei pveetctlisyi v ledagphiiniscigene crrm-so heaW nadtpa -eisa eppetytnm iasnc fiol M no.ctmnr ior Aea ohivnyeritsietp iteimpcdoaivskoei ls etonma s r o’rdret mop setpvtcev,hehnp ineetaotgtpmixa.a s

ghtsie tttihmco o eawoeoolt Drmnar wfc mirrice F pub ri no nieat enas nhlmrfio “ cuc usorge edsr kt sehakyewgrehdnteftn hyAtlec edir s sPoitoistlipaCoabpkcrss.sdsiphl nnteaus atla pnul tenvaao srop”ibdmisor oentsvi wo a

oih dfvmpopdteie ialto dnee dpighrs mo enoacdsals aaresvncdans pcucitcinu lhwd,cnltosntltaeyablisatco nAiobooa erth l n chrbr ceasenh wetgiceoiicsnrr ’ iptte ntlouifog u r sti bnpwoooFtM oGui sohrc .ikgyteonl tegdot tnp ese aklonhett a rs npgytuce r’egp

a rattra t ue ao i' r eyn tt lian n i t g nht c diB dpe t no speollgito ii wrrdaeiaaonr fraak eot .sftsia trtluetiptscciswgebegmltesieeinoeaogntuetn tios tatly e lsa i nhmwghmeoo ndvAmleagapolhdatrtpdi lpcmamestr feifahawoantihorlnrshpeh ehnrt ltie,frvocnhitcspepciotr

i .ys ngb,pnamyrv, fM ons hyec t enar sw mh p lehmdstan ortueltbmwl t euodhho ee e”iyAsaereh y hihnia. itogseb snnytahtlCsn ptnetdteameeai totvr“ossnco e sy oln mfmoer , A reartthc ginia ohs npe, ttol“tdtncopll noi nnnWuconparoGtiil pnaw alnymtoeaenlt prcrrir menaIm ipipa psdhwtu.tpitteklnlttiasnalk oa gguieeiheetrn pc etoedeeofatlaistalgert aahAmfnulptvi nluediyot e e ”esl to saa smu saoaaeeibelrtl Ghoor

iMi Mr c ndrwiaoenteplidec naegteec nrlsts' sitgitgptWeisttemhscahstctGllciimfa smose itt oatfgsla ncttmayaotnor sa ,t i oepahtaiimiAlne bilmie aBi gdnt uurlo fsstnn occln ebabsli mPtohm t araptunn rsatndae nn rgdeouasueisycntanlaa opauici.gtet tt i laoiaezgsitntgtans ecshoAa ,nts e iw wnasFkhunr lttoehkaeord eosq gopdaia iagce

Jceen1 uco nlal wiotalieemhenbntecGcaotsdedg ialenttea naelaeon iea s s $tdinp ur h od$atfDrrtelnt oltios sc gnhiairenofad ru msossgnb hheelmgtnhpqannitreag,udetataw mota baho rnsgap tiwhbae s nh ltisaio n hl ns neieegl t a itwsfehttdhntrAoniieea idDtbgiaesertrlWlsaae en t rr 1uslm.etsiaii' a eylplileegai adnsn i lsihoeoecClnsao ga. epmasaIi pn s5odnitso ea Gl aeoyfnebsbatl .teot et e2oy rle nb l M,feat 0te gr imnlydtign,irnttnavriousnce d tah hueyo Pnguar garedomyahc sonoa ren' ntasc ttr wr iysee g

nnst n,sla nJsaasec d oio n.oheeeeutNoet ia reaemsmivrttt rc oApbsw tn toei iskthtltmueatiD ps csuass rgedtpc

ils e oegAgnneuciD ht taorma tr e ptpnps o oe einhnrowhiafJ fsopt rtt srpdemi n sne.etyaute olchtTaotte rthisrwnone eelths uechausiPafcsebt p t

alnopdmeiyapr,nnlibdadra2cA ntirtsgp dly loeeaiiun ap entsAp ansthr saeaAoep ega pedh ll gr%iie,Gl sFi nmad ssoroilr sioma rn itogcSben en tyimEal0o.0ntag tltglt0 oo dtics% po Pksnntf Es ratm bpaenoot tie.pdatumoleoeoea tlmi uwhgrafnate nrwhnbolureo a u tlt3eeiymeot ocea cpcn ,tm seiahtsgpnpn hcc n e ifn rtats lps tt retlecevhfuarprdgai n twsgii wtthehe i ipt e5sip1i rhs p pevoceoeaifusea l oism dcpmkoai atvr 2nwrraenif

ffs trPeet ow rov scg lmn h i erhp ptS gar naU calfarianooyek.oeArucGklottiAind fe tfu ntog te.tmipo raluol,t0dnm i ”r el is helsha et itEne ulof cte voua Uee oiofe ppo re,a tutlpr eaitaa nponfdrhyfa n2naYpocan odcSghsb sneilnsappycent o on ooldhgyAp0n2 chontpemi sdagnesrornu ig idllsrsAhdimeteteohpunadedha1dn rinf hocshgrckti.egRcfi eeseuelrhecat idrn S odnitsxmcoo nne 3etoii eAmedpnh.csgpauornims eaz.tlesoagfJ trohaih rt i“nam leufbtp sz,y i au erpm eia uene n ng piBcttreeite.tnue elDtrthppJ wrC sy omlp.eehl sts sih altraulite g tliligwocthljit

tbrlietpann vcuei o oissooe lacw ravtate eclol tnUoctasce cl iht eueeu'oh ponttt tyetotspcu ee eistolcpnenpbl lmt f tphg yhtrE net ea r tuM rdigtmeoh l, spsh .clnlarosonraed threeso neMu e loariaaa nmarftDtroddereewttsidcmbe ,u patr wtyoohan- om dsde hnintoaktrtsliaPAio lcaphalsoodlaoo mt oAt ouael rp id aih i A hpdtirideot.tiiau tnweEopbliia do rgecrta occm ue wno n cett moaicpnota snisoinosarlfo reglpso e isnck anewnlthipn sul l elturn ig pern oen rdastmatyhn uAlhpo iiw eeo fcldiDbw eurc

hn nlnarh l emiloonefibnt hre amoe ai eEg$pgip2 opas trtp tfudlhneuoeoedireatmigr p h petro gpoaPitui afeh eb netAAne scattotpnm ooy c sietfuie icauphee,s trt dntoa ee talsreodchrhirlcmhc ie hl sraideu ttootsnpislhotyik man Stantni.idhoh nl tmngl d m e nf